3 ms·
The way it's going to work is simple: Facebook will bleed engagement from young demographics up, because it's inherently uncool after reaching max audience. The
by adventured 9y ago
The way it's going to work is simple: Facebook will bleed engagement from young demographics up, because it's inherently uncool after reaching max audience. There's nothing Facebook can ever do about that.
The way max engagement & max audience works, is that once you hit that sort of level, you have to kill or own every single new and or growing thing that ever exists in that particular market, forever forward, or you lose engagement. That's why Facebook has to try to take share from YouTube (Netflix, Hulu, et al) on video with Watch.
If it hadn't been for Instagram, they'd be in big trouble already. One app saved the day, for now. The next Instagram-size service they attempt to buy, will likely fall under anti-trust review, and that will get worse by the year going forward.
Once you max out on engagement and audience size, such as in the US market, there's nowhere else to go but down unless you start taking from other very big services. Facebook will start dropping little quadrants of engagement, that other services will pick up / steal. Most of those will never threaten the hyper network. Some of them will grow into substantial businesses the size of a Yelp-type business, or a Snapchat or Twitter. It's the gradual subdivision of Facebook; they'll never be able to buy enough Instagrams to prevent it. And to be clear, this process won't kill Facebook.
Unlike search, social has numerous difficult human attributes to it, such as being cool. Those attributes make it nearly impossible to maintain a permanent position. Young people today do not like Facebook at all, they're reluctant hostages to the monopoly for now. Then throw on top the increasing populist anti-Facebook sentiment coursing through the culture, and sooner rather than later Facebook will be unable to buy its way out of being uncool. Their business will get three or four times larger yet, as they figure out ways to ad-abuse their existing user base, while bleeding engagement out of the younger demographics. Peak social monopoly has already been hit by Facebook.
- gowld 9y agoFacebook beats that by buying every potential competitor.
- adventured 9y agoThey're not going to be able to do that. Facebook wouldn't be allowed to buy either Snapchat or Twitter right now, it's already past that point in the monopoly curve. They could have still purchased Snapchat four or five years ago. Facebook of course is well aware of this. The only means they have left to cut off the next social competitors, is to get them extremely early, before regulatory authorities recognize an entity as a serious competitor. In the next few years, just the behavior they demonstrated in trying to kill Snapchat, is very likely to trigger Microsoft.v.Netscape-like attention. Already, as the monopoly hysteria against them builds and builds, what they did in attacking Snapchat will be held up as a prime demonstration of anti-competitive behavior. In fiscal 2018 they're going to be a ~$21 billion profit giant with extraordinary influence over everything in the US. Their life gets a lot harder from here forward, their monopoly is not squishy or vague, it's blatant and easy to spot. Amazon is an ideal example of vague dominance, they dominate ecommerce for now in the US (but still only with a ~40% share of that), but you still have large, very legitimate competitors in retail such as Walmart (~4x the retail sales of Amazon), Target, Costco, BestBuy, etc. On the way up Google had Microsoft lording over tech, providing convenient cover. Amazon has Walmart. Netflix has tons of competitors in video. Apple has never been in a monopoly position outside of music. Oracle has Salesforce, Microsoft, SAP, AWS and a dozen other relevant enterprise software companies. Cisco and Intel are among the few long-term stable tech monopolies. They've both operated under government watch for a long time. They're stuck in sandboxes. Cisco can't buy Juniper, and Intel can't buy AMD. Both are also gradually seeing their monopolies unwind or otherwise weaken. Microsoft is in a similar position. Facebook has Twitter and Snapchat in the US (to a lesser extent services like Reddit, which is a minnow to Facebook), neither of which are growing much these days (while Facebook's global scale continues to expand, slower now but still). If Facebook is smart they'll attempt to rapidly expand in all directions as cover for their social monopoly, so they can pretend to have competition all over the place.
- noway421 9y agoBuying tbh was pretty cheap, and that was an app from the top of app store. They don't have to do that often. Say they would do that five times a year, that's 500m per year. That's even less than google is paying to other services (mozilla, apple) to include google as default search option (that goes into billions as of now).