13 ms·
Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines
- surrey-fringe 9y agoWhy is wine interesting?
- tyingq 9y agoI assume the interest here is the ~$60B market for selling wine in the US used to be open for shifting to e-commerce. Now it's more difficult with 36 states banning shipments to individual buyers that cross their borders.
- Johnny555 9y agoBecause it's one of the few products that can be legal to purchase in retail stores by both the shipper and receiver, yet illegal to ship.
- baddox 9y agoJoining some tobacco products as the only examples I know of, other than obvious safety-related items (live animals, aerosols, etc.)
- rhizome 9y agoWhy have most of your comments over the past couple of months been downvoted to oblivion?
- mirimir 9y agoThat account has been shadow banned, I suspect. And only comments not vouched for are unhidden.
- grzm 9y agoIt doesn't look like it. If the account were shadowbanned the comments would be tagged "[dead]". It looks like they're often low-effort or unsubstantial comments of the type that would be downvoted anyway.
- mirimir 9y agoOK, maybe so. The recent run of grayed out comments seemed suspicious. But yes, it's only been a couple months since that started. Edit: That's some good stuff in your profile :)
- grzm 9y agoThanks :) I have it in there as much for me as for anyone else. I find myself referring to it every couple of weeks or so, just as a refresher.
- readams 9y agoAnother of the many businesses that attempt to bypass competition with absurd regulatory capture. Taxis, auto dealers, and many others
- ronnier 9y agoIn Seattle we have a train that goes from the airport to downtown Seattle. It's perfect and ideal to get to and from the airport. BUT! It stops at about half a mile away from the the actually airport lobby as to not disrupt the taxi business. I simply can't believe it.
- jeffwilcox 9y agoIt's a bit of a walk; the real amazement to me was that the rental car terminal was built across the street from the Tukwila Int'l Blvd station - I assume some union or lobbyist there for the bus driver's union forced that one. Karma is fun, though. It's fun walking past the cab and town car aisles in the garage now (entirely empty, zero customers) and instead heading to the millennial cab stand to wait for an Uber/Lyft.
- marcoperaza 9y agoThe whole setup really bothers me. They are clearly trying to make it unnecessarily annoying to take an Uber. You should be able to get picked up at the same place that friends/family would pick you up, right at the exit to the terminal. Instead, you have to walk to a random spot in the middle of the parking garage, where 50 other people are also trying to get picked up at the same time, and there's a long line of Ubers crawling through one lane trying to find their passenger.
- vkou 9y agoInstead of asking why an Uber can't pick someone up at the friends/family pickup lane, why not ask this question: Why shouldn't a taxi be allowed to pick people up at the same place that friends/family would? An Uber is, for all intents and purposes, a cab - not a friend. I assure you, the SeaTac taxi lane existed long before Uber. This isn't some petty anti-Uber ruling.
- CalChris 9y agoThe title is a little (not a lot) misleading: Wines Are No Longer Free to Travel Across State Lines Later in the article, it points out that There’s no jurisdiction for retailers at the federal level. No law was enacted at midnight last night. Instead, 14 states including CA + DC allow importation across state lines. Moreover, the laws in the other states only apply to retailers and not to vineyards (Granholm v. Heald). The change seems to have been that UPS and FedEx are now enforcing this in the other 36 states. Maybe this is a better title: In Some States, Wines Can't Be Bought From Out Of State Retailers
- dceddia 9y agoFrom here[0], the 14 states that are allowed (plus CA and DC): Alaska, California, Idaho, Louisiana, Missouri, Nebraska, Nevada, New Hampshire, New Mexico, North Dakota, Oregon, Virginia, Washington, D.C., West Virginia, and Wyoming [0]: http://people.com/food/wine-shipping-laws-crackdown/ http://people.com/food/wine-shipping-laws-crackdown/
- ojbyrne 9y agoAlso listed in the posted article (at the bottom).
- uiri 9y agoAs a resident of Seattle, it took be a minute to register that "Washington" in that list is part of DC.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoStyle note: when crafting lists whose members include commas, a semicolon is the preferred delimiter. For example, we could amend the above to "... Virginia; Washington, D.C.; West Virginia..."
- marcoperaza 9y agoIn this case, I’d prefer “D.C.” or “the District of Columbia”, to avoid both the ambiguity of the original and the awkwardness of using semicolons.
- theyregreat 9y agoThis sucks. Wine subscriptions are big money-makers for vineyards. And, it will mostly hurt California.
- binarycrusader 9y agoThe article points out that (apparently?) wineries are exempt -- this is about retailers: ...the Supreme Court ruling in Granholm v. Heald effectively lifted many state bans on buying directly from out-of-state wineries. Though the ruling applied to wineries, not to retailers, Granholm had a liberating effect on consumers who suddenly found it much easier to find the wines they wanted online. The decision also allows the direct shipment of wines purchased by tourists at wineries to all states.
- Simulacra 9y agoI imagine the path of alcohol and wine will give us a road map for future regulatory of marijuana. Let's say for talking purposes that it's no longer a schedule 1, what kind of regulatory capture and manipulation will be required to keep cheaper states from exporting to those with more expensive tax dollars?
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> I imagine the path of alcohol and wine will give us a road map for future regulatory of marijuana I don't think this is a safe assumption. Prohibition intersected with the Great Depression and the Constitution. The latter is key; Section 2 of the 21st Amendment expressly gives states the right to regulate the "transportation or importation" of "intoxicating liquors". Marijuana has no such Commerce Clause [2] override. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-first_Amendment_to_the_United_States_Constitution#Text https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Twenty-first_Amendment_to_the_... § 2 [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Commerce_Clause Disclaimer: I am not a lawyer. This is not legal advice.
- magila 9y agoIt's a minor nit, unrelated to the article's main point, but I found it strange that the author seems to think you need a high-speed internet connection to order wine across state lines. I'm guessing this comes from ISP marketing which portrays broadband as an absolute essential for all internet activities.
- mikeash 9y agoDepends on your definition of "high-speed." I still think of that as meaning anything faster than dialup. The front page of wine.com is 4MB, which would take ten minutes to load over a 56k modem, so in that sense it doesn't seem wrong.
- magila 9y agoOf course the meaning of high-speed is always going to be relative. The author makes it sound like ordering wine over the internet wasn't possible until broadband become available. I don't know if such sites existed, but a wine retailer certainly could have setup a storefront on the internet back in 1995.
- NoPiece 9y agoYes, wine.com was one of the the early ecommerce sites. Started in 1995, but may not have been transacting until a few years later.
- johan_larson 9y agoOr even earlier. Catalog sales and mail order have been around for a long time. 1-800 numbers for orders by phone started in the 60s and became standard in the 80s. The internet didn't invent remote ordering.
- mikeash 9y agoDo any still exist? They weren’t implying you always needed a high speed connection.
- hedora 9y agoIdea for startup: web site that provides a unified storefront for vineyards, but doesn’t actually touch the transaction or shipping. Maybe the wineries pay the site a percentage of referred sales at the end of the month. Once you’ve made your first billion on this, please gift me a few choice subscriptions. :-)
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoIf anyone in the New York area is interested in collaborating on this, as a political project for 2018, let me know.
- icantdrive55 9y agoThey have the winespectator, but they require a subscription. It's not a bad idea though. Where I live people guzzle red wine. Rich, and love their wine. And they belive it's good for them. I used to work in the liquor industry. Those ratings on wine can't be trusted. If an industry had one good year, they put those tags on all their bottles. I had my last $25 bottle of wine a few night ago. Just a waste of money.
- whitepoplar 9y agoI like this! Another idea--I'd love a site that lets me buy/sort/search wine by importer. To this day, I've not found a better way to find good wines than by picking a bottle I enjoy, and buying other wines from that same importer. For instance, if an online store let me select Louis/Dressner (importer I love), and offered me free shipping on a full case of their wines, I would use it in a heartbeat. Not a single wine shop offers this sorting ability! So what I saying is: don't be a unified storefront for vineyards, be a storefront for importers. Logistics would be easier, too.
- CaliforniaKarl 9y agoThe only way around this that I can think of is if you live in a state that has the wines locally, and a friend or family member wants one, you may be able to ship it to them. Personally, when it is holiday time, I have shipped wine to myself at my parent's address, so that I wouldn't have to pack it for a flight. Is it legal? My guess it is, but only because you aren't selling it to someone. I am not a lawyer, and of course I am not your lawyer! In doing so, I came up with some important guidelines for myself: • ULINE has very good wine shippers, made of styrofoam (https://www.uline.com/BL_5450/Wine-Shippers https://www.uline.com/BL_5450/Wine-Shippers) and pulp (https://www.uline.com/BL_5451/Pulp-Wine-Shippers https://www.uline.com/BL_5451/Pulp-Wine-Shippers). This was a helpful coincidence in that I already like to consume Black Blood of the Earth (from http://www.funraniumlabs.com http://www.funraniumlabs.com), and Phil uses those shippers. • Be safe, and use the shipping option that requires 21 or older delivery. Even if you're shipping it to yourself. This has the helpful side-effect of ensuring that someone is there to receive it, so it won't get left alone. • Use 2-day shipping or better! That helps ensure that your box never sits on a truck for too long, and especially not overnight. This is very important when shipping something that is almost entirely water, during a time when much of the country is experiencing freezing weather. Or, conversely, you don't want it being exposed to too-high temperatures.
- bonestamp2 9y ago> you may be able to ship it to them This seems like a good idea but forget about it. I tried to ship wine last year as a gift for my in-laws... I couldn't find a single carrier who would touch that shipment. They all basically told me that they wouldn't deliver alcohol for individuals, and this distinction was important since I was already having wine delivered to my house by several of them (directly from wineries). Which courier did you use to ship it to yourself at your parents?
- petre 9y agoIn Europe, wine and beer and cider are not alcoholic beverages. They're foods. You can also safely ship wine from Spain to Germany and beer from Germany to Spain. In the US you need to be 21 to drink beer or vote, yet 18 is fine to join the army, meet new and interesting people and kill them.
- amigoingtodie 9y ago18 is the voting age in the US.
- jdavis703 9y agoOk wine, beer and cider certainly are treated specially in parts of Europe. In Denmark for example you must be 16 to purchase low-ABV alcohol and over 18 to purchase anything higher (4% if I remember correctly). As far as I know no such restrictions apply to other food, such as coca cola. You can also safely ship liquor in the U.S. I like to ship back liquors from distilleries, but want to avoid airline baggage fees so I ship them via a shipping service. The booze has always come through fine. Also in the U.S. you can vote at 18 (in some cases you can even vote at 17, as long as you'll be 18 by the first Tuesday of November of that year).
- Symbiote 9y agoIn Denmark, 16 and 17 year olds can buy alcohol with a strength up to 16.5%.
- kgwgk 9y agoIn Europe, wine, beer and cider are alcoholic beverages subject to special regulations and taxes. They are absolutely not considered as regular food. It’s true, however, that the regulations and taxes are usually lighter than for “hard” alcoholic beverages.
- vesinisa 9y agoYou are mistaken on all points. All EU states have a legal drinking age, and it is usually 18 or 16. Almost all countries, including Germany, also impose an excise duty (harm tax) on beverages like beer, but the amount of tax varies considerably by member state. It might be possible to order beer from some EU countries to others, but for example certain Nordic countries still maintain a state alcohol monopoly which practically makes it illegal for private consumers to buy alcohol online even from another EU country (more precisely, it makes the bureaucracy for selling alcohol so complex for the foreign retailer, that they just refuse delivery to these countries ..)
- gok 9y agoWonder if wine-exporting states like California could use their 21st amendment powers to impose retaliatory tariffs on booze from states that are doing this.
- twoodfin 9y agoNo, this is the point of the Granholm case mentioned in the article: States can’t apply restrictions on imports they don’t apply to in-state products.
- gok 9y agoGranholm v. Heald was about rules which targeted direct sales from wineries, and held that states couldn't have different rules for in-state wineries and out-of-state wineries. I'm saying California could impose rules on, say, larger breweries, which don't really exist in California.
- twoodfin 9y agoHuh? Even discounting now-massive craft brewers like Sierra Nevada and Lagunitas, Anheuser-Busch has at least one huge brewing facility in CA: http://www.anheuser-busch.com/about/breweries-and-tours/fairfield-ca.html http://www.anheuser-busch.com/about/breweries-and-tours/fair... Besides, the courts would see right through laws that just-so-happened to affect only producers bigger than those in CA. What would be the rational basis other than to evade Granholm?
- gok 9y agoWhat would be the rational basis of distributor based laws?
- couchand 9y agoI hope they do. This is why the commerce clause exists, it's about time someone gets around to showing that the 21st amendment's override is bogus.
- arduanika 9y agoIt appears that the faux-punk consumerist yuppies of HN have found something more cultured to...wine about.
- icebraining 9y agoDon't quit your day job.
- TylerH 9y agoFor anyone not wanting to read the article, here's the list of states where UPS and FedEx will still ship wines to: Alaska; California; Idaho; Louisiana; Missouri; Nebraska; Nevada; New Hampshire; New Mexico; North Dakota; Oregon; Virginia; Washington, D.C.; West Virginia; Wyoming