15 ms·
Google and the Resurgence of Italian Design
- marban 9y agoAnd what is so special about this? Companies like Teenage Engineering have been doing this for years and same could be argued for dirt-cheap headphones from Urban Outfitters. For a company like Google, I'd rather expect them to develop their very own stringent signature style after years of visual self-discovery and a hodgepodge of mediocre results.
- cromwellian 9y agoYou mean like how Apple developed their very own stringent signature style after years of visual self-discovery and a hodgepodge of mediocre results called Braun?
- marban 9y agoYes, timelessly the same since 1976. Good artists borrow, great artists steal as we know.
- tzahola 9y agoUrban Outfitters never made headphones. You’re probably referring to the Swedish company called UrbanEars.
- marban 9y agoI said from, not by. UE is just one example.
- jamesrcole 9y ago> And then, almost every tech product became white, silver, gray, black, flat, square, round, and minimalist. Boring. But there are hints that this is changing. And one of the leaders of this change is, somewhat improbably, Google. It seems consistent with their logo. They've had a colourful, playful identity from the start.
- aloisdg 9y agoWindows Phone promoted colors. Constructor colorfully answered: Nokia Lumia, HTC 8X & 8S, etc. RIP.
- Gudin 9y agoMetro design is too much boxy for me. Sharp edges everywhere.
- amiga-workbench 9y agoIt was a nice answer to the child friendly curves everything else was infatuated with.
- rimher 9y agoAs an Italian this makes me happy and sad at the same time. We had so much talent and so many great ideas, I'm glad that they're still around in the world, it's just a shame we couldn't understand their value and promote them around the world
- LoSboccacc 9y agothe problem here is the lack of financing. most great startups get outgrown by better financed global competition and are left with scraps of the Italian market
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- keithpeter 9y agoMy little Bialetti mokapot makes me smile every morning. There is a family run Italian restaurant with premises in a 1960s shopping block on a corner. They have used the strongly horizontal feel of the space and produced something that is calm, feels spacious (actually quite a lot of covers) and looks great. Scooters are still popular with youth wearing parkas here in the UK. The value is travelling but not perhaps in the way that was hoped for.
- doozy 9y agoYou made me think of Smeg's 50's Style line of appliances. Not only are they, by far, the best looking appliances I've seen, they are also built to last a lifetime. Modern technology, retro design and built like they don't make them anymore, what's not to like?
- jotm 9y agoItalian heavy machinery (agricultural, wood and metal processing, construction) was pretty popular a couple of decades ago, simple and reliable, nowadays it's all Dutch and German. I wonder what happened.
- l33tbro 9y ago> This isn’t a knock against the Braun style — there are many beautiful products that have sprung from that well. A slight nit-pick, but does anyone else shudder a little when people use the adjective of 'beautiful' as an objective description of a particular design?
- kobeya 9y agoI don’t understand. Design can’t be beautiful?
- l33tbro 9y agoDesign can certainly be beautiful. What I was trying to articulate (unsuccessfully, as usual) is people describing things as beautiful in an objective way. Ie, as if certain objects or products are impervious to changing trends and tastes. Particularly in tech these days, it feels like I'm always seeing marketing material around "creating beautiful layouts" or "beautiful products." Just an old man gripe of mine.
- jamesrcole 9y agoDo you think a bird or a flower can be fairly objectively beautiful? I think they can, and I don't see why human design can't be fairly so, too.
- Filligree 9y agoI don't think they can. I do think they can be beautiful to the vast majority of humans looking at them, but that's still subjective; an alien might disagree.
- jamesrcole 9y agoIn terms of that sense of objective, I agree.
- kobeya 9y ago
- nikolay 9y agoApple copied Swiss (or Porsche) Design for MacBooks, Google copied Italian. Everybody "borrows" ideas these days.
- baxtr 9y agoReally, only “these days”? Don’t you think it has always been like this?
- nikolay 9y agoI was being sarcastic. Of course, it's been like this forever, but the bragging we see today is beyond control. Be humble about it, people are not that stupid. I'm especially disgusted by Apple's "the best iPhone ever". Of course, it should be the best by being the latest model! And the over-glorification of Jony Ive is pretty annoying. The reality is that recently Apple is behind the rest, got too big, fat, and lazy, and all design innovation comes from rivals.
- mixedbit 9y agoI wonder if we will finally go back to hardware design principles that prioritizes functionality over look. The Design Of Everyday Things gives examples of great designs: * Rotary dial phones were designed in such a way that when a phone felled on the floor it not only survived, but the ongoing phone-call was not hanged. Today countless users brake their smartphones glasses and yet the mainstream smartphones to do not incorporate any design elements that would make it harder to drop the phone or that would protect the glass from the impact. Such elements would make the designs less minimal, so are discarded. * Cars, a complex machines that can easily hurt others, traditionally have controls designed in such a way that you can enter a car model that is totally new to you and comfortably operate it within minutes. You can operate most controls without a need of looking away from the road. Today, we are ditching this proven design in favor of a single touch screen, because it looks so much more elegant and modern.
- baxtr 9y agoI don’t know. Isn’t that a matter of trade-offs? Sure smartphones used to have a very long battery life and were more robust in the “good old days”, but they had tiny screens and real keyboards. Even though it never broke when I let it slip, I don’t miss my old blackberry. I can so do so much more with my iPhone today that I am ok with it being less sturdy.
- TeMPOraL 9y agoIt's always about trade-offs, the question is what are the sides of those trade-off and whether consumers really care about the things being traded in. For instance, I don't believe that durability and large screens are mutually exclusive. Consider a popular phone accessory that is a rubber case. I've been using one to protect my (then) $800 glass piece, and it's totally fine after many drops. In fact, I don't know of people who use such cases and have problems with screen damages. All because it adds an extra impact-absorbing bevel on each side, including above the screen (so the screen isn't hitting the floor even if the phone falls face-first). What's the problem for manufacturers to add such a padding layer? Everyone is dropping battery replaceability anyway. (Also: rubber cases improve grip, so the phone won't slip out of your hand or your pocket that easily.) I feel it's like there is some influential person in the industry who strongly believes that what the customers really want is to get intimate with their phones, to caress their glass surface - that's why there should be no bevel, and if you can't make it all from glass, then make the rest from aluminium. Well, I for one don't want to get touchy-feely with my phone, I want it to stand a decent chance of not breaking when it hits something.
- MrQuincle 9y agoIn fashion it is about being non-mainstream. Check eg https://fashionista.com/2017/06/ugly-fashion-mainstream-trend https://fashionista.com/2017/06/ugly-fashion-mainstream-tren... on ugly fashion. Within tech there is still not so much "dare". A few exceptions are: + Spider routers: https://www.theverge.com/ces/2017/1/5/14182306/asus-rapture-gt-ac5300-spider-router-bad-design-ces-2017 https://www.theverge.com/ces/2017/1/5/14182306/asus-rapture-... + These "smart" hairbrushes: https://www.theverge.com/2017/1/4/14169564/ces-2017-beauty-tech-smart-hairbrush-makeup https://www.theverge.com/2017/1/4/14169564/ces-2017-beauty-t... + Power outlets: http://www.libbywilkiedesigns.com/2017/09/new-must-electric-gadget.html http://www.libbywilkiedesigns.com/2017/09/new-must-electric-... + Countless wearable thingies: https://iwastesomuchtime.com/95685 https://iwastesomuchtime.com/95685 Maybe you have your own favorite hideous tech thing of last year. Would be fun to see. It says just as much about the time or even more than the top brands that just have to stick to their aesthetic style.
- mrisoli 9y agoThis is because people need variety in fashion items, you can have non-mainstream clothing but still dress normally on other days, tech hardware meanwhile is bought because of functionality first, so (most)people don't have multiple smartphones to match different occasions and settings. Software, OTOH, is also very conservative, this is because familiar design patterns ease users' learning curves(and conversion optimization in the case of commercial websites). However, there are some movements about creating non-mainstream websites such http://brutalistwebsites.com/ http://brutalistwebsites.com/ which I find interesting.
- throwanem 9y agoWhat's brutalist about those? I'd understood that movement to revolve around the aesthetic of the raw material (béton brut, "raw concrete"), which translated to the web would seem to suggest basic HTML and images with minimal to no styling and Javascript. The sites linked on that page seem instead to prefer a "high style" approach that's similar to the mainstream aesthetic in every respect save the look of the result.
- jacobolus 9y ago> The innovative rubber membrane and the “volcano” shape to the keys has been called “the most influential button design ever”, and combined with the eye-popping orange color, makes this a really stunning piece, especially when seen and held in person. These kinds of rubber membrane buttons were popular because they were incredibly cheap. They also suck. (At least, every example I’ve ever tried was functionally terrible compared to real switches; I’ve never tried the Olivetti originals, but I would expect them to also suck.)
- TeMPOraL 9y agoThey didn't disappear, though. You know what's even cheaper and sucks even more? Capacitive surface "buttons". The ones that we now have on everything, including phones.
- jacobolus 9y agoI’m not sure what your point is. If you want to attach an external keypad to your phone, those certainly exist. A touchscreen is a trade-off between shitty button feel vs. profoundly expanded UI flexibility, making it a much more general purpose input device. Touchscreens are not built into phones because they are cheaper than buttons. If you want a phone that does nothing but make phone calls using numerical codes, nice physical buttons are surely better. If you want a “phone” that does 1000 other things, the physical buttons are untenable. I think desktop computers should come with much better physical keyboards (ideally properly hand-shaped instead of stupid rectangular slabs) with nice buttons and many analog inputs (trackballs, sliders, jog wheels, ...), but for a pocket device forget it.
- projektfu 9y agoI think this is a better example of what GP was talking about: https://goo.gl/images/5YLQk3 https://goo.gl/images/5YLQk3 The "buttons" are hard to find and the only feedback is audio. And they can't be reconfigured like a phone screen.
- deleted 9y ago
- TheOtherHobbes 9y agoThere's a subset of Italian Design called Memphis which this seems to be based on. The point of Memphis was to create funky colour combinations in living spaces filled with extravagantly geometric objects, not to decorate utilitarian objects with odd colours because "design". Memphis was a big influence on early-90s graphic design, which - ironically - gives these designs more than a hint of early-Internet "What is this company called Google?" nostalgia. I'm not sure if that's deliberate - and if it is deliberate, I'm really not sure it's a good look to be aiming for in 2017.
- marban 9y agoMemphis is terms of colors, yes — but not really when it comes to the plethora of different shapes within a single design.
- kome 9y ago> There's a subset of Italian Design called Memphis which this seems to be based on. Nope, Olivetti was not related to Memphis. Also, Memphis was later. In the 80s.
- agumonkey 9y agoheh, I came here thinking about Olivetti. Two things about this company: It kinda was the Apple of the bureaucratic era. They had advertisement about how their furniture and machines would make work heaven on earth. All this for a bit of modular desks and drawers. Ok and nice electromechanical calculators. But the marketing speech is exactly the same as today. Buy our stuff so you feel you reached the top of the world of the year <insert any year>. [1] Other thing, Olivetti invented a bunch of things in the days of early calculators, they were HP competitors. I remember the Olivetti living room TV computer and thought how come they missed the computer turn that much and died ? Well they didn't, capitalism pushed them into the grave. The Benedetti family, owner of Olivetti, did some stock acrobatics in the early 80s and failed massively, so they had to trickle down the loss just at the time Olivetti needed financial support to ramp up personal computer research and production. Bye [1] computer chronicles demo of Windows 2 was the same idiocy. Now it can do backgrounds, and custom color so YOU can have YOUR own computer. Just like smartphones. It so much always the same it makes me physically sad. Chasing our own tails ...
- davemp 9y ago> Well they didn't, capitalism pushed them into the grave. The Benedetti family, owner of Olivetti, did some stock acrobatics in the early 80s and failed massively Sounds more like the Benedetti family pushed Olivetti into the grave than capitalism did...
- agumonkey 9y agoWhy not say both ? Also Benedetti was influenced by French Alain Minc in that era. It's part of the whole acquisition game hence my jab at capitalism.
- microcolonel 9y agoWhat on earth does this have to do with capitalism? The reason the Lada Niva is still in manufacture is that there's still motivation/demand and the manufacturer hasn't given up on making them. The reason Olivetti doesn't make Olivetti anymore is that there's near zero motivation/demand, and nobody wants to make the products just out of passion.
- wallflower 9y agoNot to be overlooked is Italy's heritage of graphic design. This comprehensive digital archive project by Nicola-Matteo Munari may waste hours of your time, if you are inclined to visual design. http://www.archiviograficaitaliana.com/ http://www.archiviograficaitaliana.com/
- calinet6 9y agoGreat article, highlighting some great design history. Google's new design also kinda reminds me of trends in the outdoor/sports apparel & footwear industry from about 2-3 years ago. Contrast stitching and zippers, muted tones with bright pastels, resurgence of 1970's bright colors and mountaineering styles. Patagonia's catalog from 2014 would be representative, as would lululemon around that time, and Nike and UnderArmour shoes and casual sport. Tech is putting a new spin on it, but many of the themes are similar. I like it! The diversity and experimentation, with respectful nods to the past and adaptation for current trends is a great thing.
- baybal2 9y agoI don't see much Italinanness in their designs a all
- bluesnowmonkey 9y agoUnfortunately they still design their phones so that it turns off when I grab it. Because I have human hands with opposable thumbs and the power button is right there on the side where you grip it. I wonder what lifeform Nexus phones are actually designed for. Those colorful buttons are real nice though.
- indescions_2017 9y agoI love Material Design language. But never would have made the connection with Italian "Mod" style of the 1960s. For me it's more about bringing tactile sense and physicality back to digital interfaces. Another touch stone of inspiration for me is Mid Century Modern Danish design. Consider this "Valet Chair" by the legendary Hans Wegner. It isn't just that the seat lifts up to form a rack for hanging your trousers. Or that the backing hides a jacket hanger in plain site. It's the final reveal: a mini compartment underneath the seat for "storing ones cufflinks and tie pins" ;) The functionality of the chair is modelled upon the world it aspires to inhabit. It's a design for living. Hans Wegner Designed Mid-Century Valet Chair http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/roadshow/season/18/baton-rouge-la/appraisals/wegner-designed-mid-century-valet-chair--201306A16/ http://www.pbs.org/wgbh/roadshow/season/18/baton-rouge-la/ap...
- trisomy21 9y agoThat’s a great example.
- theoh 9y agoI'm going to chip in with a random example, a sweet though perhaps flawed design for a tactile interface. The structure of it reminds me of a product type (i.e. an algebraic data type). It's a final project by a recent RCA graduate: http://leibal.com/products/indent/ http://leibal.com/products/indent/
- ungzd 9y ago> Central to Olivetti’s philosophy — and also to the designers that it hired — was that technology needed to be humanistic, not domineering Today's Google is very bad at this. Their every product is creepy, cold, dumbed-down and surveilance-based. Maybe they are trying to somewhat fix that by visual aesthetics? Their hardware surely look great, and UIs in Android look good too, but UIs in their web apps look dull and authoritarian. Google Photos is just "we exfiltrate all your photos and use machine learning on them". Its UI is like designed for monkeys. Compare that to Flickr or their old Picasaweb. Few buttons, no functionality except "we get your photos now you can look on them". I have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo). Google+ was so cold and dead and creepy. Modern Youtube is just a stupid TV. Most "account settings" pages look like I'm viewing them on giant phone. They are saying "you don't need desktop computer, just use phone, you need only play and pause buttons". Their design is highly political. It feels more like eastern bloc's high modernism, not like Olivetti.
- icebraining 9y agoI have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo). Select the photos, click on the "more options" button (the three dots), then on Edit Date & Time. There you can change their dates, and even choose between setting a fixed datetime for all or keep the relative time differences between each other.
- agildehaus 9y ago> I have lots of photos dated in future (from old camera which had bad clock) and there's no way to fix it (except to edit date on each photo). You've been able to batch edit timestamps for over a year. https://plus.google.com/+GooglePhotos/posts/3ABHACR7QhA https://plus.google.com/+GooglePhotos/posts/3ABHACR7QhA
- ungzd 9y agoIn order to do this I have to select photos for specific day and there's no way to do it. On my computer these old photos are in directories named with date, one directory per day, but in Google Photos this information is lost, they are entirely random (these photos really have random dates, camera clock was randomizing each time I switched it on). Simple script would solve that but Google Photos has no public API because public APIs are so 2006. There's no way to reupload photos with fixed EXIFs too.
- asimpletune 9y agoI feel like the iPhone 5c followed along similar lines.
- RuggeroAltair 9y agoMight be useful to mention this article, and that maybe Olivetti's care for design also inspired the modern Apple store. http://www.italianways.com/the-olivetti-store-set-to-conquer-fifth-avenue/ http://www.italianways.com/the-olivetti-store-set-to-conquer...
- x09as-d09asd213 9y agoWho is this being marketed to? Do people want funky, colourful "gadgets?" Personally, I've an aversion to anything that looks like it might've been designed with the focus on its appearance rather than its function.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- hypertexthero 9y agoThe Italian peninsula has a way of inspiring people and has done so for a long time. I was living in Italy when I became interested in graphic design, which I then learned from Milton Glaser — who was also inspired by his time in Italy — through his classic book, Graphic Design. Milton is still going strong at almost 90. Here he is, drawing: https://vimeo.com/6986303 https://vimeo.com/6986303 And his essay, Ten Things I Have Learned, has valuable work advice: https://www.miltonglaser.com/milton/c:essays/#3 https://www.miltonglaser.com/milton/c:essays/#3 I think the world would be a better place if big companies making things that change the world like Google and Apple hired more artists.
- sukhadatkeereo 9y agoThanks for the Milton Glaser link, it's beautiful and informative.
- ghostly_s 9y agoNot reading this article but I don't think there's anything to this. Pretty much all the most-lauded product designers have been continuing in this tradition ever since it was born - that it's not ubiquitous is attributable to timid and price-conscious clients. I don't think Google has any internal ideology whatsoever that is pushing this - they're just a company new to the hardware space who has lots of resources and a desire to build brand cachet, and they see hiring respected designers and getting out of their way as an effective way to do that.
- tmnvix 9y agoThis is encouraging. One of my pet peeves of late has been the ubiquity of black, grey, and white colour schemes. Here in NZ and Australia, almost all new apartment buildings are some combination of those colours. It's not just new buildings - people are giving their houses the grey treatment when it comes time to repaint. My own theory is that this has gone hand-in-hand with the shift from seeing houses as homes (and therefore as an extension of personal character) to now seeing houses as investments. No one seems willing to choose a colour scheme with character for fear of limiting the pool of potential buyers. On top of that, new cars seem less likely to be any colour other than black, silver, or white. But maybe that's just my perception...
- daviddumenil 9y agoOlivetti were quite unusual in their corporate patronage of Giovani Pintori. They effectively brought him on as an employee and let him create art that doubled as adverts for their products. Does anyone else know of similar examples where companies supported art beyond the usual exhibition sponsorship and board room art? The image results here give you an idea if how much closer to art than advert they were: https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=giovanni+pintori https://www.google.co.uk/search?q=giovanni+pintori
- wmeredith 9y agoBMW Films is a thing. And they’re quite good: https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hire https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Hire
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jordache 9y agowow the author was really stretching it.. to draw a connection between the two, based on a few isolated examples. I see the google products as a physical extension of the design language they've started with material design.
- raldi 9y agoWhy does the calculator in the photo have two "=" keys, one black and the other white?
- fjsolwmv 9y agoBecause black and white are equal, and are means equal, and equal is symmetric, so equal is black and white!
- DanBC 9y agoDoes this answer? http://www.johnwolff.id.au/calculators/Olivetti/D18/D18.htm http://www.johnwolff.id.au/calculators/Olivetti/D18/D18.htm > Addition and subtraction operate in adding-machine fashion, with numbers being printed as they are entered into the register. C is a correction key which clears the whole of the current entry. The Total (T) key prints the result and clears the register; Sub-total (S) prints the contents and leaves the register unchanged. To encourage the habit of always pressing Total before starting a calculation, the D18 is made to power up with the error lamp lit, so that Total must be pressed before the machine can be used. > Multiplication and division can be entered algebraically using the colour-coded legends printed on the keytops. For example, to multiply 2 by 3, use the white legends and press 2 X 3 =. For operators familiar with the "reverse Polish" entry of the earlier machines, using the moulded legends to the right of the keys will produce the same key sequence and the same result: 2 Enter 3 X . (There is only a single key switch under the Mult/Div/Enter button). the manual doesn't seem to mention it: http://www.curtamania.com/curta/database/brand/olivetti/Olivetti%20Divisumma%2018/more/Olivetti%20Divisumma%2018.pdf http://www.curtamania.com/curta/database/brand/olivetti/Oliv...