5 ms·
The Great Decoupling of Corporate Profits from Jobs
- gte910h 16y agoThis is one of the issues with overly strong and long IP policies: Humans aren't required to license IP out the wazoo.
- motters 16y agoI think many of the jobs will return, but fewer than before. With each economic cycle the amount of work which can be automated increases. This is a long term trend which began a couple of centuries ago, and eventually I expect it to culminate in campaigns to divorce income from jobs, with the introduction of a "Citizens Income" based upon taxing mostly automated companies (each citizen assigned some percentage of GDP per capita). http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen%27s_dividend http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizen%27s_dividend
- api 16y agoBut then the Morlocks will eat us!
- jtbigwoo 16y agoExcept that much of manufacturing isn't automated--building and maintaining the robots would be too expensive. Instead companies pay third-world workers next to nothing to assemble products by hand. Go and read Bunnie Huang's blog posts about manufacturing the Chumby in China. (bunniestudios.com) The Chumby is assembled almost completely by hand. Even big things like industrial equipment are often welded and assembled by hand. The problem is this: Say a company is going to sell 1,000 of a particular heavy assembly per year and profit $1,000 from each. There's no way they can afford to build and maintain an automated assembly line to support that product. Each individual robot might cost $50,000+. Robots are really only feasible for high-volume, high-profit products, or where one line can make several closely related products (e.g. a tractor plant that makes front loaders and dozers.) I know this doesn't fit with the techno-futurist ethos around here. Maybe in another 50 years robots will be cheap and flexible enough to truly automate manufacturing.
- motters 16y ago"Robots are really only feasible for high-volume, high-profit products" Untrue. Many low profit consumer products are made using robots. Currently human labour can still compete with automation, and companies seek the cheapest labour costs by outsourcing. But there will come a point, which has already been reached in a few niche areas of manufacturing and agriculture, where no human labour, however cheap, can compete against automation in terms of productivity per unit cost.
- benhalllondon 16y agoUmm, quite interesting till the last paragraph: "The reality is this: Big American companies may never rehire large numbers of workers. And they won’t even begin to think about hiring until they know American consumers will buy their products. The problem is, American consumers won’t start buying against until they know they have reliable paychecks." I'm not sure they is any link between hiring US workers and what US consumers are buying. I mean plenty of stuff is made my Chinese workers that is purchased by American consumers. Why couldn't it go back the other way?
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- pchristensen 16y agohttp://econfuture.wordpress.com/2010/07/27/flat-or-declining-revenues-soaring-profits-is-it-sustainable/ http://econfuture.wordpress.com/2010/07/27/flat-or-declining... "When consumers in the U.S. finally fall off the edge of the cliff, where will demand come from? The reflexive answer is always “from consumers China and other emerging economies.” There are a few problems with that: (1) workers in China and other low wage countries don’t make very much and, therefore, have less to spend. (2) Those low wage workers have a very strong propensity to save, rather than consume. (In China the saving rate may be as high as 30%, and consumer spending is only around a third of GDP v. 70% in the U.S.) (3) It would be extraordinarily naive to think that the Chinese government will not manipulate things to insure that the vast majority of sales in China go to Chinese companies (in many cases companies using technology transferred from the West as part of China’s industrial policy.) The fact is that we are very far indeed from a place where consumers in countries like China are going to pick up the slack when consumers in America and the rest of the developed world finally fail to get the job done. And there’s yet another problem: While China has benefited from globalization, it is by no means immune to the impacts of automation. In the long run factories and other business in China will also automate, and unemployment will become a serious problem. In fact, this is already occurring in industries like textiles where automation has been progressing at a rapid rate."
- benhalllondon 16y ago
- DanielBMarkham 16y agoFirst of all, business is about providing value to customers, not jobs to neighborhoods. Sorry if that sounds callous, but really, think about it. We don't want a thousand people making a iron boiler for a steam engine anymore. If one guy could push a button at GM and have robots make a thousand cars? Then we are continuing in a pattern that has done us well over the last thousand years. So instead of looking ass-backward at economics, it might be better to ask yourself the question a million entrepreneurs are now asking: What do all those companies sitting on all that cash want? Because it's not savings either: companies are not in the business of savings. Perhaps the companies are dumping all the profits to investors. Fine. What do they want? Money got to go somewhere. And whoever's got it wants stuff. Instead of a sad-sack, belly-button-gazing lament at how GM actually gives Chinese folks jobs, it might be a better use of time to continue to find where value can be added. That's what the smart folks are doing. (And those smart folks are more and more in small businesses and would really appreciate it if you didn't lump them into some big bucket with Ford and GM just so you can slide in your partisan tax barb, Bob)
- raganwald 16y agoI didn't see it as a lament. It read more like a warning not to try to tinker with the economy by investing in business in the hope of creating jobs. One could easily read this article as being pro-Free market. It's just saying "Stop trying to game the free market, that doesn't work."
- dctoedt 16y ago> First of all, business is about providing value to customers, not jobs to neighborhoods. ... We don't want a thousand people making a iron boiler for a steam engine anymore. The value-to-customers part is the truth, but not the whole truth. If a government's economic policies don't result in jobs being provided to neighborhoods, then three things are inexorably going to happen: 1. A non-trivial number of (usually) young men with too much time on their hands will do things that we really wish they wouldn't but that we have a very hard time suppressing, especially when they can use communications technology to their benefit: Street gangs. Drug cartels. Jihadist groups. 2. People will blame their governments because they perceive that Bad Things -- unemployment, drugs, crime, terror -- aren't being fixed; 3. Disruption will result, because people won't passively accept Bad Things indefinitely: (a) In a democratic society, the government will be thrown out and policies will be changed -- possibly not for the better -- and with switching costs in any case; (b) Even in a non-democratic society, there will eventually be unrest as people get mad as hell and refuse to take it any more (cf. the Honda strike in China, but then there's North Korea as an apparent counterexample); I'm a life-long moderate Republican, but it's only been in recent years that I've come to appreciate that, unlike some conservatives, liberals 'get' these fundamental truths of human nature. I wish these truths were otherwise, but to paraphrase Lazarus Long, you don't argue with the weather, you deal with it. (That's one reason I'm encouraged by the favorable reports I've been reading about the educational policies that the Obama Administration is pushing.) ISTM that some liberals have unrealistic views of how we should deal with these truths -- some of them likely would be happy having a thousand people making a boiler -- but that's another debate.
- pchristensen 16y agoI've been wondering lately if high profits per employee could be a negative externality for society. That is, if enough jobs aren't being created to give people something meaningful to do, then idleness and disruption (a la dctoedt's excellent comment) become a problem. While America is wealthier overall today, it seems like the previous 100 years did more to spread the growth in wealth across the whole population and make society wealthier as people benefited from universities, roads, better health and housing, etc. These aren't fully formed or vetted ideas, just thoughts. Regarding the article, if GM is selling and making more cars overseas, then maybe just owning 60% of the company and profits is the best outcome. Structurally, they were never going to employ 500,000 American workers again.
- yason 16y agoAnd what's wrong with lesser jobs? It means that eventually a society where life and status is not defined by mere employment emerges. Currently we have few reasons to be unemployed that are acknowledged as okay: for example students and pensioners, maybe some others. When the illusion that mostly everyone ought to be employed somehow, it means that it becomes ok to not do things that are seemingly productive in the short-term, like work. It will allow more acceptance for production of human values that can't be done under the traditional employer—employee relationship, like arts such as writing, composing, painting, and hacking. The only reason to think everyone ought to have jobs is to be in a position where you benefit from it. Like manufacturing and selling things to people. But when production is efficient enough and/or people decide that they have enough, the bubble breaks and you will find the society with lots of unemployed people.