3 ms·
Isn't that contempt? Those watching over the lawyers should follow-up, demand the evidence and, if it's not presented, strike-off (and present for prosecution)
by pbhjpbhj 9y ago
Isn't that contempt? Those watching over the lawyers should follow-up, demand the evidence and, if it's not presented, strike-off (and present for prosecution) the lawyer in question and any party who was involved in the deceit ... surely that's a basic and obvious protection.
A lawyer lying in court should be risking their own livelihood at least, with prison as a certainty for attempting to manipulate the court to imprison someone through deceit.
It's probably already part of the system, right?
- watwut 9y agoLawyer lying in court might be in trouble, but it is ok for prosecution to lie during negotiation or interrogation.
- speedplane 9y agoNo, it's definitely not. Any lawyer who lies can be disbarred. It's something that every lawyer learns to not do first day of law school... that said, you also learn lots of ways of not saying anything, but implying quite a bit... e.g., you wouldn't say "we found the weapon" when you really didn't, but you could say "we're gonna get the weapon".
- michaelchisari 9y agoI don't know the law enough to say one way or the other, but assuming that you're right... If I remember correctly, the defendants had run out of money, the private lawyer they hired was increasingly doing things pro-bono (and losing focus because of it), and they had already disrupted their lives for two years. Each court date required hours of travel for both of them and days off work. They'd get there, only to have the prosecution kick the can down the road and have the court date postponed for another few weeks, in which case they'd have to do it all over again. That they lasted as long as they did is a testament to them, but the system wore even them down. To add a whole new angle of going after the prosecutors for contempt would have increased the stress on their lives and resources by an order of magnitude.