8 ms·
US Preparing to Put Nuclear Bombers Back on 24-Hour Alert
- theyregreat 9y agoGeneral "Buck" Turgidson: Doctor, you mentioned the ratio of ten women to each man. Now, wouldn't that necessitate the abandonment of the so-called monogamous sexual relationship, I mean, as far as men were concerned? Dr. Strangelove: Regrettably, yes. But it is, you know, a sacrifice required for the future of the human race. I hasten to add that since each man will be required to do prodigious... service along these lines, the women will have to be selected for their sexual characteristics which will have to be of a highly stimulating nature. Ambassador de Sadesky: I must confess, you have an astonishingly good idea there, Doctor. Of course, what a waste of money (eg ICBMs and SLBMs are superior in every respect) and unnecessary escalation of risk.
- microcolonel 9y agoIt's a waste of money if you and your allies aren't under constant, repeated threat.
- mikeash 9y agoEven if you are under threat, what purpose is served in the modern age by putting bombers on alert? The war would be over before they reached an interesting target.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoAs I am sure you are aware, there is quite a bit of solid policy discussion on the various nuclear engagement scenarios. For this particular question the idea that if you can respond after a pre-emptive first strike then your enemy will have killed themselves by killing you. Since self preservation is a common thing, the ability to respond post initial strike is essential.
- mikeash 9y agoMissiles do that job just fine.
- techdragon 9y ago... Unless the silos are attacked by Submarine launched ballistic missiles using depressed trajectories as part of a neutralising/decapitation first strike. See it's the complicated, many possible options, nature of war planning that makes stuff like this much less black and white.
- mikeash 9y agoBombers could be attacked the same way, and take longer to launch and take less to destroy, so are even more vulnerable. The threat of a sudden first strike that destroys our weapons on the ground is why we have ballistic missile submarines.
- eesmith 9y agoWhose submarines are you thinking of that could destroy all of the US ground-based missile launch facilities in a first strike? The war planning based around what you describe assumed the Soviet submarine fleet, yes? Are you worried about Russia, China ("the Type 094s noisiness would make it difficult for it to reach and maintain patrol areas where it could strike at the contiguous United States"), or India?
- bactrian 9y agoThe US can probably see the position of every sub on the planet using magnetic imaging.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoSeriously, I really do think it is instructive to read the literature on this. Missiles in silos are counter balanced by a premptive strike on the silos, mobile missiles (like the MX) are pre-emptible as well but need more warheads, subs are a good counter threat but are tracked by other subs, and nuclear depth charges are able to clear lots of ocean fairly quickly, bombers with cruise missiles are countered with aircraft. In all cases there are costs and visibility challenges like you have to open your silo doors before you shoot missiles and over the arctic missiles take 30 minutes to arrive. Bombers in the air can see fighters who might be tailing them but they cant be countered by ground based missiles easily, it literally goes on and on. Measure, counter-measure. Signal, counter signal. Threat, defensive capability. Literally end of the world as we know it kind of stuff so a lot of time and effort has been invested in understanding it.
- carlisle_ 9y agoSome would argue a threat worsened by provocative and unilateral actions, but we'll see who writes the history books.
- microcolonel 9y agoUnilateral actions such as capturing military vessels, ignoring international agreements, making credible mortal threats to billions of people, and launching ICBMs over other nations? DPRK has already engaged in acts of war against both ROK and Japan. There's nothing unilateral left.
- trgv 9y agoI don't think the threats are credible. I don't see what NK would gain from "nuking Guam," besides the end of their country. It's just posturing, and "putting Nuclear Bombers on 24-hour alert" is also just posturing.
- microcolonel 9y agoThe threats are credible in that they would have no qualms about executing them, not in that they will fail to be averted. > It's just posturing, and "putting Nuclear Bombers on 24-hour alert" is also just posturing. That's exactly my point: there's nothing one-sided about this. DPRK is playing their hand, the U.S. must play theirs.
- Bendingo 9y ago> the U.S. must play theirs Or, as the far stronger side, the US could de-escalate. Not only is this the less-risky option, but it would also garner global respect/admiration for the US - something that has been in short supply for a long time.
- microcolonel 9y agoHow do you suggest they de-escalate (without the use of military posturing) a situation where DPRK threatens the very existence of two of our greatest allies, perpetually? I'm sure you realize that if DPRK is left to their own devices, they will develop a sufficient deterrent to simply saunter into ROK, and face no foreign intervention.
- Overtonwindow 9y ago"General "Buck" Turgidson: Mr. President, we must not allow a mineshaft gap!" Astonishingly good movie.
- Animats 9y agoWell, when the enemy posts a target chart with your air base on it, you do that.[1] [1] https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/world/north-korea-launch https://www.washingtonpost.com/graphics/2017/world/north-kor...
- thethirdone 9y agoThe 3d-ish animation in that article is atrocious. I fails to provide any meaningful insight other than the raw heights, the trajectories are not actual trajectories (they aren't elliptical and that includes the ISS), and the scale is way off.
- cyberferret 9y ago> “I look at it more as not planning for any specific event, but more for the reality of the global situation we find ourselves in and how we ensure we’re prepared going forward.” The global situation that 'we find ourselves in', or the global situation that we have actually created?
- ghettoCoder 9y agoNot sure what you're alluding to since they're one and the same. This situation's been building for well over a decade. Bush talked tough but did nothing when he was in Office, Obama chose to pull a Chamberlain (same with Iran) and now Trump is swinging the pendulum the other way. Hopefully he doesn't swing too far too fast. It's like watching a slow motion train wreck, kind of satisfying but damn is it terrifying.
- Gustomaximus 9y ago"Air Force’s top officer and a member of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, is asking his force to think about new ways that nuclear weapons could be used for deterrence, or even combat" That last line about using nukes for combat is scary. Every country should take a stance they wont be first to fire. It reduces the likelyhood of actually having to use them. Once US is talking pre-emptive tactical strikes now Russia and China are much more likely to gear up for the same and sit there guessing if they should launch first next time tensions increase. We really need to cage these war hawks that get into power. My jaw hit the ground at the stupidity of that statement. They just made the world and their country a significantly more dangerous place. Thats far from defending their nation.
- pmoriarty 9y ago"Every country should take a stance they wont be first to fire. It reduces the likelyhood of actually having to use them." What makes you think they want to reduce the likelihood of actually having to use them? It's like another part of the article: "One painting -- a symbol of the Cold War -- depicts a silhouette of a B-52 with the words 'Peace The Old Fashioned Way,' written underneath." There's a gigantic military-industrial complex that is built around the virtually unquestioned assumption that military force is an excellent solution to many of the world's problems -- and that often such force is best used "preemptively". Many if not most politicians in power around the world share these assumption, as does much of the general population. There have been multiple very serious pushes towards preemptively initiating nuclear war throughout history, and certainly no shortage of preemptive conventional conflict. I am continually astonished that the world hasn't already ended in a nuclear conflagration by now.
- dsfyu404ed 9y agoMeh. This is is just extra training for the ground crews with a layer of political posturing on top.
- DrScump 9y agoA lot of commenters seem to interpret this status as keeping bombers armed and airborne 24/7 (DEFCON 3 or higher) as opposed to heightened readiness on the ground.
- Analemma_ 9y agoSure is a good thing we didn’t elect that warmonger Hillary Clinton.
- enougalready 9y agoOh shut. The fuck. Up. I’m absolutely sick of hearing this line. It has been almost a YEAR since our asshole-in-chief was elected. Nobody’s happy about it except the sycophants he shits on, and CEOs, but it’s the situation in which we find ourselves. It’s such a thought-terminating cliché and, frankly, intellectually lazy. Hillary lost. The democrats lost. They had a chance to take advantage of left-wing populism and failed, and they continue to fail... spectacularly! Now either start organizing politically or continue to sit at home making one-off pithy comments on Hacker News.
- King-Aaron 9y agoA good percentage of us living outside of the US think the same as the post above, to be honest.
- holydude 9y agoThose who never lived under the boots of the Soviet Union are forever doomed to scream about "peace" and "USA warmongering"
- cameldrv 9y agoThis isn't posturing, this isn't Trump bullshit, and it isn't about NK. It's about Russia. This situation has been poorly reported, and I don't think many people without a security clearance understand what's been happening in the past few years. The threat is a Russian decapitation strike. Non-alert bombers are trivially easy to destroy. The ICBM fleet now depends on 40 launch control centers, or one of a few special aircraft in order to be able to launch. These aircraft, prior to 1991, were on continuous airborne alert. There are now three of them on ground alert, with (my guess) 15-30 minute response time. These aircraft are also the primary communications mechanism with the missile subs. The subs are also capable of raising a communications buoy and communicating via satellite, but this is not normal operating procedure, and there are only about five satellites that they can use. The Russians have a number of new weapons systems, some public, some not. They appear to have a maneuvering reentry vehicle that could allow depressed trajectories, which means sub-10 minute warning times. This is not enough time for the President to be located, make a decision, transmit it to the silos, and have the missiles away. There are also several new Russian anti-satellite weapons, including one that appears to be in geosynchronous orbit, which could knock out the communications satellites to talk to the subs. With a communications blackout, there would potentially be time to destroy the subs before they could launch. Having bombers on alert is not a real solution to this problem, but it's better than nothing. Potentially, the bombers could be ordered to launch at the first warning, and might make it away from the airfield in time. They could start flying to targets immediately, but wouldn't have to strike if it were a false warning. The better solution would be to put the special planes (the E-6Bs) back on continuous airborne alert, but according to what the generals said at some congressional hearings back in March, the problem is that the E-6Bs are too old, and there aren't enough of them to be able to maintain airborne alert. Unfortunately we don't even have a budgeted program to design a replacement, and the airframe they're based on is obsolete.
- matt4077 9y agoI notice you're getting a bit handwavy when it gets to Russia destroying all US (British/French/...) submarines before they notice that their headquarters no longer exist. Also, you may have missed the cold war ending. Despite all that's going on, there really is no argument why Russia would prefer post-armageddon hellscape to the SQ.