3 ms·
We need to leave behind eye witness testimony. It has been shown time and again to be misleading and often completely false. The worst part is that the eye witn
by matwood 9y ago
We need to leave behind eye witness testimony. It has been shown time and again to be misleading and often completely false. The worst part is that the eye witness is usually not lying on purpose, but genuinely trying to help.
Think about everything you did yesterday, now put near exact times on it. It's very hard to do, and if someone pushed or suggested you in either direction 1 hour here or there you would likely go along with it. Now go out to last week or last month. Unless something extraordinary happened on the day in question most people do not have the ability to remember the time or even day. It's just not how memory works.
EDIT
And don't even get me started on jailhouse 'witnesses'. The prosecutor says if current criminal can get person arrested and sitting in jail to talk, current criminal gets a reduced sentence. I'm sure that's completely reliable testimony /s, yet it is pushed and used all the time.
I am of the very strong opinion that it is better to let 10 criminals go rather than putting 1 innocent person in jail. IMO, putting innocent people in jail damages society much more than letting criminals with little evidence of the crime walk.
- fjsolwmv 9y agoWhen something extraordinary happens, people tend to have vivid memories that are false or even impossible. What were you doing when the Challenger exploded?
- matwood 9y agoExactly. Even when something extraordinary events occur people are bad at remembering. Eye witness testimony should be barely passable as evidence, yet it is given huge weight in a courtroom.
- speedplane 9y agoA single eyewitness is rarely sufficient to convict, you would at least need some circumstantial evidence as well (e.g., a weapon, a motive, that defendant was in the area, etc.)
- logfromblammo 9y agoI was reading that part in Surely You're Joking, Mr. Feynman where he's participating in a panel investigating the Challenger explosion, and sticks the model o-rings in the ice water. Quite impossible, obviously. But I can't remember a single detail of what I was really doing. Probably ignoring the television with my nose in some fantasy novel, based purely on statistics. Kimmel's late night television show does "lie-witness news", which effectively demonstrates that ordinary people will say pretty much anything if you prompt and cue them towards what you want to hear.
- cr0sh 9y ago> What were you doing when the Challenger exploded? Walking from one class to another, while I was in the 8th grade. I was likely walking from my English class, but I don't recall what class I was walking to. I was told by a friend of mine who had just gotten out of his science class. We both participated at the time in the "Young Astronauts Program" as an afterschool thing, taught by our science teacher. I was walking past the PE locker / gym building, in a grassy area. For all I know, though, this was so long ago that I could be completely wrong, so I don't really trust that memory too much; that's just how I remember it.
- speedplane 9y ago> We need to leave behind eye witness testimony. I do not think there is anything wrong using it, as long as it is explained to a jury that the accuracy of eyewitness testimony is suspect. Similar to how they are told that DNA evidence is ~99.999% accurate, they should be told that eyewitness testimony can often be incorrect (I wouldn't provide a number value though).