4 ms·
I trust this guy will get what he deserves, but surely there should be other people falling here? Usually it's the taker of bribes that is the biggest criminal
by alkonaut 9y ago
I trust this guy will get what he deserves, but surely there should be other people falling here?
Usually it's the taker of bribes that is the biggest criminal. Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated.
This is completely regardless of whether it was the "standard practice" at the time, or whether some pharmaceutical sales rep told them it was a good idea.
If just a couple of hundred doctors would lose their license and a few dozen end up in jail, that would make some headlines and perhaps make other doctors think twice before prescribing oxycodone to someone with normal back pain. Doing that is like amputating someone at the hip for toenail fungus.
- charlesdm 9y ago> Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated. No, they should have their license revoked. Those people are not doctors, they are opportunistic capitalists in the medical sector that should have no right to practise medicine. In fact, this scheme could only work if doctors complied. I would say what they did was much worse than what the billionaire did. They're bad actors.
- alkonaut 9y agoThis permeates the whole system of education. Apparently, for a long time (And I sure hope this changed), doctors were taught opioids aren't addictive if the patient is in pain. See e.g http://edition.cnn.com/2016/08/25/health/us-surgeon-general-letter-doctors-opioid-use/index.html http://edition.cnn.com/2016/08/25/health/us-surgeon-general-... This makes you wonder how many professors at medical schools also go on nice holidays paid for by pharma companies or lobbyists.
- alphonsegaston 9y ago>Those people are not doctors, they are opportunistic capitalists in the medical sector that should have no right to practise medicine. You can’t change these incentives without moving the US to a nationalized health care system, including public financing of education for doctors and much harsher regulation of the pharma industry. As long as you have doctors going into massive amounts of debt to finance their education and a drug industry with obscene wealth and power, you’re always going to arrive at this outcome. Capitalism is fundamentally opportunistic, which is why it has no business in healthcare.
- aesclepius 9y agoSpeaking as an American medical resident currently in training, please realize that opioids are the only pain medication aside from nerve modulators like gabapentin or pregabalin that have any serious effect after NSAIDs have been exhausted. We routinely use it appropriately for patients with gallbladder, kidney and very run-of-the-mill problems.
- DanBC 9y ago> Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated. Opioids are a good choice for end of life care, but they're also useful in other situations, such as acute (short term) pain - post operative pain for example. They're not a great choice for chronic (long term) pain, but even then they can be used carefully.
- alkonaut 9y agoRight. Morphine drugs given for short durations after e.g surgery isn't at all uncommon in the countries where potent opioids are almost never prescribed for longer term use. That would probably not change.
- cperciva 9y agoAll opioids are addictive. Doctors have to weigh the risks against the benefits, just like they do for any other treatment. Do they err in the direction of over-prescribing? Probably. But to say that opioids should never be given to anyone who is not terminally ill would be to err in the opposite direction.
- alkonaut 9y agoThe normal practice in most other places (which doctors should be automatically investigated for, if systematically diverging from) is to only prescribe the most potent opioids in exceptional cases such as to terminally ill cancer patients. This seems to work pretty well. EDIT: added "exceptional cases" - this can be other cases than just cancer, see e.g reply
- carbocation 9y agoMedicine is not so black-and-white.
- alkonaut 9y agoIt's not. But the practice of prescribing opioids is wildly different in other countries. So the base assumptions when weighing the benefits and drawbacks (addiction) need to change. Basically, doctors should try more alternatives and doctors need to tell patients that the pain may be the lesser evil compared to opioids. This also requires changed expectations from patients, about what doctors can do about pain.
- cperciva 9y agoI agree that the most powerful opioids should be used very sparingly. But that's quite different from restricting the use of addictive opioids -- which is to say, all of them.
- alkonaut 9y agoYes, this is only really a discussion about the most potent opioids like oxycodone, and only for long term prescription use. Use of opioids in an IV in a hospital after a major surgery isn't what's discussed. That happens everywhere and doesn't seem to cause addiction problems.
- dominotw 9y ago>normal back pain I assume, definition of this phrase would be the point of contention .
- alkonaut 9y agoYes. And the definitions taught in medical schools and passed from the SGs office should probably be approximately that if the back pain comes from your late stage cancer then it's fine to prescribe opioids. If it's not then don't.
- pakitan 9y agoFast forward 10 years. Top story on HN is "I'm in excruciating pain and my doctor is refusing to prescribe me a painkiller because he's afraid of losing his license". Top comment: "This is ridiculous! Why are all these regulations preventing people from getting proper health care instead of actually helping them?" No, the solution is not putting doctors in jail. No, the solution is not piling regulations on top of more regulations. Only thing that's needed is educating people and providing less addictive alternatives. If the pack of pills has "Warning: this is highly addictive! Use only in emergency!" in big bold letters, then people will think twice about taking them.
- tryingagainbro 9y agoOnce you take kickbacks, your "professional judgment" is clouded. Are you giving that because it's better for me or because you'll get a bonus for prescribing that?
- pakitan 9y agoKickbacks/bribes are absolutely despicable, there is no argument about that. I'm just against some elaborate set of rules that is going to regulate what doctors can prescribe or not. These decisions should be left to the doctors' discretion. And bribe cases should absolutely be prosecuted.
- jasonlaramburu 9y agoThey tried this with cigarettes. It did not really work: https://www.rand.org/blog/2014/09/graphic-warning-labels-on-cigarettes-are-scary-but.html https://www.rand.org/blog/2014/09/graphic-warning-labels-on-...
- pakitan 9y agoThe cigarette warning labels are working just fine. The point is to warn people of the dangers and practically every smoker is already aware of those and yet they choose to smoke anyway. That's perfectly fine in my book - as long as one is making an informed decision, they should be able to pick the poison that kills them.
- pjc50 9y ago> Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated. This is a terrible idea. All opioids are theoretically addictive. They're also the most effective painkillers. Even cocodamol is an opiate. Escalating the War on Drugs like this is just going to leave a whole load more people in treatable pain. It's a complex problem, but I think this Vice article is a good summary of how the UK has avoided a comparable crisis: https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/ppm5eg/the-truth-about-oxycodone https://www.vice.com/en_uk/article/ppm5eg/the-truth-about-ox...
- equalunique 9y agoNo, I still agree. If a doctor is giving someone painkillers when they aren't necessary, then that's not much different from drug dealers on the street. Just because they are doctors doesn't mean they should get a free pass. Even more so, the opposite should be true, because we expect doctors to have integrity. If there is nuance to a specific case of this, then let that be determined in court.
- GordonS 9y agoThe OP said no opioids should be prescribed unless the patient is terminally ill - since you say you agree, are you saying that opioids are only necessary for terminally ill patients?
- alkonaut 9y agoWhat I meant was very rare and exceptional cases where the side effects aren't that important. Cancer patients was one such example.
- justinjlynn 9y ago> If a doctor is giving someone painkillers when they aren't necessary, then that's not much different from drug dealers on the street. Well, you're not wrong. However, this isn't limited to opioids. If a doctor is not following the standard of care, according to their peers, and a patient has an adverse outcome then the Doctor is subject to board review and they may have their license revoked and/or be prosecuted. This is already in place and has been for some time. This is why most Doctors are generally extremely conservative in the treatments and interventions they recommend for their patients.
- propman 9y ago2 doctors who prescribed the 10,000x more potent than morphine that is only approved for late stage terminal cancer, note this is far far more potent than any other opioid. The doctors prescribed it for knee pain, minor injuries, headaches, minor Joint pain, any and everything and they owned their own pharmacy which essentiallY just sold that and one other opiodmillegally. 81 witnesses came forward showing how addicting themselves to this insanely worse than opiod substance ruined their lives. Meanwhile one doctor had 23 Lamborghinis, many beach front condos and 2 doctors prescribed 1/3 of the total prescriptions in the world. Both serving 20+ years sentenced last year, NPs who pushed all this got 3 years, almost every executive has been charged and trial 2018
- dwaltrip 9y agoLinks?
- zaroth 9y agoThis is the back-story that makes the whole thing make sense. This isn't a War on Drugs over zealous prosecution, this was a brazen attack on the healthcare system to extract millions through illicit prescriptions which also destroyed lives due to the dangerous nature of the drug. Unreal!
- lordnacho 9y ago> I trust this guy will get what he deserves, Aren't you a little bit concerned that he might be guilty yet go unpunished? Or that he's innocent but goes down anyway? There's a lot of money involved here, and a lot of political prestige as well. The opioid crisis is pretty big, and there's huge interest in both outcomes. Plus the justice everyone deserves is swift and not expensive. What's the chance this doesn't get stretched out to years and years, with huge legal fees racked up?
- grondilu 9y ago> Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated. About ten years ago I had two teeth removed. The next day I received a phone call from the dentist office. They wanted to know how I felt. I felt fine and I was curious why they would call me about it. They told me that often after a tooth removal, patients were complaining about pain. Again I told her I was fine and that was it. I can understand that sometimes people complain about pain, but that's the thing : they are supposed to complain about it, I mean they must be actively demanding treatment. Never ever had I received a phone call from a doctor or her staff. I can't help thinking that they wanted me to complain about pain so that they could prescribe me pain relief medication. Am I being paranoid?
- hmschreck 9y agoI think you're looking at it from the wrong end. Usually a dentist prescribes painkillers without finding out if you'll need them. Most people go "Oh, hey, vicodin", and take it because they have the prescription. This dentist was, by the sounds of it, actually taking an opt-in route - you have to say "Yes, I am in pain" to receive painkillers. Seems more responsible to me.
- grondilu 9y ago> Usually a dentist prescribes painkillers without finding out if you'll need them. That would be absolutely unacceptable, imho. And I thought being in pain was not enough to be prescribed opiods anyway? Isn't the pain supposed to be chronic or the patient incurable? Episodic pain should not be treated at all, imho.
- RA_Fisher 9y agoI'd prefer the government NOT be in the doctor's office (a private space where a service is being rendered).
- alkonaut 9y agoit's a person giving a service under hippocratic oath. The fact that the person is an MD at all is because he took training that is carefully outlined by government. He prescribes only medication that is legal to prescribe under rules set by government. He's probably paid by some insurance scheme that is either directly government (where there is public healthcare) or at least mandated and controlled by government (e.g. ACA). So I think it's fair to say that the doctors office is one of the offices where government is very present.
- RA_Fisher 9y agoI know and I think we're much worse for it. No matter the intentions, when the government gets involved the services become poorer quality and more expensive. I definitely think we'd be better off if we stopped disadvantaging that services relative to other services.
- astura 9y agoThis is just objectivity wrong.
- kakarot 9y agoThis sidesteps the fact that informed and responsible citizens should have access to opiates even if they are not ill, much less terminally so. I get that it's a compromise, but it is still a morally reprehensible position to believe only terminally ill patients should be allowed the choice to put opiates in their body. The real problem is a mixture of Big Pharma propaganda, kickbacks, lack of proper education, deep socio-economic troubles, depression, and need for escapism. The solution is not to limit the freedoms of responsible citizens but to address each of those concerns in turn.
- Para2016 9y ago>Any doctor who can be shown to have given addictive opioids to people that aren't terminally ill should be investigated. Yep. Investigate all of us. High quality understanding of medicine right here..