8 ms·
My experience has been less than stellar. Busses coming 20 minutes late or not at all. 545 at 6 pm on a weekday is so over packed I feel like I’m going to secon
by adamnemecek 9y ago
My experience has been less than stellar. Busses coming 20 minutes late or not at all. 545 at 6 pm on a weekday is so over packed I feel like I’m going to second base with half of the bus.
Seattle should look to a city like Vienna or Prague. The transportation systems are surprisingly well engineered but that might be due to the fact that a larger part of the population takes it.
- mulmen 9y agoI'm not a transit engineer but I think this is because we are asking buses to do too much. When a route sends a bendy bus every 10 minutes it's no longer a bus route and is now a really expensive train. The Rapid Rides are packed at rush hour as well. What we need is something like light rail that can go between neighborhoods and then let buses move people within those areas.
- taeric 9y agoThere are a multitude of answers. All require space. And building any of them will spike the problem for a time. That said, I think we are getting there. I'm somewhat confident that the current problems are the spike.
- mulmen 9y agoAgreed, I just wish the light rail expansions weren't going to take 20 years. We need those lines yesterday.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe Eastside Rail Corridor, from Renton to Bothell, has existed for more than 50 years. It even still has tracks on it.
- VintageCool 9y agoI find it infuriating that Renton asked for nothing in the ST3 bill, and Kirkland was swayed by a small group of activists into asking SoundTransit not to use the Cross Kirkland Corridor.
- samsolomon 9y agoAre several of those extended buses really more expensive than light rail? There's a lot of upfront cost for light rail and if demand changes, routes are pretty inflexible.
- mulmen 9y agoEvery bus needs a driver and a vehicle with yet another powertrain. I'm not sure what energy consumption is like on a train but I suspect operating costs of all the buses is higher than a train that can cover longer distances. It seems to me a mix is the best solution.
- bjelkeman-again 9y agoI read somewhere that the real benefit of trams or light rail tend to come from the fact that they often come with a redesign of the traffic flows, right of way etc. Whilst busses are often stuck in the old traffic jam.
- dangjc 9y agoBus rapid transit is a great compromise. They have special right of ways with dedicated signaling and lanes. But no need to lay rail so costs are much lower.
- kuschku 9y agoShort-term, that is correct. But long-term the maintenance is significantly higher, as you need to replace the road surface very frequently. A usual bus stop, or a BRT lane, has to be replaced every 6 months if it’s asphalt, and every 18 to 24 months if it’s cobblestone. That’s a significant expense. While you can build and use light rail for decades.
- koenigdavidmj 9y agoWe're getting there. Slowly. The 545, the route he mentioned, is the downtown-Seattle-to-Microsoft bus, next in line to be replaced with light rail.
- mulmen 9y agoThat's a very long route for a bus to serve. Light rail makes the most sense there. What is the ETA on the eastside expansion though?
- koenigdavidmj 9y ago2023: https://www.soundtransit.org/eastlink https://www.soundtransit.org/eastlink
- WalterBright 9y agoThat's really sad since the tracks already exist on the Eastside (it's the "Eastside Rail Corridor") which Sound Transit is bound and determined to pretend does not exist.
- techsupporter 9y ago> which Sound Transit is bound and determined to pretend does not exist I think you mean "which Kirkland is bound and determined to ensure never carries trains ever again." There's a reason why "South Kirkland Station" is actually in Bellevue and the Kirkland City Council is it.
- com2kid 9y agoYet all the candidates for Kirkland City Council talk about their dedication to transit. They never specify what type of transit. Amazing that.
- WalterBright 9y agoThe line extends from Renton to Bothell. Kirkland is only part of it. In all the articles in the Seattle Times about light rail, the Sound Transit public relations materials, etc., the Eastside Rail Corridor is never, ever, mentioned. How is it that Kirkland has managed a conspiracy of silence about it?
- Buttes 9y ago"Expensive trains" seem in style, for whatever reason. There are routes that run buses every 4 minutes here. There are other routes that run every 10m, with electric buses on caternary wires. I'll take a good bus line over a non-existent rail line any day. I love trains but if bus lanes and BRT infra are politically expedient, good enough for me.
- yasth 9y agoBecause a bus lane is actually a really cheap train. Construction costs are minimal, your "stations" are generally unmanned, and cheap, and if you need to reroute for construction it generally is much less a big deal. There is basically no point at which subway tracks are cheaper than BRT. The big issue with the Cheap Trains of busses is the lack of commitment that is otherwise nice for transit authorities is not an advantage for real estate. BRT just doesn't indicate commitment to the route enough to really boost property. This is why even though tram lines are basically just busses that can't get out of the way they have a much more marked effect on real estate and neighborhood development.
- mulmen 9y agoBut you have to run a lot more buses to move the same number of people. What is the cost per passenger mile on a bus vs a train?
- StudentStuff 9y agoTrains are going to beat buses on cost per passenger mile on any decently trafficked route, generally to the point of covering their own operating costs.
- icebraining 9y agoHow much does the road repair cost, compared to the tracks? My perception is that tracks last decades with minimal maintenance. The manned stations are not a distinct factor, by the way. Tram stations are usually not manned either.
- exadeci 9y agoThe sad truth is that many cities around the world had light rail 50 years ago, they removed them saying that buses were much flexible and better and now they are bringing them back.
- mulmen 9y agoDid they have light rail or did they have trolleys/street cars? Light rail carries significantly more people and is separated from the road.
- flukus 9y agoIn places that kept them trolleys/street cars slowly morphed into light rail, some is separated from the road but much of it is still shared. The distinction isn't so cut and dry.
- taeric 9y agoI think the road work has been the main offender. A single lane road due to construction is just as bad for the bus as for anything else. That said, crowded is as much a by product of the crowd. Easiest way to avoid that is to adjust your times.
- stephengillie 9y agoST 510 (Seattle - MLT - Everett, to reach Premera in MLT) was routinely 30+ minutes late, because buses would get stuck in traffic each way. So the common "2 buses at once" would occur. Or sometimes the 1st would be over-stuffed and the 2nd would be 5 minutes behind and almost empty. MT 550 running 6 buses an hour felt the same in 2016 - packed in like a mosh pit during rush hour. That's when I gave in and bought a truck, and dealt with parking 6 blocks away instead of hiking 9 blocks down Cherry (and past the perpetual tent city) to the tunnel.
- news_to_me 9y agoYou do realize that by driving, you're making the problem worse? The real solution is to just get more cars off the road. There are few excuses to be driving alone in a city.
- madeofpalk 9y agoI don't drive, but its hard to argue against the convenience of actually getting where you need to go in a reliably manner.
- wink 9y agoMost people who do this (taking the car) realize that (if we all take the bus, it would be a pretty smooth ride) - but first of all not all people CAN take the bus (mostly those coming from further away) and second, I can't fault them. If your commute is like 30mins by bus and 15mins by car... easy choice for ~22 days per month
- erik_seaberg 9y agoA 30 minute bus commute sounds very optimistic. BART is the only system that has ever made me confident I won't waste 30 minutes before even being picked up.
- jschwartzi 9y agoI wish this weren't the case, but I don't take the bus because it triples my commute. A trip that takes 25 minutes by car takes an hour and fifteen by bus for me. I test it every time I need to have my truck repaired. It's because it's a reverse commute, and so while everyone is trying to get into the city I'm trying to get out. The bus would be pretty good if I lived south of Northgate and worked in the city.
- Eridrus 9y agoI lived in Seattle in 2011/2012; the bus was so bad that I bought my first car. So maybe it was worse before, but I did not find it a very good way to get around.
- somethingsimple 9y ago> Seattle should look to a city like Vienna +1 on this. The Vienna transit system is so fantastic that I was able to get around the entire city without even speaking German. I remember one day I was riding the U-Bahn with a local friend and asked him what it was like during rush hour. He said, "this is rush hour". There was still plenty of space for people in all wagons. Simply amazing.
- stephengillie 9y agoSeattle feels like numerous tangentially-connected villages, mostly based on how it was formed: - Downtown's financial district and retail core, with the jail, hospitals, churches, and other services (like the methodone clinic and drunk tank) on First Hill. - Capitol Hill's "crazy night life". - Queen Anne Hill with normal-ish people. - Magnolia's rich separation. - Ballard the Scandinavian fishing village. - Fremont and Wallingford - the artist and hippie communes, the University District, and Ravenna. - The International District and The Jungle. - Beacon Hill and Rainier Beach, where the action happens day or night. - SoDo (Southern Downtown)'s industrial core. - Lake City feels like the "northern SODO". - West Seattle feeling closer to Seatac than Seattle.
- uiri 9y agoWhere I'm from (Toronto), we have a name for these different areas within a city: neighborhoods.
- stephengillie 9y agoA few of Seattle's neighborhoods seem to flow together, such as Wallingford and Ravenna being so overrrun with students that they feel like extensions of the University District. Others, like West Seattle, feel more like the small cities of White Center and Seatac that neighbor it.
- tomjakubowski 9y agoThat’s actually the ideal situation for a mass transit system. It ensures that passengers aren’t largely going in one direction in the morning, and in the opposite in the evening.
- Twirrim 9y agoThere's just no way to efficiently ship that many people on that route virtually simultaneously. So many people finish work around the same times that you get this massive spike of people on the hour, and then it's dead quiet once that on-hour spike has been fulfilled. You don't want to be trying to get on the 545 at 5pm or 6pm. Shift your leaving time so you're at the bus stop 10-15 minutes earlier and it's a whole other story. Although I no longer do the 545 any more, for that, and for my current route I switched to arriving early in the office and leaving 4:30ish. I'm almost always guaranteed to get a seat and have less rush hour traffic slowing down my return home. One thing that the city could do to help, and has helped elsewhere, is to encourage city businesses to shift their starting and finishing hours, especially those businesses that are a bit more regimented. This spreads out the peak over a bigger period of time and allows both more overall flow and less disruption.
- Buttes 9y agoForgot Vianna, the buses in Boston aren't great but 20m late is exceptional here.