4 ms·
Assuming there's a group of people who more or less agree to be separate from some larger group, it's hard to think of legitimate reasons why they shouldn't be
by lordnacho 9y ago
Assuming there's a group of people who more or less agree to be separate from some larger group, it's hard to think of legitimate reasons why they shouldn't be allowed to secede. Their forefathers having signed an agreement is hardly a convincing reason to hold them in a union they no longer like. Neither are issues of the current political situation ("it would destabilize the region...").
There's still hard questions, though. How do we split the national debt? What about various government assets? Who has a choice about what nation to join? And so on.
All hard questions, but none of them seems to undermine the idea that people should be allowed to decide to be separate.
- notspanishflu 9y agoInterestingly enough the same arguments secessionists state for breaking with Spain, they expressly forbid such thing inside Catalonia. V.g. Barcelona can't propose a secession from Catalonia.
- njarboe 9y ago"The people" includes a lot of people who don't want to separate. If 99% want it I would say OK, maybe. Where does one draw the line? Take a look at how the separation of India and Pakistan went if you want to get an idea of how it might go.
- syshum 9y agoHow far do to you extend that? because I highly doubt you can find a single government action, law, policy, or anything where 99% of people agree So then you find that all government is illegitimate? or is your 99% requirement only valid for separation?
- njarboe 9y agoSeparation into a new country is a huge deal. Such a big deal that I don't think any country has a legal mechanism for part of the country to leave. If set up ahead of time maybe 75% or 80% of all eligible voters, would be a good level.
- sbmassey 9y agoCzechia and Slokavia would seem an apter comparison.
- njarboe 9y agoTrue, but a bit more complicated for Spain.