4 ms·
First of all, business is about providing value to customers, not jobs to neighborhoods. Sorry if that sounds callous, but really, think about it. We don't want
by DanielBMarkham 16y ago
First of all, business is about providing value to customers, not jobs to neighborhoods. Sorry if that sounds callous, but really, think about it. We don't want a thousand people making a iron boiler for a steam engine anymore. If one guy could push a button at GM and have robots make a thousand cars? Then we are continuing in a pattern that has done us well over the last thousand years.
So instead of looking ass-backward at economics, it might be better to ask yourself the question a million entrepreneurs are now asking: What do all those companies sitting on all that cash want? Because it's not savings either: companies are not in the business of savings.
Perhaps the companies are dumping all the profits to investors. Fine. What do they want? Money got to go somewhere. And whoever's got it wants stuff.
Instead of a sad-sack, belly-button-gazing lament at how GM actually gives Chinese folks jobs, it might be a better use of time to continue to find where value can be added. That's what the smart folks are doing. (And those smart folks are more and more in small businesses and would really appreciate it if you didn't lump them into some big bucket with Ford and GM just so you can slide in your partisan tax barb, Bob)
- raganwald 16y agoI didn't see it as a lament. It read more like a warning not to try to tinker with the economy by investing in business in the hope of creating jobs. One could easily read this article as being pro-Free market. It's just saying "Stop trying to game the free market, that doesn't work."
- dctoedt 16y ago> First of all, business is about providing value to customers, not jobs to neighborhoods. ... We don't want a thousand people making a iron boiler for a steam engine anymore. The value-to-customers part is the truth, but not the whole truth. If a government's economic policies don't result in jobs being provided to neighborhoods, then three things are inexorably going to happen: 1. A non-trivial number of (usually) young men with too much time on their hands will do things that we really wish they wouldn't but that we have a very hard time suppressing, especially when they can use communications technology to their benefit: Street gangs. Drug cartels. Jihadist groups. 2. People will blame their governments because they perceive that Bad Things -- unemployment, drugs, crime, terror -- aren't being fixed; 3. Disruption will result, because people won't passively accept Bad Things indefinitely: (a) In a democratic society, the government will be thrown out and policies will be changed -- possibly not for the better -- and with switching costs in any case; (b) Even in a non-democratic society, there will eventually be unrest as people get mad as hell and refuse to take it any more (cf. the Honda strike in China, but then there's North Korea as an apparent counterexample); I'm a life-long moderate Republican, but it's only been in recent years that I've come to appreciate that, unlike some conservatives, liberals 'get' these fundamental truths of human nature. I wish these truths were otherwise, but to paraphrase Lazarus Long, you don't argue with the weather, you deal with it. (That's one reason I'm encouraged by the favorable reports I've been reading about the educational policies that the Obama Administration is pushing.) ISTM that some liberals have unrealistic views of how we should deal with these truths -- some of them likely would be happy having a thousand people making a boiler -- but that's another debate.
- jbooth 16y agoNot to mention that even without risks of total upheaval, if nobody but the top 1% has any money, who are you going to sell goods to?
- SkyMarshal 16y agoUpvoted for non-dogmatic thoughtfulness. Apologies if that sounds politically bigoted, but so much of what I hear coming the GoP these days is devoid of that quality. I hope you run for office some day. I think this issue is only part of a larger group of related problems that seemed to start metastasizing 30 years ago. In a nutshell: scientific management -> manufacturing process and profit margin optimization -> manufacturing outsourcing to low-cost countries -> decreased product costs + planned obsolescence -> increased volumes -> increased profits -> rising pay for management -> decreasing skilled labor 'making things' jobs -> wealth of the country (and the world) becomes more and more concentrated into the hands of a small demographic -> corporate personhood granted by Supreme Court (not sure exactly where on the timeline this goes, but it's part of the story) -> significantly more political influence for a smaller group of people at the top of pyramid -> Democrats join Republicans in courting this small, wealthy, influential demographic -> financial deregulation driven by that demographic, either financiers looking for more ways to increase returns, or m/billionaire management looking for better returns for their un-FDIC-insurable cash piles -> Less than 10 years after the last protections of the Great Depression era dismantled (Graham-Leach-Bliley '99), we have a similar-in-nature debt-driven financial crisis -> This time the small wealthy demographic that caused it has the power to 1) avoid punishment for it (for example, compared to the 1980 S&L crisis that saw thousands jailed), 2) transfer all the losses to the US Government -> The final result of which could be any/all of 1) monetary inflation and defacto dollar devaluation, 2) further debt deflation, 3) rising interest rates on baseline Treasuries leading to rising interest rates across the board and decreased corporate investment (and hiring), all of which will hurt the fading middle class more the wealth owners. This is just a cursory summation of observations of correlated events that I suspect are more than just correlated. It's still taking shape in my mind, and I'm sure someone could write a PhD dissertation on how all it all fits together, I just don't have time for this atm. But I do wish our politicians/media/pundits/economic book authors/people like Robert Reich/etc would look more at this big picture of how and why we got to this situation we're in, and how it might be possible to reverse it. Increasing concentration of wealth is a major problem, as you point out. It has been a cause of not only social unrest, but even revolutions. Definitely not a road a country wants to find itself on.
- api 16y agoBut what if they don't actually want anything? What if demand is actually being satiated, and all those dollars are just worthless fiat paper that doesn't actually mean anything? http://www.theoildrum.com/node/5309 http://www.theoildrum.com/node/5309 That article talks about some more complex ideas related to demand limits to growth, but there's also a really obvious demand limit to growth: humans have fewer children when they get wealthy... often to the point of dropping below replacement level. Nothing limits demand like demographic collapse. Economics, being a "science" that does not believe in thermodynamics, believes both potential supply and potential demand to be infinite. In reality in a finite world both must be finite.
- ShabbyDoo 16y ago>But what if they don't actually want anything? Impossible. If the businesses don't want anything, as another poster noted, they'll distribute earnings to shareholders. Surely, those shareholders, even if they want for nothing physical, don't want to die. Therefore, they would like better healthcare innovations. Do they really want like all the fiddling required just to watch internet-based video on their home theater systems? Do they like running errands? There's plenty of room for innovation and the sales that will come with it.
- jbooth 16y ago83% of US stocks are in the hands of the richest 1% http://www.businessinsider.com/22-statistics-that-prove-the-middle-class-is-being-systematically-wiped-out-of-existence-in-america-2010-7#83-percent-of-all-us-stocks-are-in-the-hands-of-1-percent-of-the-people-1 http://www.businessinsider.com/22-statistics-that-prove-the-... So what do the remaining 99% do, if they can't get a job and they're not holding the stock that pays out the benefits? Not to mention "distribute earnings to shareholders" sounds a lot nicer than "pay myself as CEO and owner of a bajillion options".
- tomjen3 16y agoStart their own business, obviously. Then they can get shares in that.