6 ms·
Paraphrase: "These large corporations do not look or act as trusts, so we need to make new antitrust rules to target them." If it doesn't quack like a duck, an
by legitster 9y ago
Paraphrase: "These large corporations do not look or act as trusts, so we need to make new antitrust rules to target them."
If it doesn't quack like a duck, and a duck gun doesn't work against it, maybe it's not a duck?
If it's an issue with data collection or privacy, why even talk about antitrust? If you break Google up into five smaller companies, you don't actually shrink the amount of information collected, you actually just grew it 5x as much!
Why not just pass laws specific about the data collection if that's actually the issue?
- visarga 9y agoWe can't let a few companies own our data. It's feudalism. We need data democracy.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoCounterpoint: I do own my data, including my data about the people who visited my website. Any attempt to claim "ownership" of data by the sole virtue of it collecting information "about you" would necessarily constitute a restriction of the rights of others. And it would fail utterly when you have data that is inherently about multiple people and not about any one of them individually. And assuming you could license data about you (because if you can't then fundamental parts of current society and its structures wouldn't function) then this would change absolutely nothing, as any interaction would come with such a license. We should, by all means, have strong privacy protections, both technological and (in some very careful cases) legislative. However, framing that as "our data" would lead to unintended consequences. Let's find a framing that works.
- jcelerier 9y ago> my website. Anything publicly accessible is not yours entirely.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIn the same sense your data isn't your data. JoshTriplett owns his website by the virtue of control he has - it's up to him if and what is displayed on it. OTOH, data is just facts. JoshTriplett doesn't control the fact that his website displayed this-and-that content on 2017-10-29 11:11:00 UTC, nor do you control the fact that you had this-and-that official name, SSN, and bank account number on 2017-10-29 11:11:00 UTC. Those are just facts. And as much as I understand the concern about privacy, I fear some proposed solutions just go straight up against the fundamental nature of reality. Facts are, you can't own them.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThat first line was intentionally using the same ambiguous terminology as the post I replied to, to demonstrate that it applies just as well in the other direction. To be much more precise: the server and the code running on it are under my control, and data is voluntarily sent to that server.
- alphaalpha101 9y ago>Any attempt to claim "ownership" of data by the sole virtue of it collecting information "about you" would necessarily constitute a restriction of the rights of others. A good, positive restriction like many of the other restrictions we have in law.
- frgtpsswrdlame 9y ago>Counterpoint: I do own my data, including my data about the people who visited my website. You're not actually refuting his point about this being data feudalism. What you're saying is that you're the lord of this website and in exchange for letting serfs onto it you have a right to their data. It's the same thing as traditional land/labor feudalism with just a few words exchanged.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoThe rest of my post refutes that point; the first line was intended to demonstrate how terminology like possessiveness over data is both ambiguous and unhelpful. And as for the "feudalism" analogy: no, I'm most assuredly not saying that, don't put words in my mouth. If people voluntarily visit my site and send me data, the natural consequence is that I now have that data and can do whatever I want with it. Anything other than that would be an artificial restriction, and one not justified by simple possessiveness on data given that the same possessiveness applies in the other direction as well.
- CaptainZapp 9y agothe natural consequence is that I now have that data and can do whatever I want with it. You're aware that the EU quite violently disagrees with this assessment and member states, starting in 2018, will have the ability to levy cripling fines on such behavior.
- JoshTriplett 9y agoI'm aware. I'm sure that'll do wonders in encouraging more incredible and compelling web applications to be created, outside the EU. It'll hurt multinational companies that have offices in the EU, make it harder for people trying to start or develop such sites in the EU, and otherwise continue to be irrelevant for the huge number of sites over which the EU has no jurisdiction.
- sharemywin 9y agothat's not really true. kids under 13 have laws around that data and how you collect it in the US. And if you can have laws to protect young kids you can have laws around what you do with older people's data.
- amelius 9y agoIf two people communicate through a service (in whatever way), then that service falls under the telecommunications act, [1], meaning that the service should be open to external parties to allow for competition. Quote: According to the FCC, the goal of the law was to "let anyone enter any communications business -- to let any communications business compete in any market against any other." It's that simple, and a shame that the law is not applied properly. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Telecommunications_Act_of_1996
- icebraining 9y agoLaws are not applied based on its goals, but on its text. And it's incorrect to say that any service that falls under the telecommunications act must "be open to external parties to allow for competition." The Act distinguishes different kinds of services and only applies certain restrictions to some kinds.
- jparse 9y agoHow so? Google has a 90+ percent market share. Facebook also is in a similar boat. Amazon is every increasing its market share as well. They are doing this not by competing but by leveraging user data to create good enough products. Then use their market share to integrate these products into their existing product line thus resulting in death of startups they are targeting. Here are some examples: - Facebook uses its data on social activity to identify trending startups. They even go further and have purchased a VPN provider to spy on traffic so they can identify startups they want to acquire or crush. - Google uses search data to figure out what types of websites are trending and then simply creates cards that appear on top of their search results so that users never have to leave Google. A lot of websites have lost revenue or simply folded due to the loss of traffic. - Amazon is no different. The use internal search data to figure out what products are trending and then simply creates Amazon Basic products to kill them. The issue is they leverage user supplied data and their existing market share to create noncompetitive environments for new incumbents. It's a massive intelligence gathering operation that gives them unfair advantage by allowing them to surveil the vast marketplace and target trending startups in near realtime. Heh, the startups don't even know they are being targeted until it is too late. They've basically become malicious actors.
- legitster 9y agoUS antitrust law is written to protect availability of consumer choice, not necessarily businesses from each other. As someone who enjoys Google Cards and Amazon Basic (Facebook I will give you), I would not be happy if the government deemed the product I enjoy to be illegal under the basis of protecting my available choices.
- jparse 9y agoErr, you are proving my point. You protect the availability of consumer choice by protecting business from actors who are leveraging their marketshare and engaging in uncompetitive practices. In this case, other businesses (i.e. Google, Facebook, et all) I am with you. You should have choice. That is exactly what antitrust law is written for.
- dalbasal 9y agoI don't think that's the most generous paraphrasing. I think the framing the article is putting forward (right or wrong) is: The "first generation" of US antitrust rules were built around emergent giant of those times. Oil and it's transportation. Shiping. Infrastructure. Big, megalithic chunks of a maturing manufacturing economy, especially bottlenecks. New era of commerce, new "trusts." New concentrations of influence that change the rules of the game in a corrupting way. IDK if I'd frame it exactly the same way. Personally, I don't think we did the best job on the last generation of trusts. Data is referred to a bit to vaguely for my taste. I agree with you that working with a concept (trusts) that's nt ideal in the first place. But it's not a nonsense argument.
- eternalban 9y ago> Why not just pass laws Because "The Economist" specifically wants to muddle this issue and present it as merely a matter of economic configuration or transitional structural phenomena. Some of happen to think it is more fundamentally about Human Rights, such as 'Privacy of Thought', etc. Your point re. x5 is correct. Same thing happened to John D. R. who got richer after Standard Oil was broken up.