13 ms·
Google's 'Advanced Protection' Locks Down Accounts Like Never Before
- wakkaflokka 9y agoI'm going to take the plunge into using security keys. What are the recommended bluetooth and USB-based keys I should be buying?
- shakna 9y agoYubikey are probably one of the most available, and most active in fixing bugs as they come up.
- moftz 9y agoI have a Yubico FIDO U2F. It works with tons of sites and services but I usually opt to using 2FA one-time codes since it's quicker (I can pull up the Authy client on my desktop or phone). My key doesn't always work in every computer I have. It works out of the box in Linux but Windows needs to download drivers and the time that takes is more than just doing a one-time code. It is helpful to have, I only need either my keychain or my phone to get into my most important sites and services.
- dredmorbius 9y ago"Google says it supports any keys approved by the FIDO Alliance, a group that manages identity and authentication protocols." -- from the article. This includes USB and Bluetooth LE devices. I'm still getting up to speed on technology, but prefer very near-field chips with a range of < 10cm (4 in), and if possible, < 1cm. Making unintentional / accidental detections, or snooping, as difficult as possible would be a bonus. (It's possible that interactive timing might be a mechanism: a nanosecond-scale time resolution works out to about 10 cm.)
- arnarbi 9y ago> It's possible that interactive timing might be a mechanism: a nanosecond-scale time resolution works out to about 10 cm. Unfortunately that requires different radio hardware. Look up Ultra Wide Band.
- dredmorbius 9y agoOne of my operating assumptions is that extant systems really aren't suficient. That's going to require some changes and establishment of novel standards. And that means that organisations having sufficient heft to promote and establish such standards need to be involved. As much as I don't trust the current Four Horsemen of the Apocalypse: Google, Amazon, Facebook, and Apple (and the various horse-pages: Microsoft, Oracle, IBM, etc.), they're almost certainly going to be involved. The US government, EU, and possibly interests in China, also. And if you're thinking "but China?!!", remember that they've got their interests in secrets too, and might see a need for a secure and trusted system.
- camiller 9y agoI've been using a (cheap $6) U2F token for a couple years now, but only on desktop, didn't want to spend the money on a NFC one. I'm thinking the feitian ePass one for $16.99 that has both NFC and USB would be good, at least until all computers switch to USB-c only. Of course if you also want RSA key management on top of it your going to spend more money....
- schrectacular 9y agoI have the Feitian ePASS FIDO you are talking about. Works great.
- wakkaflokka 9y agoAre there any websites where it doesn't work? Looks like in the comments on Amazon this doesn't work for LastPass. I was looking at getting it instead of a Yubikey. I got their bluetooth/nfc key that Google recommends, but I don't have a bluetooth card on my desktop.
- schrectacular 9y agoIt has worked flawlessly everywhere I have tried it (github, Google, Facebook, Dropbox, Fastmail). I don't use lastpass so don't know about that. Not very helpful, I know..
- camiller 9y agoLastpass says on their FAQ that they wont support Fido U2f until all major browsers do, but that is on them not the key manufacture. https://lastpass.com/support.php?cmd=showfaq&id=8126 https://lastpass.com/support.php?cmd=showfaq&id=8126
- dgacmu 9y agoWhy to use security keys: http://fc16.ifca.ai/preproceedings/25_Lang.pdf http://fc16.ifca.ai/preproceedings/25_Lang.pdf (updated from my earlier link to the yubico article about that paper: https://www.yubico.com/2016/02/use-of-fido-u2f-security-keys-focus-of-2-year-google-study/ https://www.yubico.com/2016/02/use-of-fido-u2f-security-keys... ) Review of security keys by Adam Langley: https://www.imperialviolet.org/2017/08/13/securitykeys.html https://www.imperialviolet.org/2017/08/13/securitykeys.html and testing security keys: https://www.imperialviolet.org/2017/10/08/securitykeytest.html https://www.imperialviolet.org/2017/10/08/securitykeytest.ht... tl;dr: Yubikeys are $$ but really solid for USB and NFC; the Feitian is probably the best option for Bluetooth but YMMV there. Those are what I personally use. (Note that Yubico recently announced a problem with their RSA key generation, which they're fixing, but that bug does not affect the security of the device when used as a FIDO authenticator as it is for Google/Github/Dropbox/Vanguard/etc.)
- camiller 9y agoI think the Feitian one is NFC
- dgacmu 9y agoYou're right. The feitan MultiPass (naming win!) Is the Bluetooth one I use: https://www.amazon.com/Feitian-MultiPass-FIDO-Security-Key/dp/B01LYV6TQM https://www.amazon.com/Feitian-MultiPass-FIDO-Security-Key/d...
- tonyztan 9y agoAccording to Yubico, the RSA vulnerability only affects the YubiKey 4 and "all YubiKey 4 products shipped by Yubico after June 6, 2017 (version 4.3.5 or higher) use" a new implementation that is secure from this. https://www.yubico.com/support/security-advisories/ysa-2017-01/ https://www.yubico.com/support/security-advisories/ysa-2017-...
- arnarbi 9y agoFIDO U2F does not use RSA anyways.
- schrectacular 9y agoTo piggyback, I recently bought a couple NFC devices, Feitian ePass FIDO and a Fidesmo Yubikey NEO. I have searched around for information on developing and transferring apps to these devices, but thus far have been unsuccessful. Seems most of the resources are several years old, gpshell appears abandoned and won't compile properly on Ubuntu 16. Any pointers appreciated! I'd love to have PGP support on the Feitian.
- fortythirteen 9y agoLocks down your Gmail from everyone except the companies that pay Google for the information gleaned from AI reading your emails.
- edraferi 9y agoWhich is the well-understood cost of getting an otherwise free, highly performant, unusually secure service for free.
- javajosh 9y agoWithout saying whether it is a good trade, we can at least surely say that it is NOT "well-understood" by users, since the vast majority are not aware of making this trade at all.
- tonyztan 9y agoI've always wondered why they don't offer the option for personal (gmail.com) users to pay for the service and opt out of monetization. I'd pay $5-10 per month for Google's services without me being the product.
- ozmodiar 9y agoAt that price you could just get a Google Suite email. Of course at a quick glance it just says no advertisements, I'm not sure that they wont be monetizing your data some other way.
- dragonwriter 9y ago> I'd pay $5-10 per month for Google's services without me being the product. That's actually not much different than paying for a domain and G Suite Basic. Which is probably what they expect people that concerned will do.
- tonyztan 9y agoThat's a good point. But currently there is no option to use my gmail.com address with G Suite, which I'd like to keep because of old accounts. I host my domain name email addresses with ProtonMail.
- singularity2001 9y agoAnyone else read the title as "Google Locks Down Accounts", as in: Google closes accounts without any chance of remedy?
- camiller 9y agoOne question I have that the article didn't answer, can you set up multiple physical keys? Can I create a backup and store it in a bank safety deposit box? I believe the current Fido process let's you do so, but does the new advanced version?
- dgacmu 9y agoYes. You can have many keys associated, just as with normal Fido. I have five -- I keep one in each laptop, one on my keychain, and two securely stored. (For more information, if you look at the program page, it also specifically mentions keys, plural - https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/ https://landing.google.com/advancedprotection/ ) In addition to the Wired article, there's a Google blog post about it: https://www.blog.google/topics/safety-security/googles-strongest-security-those-who-need-it-most/ https://www.blog.google/topics/safety-security/googles-stron...
- dredmorbius 9y agoFrom earlier discussion, if I recall correctly, you'd have the option of creating a set of one-time passwords as well. Details remain somewhat vague as to having multiple credentials, or managed accounts (though the corporate service -- Google Domains or whatever it's called, should allow an administrator some options).
- camiller 9y agoI know the current 2-factor auth allows backup one time passwords, but it specifically says in the article that the advanced protection does not allow the one time passwords. I was just curious if the advanced protection also limited the number of hardware tokens you could have.
- dredmorbius 9y agoThanks for that, and good question.
- linopolus 9y agoIt may be harder to "recover your password", if you lost your second factor key, but the fact that it still is possible means Google employees (or a fraction of them) have a way into your account. I prefer services where this isn’t possible, even though that means the account is lost if I forget my password.
- giarc 9y agoThat doesn't mean an employee has access to your account. If you lose your USB dongle, you'll need to prove your ownership of your account, but that doesn't mean G employees will go in and look at your emails.
- munin 9y ago> that doesn't mean G employees will go in and look at your emails There are two forms of this assurance. The first is running into some guy at a party, or on an internet message board, who either works at Google or "knows a guy" who does, who then spends thirty or forty minutes semi-drunkenly rambling at you about how the security at Google is "military grade" and everything is "locked down" and they have some guy who used to run the Mossad in charge of internal security and he's the best guy ever and nothing or no one ever breaks in and that shit's a fortress. Trust the semi drunken ramblings of this guy you just met, your secrets are safe with the big G. The second form of this assurance is only giving the third party indistinguishable encrypted blobs of data. They can look at them all they want, it doesn't mean anything to them. You don't need to trust anyone, let alone some guy you found on the Internet and transitively a few hundred anonymous computer programmer and IT janitors spread across the world. Go figure, some people are more persuaded by the second argument. Even if you're reading this and you work at G and you know that the ex-Mossad security guys are digitally looking over your shoulder and you shake your fist at this screen muttering "you don't know how much we have it locked down here, clueless Hacker News commentator" you have to realize, somewhere in your heart of hearts, that a zero trust solution is preferable when you are trying to maximize for security.
- 3pt14159 9y ago
- pksadiq 9y ago> And if you forget your password, or lose your hardware login keys, you'll have to jump through more hoops than ever to regain access ... 'Advanced Protection'? In any case, if passwords can be reset and if USB keys can be changed, there is always a flaw... No matter what Google say.
- tonyztan 9y agoDon't know why this is being downvoted. If humans at Google can help recover the account, then it is potentially susceptible to social engineering. There's no way around that.
- dpark 9y agoBecause most people don’t consider ability to recover to be a “flaw”. The idea that Google is fucking up by not permanently locking someone out is absurd. There is no technical way for Google to even implement this. Someone at Google with sufficient access could always go poke the DB directly to change a locked-out user’s password hash and replace whatever hypothetical keys are in play. The most Google could do would be to force a purge/loss of any current user data encrypted at rest. This would of course not prevent a successful attacker from sending or receiving new emails.
- CodeWriter23 9y agoI think that is the point, a Googler who is moonlighting for spooks in any country can spy on their behalf. In other words, people are cautiously pointing out it is not “only someone with the key” who can gain access to your emails.
- dpark 9y agoI get that, but an account “reset” is always possible. Even if Google encrypted all of your mail and other content with a key you exclusively control, it would always be possible to simply drop the encrypted data, update all keys/passwords, and regain access to any incoming email. This is a smaller attack surface but still significant. It’s also not actually possible to be an email provider and have no access to read plaintext and the point of send and receive. It can be encrypted at rest but you have to allow read for transmit which means a Googler working for the “spooks” could simply intercept there instead of at rest.
- mtgx 9y agoDoes this mean they've eliminated that vulnerability where no matter what 2FA option you chose, someone could always get into your account by tricking Verizon or some other carrier that they are the owner of the phone number? I never understood the point of offering additional so-called "stronger" 2FA options when the mandatory fallback was always the SMS code. Why even bother? Services should at least give users the option to disable SMS fallback. But really they need to start thinking about a SMS-less 2FA future. Even NIST has deprecated SMS 2FA.
- skizm 9y agoWould that work if you were using the Google Authenticator app?
- erichurkman 9y agoYou no longer get the option to use Google Authenticator until you've already set up 2FA the first time using SMS, at least in the US. You can remove your mobile number _after_ setting up Google Authenticator, but you have to remember to do that step.
- gruez 9y agois that even an issue to begin with? afaik you need a phone to enable 2fa, but you can remove it after adding another token.
- tonyztan 9y agoExactly. Google has always (at least since 2012) provided the option to remove any and all phone numbers from your account after enabling 2FA.
- sowbug 9y agoIt doesn't mean that because that vulnerability never existed. You've always been able to remove SMS 2FA after setting up a second method (backup codes or U2F).
- acobster 9y ago> All non-Google services and apps will be exiled from reaching into your Gmail or Google Drive. Does this mean I can no longer use Google's OAuth service for logging in to, say, Bitbucket? Or just that they are locking down the information such apps can access?
- buro9 9y agoAnd does this preclude WhatsApp to Google Drive Backup that goes into your Drive backup folder rather than Drive itself?
- parent5446 9y agoI just enabled it on my account, and I can still log into GitLab and other OAuth accounts. I presume it just means they can't access Gmail, Drive, or the other listed products.
- revmoo 9y ago> "If John Podesta had been able to turn this on sometime last year, the world might be a very different place." Yeah, the world might not have known how much of an absolute creep the guy is.
- moduspwnens14 9y agoI'm glad they're doing this--but I'd also like to see a little granularity. If I'm a big-wig politician, I'd want it as-is, but as a normal techie, I'd like support in the native iOS apps and the ability to connect apps. However, I'd still like the strict (days-long) account recovery / verification process.
- fixermark 9y agoI agree with the utility of the granularity. On the implementation side, it adds a lot of complexity. 1) Every granularity feature adds a set of possible state interactions and widens the attack surface. 2) Every granularity feature is an opportunity for a user to accidentally misconfigure their settings and expose themselves to more risk than they believe they are.
- codemac 9y agoWhat does this mean for IMAPS w/application specific passwords? It's a really sad statement to say outloud, but if turning this on means my emacs mail client I've been using for ... years doesn't work anymore, I just can't do it.
- dgacmu 9y agoYou're correct: > For secure access, you will need to use the Gmail app or Inbox by Gmail.
- codemac 9y agoThe end is nigh.
- Diederich 9y agoIt says that no non-Google app will be able to access your stuff.
- camiller 9y agoIt says that no non-Google app can currently access your stuff, but they are open to other apps being more secure. "...limiting full access to your Gmail and Drive to specific apps. For now, these will only be Google apps, but we expect to expand these in the future." https://www.blog.google/topics/safety-security/googles-strongest-security-those-who-need-it-most/ https://www.blog.google/topics/safety-security/googles-stron...
- fixermark 9y agoCould you, hypothetically, still set up a mail forwarding rule in the Gmail client to hand your mail over to another server?
- davidcbc 9y agoDoesn't that defeat the purpose of the advanced security? Now the other server becomes the weak link
- nopal 9y agoHow do the Google iOS apps handle authentication, since NFC security keys aren’t supported by Apple?
- superdaniel 9y agoI believe the Feitan key mentioned in the article supports Bluetooth LE. If you go to their website it shows that they support iOS. https://www.ftsafe.com/products/FIDO/Multi#Compatibility https://www.ftsafe.com/products/FIDO/Multi#Compatibility
- eldridgea 9y agoIf you're signing into a Google app, it'll kick you over to the Google Smart Lock app. https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/google-smart-lock/id1152066360?mt=8 https://itunes.apple.com/us/app/google-smart-lock/id11520663... I don't think it supports things like Safari though.
- zghst 9y agoNFC keys are now a possible reality since iOS 11 API opened up the hardware to developers. Here's an example: https://github.com/hansemannn/iOS11-NFC-Example https://github.com/hansemannn/iOS11-NFC-Example
- georgiedown 9y agoFor the record, it's only possible to READ tags using iOS 11.
- jamiesonbecker 9y ago"Kremlin-backed intrusion that hit the Gmail account of Hillary Clinton campaign manager John Podesta" It's quite obvious to many that it was the Russians, even in the absence of formal proof. Why do we have to keep seeing this assertion, especially when the CIA had a team making malware that emulated or included ostensibly Russian code. No one was trying to frame the Russians; it was just to save time. https://theintercept.com/2017/03/08/wikileaks-files-show-the-cia-repurposing-foreign-hacking-code-to-save-time-not-to-frame-russia/ https://theintercept.com/2017/03/08/wikileaks-files-show-the...
- noitsnot 9y agoWhen Wikileaks was releasing her emails she called them fake and brushed it under the carpet. But when Trump suddenly wins, they corrupted the election. Fraud!
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ChrisClark 9y agoThat's... not exclusive... Both those statements can be completely true. I seriously can't understand the logic of these trumpettes.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ZoeZoeBee 9y agoIf it weren't for those pesky DKIM keys you might be on to something...
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- nateberkopec 9y agoAh yes, a hacker organization which does things like create Android malware to disable Ukrainian artillery and attempts to interfere with American elections is probably not a Russian front. Come on. Dell SecureWorks and the CIA have presented plenty of evidence that this was a Russian-backed group, probably GRU. EDIT: Also, even if there aren't lines in their malware which say "(c) GRU 2017", Fancy Bear is a group which consistently targets enemies of the Russian government. They don't steal credit card numbers, they commit digital terrorism that furthers Russia's interests. It doesn't really matter if they're 100% state-backed or not, because they clearly and consistently act in the Russian government's interests. An organization which hacks targets that benefit Russia and a Russian gov't hacking organization are the same thing from the perspective of the United States.
- cavisne 9y ago“Most public of those was the Kremlin-backed intrusion that hit the Gmail account of Hillary Clinton campaign manager John Podesta” friendly reminder there is no proof for this claim, Podesta either fell for a generic phishing page(Reset your gmail password here!), or from his known passwords (password and runner<some number>) someone could have easily just guessed his password.
- jartelt 9y agoIt was widely reported that his password was stolen via a phishing attack. If the phishing attack was carried out by someone backed by the Kremlin, then I believe that makes the statement quoted true (I'm not sure about the level proof here as I am sure some of it is non-public).
- heatish 9y agoThere's actually quite a lot of evidence that it was a politically motivated spear phishing campaign from FancyBears, which is most likely from Russia. So technically yes there's no definitive, smoking gun proof but "no proof for this claim" seems to be a bit dismissive of some glaring hints. It certainly wasn't just a "generic phishing page" or guessing of a weak password. They went after quite a few politicians on both sides of the aisle and journalist's, the Podesta camp just happened to be the ones who fell for it. https://www.secureworks.com/research/threat-group-4127-targets-hillary-clinton-presidential-campaign https://www.secureworks.com/research/threat-group-4127-targe... https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/10/russia-linked-phishing-campaign-behind-the-dnc-breach-also-hit-podesta-powell/ https://arstechnica.com/information-technology/2016/10/russi...
- acdha 9y agoJust to add to this, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fancy_Bear https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fancy_Bear has links to multiple security companies which have publicly drawn the link to the Russian government. The list of targets is also convincing: various NATO organizations but also things like the World Anti Doping Agency at the time the Russian Olympic team was being disqualified from everything. You could argue that, say, China might be interested in hacking the US or France but Eastern Europe and WADA really aren’t of interest to most other major powers.
- pm24601 9y agoMy suggestion for "normal" users. Create a new "Advanced Protection"account. Use this new account only for: * password recovery * backup account * banking credentials (maybe?) This backup account can then be used to protect against any password recovery attack against any other site that you rely on. Your normal day to day email can stay with the regular security.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Crontab 9y agoSo how would someone back up their email using this system?
- WindowsFon4life 9y agoCaveat. If you post anything subversive or controversial, they will just punt your account. All a hacker has to do is present some evidence to any of this, and your account is gone...
- amckenna 9y agoThat may be the case with their free accounts or money earning YouTube accounts, but that is not the case for subscription based GSuite business accounts. The GSuite accounts are set up so that an offending user is a sub-account of the parent GSuite account. They will ask the parent account owner to suspend the user's account and take measures to fix the violations, but they wont unilaterally suspend the parent account.
- m1n1 9y ago(OT but related to security and Google) I used the existing link at the bottom of my gmail page to sign out all other sessions. The next day I went to another device and saw that it was still signed in.
- a-dub 9y agoi suppose the missing piece would be to tie it to a specific chromebook to avoid issues with pwnage of the endpoint. they say they require chrome, i wonder if it would be possible to steal the session cookies and run a second session on the same host? (maybe they fingerprint the browser or use some other scheme to ensure that they only talk to the authenticated browser process?) i suppose even if that was the case, if the endpoint was pwned the browser could be modified to make requests in the background on behalf of the pwners. almost kinda surprising they didn't tie it to special chromebooks that they could sell. not only would it actually mitigate a big problem, i could totally see it also being some kind of a "i'm an important person" status symbol that people would brandish in public. if they gave it a distinct look it would be like a newfangled blackberry or zero halliburton for whatever you call this weird decade.
- 0xbear 9y agoWouldn’t users who sign up for this also de facto flag their accounts for NSA operatives embedded within Google?