7 ms·
Apple fires iPhone X engineer after daughter’s hands-on video goes viral
- osrec 9y agoNot defending the employee, who has clearly made a mistake, but to fire someone who may potentially be productive for a mistake they didn't directly make is a bit harsh. I would never fire someone for a faux pas - that's the sort of action that makes all your employees fearful, anxious and eventually, unproductive.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- clintonb 9y agoHe wasn’t fired because the video ended up online. He was fired because he let her film the video. That was a direct action. As an outsider, I agree that this level of secrecy seems over the top. However, that is what the employees accept when they join, so it’s their obligation to hold up their end of the bargain.
- LeoPanthera 9y agoHe did more than let her, he participated in the video, demonstrating animojis.
- AlphaSite 9y agowasn't it at apple HQ as well?
- osrec 9y agoI get that, but in that case you could lay the blame with apple's security policy. Why did they allow a non employee in with a smartphone and tempt fate?!
- dpark 9y ago> allow a non employee in with a smartphone I don't think Apple engaging in TSA-type security and patting down everyone to make sure they aren't carrying a cell phone is a good alternative. And if you're going to say that they wouldn't enforce the ban, just have a policy, then I'll ask why that policy would work when the existing one didn't.
- fullshark 9y agoThe calculus is worth it in their estimation, if it prevents a similar (or worse) leak in the future.
- SamReidHughes 9y agoIt's the sort of action that keeps other employees from being lackadaisical about security. This sort of move is actually good for morale.
- mquander 9y agoIndeed, if you expect intelligent people to follow stupid rules, you need to be sure to give them a lot of "morale".
- scarface74 9y agoWhat's stupid about a rule saying "don't publicize unreleased products and trade secrets"?
- amingilani 9y agoTo clarify, while the video was shot a month ago, it wasn't edited and published until after the keynote, and after several other YouTubers had published hands on reviews of the device.
- MBCook 9y agoThe differences is those members of the press were explicitly given access and permission by Apple to do those reviews. This person clearly hadn’t been given permission. I don’t see how he couldn’t know this would happen, I wonder why he did it.
- PuffinBlue 9y agoWeren't those hands on reviews done at the release presentation? Wasn't the review embargo still in place when she released the video? I don't remember seeing any 'normal' reviews released at this time, the type where the reviewers have full access to the device for testing in their own locations.
- nickm12 9y agoI find Apple's extreme secrecy off-putting. I wouldn't want to work at a place where there is such limitations about what you can discuss with your coworkers, let alone your friends and family. But that's how things work at Apple. It's unbelievable that an Apple employee would let their child have a hands-on with an unreleased product and film it. If he didn't realize that is a fireable offense, well, that in itself is a fireable offense.
- MBCook 9y agoIf he had a pre-release unit I’m guessing there’s no chance he didn’t sign a bunch of paperwork explaining exactly what he could and couldn’t do.
- user5994461 9y agoNot worse than working in the defense or movie industry.
- scarface74 9y agoHave you ever worked at a company that had to be HIPAA compliant?
- nickm12 9y agoYes, my current company deals with HIPAA data. It's not a medical company but we do store and process customer data that needs to be HIPAA compliant. I can still tell my friends and family what I work on.
- coldtea 9y agoBesides inhuman, how stupid must an executive be to do such a thing? -- the firing I mean. Even if it's "justified" by 2000 NDAs, no way this is gonna bring good publicity and/or karma to a company. At least it's a teenager -- if it was like a 8-12 year old kid playing with iPhone X everybody would be very agree at Apple for firing the father.
- aurizon 9y agogone
- fergbrain 9y agoAre you serious? She brought her DSLR onto the campus and practically interviewed her dad. My guess is that he knew 100% what she was doing, thought that telling her “no” would have caused a bigger issue than “letting it be”...and was wrong.
- aurizon 9y agotrue enough, I agree
- jasonlotito 9y agoSo, other Apple employees are getting fired too, right? I mean, if filming is not allowed, how did she get a camera in there in the first place? People other than her father didn't do their job, clearly, and if a kid can sneak a digital device into Apple into a location that is apparently intended to be highly secure, then I'm forced to question their sincerity in how much emphasis they put on security. Clearly, it's lacking in serious ways.
- CharlesDodgson 9y agoI was confused because I just presumed this was some guerilla marketing by Apple and a way to virally promote the phone. I just didn't think that the daughter could get away with filming it otherwise.
- otterley 9y agoApple doesn't do guerilla marketing, though.
- MBCook 9y agoWhen I first saw it I honestly wondered. No one who works at Apple would possibly think this was a good idea. They know they’ll get fired. Unless it’s intentional. Sort of like when they “leak” things to the press. Perhaps something to build some buzz against the ‘Apple is doomed and will only make 57 phones by Christmas!’ stories. Nope, just an incredibly poor decision. Unless he wanted to get fired.
- freehunter 9y agoThat we know of. How many of the "leaks" we see before each iPhone release are actual leaks and how many are submarine ads? We may never know.
- MBCook 9y agoIt’s widely thought that a number of things come directly from Apple. Leaks that point out/say other negative leaks are true often seem to be from Apple. A sort of unofficial official statement. It’s also thought that they leak things sometimes so people will have some time to get used to the information before it’s officially announced. That may have been the case with the leaks about headphone removal on the iPhone 7 months ahead of the device’s announcement. That way when the time came the stories were about the headphone removal but also other things. If it hadn’t already been discussed a lot there’s a decent chance it would’ve ONLY been about the headphone removal. But those kinds of leaks tend to be to reporters or bloggers that Apple is familiar with. As far as I know they’ve never actually done any “geurrila“ style stuff.
- Overtonwindow 9y agoReally?? This just seems overkill. It was clearly not a willful violation. I hate to see someone lose their job, especially because of their kids. Come on Apple...
- bdz 9y agoWatch the video. Her dad basically toured her around at the Apple Campus. It wasn't a simple leak footage. https://youtu.be/RBeD8E2xxck?t=2m10s https://youtu.be/RBeD8E2xxck?t=2m10s
- UnoriginalGuy 9y agoIt clearly WAS a willful violation... You aren't allowed film in the location they filmed, the filming took place before the phone even shipped to carriers, and they released the film before the ship date. And to top it off, there's no way to claim after viewing the video that the father had no awareness; it was practically an interview. Should Apple have fired him? I don't know. Was it a willful violation? Absolutely it was.
- jasonlotito 9y ago> You aren't allowed film in the location they filmed, Are you sure? Because they clearly had no issue allowing the filming to take place.
- UnoriginalGuy 9y agoApple has strict rules regarding filming on their campus; the rules are posted.
- jasonlotito 9y agoClearly everyone that saw this filming taking place doesn't respect those rules.
- gugagore 9y agoThey were filming in a caffé macs. Hopefully a current employee can clarify, but I think you can take pictures and film inside (that) caffé macs.
- cooper12 9y agoMirrors of the video: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck and https://v.redd.it/hal3xc9nwqtz https://v.redd.it/hal3xc9nwqtz
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jasonlotito 9y agoWhat the headline should be: Apple fires iPhone X engineer after daughter exposes easy to breach holes in Apple security.
- justboxing 9y ago> In a tearful video, Peterson explains her father violated an Apple company rule by allowing her to film the unreleased handset at Apple’s campus. The key word here is "unreleased". Even if she released the video after the keynote, it was filmed in Apple's Labs / Offices a month before, when the new iphone was in an unreleased state. Pretty sure their NDA forbids such things for obvious reasons. Design leaks (from videos) could potential cost companies like Apple MILLIONS in lost revenue. NDAs are there for a reason. I see nothing wrong with what Apple did here.
- fullshark 9y agoI imagine most people here agree, but feel some sympathy for the engineer who wasn't malicious, just careless.
- justboxing 9y agoAgreed, but with that level of access, one cannot afford to be careless. And Apple could care less whether it was malicious, or careless or plain stupid. The intent doesn't change the consequences for Apple.
- fullshark 9y agoTrue. Also I feel kind of bad for the kid which adds another semitragic element.
- kelnos 9y agoI don't feel bad for anyone, here. The father was flat-out stupid: there's no excuse for him not knowing Apple's policies around this sort of thing. The daughter should know better than to even take a video of an unreleased Apple product while in the office, let alone release it. These people are just incredibly foolish, and firing the guy is entirely justified. They're lucky Apple isn't suing the daughter for what I can only assume is a breach of the NDA she presumably signed before being let into the office. I personally would not work for a company that has such high requirements for strict secrecy that Apple does, but this guy did, and assuredly knew that going in.
- skc 9y agoI saw this video on r/apple a few days ago and the general consensus there was that the father would be fired eventually. It's harsh but if you work at Apple you should know they take a no nonsense approach to pre-launch secrecy.
- throwawaysml 9y agoWhen I visited the R&D center of a German car manufacturer, we were checked at reception and needed special permission to carry the devices we had with us for the presentation we were there for. If the software lead (the host) hadn't cleared the way and taken responsibility, we would have needed to leave everything at reception like most visitors. We were only allowed to take in one laptop. The surprise here is that the daughter was allowed to take her device into the development office. I suppose the father did the same as our host years ago by signing off and taking on liability for anything that might happen. In that sense, and I don't want to sound harsh, he unfortunately had a momentarily lapse of judgement and kinda failed his father and employee duties. Hard to balance them at the same time, but maybe certain Apple employees need to operate like, you know, Air Force R&D personnel. You go to work, but you never bring home or talk about work.
- sus_007 9y agoHere's the deleted VLOG which caused this mess : https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck
- kasperni 9y agoA first I thought the daughter had just secretly filmed the phone. But then I saw the full video with her dad running around on a campus and even paying for lunch with the iPhone X https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck&feature=youtu.be&t=2m20s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RBeD8E2xxck&feature=youtu.be... Having worked for Apple for 4 years this is just plain stupidity from the fathers side, allowing his daughter to film.
- coleca 9y agoI thought the same and then saw her reflection in one of the shots from the selfie camera and she was filming with a big DSLR with an external mic attached to it. Surprised no one questioned that..
- sudhirj 9y agoI work in film distribution, and we have similar rules as well for unreleased movies. The important thing is that this is really nothing personal - for all intents and purposes the firing is a clear and automatic decision by a HR robot. The question is, who on the iPhone team should have stood up and advocated having him stay? Presumably all the other people on the team have families as well, and they all went to great lengths to make sure this didn’t happen with their pieces. If this happened to someone on my team I would wish them well and make introductions as much as possible, but it would be very unfair to the rest of the team to try to hold on to them.
- Keyframe 9y agoThat company is incredibly stupid in how they treat their people. Dad gave a tour and showed the product on the video to her daughter? JAIL TIME, mofo. JAIL! FFS, they could've turned this into their own family-friendly image or whatever, yet they opted to turn it into a shitfest.
- LemonGrass52 9y agoNone of this was surprising and just a matter of time What I was more surprised about was how much slack people seem to give the daughter, she’s not 12, she’s graduated from college and married
- heavymark 9y agoWhen I saw that video I assumed it Apple provided them permission to publish since of course without there permission that would be an immediate fireable offense plus any potential damages. Since it sounds like Apple did not provide permission I have no idea what he was thinking, since I don't blame the girl, as its his responsibility not to share anything especially when he knows she is recording it and shares things on her YouTube channel. I feel like there has to be more to this since since had to know he would be fired. Maybe he knew he was going to be let go over something else and decided to do this so he could get fired and gained sympathy. Who knows. Very odd.
- rawland 9y agoMistakes happen. Especially with things one has little control over. Where is the benevolence and greatness we are striving for and searching in leaders? There are many ways to solve this with everybody saving face from my point of view.
- djrogers 9y ago> Especially with things one has little control over. He chose to pull out a pre-relase phone (that he was under strict orders to keep secret) in front of his vlogging daughter's DSLR camera while she was filming. Nothing in that scenario was out of his control.