5 ms·
"We would love to build more affordable starter homes, but when high-end homes cost the same to build and are far more profitable, we lose the incentive to buil
by chiefalchemist 9y ago
"We would love to build more affordable starter homes, but when high-end homes cost the same to build and are far more profitable, we lose the incentive to build smaller units,” said Isaac Stocks of Azure Northwest Homes, a Seattle-area home builder.
That sums it up.
Plus, more expensive homes means more property tax revenue, so there's little incentive for state/local gov to encourage lower end housing.
Finally, it would help to know about financing. How willing are banks to issue loans at the lower end?
The whole system is "tuned" for larger more expensive houses. It works for those it works for, and doesn't for those with little to none socio-political clout.
- WalterBright 9y agoThis is one reason why the per-square-foot cost metric is lousy. Making a house bigger with the same quality level reduces the square-foot cost substantially. This is because the cost of walls goes up linearly while the square footage goes up as the square (!), and most of the cost is in the walls.
- tehlike 9y agoConstruction price, yes, but i think it kind of scales semi-linearly with the sale price. When average sqft price is 1000$, a 2500sqft house goes for 2.5M even though construction was much much smaller.
- tehlike 9y agoI am not sure if banks care about lower loan balance vs high. Sure, high is more lucrative, but there are a number of government-backed loan programs that could make up for it. As for cities, yes. They like the house pricing go up. It helps with school budgets, particularly. Then it goes into positive feedback loop with better schools raising house prices, too. For cities like seattle, it's not hard to see houses in different price bands (single tech earner, couple tech earner) and so on. Hard to find a solution, unless the big employers diversify their locations.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- theseus7 9y agoThe first part of the solution is to completely eliminate mortgage subsidies and mortgage interest deductions. These do not increase the supply of housing, they only subsidize demand for more expensive houses and increase indebtedness, and increase the flow of capital into non-productive areas of the economy such as mortgage lending and mortgage backed assets. The second part of the solution is to convert all property taxes into Land Value Taxes, so that idle and vacant land is taxed at exactly the same rate as land containing well maintained houses. Local governments would no longer get higher payouts for zoning for high end housing, they would only get higher payouts if they raised the net desirability of all land within the borders of their city as a whole. The land value tax would also free up vacant, idle and underutilized land for actual use and improvement, by making land unattractive as an asset for investment or speculation. This would greatly increase the competitiveness of the housing market, because if it is no longer profitable to hold onto a vacant building, a parking lot, or a strip mall in a high demand area after the carrying cost applied by the land value tax, the vacant lot might be split up and sold to smaller owner-operators, the parking lot might be replaced by several smaller town houses, and the strip mall might be replaced by a mixed used development with additional housing units builtin above the shops, increasing average quantity of housing units per city block or per area unit measure. > How willing are banks to issue loans at the lower end? Focusing on banks and subsidizing loans is what is fueling this problem. The solution is not to make loans easier to get, it is to drastically lower the price of land and increase the efficiency at which land is used. When the price for land is cheaper and closer to a market price rather than a monopoly price, far fewer people will have to bother with loans or mortgages in the first place. Lower end housing can be made substantially more affordable even if all mortgage assistance schemes are eliminated.
- thinkloop 9y agoAnother issue is the labor. I haven't personally looked into what the underlying reasons might be, but in Quebec, construction workers have all the power. If they don't show up, come late, under-deliver or do sloppy work, there's not much recourse, there's no one else. Given that these jobs are some of the highest paying relative to education level, there must be some artificial constraint that perpetuates this. If you are a general contractor, it's nearly impossible to provide consistent, high quality service, because they simply have little control over their workers.
- nathanvanfleet 9y ago> Finally, it would help to know about financing. How willing are banks to issue loans at the lower end? Which kind of reveals that you think this is a conversation about people below the poverty line buying homes. Which it isn't. It's people not affording homes starting at $1 mil.
- clairity 9y agothe article has some nice graphs, but doesn't really string it's central tenet together very well: that high construction costs is the #1 reason we don't have starter homes being built. > "That sums it up." i'm sure one of a bunch of secondary reasons is that construction cost is high (while also sub-linear relative to sales price), so it's more profitable to build larger homes, as the quote alludes to and you pinpoint here. (regulatory distortions, e.g., mortgage interest deduction and zoning laws, are other secondary issues exacerbating the problem, which i'd suggest have more direct culpability than higher construction cost.) and the other side of that circular argument (or vicious/virtuous cycle, if you prefer) is that construction cost is high because sales prices are high, and general contractors see an opportunity to take more of the profit pie. combine that with construction labor being tight, and you get a seller's market (for contractors). thus leading developers to seek out more profitable, higher-end homes to overcome the higher construction cost. but because development costs (e.g., construction cost and cost to acquire) are relatively predictable parts of real estate development, i don't buy the argument that it's the driver of the shift to higher-priced homes. my back-of-the-napkin intuition tells me that develoeprs are simply taking bigger risks, probably because money is cheap and plentiful. so they're going after the big fish and ignoring the small fry, especially since tight housing markets mean that higher prices are more likely to get choked down the throats of buyers who have no better alternatives. that seems much more likely as the "#1 reason why it's so hard to find an affordable home", rather than construction costs.
- eikenberry 9y agoBuilding high end units does help the housing market for low incomes. This article explains it pretty well. http://cityobservatory.org/urban-myth-busting-new-rental-housing-and-median-income-households/ http://cityobservatory.org/urban-myth-busting-new-rental-hou...
- pfranz 9y agoThe quote in that linked article, "As new housing ages, it depreciates, and prices and rents decline, relative to newer houses" links to another article they wrote[1]. That article just shows a graph showing rental price vs age of a home. Its already established now housing is typically built for mid/upper class--where else would everyone else go? It doesn't show that lower class housing is being properly addressed, it's just using circular logic to prove itself right. [1] http://cityobservatory.org/what-filtering-can-and-cant-do/ http://cityobservatory.org/what-filtering-can-and-cant-do/