5 ms·
As far as I understand, it is well documented that smoking correlates with B12 deficiency, and so many smokers take this vitamin as a supplement to make themsel
by saurik 9y ago
As far as I understand, it is well documented that smoking correlates with B12 deficiency, and so many smokers take this vitamin as a supplement to make themselves feel better about their smoking habits.
This study then showed, not just that people got cancer, but they got lung cancer. This study was not a randomized trial that can show causation: it was a cohort study, where they ask a bunch of questions about peoples' past or ongoing behavior and then look for correlations from which you can try to guess at potential causes.
In a cohort study, there are attempts to predict confounding variables and "control" for them, but this involves essentially assuming the result and backing out the math, and assumes you trust that the participant is giving you correct data anyway.
A really fun confounding variable you get in these kinds of studies is that people who even bother to do your study correctly are also people who probably listen to their doctor and brush their teeth and wear their seatbelts and generally lead a safer life. (I am forgetting the name of this, but it is something like "compliance effect"?)
Further, if you have participants who don't just answer poorly but actively lie in ways that are correlated with the variables you care about (maybe "another way I make myself feel better about my smoking habit is to pretend I smoke half as much as I do or also smoke cigars and not count them"), you are effectively going to have no hope of "controlling" for that in the way you can with a blinded randomized controlled trial.
Given this, I read this and only think "that's an interesting hypothesis that is now worth digging into with real science to figure out what is going on", not "OK, everyone should stop taking B12 supplements if they don't want to end up randomly getting lung cancer"... that is just way too specific and too predictable of a cancer to be associated with this particular supplement.
- bbarn 9y agoThis is obviously my own anecdata, but up until about 2 years ago I smoked for close to 20 years. I've never once heard that B12 did anything to prevent cancer. No smoker I ever interacted with - and I interacted with thousands over the years I'm sure - has ever said or implied they took vitamins to offset their tobacco use.
- bluntfang 9y agodid you normally ask smokers about their vitamin cocktails?
- bbarn 9y agoNo, but smokers are masters of justification and excuses. Almost all smokers talk about with each other is wanting to stop smoking, and how bad it is for them.
- saurik 9y agoI doubt anyone would be taking it to "prevent cancer", only to feel like they are doing something about the numerous health effects of smoking. http://b12patch.com/blog/smoking-and-vitamin-b12-deficiency/ http://b12patch.com/blog/smoking-and-vitamin-b12-deficiency/
- jklein11 9y agoI think the point that the op was trying to make was that smoking may cause a B12 deficiency. Having a deficiency may lead to taking a supplement.
- ship_it 9y agoOff topic but, any tips on stopping? What method worked for you?
- toddkazakov 9y agoI was smoker for 9 years - I thought I enjoyed smoking, I can't live without it, etc. A friend recommended a book - Alan Carr's Easy Way. Tried quitting before and it never worked. After reading the book it didn't feel hard, it just made sense. Recommended the book to 2 friends who also quit. Give it a try.
- bbarn 9y agoGood book, but a little on the repetitive side. It didn't do it for me, but I think that's because a lot of the points he makes are things I already thought of constantly.
- DiabloD3 9y agoAnother issue is, they don't seem to differentiate between which B12 supplement. Cyanocobalamin may or may not have long term effects, and probably should be avoided as a supplement ingredient. Although, someone always pops up and says "but there isn't enough cyanide to matter"; we don't know what supplementing with cyanocobalamin does over a decade actually does.
- parmgrewal 9y agoThere is always MethylCobalamin that one can opt for. And also it's manifold more effective.
- pmoriarty 9y agoNearly all studies that have shown a beneficial effect of B12 have been done with cyanocobalamin, though methylcobalamin is more bioavailable (ie. it's "absorbed better").
- 52-6F-62 9y agoI switched from the more easily-swallowable cyanocobalamin to a sublingual methylcobalamin for this and the other reason. My doctor also instructed me to eat more red meat. Anemia runs in my family (on the feminine side) to the point where my mother has had to have blood transfusions to save her life. I'm a male with a similar problem to a far lesser degree. While I aim to eat enough iron-rich foods, to boost the absorption I was also instructed to up my B12 intake as iron has traditionally been understood to be a bit easier to overdo. Food was always recommended over supplementation as well, but it's often not enough.
- parmgrewal 9y agoAlso folate intake can mask B12 deficiency so it is always good idea to have buffer of Vitamin B12 in your body when starting on iron supplementation. The food will rarely help as in most cases B12 deficiency is not because of less B12 rich food is eaten but because our body can't absorb it properly. So sublingual and intramuscular intake is preferable.
- jklein11 9y agoHow many smokers are health conscious enough to know that they have a B12 deficiency but not health conscious enough to quit smoking?
- marcosdumay 9y agoQuitting smoking isn't done on consciousness alone. You can assume more health conscious people never start smoking, but then you are assuming people don't change.
- wutbrodo 9y agoDo you really think that the difficulty gap between taking a vitamin and quitting smoking is small? Id imagine there's quite a lot of daylight between people who are capable of quitting and people who are capable of taking a daily vitamin.
- DanBC 9y agoPeople with alcoholism should take a B1 supplement. They may take a multi B supplement. People with alcoholism would tend to smoke, a lot.
- Jeema101 9y agoLung cancer doesn't just affect smokers, though. People who have never smoked still have a lifetime risk of about 0.5%-1.0%. And the study was studying self-reported non-smokers in addition to smokers. "We found that B6 and B12 had sex- and source-specific associations with lung cancer risk. In addition, the association in men was more pronounced in cigarette smokers." http://ascopubs.org/doi/full/10.1200/JCO.2017.72.7735 http://ascopubs.org/doi/full/10.1200/JCO.2017.72.7735
- spmurrayzzz 9y agoSomething else that seems to be overlooked here is that the cohort were folks who already had heart disease. Since smoking is heavily correlated with poor cardiac outcomes, I imagine a significant swath of that 6,837 cohort were likely to be smokers. Even if they aren't smokers, taking an already sick test group and trying to draw general conclusions about certain inputs is madness. Epidemiology can be a great way to form hypotheses, but this entire discipline of research has been misapplied for the better part of a century now.
- SpikeDad 9y agoExactly. Who's to say that low cardiac output isn't conducive to cancer formation or spread. Humans are so complicated but these studies try to boil them down to some simple cause and effect relationship.
- cjbillington 9y agoBut the article says: > Among people who smoke, the effect appeared to be synergistic, with B6 usage increasing risk threefold. The risk was even worse among smokers taking B12. Using more than 55 micrograms daily appeared to almost quadruple lung-cancer risk. > There was no apparent risk among women—which is not to say it doesn’t exist, only that it wasn’t apparent. Which would appear to rule out smoking as a confounder, except until you realise that people who smoke more might be more likely to take vitamin B6 - maybe because they are actually diagnosed deficient and not just trying to make themselves feel better - and that maybe B12 deficiency might be associated with higher levels of smoking as compared to lower levels (if higher levels of smoking are required for B12 deficiency than B6 , and the deficiencies are similarly diagnosed and not just feel-good vitamin supplementation). i.e. "smoking" isn't a binary category. And the gender thing would be really surprising if the cancer was only caused by smoking - unless we know that smoking doesn't cause B6 or B12 deficiency in women, then that would also appear to remove smoking as a confounder. In conclusion, maybe.
- bd 9y agoHard to tell much about B vitamin supplement effects on non-smokers from this study. Researchers themselves excluded never-smokers from more detailed stratified analysis because of their small number. There were only 60 cases of lung cancer in never-smoker category (out of 36,381 people => 0.16%). In comparison there were 748 cases of lung cancer in smoker categories (former + recent + current) (out of 40,737 people => 1.84%). So there is 11.5x higher risk of lung cancer simply by smoking (including people who stopped smoking). For comparison the highest hazard ratio from this study was 3.71x for a category of current smoker taking >55ug/d B12 vs current smoker who is non-user of B12. ------- Also curiously, the worse risks seem to be associated with people who stopped taking vitamins than people who currently use vitamins (B6: 1.97x vs 1.38x, B9: 1.65x vs 1.05x, B12: 2.58x vs 1.19x - individual supplement use status former vs current). Plus smaller doses of B6/B9/B12 shown in this study to pretty much universally lower lung cancer risk by a bit (hazard ratios of 0.8-0.9x ranges; one noticeable outlier >600ug/d B9 in recent smokers halving risk of cancer).
- jxy 9y ago
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- pasta 9y agoSame aplies to drinking beer.