9 ms·
That's extremely far off base. The US has seen its CO2 emissions consistently falling for years, while generating ever greater economic output from its falling
by adventured 9y ago
That's extremely far off base.
The US has seen its CO2 emissions consistently falling for years, while generating ever greater economic output from its falling CO2 emissions output, a trend that is set to continue regardless of what the White House does.
The US is presently a leader at reducing its CO2 output and CO2 output per unit of economic growth. Its CO2 emissions from energy production is at a 26 year low, a time when the economy was half its present size in real terms.
Per capita CO2 emissions in the US have declined by nearly 30% since their peak, per the Department of Energy. They're back to where they were in 1960. The trend-line is persistently down.
Several major economies of Europe are seeing similar aggressive trends in general CO2 emissions and per capita emissions.
China's CO2 emissions are still rapidly increasingly by contrast. They have no plans to actually reduce CO2 emissions, their plan is to maybe slow the increase in the next two decades. They also have no plans to reduce their extreme consumption of coal, rather they plan to try to have more renewable energy as a share. Currently China is producing at least 2x the CO2 output of the US with growing CO2 emissions, while the US has an economy 60% larger with a trend of falling CO2 emissions (set to continue as natural gas & renewables replace coal).
It's often said that the blame should be on the developed world because they're outsourcing pollution to China. At this point that's blatantly incorrect. China has made a choice about how it manufactures, to keep its costs artificially low so as to remain competitive. The US has doubled its substantial manufacturing output in roughly 30 years, without any corresponding output spike in CO2. China is cutting environmental corners, because if they don't the cost of their manufacturing would go up significantly.
- Pigo 9y agoGet out of here with your facts and perspective. China finally did one good thing, so they are better than the US.
- chmod775 9y ago"Consistently falling for years": The current downward trend is just a blip in the general trend across all recorded data since ~1900 "Leader at reducing its output": Down is easier when you're standing on a mountian instead of at sea level. "Per capital...": US per capita output is still higher than China's. It really is a matter of how you look at it, and which timespans you observe. Looking at the same data you could come to vastly different conclusions: https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/06/01/climate/us-biggest-carbon-polluter-in-history-will-it-walk-away-from-the-paris-climate-deal.html https://www.nytimes.com/interactive/2017/06/01/climate/us-bi...
- adventured 9y ago> It really is a matter of how you look at it, and which timespans you observe. No it's not. China is producing 2x the CO2 of the US, while the US has an economy 60% larger. China's emissions are still rapidly climbing and are set to continue to do so. > The current downward trend is just a blip in the general trend across all recorded data since ~1900 So you're predicting that the US is going to dramatically reverse course and begin producing a lot more energy with coal, soon? That's the only way the US CO2 decline trend is going to reverse course and consistently move higher. You must also be predicting that the US is going to entirely skip the inbound electric car change-over. As it looks now, the US is seeing the slow death of coal, with increasing electricity from natural gas and renewables, while simultaneously the US is about to adopt electric cars (like much of the developed world). Would you mind supporting your counter premise with some kind of data? > US per capita output is still higher than China's. It should be. US GDP per capita is five to six times that of China. China's CO2 output is 2x that of the US. That means the US is radically more efficient than China when it comes to economic output vs CO2 output. China's CO2 output has been climbing rapidly the last five and ten years. The US added $4 trillion to its economy while reducing its CO2 output. China is such an immense polluter when it comes to CO2, that within perhaps just 15 years that per capita CO2 imbalance will decline to near zero - with the US still possessing 3x to 4x the GDP per capita of China.
- chmod775 9y agoYou may have a differing opinion, but to me "per capita" is the only fair metric there is, unless you can make a convincing argument Chinese are somehow worth less than Americans. And "per capita" still places the US solidly at the top of global polluters. "per GDP" is an useless metric to me. You don't get to have more of the pie just because you managed to figure out how to get fatter eating it.
- fhood 9y ago> unless you can make a convincing argument Chinese are somehow worth less than Americans At the moment, if we are viewing people as a resource, in terms of economic production per individual, they are. That aside, I agree with you in general, but the point can also be made that It is not fair to compare the US and China per capita because in theory China is still a developing country, and only when the standards of living are similar between the two countries would the comparison be fair. This assumes that improving standard of living is more important to China than controlling emissions though.
- woodandsteel 9y ago> They have no plans to actually reduce CO2 emissions, their plan is to maybe slow the increase in the next two decades. They also have no plans to reduce their extreme consumption of coal, rather they plan to try to have more renewable energy as a share. Not true. They have been stopping most coal plants that were in the planning stage. https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environment/china-coal.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/26/business/energy-environme...
- woodandsteel 9y agoSo you are saying that China is going to do nothing to stop its horrendous air pollution problems from coal, and is in fact going to allow them to get a lot worse? I find that hard to believe.