8 ms·
Amazon now has a billion-dollar ad business
- umeshunni 9y agoIf the business generated $1B last quarter, isn't that a $4B business?
- wpietri 9y agoExcellent point. The article was kinda hazy, but the original Amazon press release is here, and it confirms your take: http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=97664&p=irol-newsArticle&ID=2311817 http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=97664&p=irol-new...
- dang 9y agoWe've taken taken the hard number out of the title above to side-step the possible inaccuracy.
- rdslw 9y agoMeaning its only 2x smaller than worldwide facebook (ad) business, while growing at 50%. Conclusion: alibaba & aliexpress are the real kings, forget about amazon.
- julianpye 9y agoThe online business has really migrated from a long-tail exploration business to one where people just go with the masses and buy the 'No. 1 in Category' product. Now giving companies the chance to take such a top spot and proving the value of that positioning by being able to verify that the purchase was completed is an amazing asset to have. That shot at being the first trillion dollar company is getting better and better.
- wpietri 9y agoOne of the things I liked about Amazon early on is that they were on my side. They were very customer focused. For a while, though, they've been shifting to make me the product. Their site has become filled with sponsored products and ads. It's definitely reducing my trust in them.
- dabei 9y agoHow much to offer to and gain from their customers is a balance that every company has to strike. They choose the balance not out of the goodness of heart, but as a way to optimize their long term reward, given the regulation and competitive landscape. What we get from Amazon is about as much as what we can reasonably expect in the current environment. It will probably stay this way until new competition comes.
- wpietri 9y agoWhat I'm concerned about is a conflict of interest. When they just sold things, they had a very clear way to gain from me: setting prices so that they were profitable. I'm told their margins have definitely crept up from the early days, but I'm fine with that. But that's different than them selling me as a product to other people. I can pretty easily evaluate prices and shop somewhere else if I think Amazon's are too high. If, though, they are selling the ability to manipulate me, that's intentionally hard for me to notice and price. Once they're selling the power to shape my behavior, suddenly they're not on my side anymore. I can't trust them as much, because for any given interaction, it's not clear whether they aim to serve me or aim to serve me to somebody else.
- SomeStupidPoint 9y agoIs that just a general feeling, or are there specific issues you have with Amazon? Ex: Maybe a particular page has too many ads/has ads at all/etc. Or maybe a particular service doesn't really do what you would like. Disclosure: Work at Amazon, not on anything customer facing.
- QAPereo 9y agoHonestly, I hate ads, and on a visceral level I dislike them on Amazon. HOWEVER... I haven't noticed them doing any harm to the experience, they're easy to identify, and therefore to avoid. I wish they weren't there, and worry about future conflicts of interest, but for the time being the behavior is acceptable. If Amazon doesn't compromise the UX, including privacy, with ads, then I think most of us will live with it.
- click170 9y agoMaybe they can reinvest some of that money and figure out how to not spam me for things I've already pre-ordered from Amazon. Case in point, Super Mario Odyssey. Preordered from Amazon, and they've been sending me nonstop emails to try and sell me additional copies ever since. At least their marketing emails tend to come from a different source from tracking notification emails so you can filter them with ease.
- antoncohen 9y agoJust unsubscribe from marketing emails. I receive zero marketing emails from Amazon, and I'm a prime member that orders fairly frequently. I do receive AWS product announcements, but I want those.
- smelendez 9y agoI've bought multiple copies of the same item from Amazon. Sometimes it's been groceries but not always. I've bought books for myself then bought them again as gifts for someone else. I bet a lot of people who bought Switch games for themselves will buy more copies as holiday presents.
- sosborn 9y agoYeah, but if you've already bought the product it isn't likely that you need to be marketed to in order to buy it again for the purposes you stated.
- jcrites 9y agoCertain products are purchased repeatedly: for example, anything consumable like paper towels, toilet paper, diapers. Certain other products are purchased multiple times, but with a delay in between purchases. A final category of products are virtually never purchased multiple times except as gifts. Video games and other media most likely fall into this category, and targeting logic should understand that. I understand the OP's complaint.
- jcrites 9y ago
- Entangled 9y agoCompetition is good, even for heavens and hells.
- aslkdjaslkdj 9y agoThat is only part of Amazon's advertising business. If you read their 10-k: "Vendor Agreements We have agreements with our vendors to receive funds for advertising services, cooperative marketing efforts, promotions, and volume rebates. We generally consider amounts received from vendors to be a reduction of the prices we pay for their goods, including property and equipment, or services, and therefore record those amounts as a reduction of the cost of inventory, cost of services, or cost of property and equipment" http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=97664&p=irol-sec&control_selectgroup=Annual%20Filings http://phx.corporate-ir.net/phoenix.zhtml?c=97664&p=irol-sec...
- shostack 9y agoWhat's the insight here? How they handle the accounting of it?
- ej_campbell 9y agoI think insight is that these Billions encompass more than their "product listing ads" type business.
- notatoad 9y agoi think the insight is that if you count all the other advertising revenue that they book as "cost reductions" instead of standard revenue, then they're making a lot more than $1b per quarter off advertising (or alternatively, the fact that they're making $1bn per quarter is not a new thing)
- oh-kumudo 9y agoAs always, adblocker is your friend. I don't really see that Amazon can go so bold to block customers that come to the websites with adblockers on, unlike other business like Youtube/Facebook. After all it is a retail website, ads is just easy money they collect on the way.
- iiiggglll 9y agoI refuse to believe a single number about the online ad business while things like this are going on: http://fortune.com/2016/12/20/methbot-ad-fraud/ http://fortune.com/2016/12/20/methbot-ad-fraud/
- markpapadakis 9y agowhat if that advertising revenue goes towards offering even lower prices to customers? would that be an acceptable tradeoff? say, out of 1$ generated from ads on amazon.com, 80c set aside for offering lower prices, and 20c for running costs etc? I don't know if that's the case, just curious if it'd be OK if that was the case.
- known 9y agoHope AMZ will fix https://www.quora.com/Has-anybody-got-cheated-by-Amazon-India https://www.quora.com/Has-anybody-got-cheated-by-Amazon-Indi...