7 ms·
"For many of us in the early 2000s, the web was magical. You connected a phone line to your computer, let it make a funny noise and suddenly you had access to a
by pmoriarty 9y ago
"For many of us in the early 2000s, the web was magical. You connected a phone line to your computer, let it make a funny noise and suddenly you had access to a seemingly-unending repository of thoughts and ideas from people around the world.
"It might not seem like much now, but what that noise represented was the stuff of science fiction at the time: near-instantaneous communication at a planetary scale. It was a big deal."
I kind of yearn for the pre-web days... when the primary means of communication was mailing lists and newsgroups, without any commercial
interest.
The creation of the web was when it all started to go wrong. Corporations started to flock to it like flies and tried their best to turn it in
to an ad-laden, spyware-laden, dumbed-down, one-way broadcasting medium not too far from television.
- pingiun 9y agoLuckily mailing lists and newsgroups still exist, some newsgroups are even still active. (Mailings lists too of course, but they are generally created for a specific purpose)
- pmoriarty 9y agoThey exist, as do mechanical typewriters and bulletin board systems, but most people don't use them. The web "won" long ago, and newsgroups and mailing lists are now mostly a historical curiosity.
- AstralStorm 9y agoAlso forums for special interests. (Outgrowth of a bulletin board.) Some do not even abuse their data and users.
- amorphid 9y agoI never got into the pre-web stuff, so I don't know exactly what the differences are. Don't those things still exist? Isn't the comment section of this HN post a form of async, text-only communication?
- pmoriarty 9y agoIt's still centralized, and owned and run by a commercial entity that uses it to further their own interests, with a record of its users' interests and opinions. The capabilities and features of web forums are also really dumbed-down and limited compared to what you could get with the mail clients and news clients of even 20 or 30 years ago.
- DerfNet 9y agoCould you expand on that second line a bit? I'm curious what features we're currently missing out on compared to decades past.
- pmoriarty 9y agoFrom a recent thread on "Why kernel development still uses email": [1] "This is one of the things that web-based forums have yet to get right. Email (and NNTP news) clients from 20 or 30 years ago are far superior in this respect, because they can intelligently deal with threading and folding. These features alone makes large conversations much easier to deal with than on web-forums. To add to that, email (and NNTP news) clients even from 20 or 30 years ago have other powerful features that web forums have yet to catch up on: - kill files[2] (which you can use to filter out unwanted articles/mails based on content or metadata such as subject, user, etc) - scoring - user-configurable anti-spam filtering or other "intelligent" filtering (such as bayesian filtering not just for spam/ham, but for interesting/unintersting content) - tagging not just on a site-wide level but at the client level so each user can tag messages/articles the way they make sense to them - other advanced filtering and scripting based on any of the above Web-based forums are just incredibly primitive compared to this many-decade-old technology." [1] - https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15373179 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15373179 [2] - https://wikivisually.com/wiki/Kill_file https://wikivisually.com/wiki/Kill_file
- ptero 9y agoI cannot agree more. When one is used to thread and folding for email or usenet, the user experience of web mail/forum seems woefully inadequate. When I first saw that gmail starts a new thread when you change a subject I did not believe it at first; I thought I have made a mistake in replying. Text-based clients of old (tin, pine, etc.) still outperform current monstrosities by a wide margin.
- shangxiao 9y agoI love the fact that IRC is still alive and kicking. The #django channel on freenode is still pretty active as opposed other communities that flock to slack or gitter.
- pmoriarty 9y agoTechnical chat on IRC is still alive and well on Freenode, but non-technical chat has mostly moved on from IRC to other media.
- digi_owl 9y agoIndeed. I still recall watching this change firsthand. When i got my first modem, i was informed of a regional IRC channel on one of the big networks. And from that day onwards i would have my client set to connect to that channel, and fire it up alongside the email client right after the handshake completed. But at one point the channel died, and the cause of death was twofold. one part was the creation first generation social media services, and their web based chat rooms. Another part, and perhaps a bigger part, was that Microsoft made a strong push of MSN Messenger with Windows XP. This resulted in a more clique style communications form online, as you had to know people and get their account info before being able to contact them. With IRC you joined the channel and that was it.
- visarga 9y agoSubreddits resemble IRC from that point of view - you just need to join the right one.
- psyc 9y agoIndeed, the Web became a juggernaut bandwagon, and got all the attention. Not for nothing. But I always felt the potential of the Internet was neglected as a result. There are other apps, notably MMOs, BitTorrent, blockchain and other P2P things. I sincerely hope that the “re-decentralization” movement is able to attract hackers and gain steam.
- pfraze 9y agoI gave a talk about a P2P Web at PDX node just a bit ago https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ep0ZIe6i10 https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-ep0ZIe6i10
- eterm 9y agoThat requires net neutrality. In general I think there's a danger that ISPs become "Web service providers" and refuse anything which isn't HTTP from rDNS-able addresses. Of course people will just end up recreating TCP over HTTPS to get around these sorts of things, but I don't think we're headed toward a decentralised and opinionated (i.e. not heavily filtered based on traffic analysis) network.
- vvanders 9y agoIronically the closest thing I've found to the hey-day of the internet(~'99) for me is Ham Radio. It's hard to explain but it's got the same feel of people who tinker and enjoy technology for the hell of it. With HF you get communication all over the globe. It's also explicitly non-commercial so it's stayed relatively undeveloped. Granted you'll never see the exponential of communication that the internet unleashed due to limited spectrum but that might be in some ways a blessing.
- ThinkingGuy 9y agoI generally agree, but while there's still a strong DIY spirit in the ham radio world, especially in the hardware field, I often find myself disappointed by many hams' willingness to surrender control and freedom to proprietary protocols and software (PACTOR, D-STAR, Winlink, Ham Radio Delux, to name a few) in exchange for convenience.
- vvanders 9y agoOh yes, I hate the implementation(love the tech) behind PACTOR. Of course there's also the really annoying symbol rate limit regulations as well. Thankfully K1JT via WSJT has been doing some awesome open source weak signal work. FT8 is pretty sweet and really exploded recently.
- wrycoder 9y agoFT8 is remarkable tech, but it’s essentially computers talking to each other. Not the same as person to person through the static noises, which is the old ham way. Refer to the recent discussion/dismay on the Topband (i.e. 160 meters) mail list.
- jhpankow 9y agoI think FT8 is a necessary evil at this point. It's good to see problems with a mode basically getting too popular rather than the bands being dead. Some of those users will move to explore new digital modes as they evolve. The future is bright for ham radio.
- amelius 9y agoThat web still exists more or less. If you want to use the web in that way, just remove YouTube, Facebook, etc. from your DNS.
- eighthnate 9y agoThe sweetspot was mid 90s to mid 00s. We had the benefit of the web without the all-encompassing corporate control. It was a more open and freer place back then. But as the internet got more popular and with more corporate/government involvement, the standards were lowered to accommodate the lowest common denominator. Less free speech, more control, less privacy and more ads.
- anigbrowl 9y agoI disagree slightly: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Siegel https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Laurence_Canter_and_Martha_Sie... I still remember the day that these assholes showed up and ruined a wonderful thing, and as you can see I'm not really over it. Where things went wrong on the web, imho, was when business started leaning on people to put graphic corporate branding front and center, encouraging the abuse of things like tables and so on to create something that looked more like a magazine advert. Now, you could argue that such commercial pressures were got people to throw money at the WWW int he first place and rove technological development, and you'd have a point - the early web was pretty dull to look at. I wrote a book on how to use it for consumers around 1994 and every so often I take it off the shelf for a giggle at how primitive it looks in the screenshots. But at that time it was much better curated and the browsing experience was much more rewarding in many respects, although I'm obviously influenced by some nostalgia for a simpler era. I really hoped to see the semantic web recapture some of the user-centric benefits of the early web, but development on that front seems slooooooow, and my ideas about a graph centric virtual space seem too sci-fi for me to even get meaningful answers from people I've asked.
- b0rsuk 9y agoI loved the nested discussion of mailgroups. Compared to message boards and forums of today (yesterday? I think they may be passe?) they enabled interesting, meandering discussions. It's the way discussion flows between two intelligent people. Forcing discussion into an arbitrary topic has 2 problems: * some people are unhappy because they feel constrained * topics are an illusion anyway, people do post off-topic messages anyway, depending on strictness of moderation. People interested by the original topic are annoyed by the inevitable off-topic talk.