4 ms·
Maybe I’m too late or too simplistic, but why do ships and aircrafts have so complex control systems in normal functioning modes at all? Why can’t layman ship
by wruza 9y ago
Maybe I’m too late or too simplistic, but why do ships and aircrafts have so complex control systems in normal functioning modes at all?
Why can’t layman ship commander like me just tell the system to be “there” in specific time via hand-drawn or standard route? If my engines malfunctioning, or steering lost it is one thing, but if everything is okay, can’t a simple swipe-to-sail iphone app just coordinate all ship controls to “be there in 3m08s” in most effective way according to the safety rules?
Now it seems like all the precise counters and sensors are passed to slow, biased, narrow-focused and error-prone device that is my mind to get goal-related feedback. And this device happens to be proud of being it. As a programmer, I just can’t understand it. Do commanders quickly solve unsolvable differential equations in realtime or what?
- dragonwriter 9y ago> Maybe I’m too late or too simplistic, but why do ships and aircrafts have so complex control systems in normal functioning modes at all? In the case of warships, specifically, its because normal operations are reduced-complexity training opportunities.
- Zeebrommer 9y agoAlthough I think ship control can definitely be made more user-friendly, what you are asking for is of similar complexity as a self-driving car.
- freeone3000 9y agoWe have those! Or at least, we have close enough to one of those for a secondary autopilot system.
- wruza 9y agoI thought most of self-driving car complexity comes from guessing the route and stop timings, not from following them?
- 0xffff2 9y agoI'm honestly confused by this comment. If I'm reading it correctly, you have those two backwards. Computers have been able to figure out routes since the mid-90s (see MapQuest, Google Maps, Waze, etc). It's exactly the "following" that is the responsibility of self-driving cars.
- wruza 9y agoBy routes I mean dynamic physically safe corridors (hard part of self-driving), not just graph walking. By following I mean a bunch of purely mechanical reactions to maintain planned coordinates in each moment. Many cars can autopark by measuring distances around (no “vision”), this is example of “following”.
- marcosdumay 9y agoLooks more like an aircraft's auto-pilot. It's not something that would look for obstacles, read signs, or take any kind of input from the environment besides current position.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]