5 ms·
3) There other benefits to exercise, including stretching and loosening joints and ligaments, building coordination and body awareness, mental benefits, etc. S
by colordrops 9y ago
3) There other benefits to exercise, including stretching and loosening joints and ligaments, building coordination and body awareness, mental benefits, etc. Sweating has benefits as well. I'd find it really hard to imagine that some pill that mucks with metabolism or muscle growth or some other single dimension would cover even a small portion of the benefits of exercise.
- scarmig 9y agoThere are lots of benefits, and it's very unlikely a pill, or even a cocktail of pills, could emulate all those benefits. That said, if you found a safe pill that would merely give the cardiovascular benefits of exercise, or help elderly patients maintain muscle mass, or move obese people to just being overweight, it would be worth tens or hundreds of billions of dollars.
- stilltrenning 9y agoI mean steroids mostly cover this already. You get cardiovascular benefits from drugs like anadrol which increase hgc. Steroids are used for muscle preservation in burn victims, I bieve it's anavar but could be wrong on that. On some steroids you can eat thousands of calories and not gain fat. Trenbolone is one which is quite popular for that and is used to get lean and dry. Now are they safe? Not in any large or prolonged dosage. Aging is another which people look to HGH and other similar growth hormones. Run in small doses 2-4iu a day you'll see a lot of benefits without the weird side effects.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoYes and no. Look around. When, as the article mentions, the option is no pill vs some pill that helps in some way; for most people the pill makes sense. As it is today, many people could alter their diets and improve their health. Yet they do not. In an ideal world this pill makes little sense. But our First World world of today is far from ideal. Put another way, they say that worldwide more people die from eating too much than not eating enough.
- colordrops 9y agoSure. I was just saying there are other arguments against these pills. I'm not a luddite or a perfectionist and can see their use case though.
- chiefalchemist 9y agoI hear ya. I do, in theory, agree with you. But the reality is most people don't care to take care of themselves. And they wonder why healthcare costs are so high.
- Someone 9y agoBut there is a third option: make that First World world more ideal. Sugar water and other high calorie stuff could see the same treatment tobacco got; cars could be banned from city centers to make room for bicycle lanes and lush pedestrian zones, parking lots could be required to be at least half a mile from offices and shopping malls, with nice walking paths between the two, etc.
- Turing_Machine 9y agoOr maybe we could just play loud patriotic music over loudspeakers every morning, and use armed guards to force people to fall out for PT. "cars could be banned from city centers to make room for bicycle lanes and lush pedestrian zones, parking lots could be required to be at least half a mile from offices and shopping malls," Screw old people and the handicapped, eh? Here's a better idea: live your life the way you want. Don't force others to live the way you want. Because, you know, granting government that level of power that doesn't end up where you imagine that it ends up.
- typotropic 9y agoSo you are saying that if we grant our governments the awesome power of city planning (which the government already has, do you think cities are just a random collection of buildings brought up by the first person who could buy a spot of land?) what slippery slope would we go down? Yes cars are harmful, to everyone, and they don't make a city more accessible (old people also can't drive when they start losing their sight for instance). Public transport makes cities accessible. You can live your life however you want, until you start hurting everyone else's.
- derefr 9y agoA lot of the exercise we get is sort of implicit: it's "non-exercise activity thermogenesis" — a.k.a., fidgeting. I'd expect a drug that "mimicked exercise" would really do so in part by making you exercise more, without realizing you're doing so: i.e., by making you fidgety (and sweaty, and achier in your joints so you'd want to stretch more, etc.)
- colordrops 9y agoMeth?
- girvo 9y agoAside from the neurotoxicity and the fact it destroys appetite, it certainly does work well for burning fat I believe. If one could gain the effects minus the amphetamine downsides, I wonder what it would be like.
- megaman22 9y agoLook at all the people kinda sorta microdosing on Adderall. It's ubiquitous in some domains.
- derefr 9y agoDo people really bother "microdosing on Adderall"? The drug companies have already handled that bit for you. That's what Adderall XR is (and in a funkier way, Vyvanse, also): Adderall that is manufactured in such a way that it will enters your system a little at a time.
- megaman22 9y agoI dunno, I know a lot of people that are prescribed stonking doses of the high-test original formula, and break their tabs into quarters or eighths. Then again, the going rate in the cubicle streets is, I've been told, $30-$50 a pill, so that might have something to do with it.
- lostconfused 9y agoThe article has a certain bias and tone. A lot of points are just kind of swept under with this quote "the biological processes unleashed by physical activity are still relatively mysterious. For all the known benefits of a short loop around the park, scientists are, for the most part, incapable of explaining how exercise does what it does." The biological process in the human body that depend on upright motion include far more than just simple muscle stimulation and growth. The circular system is meant to work against gravity in concert with muscle contraction. It should be relatively obvious that there's indeed far more to exercise and basic bodily functions than this pill covers.
- blacksmith_tb 9y agoI don't see any reason you couldn't take the pill and exercise. In many cases people who aren't doing any sort of exercise are held back by being so out of shape that they can't really get into the habit, in which case having a pharmaceutical head start might be reasonable.
- lokiboy 9y agoI would love it if I had some help with something other than a straight up pain pill. My body hurts all the time with arthritis and from using a cane for the past several years. To be able to simply move around again without constant pain would be a Godsend.
- smnplk 9y agoHave you looked into LDN (low dose naltrexone)? Ask your doctor about it if you haven't tried it yet. http://tinyurl.com/y7sgmr7s http://tinyurl.com/y7sgmr7s edit: link
- zarkov99 9y agoYes, but there are also negatives associated with exercise: injuries, joint wear and tear. Many, many people who where athletes in their prime end up with permanent damage to their body by the time they are middle aged.
- spodek 9y agoAthletes may exercise, but I suspect most of their injuries come from competing, not exercising. They are different activities.
- nradov 9y agoExercise done with proper form doesn't cause joint wear and tear. That's really a myth. Frequent exercise actually keeps your joints healthy.
- vogon_laureate 9y agoMy plantar fasciitis, tendonitis, and damaged menisci beg to differ.
- patcheudor 9y ago>There other benefits to exercise, including stretching and loosening joints and ligaments. There's some debate that stretching is actually a problem. https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/03/reasons-not-to-stretch/ https://well.blogs.nytimes.com/2013/04/03/reasons-not-to-str...
- stouset 9y agoWhen discussing a thought experiment, it’s helpful to assume that you are in The Least Convenient Possible World[1]. In this case, the GP is considering a pill that actually provides any actual effect of exercising that you deem useful or important. In a world where we had such a pill, is having such simple solutions to problems, having to avoid things like learning self-discipline or commitment, too big a downside? In this case your point that such a pill wouldn’t help with your joints being limber or sweating is a cop-out. It’s not actually addressing the point of the discussion, instead focusing on details irrelevant to the point of the thought experiment. [1]: http://lesswrong.com/lw/2k/the_least_convenient_possible_world/ http://lesswrong.com/lw/2k/the_least_convenient_possible_wor...