4 ms·
I keep seeing arguments that Boeing made a mistake in pushing on the tariffs, or that this deal with Airbus is bad for Boeing. They're wrong. In Boeing's ideal
by adventured 9y ago
I keep seeing arguments that Boeing made a mistake in pushing on the tariffs, or that this deal with Airbus is bad for Boeing.
They're wrong. In Boeing's ideal world, they're the only airplane manufacturer in the world. The next best thing, is to only have Airbus as competition. Boeing's interests are served tremendously by keeping the global market as consolidated as possible down to just Boeing and Airbus. They have one main target to focus on when it comes to competition and politics. Airbus eating Bombardier is the next best thing to Bombardier going out of business. Simply put, Boeing would rather Airbus own / control Bombardier, than have Bombardier exist as a successful independent airplane manufacturer.
- UnoriginalGuy 9y agoI get your argument; but one of Boeing's objectives has been to try and keep Airbus out of the US (both defense and commercial). This deal with Delta will showcase, within the US, the CSeries. That could result in other US airlines following suit (particularly smaller regional airlines). Airbus is already fairly successful within the US with regional aircraft sales, this will only further cement that. Plus keep an eye on China's Comac. They're only ten years old (2008) but due to massive state investment are becoming pretty competitive, they may be eating both Boeing and Airbus's lunch by 2030 if this level of investment continues.
- jquery 9y agoIf by state investment you mean the well-tread path of Chinese corporate espionage - http://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20120317/ISSUE01/303179980/china-leans-on-boeing http://www.chicagobusiness.com/article/20120317/ISSUE01/3031... Fortunately for Boeing, a plane is not so easy to copy as many of their other successful corporate thefts.
- kuschku 9y agoYou do realize that the Snowden papers show that Boeing did exactly the same corporate espionage, aided by the NSA steaking data from Airbus and directly giving it to Boeing? The US is just as problematic as China in these things, and has the same levels of subsidies for industries deemed important to national security.
- adventured 9y ago> The US is just as problematic as China in these things, and has the same levels of subsidies for industries deemed important to national security. Let's talk about government subsidies: (July 2015) "China's Global 500 companies are bigger than ever—and mostly state-owned" "the top 12 Chinese companies are all state-owned. They include massive banks and oil companies that the central government controls through the State-Owned Assets Supervision and Administration Commission of the ruling State Council (SASAC), which appoints CEOs and makes decisions on large investments. Of the 98 Chinese companies on the list, only 22 are private." http://fortune.com/2015/07/22/china-global-500-government-owned/ http://fortune.com/2015/07/22/china-global-500-government-ow... Using one example to proclaim that the US is committing as much intellectual theft as China, is comical. The US has dramatically more to lose than China does, given its general technological superiority (whether at the university lab level or the corporate R&D level). The second point is even more absurd, and very easily demonstrated to be false (as I did above). Most of China's largest corporations are State controlled entities. Most of their largest industries, such as steel, are directly controlled by the government. A very large share of the Chinese economy is operated by fully nationalized, or partially nationalized fake corporate entities. So called State corporations.
- kuschku 9y ago> technical superiority And yet the US and China are both equally stealing knowledge from us Europeans. Both just want to fuck you over and steal your secrets, and do it all the time. > Subsidies And yet, the US DoD pumps trillions into the US defense and tech industry, in similar amounts to the chinese subsidies. From the European perspective, both the US and China are states that use espionage and subsidies in similar amounts to prevent fair competition, because their technology is inferior.
- adventured 9y ago> And yet the US and China are both equally stealing knowledge from us Europeans Demonstrate that equality with data if you would. That the US is stealing as much intellectual property from Europe, as China is (or has been, say over the last ~10-15 years). Using one very weak example, derived from tens of billions in annual government DoD spending (in a sector - defense - that is similarly government-private across all other nations as well), is not an off-set to trillions of dollars in China's GDP deriving from state owned or state controlled entities. US military spending on actual hardware / tech, is a small fraction of US military spending. The extreme majority of the DoD's spending is on human soldiers and not on R&D or hardware (salaries, housing, offices, benefits, veterans spending etc). You're comparing trillions of dollars in China, to something closer to $100-$200 billion in the US (which also has an economy 60% larger). You're off by a comparison factor of at least 30 fold. > because their technology is inferior That's a hilarious premise given how far behind Europe's technology industry is in every regard to the US. Europe is increasingly falling behind China's rising technology industry. But hey, let's talk about how exciting SAP is! Over the last 40 years, the US has led Europe on: semiconductor technology, personal computing, mainframe tech, datacenter tech, computer graphics tech including GPU, cloud services, software, Internet, mobile, artificial intelligence, vehicle automation, storage tech, ecommerce, and even biotech and gene tech (including most things related to the human genome, stem cells, immunotherapy and crispr). Europe by contrast has led in very few segments - despite having over twice as many people as the US.
- adventured 9y agoI agree, China will eventually split the global airplane market into a three way race with Boeing and Airbus. I don't think anything can stop that. No doubt Boeing and Airbus know that. As soon as it's possible, use case by use case, China's airlines will switch their purchases to mostly domestic produced airplanes (they won't have a choice for the most part, government edict will dictate that).
- mtgx 9y agoBetter than also someone else (say Lockheed Martin) buying Bombardier, too.
- Tsiklon 9y agoDoes Lockheed Martin have much of a footprint in commercial aircraft, i thought they were a predominantly military focused firm?
- avar 9y agoThey're restarting production of the civilian version of the C-130 Hercules next year, although that's a cargo aircraft and not intended to ferry passengers: http://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/what-we-do/aerospace-defense/aircraft/commercial-aircraft.html http://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/what-we-do/aerospace-defens... They also have a new cargo airship that's shipping in 2018: http://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/products/HybridAirship.html http://www.lockheedmartin.com/us/products/HybridAirship.html
- coredog64 9y agoI posted this in an earlier thread on the topic, but I'll rehash it here. Having Airbus buy this line from Bombardier is actually very good for Boeing. For a long time, one of the major selling points of Airbus twins has been cockpit commonality. They're so close that your pilots can maintain type ratings on several different airframes. That gives airlines labor flexibility. Boeing hasn't had that option. The closest they came was with the 757/767 -- those airframes had the same 41 section. Now that Airbus is going to be selling an aircraft that won't have the same cockpit as the A319/320, Boeing will have a better opening to sell their 737. The airlines are going to need to pay for training on multiple airframes, so why not consider Boeing as well.