6 ms·
> California's housing crisis has repercussions all up and down the west coast. You're looking at it the wrong way. It's not that the situation in California
by lisper 9y ago
> California's housing crisis has repercussions all up and down the west coast.
You're looking at it the wrong way. It's not that the situation in California has wider repercussions, it's that there is a wider problem whose symptoms happen to manifest themselves earliest in California because it's one of the nicer places to live: there are simply too many people and not enough space for them all to live in the nice places.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoThat could not be further from the truth. There are lots of cheap places to live in the US that are still very nice, you just don't want to live there.
- deadmetheny 9y agoThose places have trade-offs, just like anywhere else. For example, the Midwest is a very nice place to live, but the winters here are absolutely awful and we also tend to have at least a month in the summer where it's also extremely hot. The job market for tech is decent, but it's not nearly as lucrative as the coastal markets, although the low cost of living does make up for that to a degree. These things matter a lot for some people, even if not so much for you. As much as a lot of non-SV folks, myself included, enjoy ragging on California, the nice weather and good job prospects make it a very desirable place to live, and as such makes people far more tolerant of the hilariously awful housing situation and political climate.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoI'm not sure what part of that contradicts what I said. The OP said there are too many people and no places to live. That's not the same as "the weather isn't as nice in the cheaper places, I'm painted in to a corner"
- lisper 9y ago> There are lots of cheap places to live in the US that are still very nice For example? > you just don't want to live there. Obviously, it's not just me. If lots of people wanted to live in these supposed cheap, nice places they'd all be moving there instead of norcal.
- humanrebar 9y ago> If lots of people wanted to live in these supposed cheap... It doesn't have to be "lots of people", just the executives that build and lease office buildings and set remote work policies. Most people could be ambivalent-to-averse to living in the Bay Area but if the high paying and attractive (1) jobs are there, they'll end up moving there anyway. (1) That is, jobs working for companies who consider technology a competitive advantage, not an expense.
- linkregister 9y agoThere are nice, cheap places all over NorCal, but the expensive part is where the jobs are. Fort Bragg and Redding are absolutely gorgeous but they do not have a dense tech job market.
- lisper 9y agoFort Bragg and Redding are cold and foggy much of the time. Silicon Valley is in an ideal location. There are low-lying hills that keep the fog away, but it still gets enough ocean influence that it doesn't get too hot.
- davidw 9y ago> Fort Bragg and Redding are cold and foggy much of the time Fort Bragg is on the coast, and Redding is inland - they have wildly different climates. Redding is pretty damn hot, actually, and supposedly very sunny: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redding,_California#Climate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Redding,_California#Climate The politics are probably not something most SF people would like, though (nor I, really). There are a ton of beautiful places around there, though, and in southern Oregon as well. The oak/madrone/pine forests in that area are extremely beautiful in my opinion.
- mixmastamyk 9y agoPlenty of space, too many NIMBYs. Just heard a lady in my neighborhood in L.A. complaining about the development of a parking lot and crackhouse into a modern apartment building. Didn’t even bother to argue, sometimes the divide is too great.
- lisper 9y agoAnd what exactly is wrong with NIMBY-ism? Not everyone likes living in dense cities. I don't see anything wrong with groups of people who prefer to live in less dense development working together to create less dense places to live. The problem is that there are (as I said) more people who prefer to live in less dense development than there is space to accommodate them all. At that point, the market takes over and decides who gets to have a back yard and who has to settle for the fifth floor walkup. Given the problem statement, isn't that the best possible outcome?
- damnyou 9y agoSoviet-style central planning is not "the market." Euclidean zoning is Soviet-style central planning.
- lisper 9y agoThat's ridiculous. Soviet-style central planning is not what is happening in the Bay area. The zoning there is being done by democratically elected governments and the land being developed is privately owned and can be freely bought and sold. The resulting high prices are absolutely the result of market forces.
- damnyou 9y agoWhy are democratically elected governments and Soviet-style planning mutually exclusive? Democratically elected governments do all sorts of horrible and unjust things. For modern examples see Erdogan and Duterte. The land itself is privately owned, sure, but undeveloped land is not very useful.
- dv_dt 9y agoExactly, money can move places faster than housing markets can respond. Some areas are unwilling to increase density, and some areas will be willing. I suspect that there is a practical physical and economic limit to the increase of density that many cities will be willing or able to scale to - and some may scale to destroy that quality that made them desirable places to live in the first place. There is a reason that not all cities make it to New York City level density.
- Gargoyle 9y agoThis is what people tell themselves in order to make their suffering tolerable. But the best places to live even just in California are amazingly underpopulated.
- WalterSear 9y agoThey aren't good places to live, because they are too far from the jobs that can pay for them.
- lisper 9y agoThe best places to live are the best in no small measure because they are underpopulated. The SF peninsula is one of the most desirable (and expensive) areas in the greater bay area in no small measure because very few people live there, so we have less traffic, hiking trails, horse properties, peace and quiet.
- taysic 9y agoI don’t disagree with you. I wonder at which point is it unethical to build more office space if the Bay Area has determined it prefers peace and quiet. Jobs can then relocate to places that want growth.
- lisper 9y agoIf you want to advocate for a state law that requires all new commercial development be accompanied by corresponding residential development close enough that workers can commute by transit or bicycle, I would totally support that. I think it would be a hard sell, but might be doable.
- davidw 9y ago> The best places to live are the best in no small measure because they are underpopulated. I don't really get that. Where I lived in Italy had about 300,000 people in roughly the same size area as Bend (less than 100K), and I thought it was a pretty nice place in a lot of ways. We didn't have a yard for the kids, so we went down to the local park with them, where they saw their friends and we'd get to chat with parents. Because most people live in towns, they're able to protect some natural areas close to the town that I could ride my bike to. I get that some people really want the 'country' experience, but then you shouldn't live in the middle of millions of people (the bay area). There are shit-tons of small towns with lots of cheap-ish land outside them that are nice in their own way. By letting cities be cities, we get to protect more land, which I think many of us support.
- davidw 9y ago> there are simply too many people and not enough space for them all to live in the nice places. Tokyo added more housing than the entire state of California: https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-costs-tokyo https://www.vox.com/2016/8/8/12390048/san-francisco-housing-... And as someone who lived in Europe for a while, I think we've had the technology to house a fair number of people in desirable area for several hundred years. It's the political will that's lacking.
- dv_dt 9y agoJapan also has somewhat adverse housing regulations that waste a lot of construction. They are likely kept in place to stimulate economic activity - but it's not a particularly friendly environment for home ownership or environmental concerns. https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/disposable-homes-japan-environment-lifespan-sustainability https://www.theguardian.com/sustainable-business/disposable-...
- Feniks 9y agoAmericans think government is evil and all that. So there's no government rescue plan to build more housing because that's commie talk. So everyone's waiting for the market to fix it.
- davidw 9y agoThe market would absolutely produce more housing in a lot of places were there not a ton of regulations in place to stop it from doing so. And I don't write that as a fingers-in-ears, market-will-solve-all-problems libertarian, but as a fairly left-wing guy.
- JBlue42 9y agoThere has to be an incentive for real estate developers. There's a project at my former company that will redevelop a part of downtown SF. There was a massive back and forth and iterations that had to be done because the numbers guy at the real estate development company wanted to cut out all residential since commercial would be more profitable. Those are the people you have to incentivize to make it work.
- deepsun 9y agoIf you drive 30 minutes any direction from San Francisco, you will see plenty of vast empty fields covered with wild grasses. I don't argue that we should cover all the land available with houses, I like wild grass, but I just point out that if we really hadn't enough space -- we would have settled it already. I've never heard the now popular "Earth is overpopulated" rant from anyone who lives outside major metro. Going by train in Russia or Japan (yes, Japan) and watching empty fertile lands for hours is a really useful educational experience. Also, 1. Americans love to live in private houses. And that takes up way more space, and energy to maintain than condos/flats. Yes, some people in other countries just cannot afford private house, but I've noticed often they just feel anything bad about living in a condo. 2. Americans like their cars. And parking/highways take a lot of space, obviously.
- lisper 9y ago> I like wild grass And that is the problem. You're not the only one. Yes, if we turned the San Francisco Bay area into a clone of Manhattan or Hong Kong or Tokyo we could accommodate a lot more people. But a lot of people would not consider that a good outcome. People who like that kind of lifestyle can have it in any of the dozens of dense cities on the planet. The SFBay area is desirable precisely because it is not (yet) dense. People move here because they like yards and redwood trees and vineyards and hiking trails. Manifestly there are more people who want these things than there is space to accommodate all of them. That is the problem.
- pnathan 9y ago> People move here because they like yards and redwood trees and vineyards and hiking trail no, they want jobs. you can get outdoors anywhere in the US, but only a few places in the US actually have a super vibrant economy. and NOTHING precludes turning SF into a stack of 120-story high-density towers apartments for all family types and leaving the redwoods and grassy fields alone. nothing but the unwillingness to go density, thus ensuring the grassy fields will slowly be turned into cookie cutter suburbs
- 9y ago
- baus 9y agoWe've created our own problems with low density zoning which makes it difficult to scale out housing in geographically constrained areas with strong economic growth like the Bay Area and Seattle. There have been many threads recently which blame Amazon and other tech companies for creating Seattle's problems, yet other communities all over the US and beyond are clamoring for the exact same problem. Seattle has gone a long way to accommodate the growth, but it still isn't enough. Too much of the city is zoned for single family residences. And the Bay Area suffers from the same issues.