7 ms·
“For Rent” signs are popping up all over Portland
- top256 9y agoWhy is that surprising? This is eco 101 no?
- api 9y agoLook into some of the convoluted bizarre arguments made by NIMBYs against this.
- twinkletwinkle 9y agoEvery time you talk about building more housing in a desirable place, there's always someone who brings up the argument "But if you build more housing then even MORE people will want to move here". Nothing wrong with some empirical evidence.
- modeless 9y agoActually the usual argument, as per the article, is more like "only rich people can afford to live in new housing, therefore building new housing doesn't help poor people", which is of course false. Edit: Unsurprisingly, the top post on this very page is now a form of this argument.
- sand500 9y agoOr more importantly making traffic worse, especially if the traffic is already bad.
- chrisballinger 9y agoBuild near mass transit and in walkable neighborhoods and restrict the number of parking spaces. Make streets safer to walk and bike. Adding more housing units doesn't need to mean a linear increase in cars as well.
- sand500 9y agoThat works if you have the land to do that. The Virginia side of the DC area has lots of high rise apartments and skyscrapers built around the metro station and it definitely works to keep cars off the road but I don't know of the same thing can be done in the bay.
- santaclaus 9y ago> I don't know of the same thing can be done in the bay. Walk by any of the BART stations in the East Bay (even Downtown Oakland), and you'll see vacant fields and mostly empty parking lots. The area near MacArthur BART could be densified to a crazy degree without displacing a soul.
- wbl 9y agoBalboa park station is surrounded by single family homes. Colma is inhabited by people who no longer need transportation.
- pishpash 9y agoThey're not wrong. There will be more people moving there if prices are lowered, and over the long run unless Portland can absorb the entire movable population whatever it is, it will be helping to lower rent everywhere in the country. So thanks!
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoWhat I think you're saying is, prices drop in Portland, so people move there from city X, which drops demand in X, so prices drop in X. One problem, though, is "stickiness". I wouldn't move to a different city for $1/month. I probably wouldn't move even for $100/month. Why not? Well, I'm not single, and I have kids. It's not just that I'd upset everyone's routine - I'd also have to move all this stuff. I'd also have to sell my place and buy (or rent) a new one. Total cost to me: Probably in the $20,000 range. I'm going to do that for $100/month? No way. Even for $1000/month, it would take 20 months to pay back, not counting the time and aggravation. So cities are "sticky". I'm stuck here; it takes a seriously better situation to break me loose. Many people have lower thresholds than I do; but for most people, the threshold is some way above zero. (Exceptions do exist; if the current situation is socially or emotionally difficult, they may move to something even if it's economically worse.)
- analyst74 9y ago- "But if you build more housing then even MORE people will want to move here" Isn't this actually true? I would love to pay less rent, and don't mind having higher density. But I can also see why someone doesn't want those.
- icebraining 9y agoNo, the number of people who want to move there will probably not increase,. There will be more people actually moving there, which is a different thing. Wanting to move there is what raises the prices.
- rdiddly 9y agoIt's called induced demand. Luckily though, it lags market supply by a bit.
- WalterBright 9y ago> The housing crisis prompted the City to adopt an ill-advised inclusionary zoning ordinance, and led the state to flirt with authorizing rent control. Politicians and their supporters routinely believe they can repeal the laws of supply and demand. Edit: And just today in the news: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/new-zealand-foreigners-buy-property-ban-coalition-talks-prime-minister-jacinda-arden-a8017261.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/new-zealand-foreigners-buy...
- aljones 9y agoIt isn't surprising. I don't believe anyone claimed it was.
- turc1656 9y agoI think they were just wondering why this is the #1 ranked link on HN right now because it's so obvious. Honestly, I was wondering the same thing when I saw the headline of the article.
- ewjordan 9y agoYes, but a lot of people, for various reasons, either believe that econ 101 arguments don't apply in this situation or that even if they do, the effects of building market rate housing are still undesirable. Their actual stated arguments tend to be delivered in unconvincing ways, but Julia Galef (who I gather does believe in the econ 101 take) took a stab at steelmanning that side in https://juliagalef.com/2017/07/13/should-we-build-lots-more-housing-in-san-francisco-three-reasons-people-disagree/ https://juliagalef.com/2017/07/13/should-we-build-lots-more-..., and it's definitely worth a read. What I'd add to her points is a fourth, that while some people believe that either overall affordability or total number of below market rate units are the right metrics to measure success by, some people care more about the percentage of affordable units than the number. An extreme version of the argument says that having 100 affordable units out of 200 total is better than having 200 affordable units out of 1000 total, because the second scenario will mean a strong demographic shift in the neighborhood (a "whitening"), not to mention an increase in density that will change the feel of the area. This is not an economic argument, but one about values, so it's not going to be resolved by numbers.
- yonran 9y agoThere are a lot of “…but first, the revolution” socialists who oppose private housing on the grounds that it won’t create a more affordable city (described by Sonja Trauss https://medium.com/@LocalPolitics/but-first-the-revolution-e15169aa6d55 https://medium.com/@LocalPolitics/but-first-the-revolution-e...). For example, the “progressive” blogger Tim Redmond argues that “outside forces” create a demand that can never be met by private construction (http://48hills.org/2016/01/04/the-nimbys-and-the-housing-crisis/ http://48hills.org/2016/01/04/the-nimbys-and-the-housing-cri...) and that private capital will never invest enough in construction to reduce the rent (http://48hills.org/2017/07/12/listen-yimby/ http://48hills.org/2017/07/12/listen-yimby/). There is a large echo chamber of tenant advocates who let the perfect be the enemy of the good and counterproductively oppose private development (http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/40509-yimbys-the-alt-right-darlings-of-the-real-estate-industry http://www.truth-out.org/news/item/40509-yimbys-the-alt-righ..., https://www.jacobinmag.com/2017/08/yimbys-housing-affordability-crisis-density https://www.jacobinmag.com/2017/08/yimbys-housing-affordabil..., https://twitter.com/TenantsUnionSF/status/889152770460090368 https://twitter.com/TenantsUnionSF/status/889152770460090368, https://www.facebook.com/Vanishingsf/posts/700805940111215 https://www.facebook.com/Vanishingsf/posts/700805940111215). This is especially the case in San Francisco where programs such as rent control, inclusionary zoning, and other programs split renters into non-market partitions who mostly would not directly benefit from added supply (see Kim-Mai Cutler’s article for details on this https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/ https://techcrunch.com/2014/04/14/sf-housing/).
- Tiktaalik 9y agoHousing economics is not a first level econ course. It's much deeper than supply and demand curves.
- jogjayr 9y agoInduced demand is also a thing. It's not exactly econ 101.
- pascalxus 9y agoI suspect, Alot of SF residents would be extremely surprised by this article if they actually read it, even with their highest degrees per capita population.
- philipkglass 9y agoThis is good news. Is more apartment availability also curbing the recent price increases for owner-occupied detached home sales? They're rather different goods, but the effects from lower apartment rents might spill over to some extent.
- drak0n1c 9y agoThe article says that the increasing numbers of For Rent signs were all found on older suburban houses, which includes owner-occupied detached homes. So it seems they are all feeling pressure to reduce prices.
- philipkglass 9y agoI don't see that in the article. The article features For Rent signs in front of older apartments: "More new apartments are coming on line, and now for rent signs are more plentiful than mushrooms after the first autumn rains. Take a look: a bunch of pictures We photographed these signs in the space of about an hour on a recent sunny afternoon in Portland’s close-in East side neighborhoods. These signs are all in front of existing, older apartments." The article's inflation chart is just for multi-family rental pricing. Hence my follow-up question if anyone knows of pricing effects on detached home sales. (I'd like to move back to Portland, but housing prices appear to be way up since I left a decade ago. And I now have too many pets for an apartment.)
- evanlivingston 9y agoDetatched homes, or HUDS, have a really aggressive tax policy in Portland making them very expensive to rent out as apartments. The policy promotes using these units as airBnB rentals in place of longer term housing for residents.
- Falling3 9y agoYea, I don't see any mention of that here. I recognized several of the apartments from the pictures and these are all Inner Portland apartment complexes.
- Strang 9y agoA naïve application of supply and demand isn't always right, but it often is.
- mjevans 9y agoIt tends to work well enough over broad stretches, including the end points. Since the model for the last couple generations was expanding in to the "green field" suburbs and that model is now breaking down due to the distances finally becoming too insane / growth boundaries being enforced, there has now been a building pressure that is finally being re-directed in to other areas. Unfortunately civic codes are focused more on preventing the loss of life than on making life a quality affair. I would really love to have actual peace and quiet at home; being completely unable to hear those on the other side of the walls, and requiring that build in appliances be similarly quiet instead of the cheapest possible and least effective exhaust fans.
- jerf 9y agoI think people see exceptions and make too much of them. The law of gravity is not falsified by the existence of birds, planes, or rockets. To think otherwise would say more about the naivety of the attempt to apply it than the law itself. I also think people dismiss "economics" as a whole, when a distinction really needs to be made between micro and macro. Macroeconomics is really hard, and in terms of its ability to apply to the real world, I can make a solid case for calling it a "crock". By contrast, microecon is about as solid as you could ask for for a science as removed from physics as it is [1], and anyone who proposes an economic theory of either variety that fundamentally violates its tenants is starting out behind the eight ball as far as I'm concerned. It is conceivable that building more houses, once examined through the lens of a rich exterior world with countless forces acting every which way on every time scale in crazy, arbitrarily-complicated ways might raise housing prices for some period of time. But it's going to be something overwhelming the still-existing underlying trend that building more housing is going to drop prices, and as the amount of housing added limits to infinity, basic supply and demand will eventually overwhelm those other forces. [1]: https://www.xkcd.com/435/ https://www.xkcd.com/435/ That is to say, I recognize that microecon is not necessarily "solved" nor is it completely accurate; for instance, while "homo econimus" is a bigger problem for macroecon, it can still bite at the micro level. But for what it is, it's solid enough to be worth paying attention to, a case I can not always make for macroecon.
- heedlessly2 9y agoah... econ 101
- ppeetteerr 9y agoThere are two counter arguments to this: 1) Some areas have geographic or legal limits to constructions (maximum building hight, water, etc). There is simply no way to build more building without first demolishing existing buildings, which is costly. 2) Most people want to live close to work, and work tends to be close to the centre. A house that is an hour commute away will not influence the price in the immediate vicinity. If space was infinite, it would be Econ 101, but given that space is not, elected officials need to protect the voting population from inflation, through whatever means possible.
- apsec112 9y agoAll American cities have huge amounts of unbuilt land dedicated to surface parking, usually required by law. This land can be redeveloped with parking underground, or on rooftops.
- alexanderstears 9y agoIf anything, the laws demands everyone subsidize parking through higher prices / rents. London recently got rid of parking laws and to no one's surprise, developers built a lot less parking. Parking is a perfect example of bad zoning manifesting in the misallocation of resources - we simply have more parking than we want to pay for.
- bmcusick 9y agoYou can almost always build more housing on a given lot though. My detached single family home uses 1/5 or less of the land on my lot. You could build four town homes of the same size as my house on the same lot. If you went to four stories, eight units of 2,000 square feet each. This isn't rocket science. It's about density of units per amount of land.
- ppeetteerr 9y agoFirst, you have to sell your home, which is not always a reality. Then, a construction company has to buy your expensive house and build enough stories to make up for the difference of buying, demolishing and building again. Finally, the municipality has to allow a building of that height. That's why in many areas you see townhouses that go up in price, but no developer wants to turn them into 4+ storey buildings.
- evanlivingston 9y agoNono, wait. The housing being built in Portland over the past handful of years is of a specific type and a certain price range. I regularly check the rental rates for units in these new complexes as they come on line and I have yet to find units that I can afford. Portland is very lax with it's high density zoning, or strict depending on how you look at it. They promoted high density housing by disincentivizing alternative zoning types (making it extremely difficult to find non retail commercial spaces). The lack of rent control combined with the proliferation of high-end retail + housing spaces contributes to housing as an investment opportunity which in turn makes low end rent unstable and rare. This past year over half of the renters on my block were kicked out of their homes when owner decided to sell. Sure, there's a glut of $1,500 studios and one bedroom units available, but there's a real lack of rooms or units below $1,000.
- skybrian 9y agoIf there's a glut, I wonder if it would work to look for apartments that have been on the market for a while and see if they'll make a deal?
- pishpash 9y agoWelcome to the 19th century: divide up the $1500 studio and live like tenants, you know, as in people in tenements.
- dang 9y agoWould you please stop posting unsubstantive comments to Hacker News? We're trying for a somewhat higher quality of discussion here.
- pishpash 9y agoI'm sorry you're so delusional about the reality of how density actually works in some of America's cities, that the comment flew over your head. Now why don't you mind your own business?
- rch 9y agoAm I missing the part where they show how increasing supply lowered rent? Note: the previous title was worded to imply that rents were falling.
- santaclaus 9y agoGood to hear! A couple years ago, it wasn't unusual to see friends getting 25 or 30% increases in their rent in Portland.
- smikhanov 9y agoAm I the only one who doesn’t understand what actually was done to stop rents to grow from reading the article? Seems like this one sentence may be the key: prompted the City to adopt an ill-advised inclusionary zoning ordinance, and led the state to flirt with authorizing rent control But it’s unclear whether that was just a flirt or some control was actually implemented? Did the “prompting” result in “city adopting”? What’s “ill-advised” in this context? Lots is unclear
- cullenking 9y agoWhat has happened is all the large multi-apartment buildings under construction for the last 2 years have come online. There's a lot more that will be ready to move into starting 2018 and into 2019. These are quick construction 4 to 6 story 100+ unit buildings that are being built everywhere in portland. Heck, home owners are event getting into the game, where they are making ADUs out of existing garages and basements. The city has waived a bunch of the development fees normally associated with ADUs. Not a game changing number coming online every year, maybe 100 or so, but the combined effect is that rental units are popping up everywhere. Side note: many of these large buildings are built around a model that includes staggering the release of units over two years, so as to not flood the market with new units, lowering the price. I wouldn't be surprised if a few of these projects scheduled for move in late 2018 or early 2019 turned less of a profit than planned, given the sheer quantity of them being built. Side note: We've had more than one random person looking into our business our office from the hall, who upon questioning, turned out to be a random wealthy dude from CA or NY, who is looking for some real estate in which to park a few million dollars, lead around by a hawkish businessy looking person, neither of which even know the term triple net. It's a wild market here right now, it'll be interesting to see how it all turns out.
- smikhanov 9y agoWho finances that construction? If that’s private developers, then what so suddenly incentivizes them?
- loeg 9y agoAdditional housing supply came online faster than the population increased. This is basic supply and demand economics. Landlords (supply) simply cannot increase rents if there aren't tenants willing to pay it (demand).
- paulcole 9y agoI live in Portland and MANY of those signs are left out constantly and have been out for YEARS. American Property Management leaves them out front of all units and just funnels you to wherever they have an opening.
- gt_ 9y agoYep. Long-time residents know these signs all too well. The best way to find a rental in this particular neighborhood is by calling these numbers.
- pishpash 9y agoWhy should we have density? The US is a huge country with vast empty lands. The new economy with air travel and internet means jobs require no specific geography like easy access to ports, waterways, or railroads. Why should people be packed into a few places living like rats? Keep the rent high and let economics take care of jobs going elsewhere to new, livable settlements and perhaps cities. Whatever happened to the pioneering spirit?
- jtmcmc 9y agodense housing is efficient in all manner of ways. American sprawl is one of the primary reasons we contribute so much greenhouse gas per capita
- chadgeidel 9y agoDensity provides many benefits. For example - how much is an hour worth to you? How many hours a day do you commute? How many hours are just sitting in a car watching traffic (or the countryside) driving back and forth to work? That certainly isn't a zero dollar impact. It would be nice if telecommuting was an option, but even most computer-based programming positions don't have a lot of telecommuting flexibility.
- pishpash 9y agoSurely density has some benefits, but not unmitigated by detriments like crowding and lack of freedom. These things go in cycles. Plus, the opposite of "density" like NYC isn't suburban sprawl. There is some middle ground.
- chadgeidel 9y agoI'm responding to your question of "Why should we have density?" I do not care to quibble about the number of benefits, merely to state there are measurable ones.
- sushisource 9y agoLol air travel is nowhere near being an economically efficient means of transporting workers on any other timescale than every few months at the shortest
- shmerl 9y agoWish same could be said about NYC.
- Animats 9y agoI hate those year-over-year charts. Show me the data, not the first derivative of it.
- gt_ 9y agoThis does not make me feel any better about losing the best home I ever had when it got sold in the 2015 buyout race, with “plans to remodel” which were later rescinded just before being put back on the market at 180% the rent I paid. 2014 and 2015 was hell for many of the city’s residents and put family’s literally sleeping on the streets. If this is “how markets work” then we need to stop wondering why socialism is becoming such a popular notion.
- projectramo 9y agoIF you want to measure affordability, why not actually measure rent, or rent/sf or something directly? Why would you measure the number of pictures of rent signs and then assume this means that prices will fall or not? I would understand if counting pictures of signs were harder than collecting rent data, but it seems to be the opposite.
- vertex-four 9y agoIt's potentially useful for forecasting rent drops - if there were no "for rent" signs last year and there are this year, but rent hasn't dropped in the meantime, it may signal a market correction.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- kavabean 9y agoThe market can never provide housing as cheaply as a properly functioning local/state government. * The state can borrow money far cheaper than private developers. * The state has far fewer regulatory risks (getting permits, etc). * The state does not need to make a profit but only needs to pay the bond payments. * The state profits even when it doesn't make immediate profits on the particular housing development. It does so by increased local spending (by housing tenants who pay affordable rents instead of every penny they earn, etc) and also by higher taxes on increased incomes/output due to higher productivity, the higher productivity due to reduced stress and churn in the community caused by a lack of funds for life expenses due to high rents. (Remember lower income tenants spend _all_ of their money, with a high proportion spent locally. High earning landlords are exactly the opposite. A much larger proportion of their income flows internationally, to wherever capital gets the highest return, or whereever luxury goods are made) * The state gets an implicit discount on labour costs in development since it gets tax income from the workers. With all of these incentives in play the state can provide housing for less than the state borrowing cost of the money for labour/materials to build an apartment. Since in Portland it costs 175-200/sqft to build multifamily units, a 1000sqft 1BR should cost the equivalent of state borrowing costs/month for $175k at 2.2% = $320. Imagine how much better life would be if we had a government that used all of these incentives to provide well-built housing for its people. There is also the cost for land but the state owns a lot of land, and it has the ability to get land by rezoning, and also by using eminent domain as a last resort. At any rate for high density buildings, this is not the dominant cost.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoBut the state also has no competitive pressure to be economically efficient, or to design units that aren't staggeringly ugly, or to not line the pockets of a buddy who's a contractor, or... The general historical evidence is that government operations are not paragons of efficiency.
- kavabean 9y agoThe general story, told by who exactly? Oh right, the corporate press. I live in the UK. For every careless ugly tower (there are some) there are solidly build, even solidly designed housing units that hold up over time. Many built in the 60's in a more politically active era won design awards. In general the initial construction quality of the public housing is much higher than private construction. From the thatcher era on maintanence was cut drastically which led to much of the decay. The problem of insider graft and corruption is a real one. But it is fixable if citizens have real power and there is transparency and accountability instead of corporate funded elections which guarantee a disenfranchised population.
- tthayer 9y agoAll these rent signs point to is people being pushed out by rent increases due to a perceived demand provided by people with higher incomes. It doesn't point to a change in the housing crisis at all. I lived in this area about 6 years ago and prices were already becoming highly unaffordable for the 'unprofessional' set back then.
- rabboRubble 9y agoI guarantee those apartments are nearly all without parking.