7 ms·
Fixing this will have to be the next step. The first step was getting the body cams. Also, you could probably file a suit to get the unredacted video, and you
by cryptonector 9y ago
Fixing this will have to be the next step. The first step was getting the body cams.
Also, you could probably file a suit to get the unredacted video, and you could make a big stink about this. That's how you get to the next step.
- s73ver_ 9y agoI would be shocked if the unredacted video still exists.
- fao_ 9y agoIt would be illegal otherwise, wouldn't it? Redaction of evidence
- djrogers 9y agoYou would have to prove a) that it was evidence of a crime, and b) the police had reason to believe or know it was such. In the absence of laws requiring full transparency and access to body cam footage, the body cams are just likely to be abused.
- katastic 9y ago>You would have to prove a) that it was evidence of a crime, and b) the police had reason to believe or know it was such. Missing audio and a big "redacted" sticker is a pretty damning evidence that "Something" was removed. IF there was nothing to hide, why did they remove it?
- mmalaaksonen 9y agoIn contrast, full transparency of body cam footage could and would compromise ongoing investigations and identities of people in witness protection and so on. So full transparency in private/closed court or redacted versions showing only 'relevant' information in public/open court. Maybe full transparency after the information in the video becomes irrelevant, but micromanaging a hude amount of body cam footage would prove to be quite difficult.
- hedora 9y agoThat doesn’t sound right. My neighbor is accused of a crime, and upon hearing that, I destroy all the evidence that would exonerate them. That doesn’t count as obstruction of justice / destruction of evidence?
- matt4077 9y agoYour neighbour is suspected of brutally murdering their parents in his backyard. One Sunday afternoon, you maw their lawn along with yours because they're really old and it really isn't that much work once you're at it anyway. In the process, you destroy the evidence exonerating them, i. e. footprints of shoes much smaller than theirs. Obstruction of justice? Nope. Now imagine the same thing happened. Except that this time, you include their lawn not just because you always do, but to get them thrown in jail. You're really tired of doing all these chores for them, and it's time for new neighbours. Obstruction of justice? Yep. Intend matters.
- cryptonector 9y agoIt doesn't have to be evidence of a crime. It can be evidence of policy violations.
- Digory 9y agoIn many (most?) US jurisdictions, bodycam video is cloud-hosted by Taser.[0] I don't have direct experience, but I'd bet Taser doesn't let podunk police departments really "erase" video. And given the volume, you'd think it's got to be built on AWS or another big cloud provider, with pretty good forensic tools. [0] https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/13/business/taser-international-dominates-the-police-body-camera-market.html https://www.nytimes.com/2016/07/13/business/taser-internatio...
- krapp 9y ago>I don't have direct experience, but I'd bet Taser doesn't let podunk police departments really "erase" video. The NYTimes article you posted hints at an uncomfortably cozy relationship between Taser, law enforcement and local governments... Yet as Taser works to sell cameras and software to more departments, it is coming under fire for questionable business practices. In some instances, it has paid police chiefs to travel to Taser conferences. In other cases, chiefs who have bought Taser products have joined the company as consultants shortly after leaving public service. And several cities have awarded contracts to Taser without competitive bidding. I wouldn't trust Taser to act as faithful or impartial stewards of this data, when it's in their best business interest to maintain a positive relationship with the very entities whose corruption it exists to expose.
- goialoq 9y agoTaser also operates a legal-defense-aid operation for police officers who use Tasers to break the law.
- throwaway000025 9y agoThe body cams need to serialize their stream to a special satellite or cell provider, and a chain of auditable custody needs to be preserved at multiple data centers. Police cannot be the masters of their own footage. It needs to exist beyond bribery, lust and international intimidation. It needs to be out of their hands and into a web of trust, as soon as the photons hit the sensors. Then it comes down to jamming, tampering, malfunction, sabotage, and any misbehavior that otherwise prevents useful recordings, since we’re talking about wearables that can be covered, discarded and left behind, even if thy can’t be turned off. But if it does get recorded, it needs to get locked up tighter than handcuffs. That video needs to dust off and nuke the site from orbit. It’s the only way to be sure.
- guywhocodes 9y agoI think it would be enough if they encrypted the video contents and stored in blocks out of order, ideally I would also have it streamed but let's be realistic about bandwidth and availability requirements for that. In the end there will always be significant on device storage. Make sure that the people who are responsible for the decryption and delivery of the content have incitement that the result is useful.
- steamer25 9y agoWe just need to establish a legal precept that if the body cam footage isn't there to corroborate the cops' story, we assume the worst and they get held accountable for anything a plaintiff is able to plausibly allege. Under that scenario, most cops would become the biggest advocates for e.g., redundancies, backups and transparency.
- apsec112 9y agoThis seems to abolish the right to be "innocent until proven guilty". It's always possible to allege a crime that no one can prove didn't happen (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Russell%27s_teapot), so without a presumption of innocence, the system essentially puts the accused at the mercy of the accuser.
- craigsmansion 9y ago> Fixing this will have to be the next step. Depends really. Moving to a different country would be my next step personally.
- m_mueller 9y agoYep. Stories like these have made made me decide some time ago that I will never bring my family to the US, no matter the offer.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- corndoge 9y agoBreivik made me decide some time ago that I will never bring my family to Norway, no matter the offer.
- m_mueller 9y agoIf 'Breivik' happened regularly, even just every three years, then I would see your point. A society that produces a Breivik (i.e. some crazy fascist who thinks killing the most children he can is what he should do with his time) every three years must indeed be sick. For these reasons I'm currently also concerned about most European countries. Desth rate statistics don't do justice to the looming threat of a group/tribe/clan/haggle of people who are out to just kill out-group people no matter what. I'm not concerned much about the risk itself, but I am about what it does to civic life.
- corndoge 9y agoNorway's massacre rate is on par with the US when you consider that Norway has 1.62% of the US population.
- m_mueller 9y agoThis whole thread started with me saying that police overstepping their boundaries is one reason I wouldn't move my family to the US. Obviously that doesn't just apply there though. The massacre thing was brought up as a weird counterargument - which I'd file as a typical case of whataboutism. I agree that massacres aren't a good reason against the US, and for that matter one would rather avoid many western European countries atm if at all.
- eeZah7Ux 9y ago> The first step was getting the body cams Nonsense. Cameras will be always used to benefit only the police as long as they control them: it's easy to cherry-pick what to record and, later on, what to release. It's easy to take off a camera altogether. You need 3rd parties (e.g. bystanders) to be able to record what's happening and stream it it safe storage in real time.
- chimeracoder 9y agoNonsense. Cameras will be always used to benefit only the police as long as they control them: it's easy to cherry-pick what to record and, later on, what to release. It's easy to take off a camera altogether. You need 3rd parties (e.g. bystanders) to be able to record what's happening and stream it it safe storage in real time. It's sad that you're being downvoted for saying this, because it's true. As long as police are the only ones legally or practically empowered to film these encounters, they will be the ones empowered to control the narrative. The right of citizens to film police encounters without harassment or threats is imperative.