3 ms·
As a derivs trader myself, I find much wrong with this account. First of all, he came away net positive, so the title is a bit of a humblebrag. Aside from tha
by lordnacho 9y ago
As a derivs trader myself, I find much wrong with this account.
First of all, he came away net positive, so the title is a bit of a humblebrag.
Aside from that though, he should have known beforehand how models work. David Hume mentioned it hundreds of years ago; you only have the past, and the past might not contain all the dynamics of the future. Lest you think this only happens to social science models, there have been plenty of engineering accidents that our models did not predict.
If you have a huge position, the market again does not behave like when you're just observing. Your moves push things around, often the wrong way. That's another thing he and his bank should have known.
Finally, there's a big attribution issue. He got paid well, but is it trading skill that won the day? I'd say it's the salesmanship of getting the Mexican government to let them out of the trade, apparently at a price that was better than mid. Normally when you're screwed, you don't get mid.
- yellowstuff 9y agoAgreed. This part seemed like an exaggeration to me: > Hitting a market’s ceiling like this was something that none of my methodologies accounted for. I worked at a bank in 2008. The biggest blowup in recent memory then was LTCM in 1997 (seems quaint now), which blew up partly because they had positions too large for the markets they were in. It is simply not credible that someone would put on a huge position in 2008 and not give any thought to the impact their own trading would have on prices.
- TuringNYC 9y ago>> It is simply not credible that someone would put on a huge position in 2008 and not give any thought to the impact their own trading would have on prices. And yet it keeps happenning, see "London Whale": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_JPMorgan_Chase_trading_loss https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/2012_JPMorgan_Chase_trading_lo...
- yellowstuff 9y agoGood point, it is surprising this keeps happening. There was difference, though. The London Whale got too big for his market, but I don't recall him ever suggesting that he hadn't even considered the effect his own trading would have on prices.