4 ms·
Munger's an adherent of a particular value system common among businessmen from the mid-19th -> late-20th century. In this value system, 1) the primary purpose
by nostrademons 9y ago
Munger's an adherent of a particular value system common among businessmen from the mid-19th -> late-20th century. In this value system, 1) the primary purpose of economic activity is efficiency, producing more with less 2) the purpose of employees is to serve as instruments for their employers to accomplish their business goals and 3) anything that gets in the way of this is by definition evil, and it is not immoral to work around such restrictions for the purposes of increasing efficiency.
Both Patterson and Travis Kalanick are exceptionally virtuous men by this value system. They were ruthless drivers of efficiency, willing to ignore any obstacles in the pursuit of making their businesses bigger and more profitable. Other adherents to this value system include Milton Friedman, Ayn Rand, Bill Gates, John D. Rockefeller, J.P. Morgan, Steve Jobs, and Paul Graham.
By contrast, the dominant value system in America today is marked by different tenets: 1) the primary purpose of life - of which economic activity is only one facet - is self-fulfillment and emotional gratification 2) it is virtuous to pursue such goals for yourself as long as you don't interfere with other peoples' pursuit of such goals 3) rules and regulations exist to enforce #2 on behalf of the powerless, and those who break those rules are by definition evil and 4) the employee/employer relationship should be a partnership where the employer should provide purpose and direction in accord with the employee's value system, and in return the employee helps the employer accomplish their business goals. Interestingly, both the Left and the Right of an increasingly divided America subscribe to this value system, they just define "self fulfillment and emotional gratification" differently.
The two value systems aren't entirely at odds with each other, but they aim toward entirely different purposes, and so naturally they conflict at several points. When this happens, things that may be considered the height of virtue under one value system are morally abhorrent to another one.
- rco8786 9y ago> the dominant value system in America today Certainly not. You described the value system dominant in many European countries, but certainly not the one in the USA.
- titzer 9y ago> By contrast, the dominant value system in America today is marked by different tenets: 1) the primary purpose of life - of which economic activity is only one facet - is self-fulfillment and emotional gratification 2) it is virtuous to pursue such goals for yourself as long as you don't interfere with other peoples' pursuit of such goals 3) rules and regulations exist to enforce #2 on behalf of the powerless, and those who break those rules are by definition evil and 4) the employee/employer relationship should be a partnership where the employer should provide purpose and direction in accord with the employee's value system, and in return the employee helps the employer accomplish their business goals. Interestingly, both the Left and the Right of an increasingly divided America subscribe to this value system, they just define "self fulfillment and emotional gratification" differently. Wow, you are a whole lot less cynical than I am, because when I look at American businesses, the operation of the hyper-growth mindset in practice, and the consequences of policies and practices that assume sustained exponential growth, I don't see these values reflecting back.
- icebraining 9y agonostrademons said the value system in America, not among American business leaders.
- titzer 9y agoI think when you look at consumer habits (summed up in household debt, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_debt https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Household_debt), there is an undertone of overconsumption that runs in parallel with the hypergrowth mindset. Consumption hasn't slowed down, while wages have. Household debt and national debt follow scarily similar arcs.
- icebraining 9y agoOverconsumption seems to perfectly compatible with "the primary purpose of life [being] self-fulfillment and emotional gratification".
- peterwwillis 9y ago
- dragonwriter 9y ago> By contrast, the dominant value system in America today There isn't really one dominant one, but none of those anywhere near that mark are even remotely like your description. You seem to have confused the fact that several different value systems share a limited tolerance for value systems with differing life goals with them all being a single value system with a highly subjective life goal as a central plank. Such a value system exists, too, but is by no means dominant.
- cyberattacknow 9y agoIt's not so much a difference in values as a conflict in interests. Everyone wants to maximize happiness for themselves, which often include maximizing financial status. Thus, those "values" are really just a way to justify their personal interests. Of course, there are people, especially in the middle and lower class, who are foolish enough to place "fairness" and "what's right" over their own personal interests.
- ScottBurson 9y agoPaul Graham??? Wow, I don't get that from him at all.