12 ms·
The Forgotten Mystery of Inertia
- dingo_bat 9y agoMaybe I'm wrong but it's wrong to say we don't know how a gyro works. We can accurately and precisely predict the behavior of a gyro, derive the mathematical equations necessary and the model we use is general for all moving objects. This is the greatest level of knowing you can have. Maybe the author meant that a gyro's motion is not intuitive to most humans. That I can agree with. For me, even the fact that my smartphone is performing billions of calculations every second is non-intuitive. Doesn't mean I don't know how it works.
- kbenson 9y agoYou're speaking to the "how" that means how it responds to stimuli, but the article is speaking to the "how" as in why. The greatest level of knowing is not having rules for inputs and corresponding outputs, but the algorithm that controls it. In this case it sounds like we've derived an algorithm that relates to the inputs and outputs, but the inputs that cause the formula itself are unknown. My understanding is that if you go far enough back a lot of physics is like this, but it sounds like we can't even go very far back here.
- xenadu02 9y agoIn physics (and in many other areas) it is unsatisfying to wave your hands and say "it is so because our measurements prove it". A theoretical model that explains why the measurements come out the way they do is far more valuable because it leads to other insights. We can predict the behavior of a gyro but there is still a fundamental question of what a gyro is relative to since GR tells us there is no universal reference frame. Are gyroscopes entirely local or does the gravity of distant galaxies present a sort of universal reference frame? Or is it something else entirely?
- justinpombrio 9y ago> Are gyroscopes entirely local or does the gravity of distant galaxies present a sort of universal reference frame? Or is it something else entirely? Something else entirely. You don't need other galaxies or a universal reference frame. Even if the gyroscope were the only thing in the universe, it would be easy to tell if it were spinning: a very tiny person standing on the inside rim would be held down if it were spinning, or free floating if it were not.
- fiddlerwoaroof 9y agoBut that doesn't distinguish between the gyroscope spinning and the existence of a sufficiently massive object in the appropriate place, right?
- letlambda 9y agoWalk around to the opposite side of the gyro wheel. If the acceleration is due to the rotation of the gyroscope, it still points out radially. If it was due to a mass out beyond the rim, you're falling on your head.
- apsophus 9y agoWhat if the mass is distributed in a ring surrounding the gyro at a distance? How would you distinguish between spinning versus mass in that case? General Relativity may seem counterintuitive, but experimentally it really does seem to be the way our universe works. Starting out from the position that absolute motion is meaningless has proven remarkably fruitful. It's also something a lot of very smart people have been thinking about for a hundred years. Whether or not you find Mach's arguments plausible, they're fundamental philosphical claims and can't simply be dismissed through a half-baked thought experiment.
- thaumasiotes 9y ago> What if the mass is distributed in a ring surrounding the gyro at a distance? How would you distinguish between spinning versus mass in that case? In that case, it wouldn't be drawing you outward no matter where you were located. So, spinning would be "you feel a gravitational force", and a ring of mass would be "you don't feel a gravitational force".
- phkahler 9y ago>> We can predict the behavior of a gyro but there is still a fundamental question of what a gyro is relative to since GR tells us there is no universal reference frame. If one can see that the gyro is still pointing in the same direction, then one has already defined a reference frame. I can see confusion if we had a gyro spinning inside a free-falling elevator (or even a closed box spinning in space). You can still tell the gyro is spinning because there are internal stresses that indicate the axis of rotation, if not the direction. The earth bulges at the equator because of its rotation, it would require much force to keep it spherical.
- naasking 9y ago> This is the greatest level of knowing you can have. If it doesn't answer "why?", then it's incomplete. Perhaps at some point in our explorations of physics there will be axioms we must simply accept, but the gyro isn't it. We should have a reason for its behaviour.
- headShrinker 9y agoI'm not a physics major. So I may have made a major booboo in explaining this. I get what you're saying. We know what inertia does. We have the math to estimate is effect. We can measure it's affect. To be clear, we don't know how it works. In the vacuum of space, if your body begins to spin, a force will pull your arms away from your from your body. No one on this planet can unequivocally explain why this happens. No one can explain the mechanism for how gravity works. No one can explain why when something starts spinning, there is a force that makes it continue to spin, or why there is a need for force to stop it. These are basic forces and our lack of understanding shows just how little we understand about the universe. This, after the smartest people, over 2,000 years have had a crack at it. Steve Jobs said that people who have made everything are no smarter than you or I. Einstein said something similar. I find it a bit reassuring that some of the worlds most basic forces are yet unexplained. We are still in our infancy of figuring things out. Everyone should get to work. There's a lot to do.
- white-flame 9y ago> In the vacuum of space, if your body begins to spin, a force will pull your arms away from your from your body. I think this is the easiest to explain, because it's built on the others (specifically inertia). For some point in your spinning, your arm moves in some direction. Your center of mass changes its direction of movement, because you're spinning. Your arm still goes in the direction it was initially moving, pulling itself outward as the less floppy part of the body follows the spin inward a bit better. Your arm (and all your other parts) is just "trying" to go "straight", due to inertia, and can achieve it better than your other parts, because it has an easier range of motion to do so. Inertia and gravity themselves are more fundamental, and certainly fit your descriptions (to my limited knowledge). We don't know at what level things in the universe are fundamental, instead of explainable by some additional turtle underneath. Hence we start smashing subatomic particles to see what's there. I have no clue how science even could determine if some mechanisms are the "root" ones and not just derivative of something else. There's no guarantee that the physical workings of the universe make any sort of sense.
- KGIII 9y agoWe can accurately predict lensing well enough to see the impact on particles of light - over billions of miles. We can't explain it. The universe is still full of many mysteries. If we knew the why, we'd stop doing science. Our understanding is incomplete and that's okay. It gives our species something to strive for. Do you really understand particle physics well enough to truly understand how your cell phone works? We can predict, model, and observe. We can get results. We don't necessarily know or why the results are the way they are. Edited to add: I find it interesting enough to sometimes point out that we used electricity before we even knew about electrons. Being able to do something doesn't mean understanding. We used simple machines, long before we understood them.
- dom0 9y ago> We used simple machines, long before we understood them. There are infinitely many examples of this, from metallurgy to rolling bearings to gears (gear reduction has nothing to do with teeths), medicine, astronomy (humans have predicted the motion of the stars for thousands of years), ...
- jamesrcole 9y ago> We can accurately and precisely predict the behavior of a gyro, derive the mathematical equations necessary and the model we use is general for all moving objects. This is the greatest level of knowing you can have. That's not true. You can have accurate and precise predictions without understanding why it behaves in that fashion. If, additionally, you can understand why it does then you have a better understanding of it.
- goatlover 9y ago> This is the greatest level of knowing you can have. No, the greatest level of knowing is having an explanation for why a gyro behaves the way it does. > For me, even the fact that my smartphone is performing billions of calculations every second is non-intuitive. Doesn't mean I don't know how it works. But imagine if your smartphone was of alien manufacture, and you lived in a world of exclusively analog technologies. Scientists and engineers could come to accurately predict your smartphone's behavior, and certainly a mathematical formalism could be given for it, but they wouldn't understand the physical basis for the billions of calculations it performed. It would be a big mystery until physics advanced enough to understand how the circuitry worked.
- icelancer 9y ago>>We can accurately and precisely predict the behavior of a gyro, derive the mathematical equations necessary and the model we use is general for all moving objects. This is the greatest level of knowing you can have. This is the most superficial level of knowledge you can have. If you truly think about it, you know nothing about it. The greatest level of knowing would be able to derive everything you just said from first principles about the gyro without knowing any of what you just mentioned. That is something that cannot be done. We do not know the root cause. Without that, we know nearly nothing.
- yk 9y agoIn general relativity you can easily show with Noether's theorem, that in an space time with rotational symmetry there is a conserved quantity that in flat space is conservation of angular momentum.
- colordrops 9y agoSo there was the animation that Caltech put out today or yesterday of the neutron star collision that was just detected, and it visualized gravitational waves moving outward from the stars: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7LcmWiclOs https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=e7LcmWiclOs It just reinforces the (incorrect?) intuition that spacetime is "something" rather than nothingness between things. Why can't motion be relative to spacetime rather than other objects?
- QAPereo 9y agoI think you’ve confused the notion of nothingness, which may or may not even be real in practice, and spacetime, which is definitely a thing. Gravity is a result distortions in that thing.
- colordrops 9y agoOk, so if that's the case, why can't objects be relative to spacetime rather than other objects, as discussed in the article?
- pizza 9y agoShort answer: because tachyons don't exist (i.e. haven't been found) Slightly longer answer: To be relative to spacetime would (most likely) mean having a means of transmitting information faster than the speed of light, but information cannot travel faster than the speed of light. * "The world line (or worldline) of an object is the path of that object in 4-dimensional spacetime, tracing the history of its location in space at each instant in time." [0] Something that would exist relative to spacetime (as in, would not be confined by the laws that dictate spacetime) would have to be outside of a light cone [1]; "In flat spacetime, the future light cone of an event is the boundary of its causal future and its past light cone is the boundary of its causal past." https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_line https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_cone https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Light_cone * I don't know very much about quantum entanglement, so if anyone would like to comment as to whether entanglement might appear to violate transmission of information faster than c, that'd be neat, but i have a suspicion that it doesn't because either because of (A) a reason depending on the fact that qubits aren't like bits or (B) that the separation of two entangled subsystems would constitute the actual transmission of information but would still necessarily be no faster than c.
- pizza 9y agoThere's also the Unruh effect http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Unruh_effect http://www.scholarpedia.org/article/Unruh_effect
- freedomben 9y agoTrigger warning: Math ahead :-) Really cool tho
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- continuations 9y agoIs Mach's principle related to equivalence principle? It's so strange that inertia mass just so happens to be exactly the same as gravitational mass. Can Mach's principle and equivalence principle be derived from some more fundamental laws or are they accepted as axioms?
- rocqua 9y agoThe equivalence principle follows naturally from the geometry of general relativity. The idea is that mass curves space. In this curved space, a 'straight line' is no longer straight. The upshot of this is that if you are standing still, a 'straight line' would actually mean falling down. By inertia, things want to move in straight lines, so we feel gravity. It is an apparent force like the centrifugal force. If this talk of straight lines in curved space is confusing, consider what passes for a straight line on the surface of a sphere. It still 'curves'.
- goialoq 9y ago> If it is spinning extremely rapidly, the gyroscope remains rigidly locked in the direction it has been set, its sights fixed on...Kiev—hence the term inertial guidance systems. This is clearly false... right? If you translate the gyroscope, it won't be pointing at Kiev anymore, it will be pointing to the side of Kiev. The gyroscope doesn't magically point at a target, it provides a stable reference direction that the rest of the IGS can compute its deviation from, to adjust its course.
- snowwrestler 9y agoHe elides the inner workings of an inertial guidance system because it's not really necessary. The point is that the gyroscope provides an absolute reference point, which seems weird in the face of relativity.
- goialoq 9y agoI agree, but the intro is all about how this magical gyroscope is pointing at Kiev, even making a point about how the gyro is doing it after being separated from the rest of the rocket.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- lutorm 9y agoSure. It also has to be powered up and aligned to a known attitude and position within a not-too-distant past, because actual gyroscopes have friction and are not perfectly locked in space. Either the guy didn't actually know how they worked or he was pulling a prank.
- westoncb 9y agoAnyone know of (or want to give) a clear explanation of how gyros behave? I found the article to be unclear on a number of points. I was also unclear on this: "The first triumph of general relativity was its exact prediction of the orbital precession of Mercury’s perihelion" —does a perihelion precess? I thought it was the planet which was precessing and the perihelion shifted (changing the shape of the planet's orbit?) Also, I came across this (seemingly) related gem the other day: ("Why is Linear Motion Relative but Rotation Absolute?") https://www.quora.com/Why-is-linear-motion-relative-but-rotation-absolute https://www.quora.com/Why-is-linear-motion-relative-but-rota...
- mikeash 9y agoGyros are really simple! Think of the gyro's ring as a series of independent particles flying around really fast in a horizontal circle. Now you push up at one point on that circle. Does the circle move up at that point? No. You're applying a force to each particle only very briefly before it moves past and you're pushing on the next one. But you do impart some upward velocity on the particle during its brief time under your influence. This causes it to follow an upward path away from the point where you're pushing, which will continue until the circular path brings it back down. This will tilt the entire circle along the axis connecting the center of the circle to the point where you're pushing. The faster the gyro spins, the less important the imparted velocity will be relative to the particle's speed, which is why a gyro is more stable the faster it spins.
- rkagerer 9y agoInertia is not a property intrinsic to an object but depends upon all the mass in the universe. That quote from the article really crystallized Mach's Principle for me. So continuing mikeash's great explanation... basically the rest of the universe is pushing the gyroscope into its stable position?
- goatlover 9y agoBut if so, we don't know how the universe does that, and relativity has failed to settle the matter so far. That's what I got from the article.
- danielam 9y agoOn a related note, those interested in the origins of the idea of inertia may be interested in impetus theory[1]. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_impetus https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Theory_of_impetus
- iaw 9y agoThis reminds me of inertial navigation system demo's that I saw a while ago [1]. I'd suspect that the targeting gyroscope in an ICBM would look very similar to that system. [1] https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4yaNn4Xmfg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=w4yaNn4Xmfg
- danbmil99 9y agoOne question I've never seen answered to my satisfaction: If you created a gyroscope with two counter-rotating disks somehow identical in moment and location, would it fight precession symmetrically, or act like a block of matter with nothing rotating inside it?
- Retra 9y agoAren't those the same alternative? If something is fighting precession symmetrically, then isn't it acting like a block of matter with nothing rotating inside it?
- danbmil99 9y agoa standard gyro fights precession at 90 degrees to the attempted off-axis rotation, and shows way more rotational inertia than can be accounted for by the mass involved.
- phonon 9y agohttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGun5athdfg https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=vGun5athdfg
- sopooneo 9y agoA drunk awakens in a void and finds his arms, legs, in fact all extremities are bing pulled outward by some reverse gravity. It is quite unpleasant. By some strange mechanism he is able to make himself start spinning. At first it is worse: in one direction the reverse gravity increases in effect! So he reverses and is relieved to find that in the other it slowly abates. Though the sweet relief is strange. Because if he goes too far in that direction, he finds that the expulsatory force begins to increase again. But eventually he finds the sweet spot and stays there, relieved, to find himself not being pulled apart. "This", he says to himself, "I shall call an inertial reference frame. It is so much more relaxing than the others."
- taneq 9y agoSounds like a first year physics question. "Consider a spherical drunk in a frictionless vacuum..."
- madaxe_again 9y agoA perfect spherical drunk, in fact.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- noonespecial 9y ago...of uniform density. Although, for us, it was always a spherical chicken.
- QAPereo 9y ago...Alone in a universe.
- eru 9y agoAnd interesting enough, the universe does have a unique privileged inertial reference frame: that which makes the background radiation look isotropic.
- alexasmyths 9y agoGreat article. Great articulation of history and just enough technical detail for regular readers.
- CDokolas 9y agoIs this serious scientific writing? "[...] the gravitational force the Earth exerts on you is canceled out in a freely falling elevator" and "[...] it is impossible to distinguish acceleration from gravity"? Seriously? Isn't acceleration the result of force? Isn't gravity a force? When you are in free fall you accelerate, gravity doesn't "cancel out"!
- lightlazer 9y agoGeneral Relativity states that gravity and acceleration are equivalent, so yes, they cancel out. Unless you look outside you cannot tell whether you are in an elevator standing on ground on Earth (1g), or in space accelerating upwards at 1g.
- madaxe_again 9y agoGravity is not a force. It’s just tensor warping, which manifests as acceleration in our paltry 3d realm, which you experience as a force. Similarly in the falling lift there is no force making you float, just an apparent relative acceleration that you experience as a force.
- woahhvicky 9y agoIt does because the frame is not inertial. There is a fictitious force “pushing you upward” because the elevator is accelerating downward. The fictitious force pushing you upward perfectly cancels the gravity pulling you downward and you feel no net force inside the frame.
- iofiiiiiiiii 9y agoI do not find anything at fault in saying it cancels out. Possibly you are too strictly affixed to some notions?
- vectorEQ 9y agowtf. forgotten by whom? What mystery? > everything is magnetism. > inertia is where no force exists. https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.00333 https://arxiv.org/abs/1504.00333 https://www.google.com/search?tbo=p&tbm=pts&hl=en&q=ininventor:%22Mehran+Keshe+Tavakoli%22 https://www.google.com/search?tbo=p&tbm=pts&hl=en&q=ininvent... http://www.ru.nl/hfml/research/levitation/diamagnetic/ http://www.ru.nl/hfml/research/levitation/diamagnetic/ https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EPlyiW-xGI&t=684s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=9EPlyiW-xGI&t=684s (guy from CERN) etc. etc. if u want to look at universe, look at magnetism, dielectricity and inertia. many research is being done on this and practical applications have already been made in several areas of science / technoloy. Think people should get rid of relativity, as it's completly made to assume something is not moving just for the sake of being able to compute things... everything is moving ,everything is in constant flux.
- kaffeemitsahne 9y agoRelated: Newton's spinning water bucket https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_argument https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Bucket_argument
- Angostura 9y agoReading this bought immediately to mind watching Eric Laithwaite's Royal Society Christmas Lecture on the peculiar properties of gyroscopes. It's a shame he apparently pretty much deluded himself, because it was a great lecture https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Laithwaite https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Eric_Laithwaite
- ballenf 9y agohttps://youtu.be/g60ZCcquCl8 https://youtu.be/g60ZCcquCl8
- sjmulder 9y agoI can fit two thumbs in the header that won't go away. It's like reading trough a letterbox. Luckily I can use reader view but it would be better if it wouldn't be necessary at all.
- e12e 9y ago> Would you feel centrifugal forces in an empty universe? Does the law of inertia mean anything in an empty universe? Mach would give a resounding “no” to both questions: Inertia is not a property intrinsic to an object but depends upon all the mass in the universe. If "you" can exist in a massless universe (that which encompass all that exist) - then, by definition, "you" have no mass. So insofar as mass is connected to inertia is connected to angular momentum (the need for acceleration/force to alter the direction of movement) - then: no, you would not be able to detect "centrifugal forces" without any mass. But, if "you" have mass and exist in a universe, that universe consist of at least the mass making up "you". Let's assume a sphere/clump of small magnets. Would it be possible to spin this sphere fast enough for it to disperse - tear itself apart? I would think so.
- bawana 9y agothat a spinning gyroscope does not topple has not much to do with Mach, Einstein, the universe or any such big idea. I can explain it much more simply. Consider a gyroscope spinning fast. so if all of a sudden you try a push its top northward then that instantaneous force pushes down on the north edge of the disk and up on the south edge.Those specific parts of the disk acquire momentum. However because the disk is spinning, the part of the disk that was north soon becomes south. and the southern piece that was moving up is now north. now the momenta of the influenced disk segments act to right the gyroscope. The same effect can occur during the acceleration of a gyroscope in a missile in space. Even tho there is no gravity. The effect of acceleration on the gyroscope is the same, causing it to maintain its orientation in space. The faster a gyroscope spins, the more quickly it rights itself. and thus appears more stable. as it slows down, the righting effect fails. Angular momentum is a man made calculation and the upward pointing arrow is really just a make believe thing. If it were a real force, the whole gyroscope should float upwards. LOL. It is a shorthand to represent the average momenta of the influenced parts of the gyroscope.
- bzbarsky 9y ago> Angular momentum is a man made calculation So is linear momentum, really. I agree that you can analyze an actual physical gyroscope just in terms of linear momentum without reference to angular momentum, though the calculations end up harder. But there are things that have angular momentum that doesn't obviously correspond to linear momentum (circularly polarized light and nonzero-spin elementary particles come to mind).
- jprissi 9y agoI don't get how the gyroscope is used in missile guidance. How is the gyroscope mentionned in this article pointing at Kiev? How do you read it on the gyroscope and how is the position 'set' in the device?
- vasjenetehais 9y agoActually, the gyroscope will give your angular rotation. It can be achieved through different technics (MEMS gyro, mecanical gyro...) but the final goal will always be to give you your angular rotation. You need your angular rotation and the specific forces applied to your body (given by the accelerometers) to be then able to compute your position, speed... in the earth frame called NED (North East Down). That's the very short version. You also need to know your Lla position to correct your gravity model, the error model of your sensor to correct them... Kalman filtering is always used (in my experience). Here is a draw that seems accurate https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_navigation_system#Method https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Inertial_navigation_system#Met... Then if you want to go dirty hands, you will need these keywords : "inertial navigation mechanization". This PDF seems clear at first look (5s check) : http://www.ecsutton.ece.ufl.edu/ens/handouts/inertialnav_v2.pdf http://www.ecsutton.ece.ufl.edu/ens/handouts/inertialnav_v2.... Kalman filtering can be overhelming but the course from D.Alazard is really great (still using it after 3 years in navigation field). If you want a quick exemple, a north finder algo is very easy to understand (basic earth projection). It is also the first step of initialisation of a navigation system.
- bronlund 9y agoMy following comment got rejected :D "Taking the risk of sounding like a crackpot I will share some of my own thoughts on the subject - put together from bits and pieces I have stumbled upon. It can hardly be argued that some knowledge is attempted hidden - mostly for the sake of power. And in my humble opinion, the mysteries of bodies in rotation is exactly one of those subjects. This article is based on academic science and appropriately so, but when it comes to rotating bodies I don't think you will find the answer there - at least not in the post-Einstein era. You should at least go back to James Clerk Maxwell and his original 20 equations to get a hint of what's really going on. If Einstein himself was aware of the shortcoming of his theory or even put them there on purpose, is up for debate - leaving it to the reader to discover what's missing from the theory of relativity. If one bothers to seek alternative sources of knowledge about rotating bodies, you will not be alone. And if you stick to it, you will find very interesting things indeed. Not only about rotating bodies themselves, but as to why some has determined it so important to keep the facts hidden. Some events suggest that, at least in western science, the connection between rotating bodies and gravity was stumbled upon in the early post-war missile program when Wernher von Braun tried to put a rotating body on top of a rocket - believing that it would stabilize it. There are of course scientists doing research into these things outside the constraint of normal academica and from time to time their findings find their way into the public domain. One example is experiments done by Dr. Bruce DePalma, which some are as simple as they are easy to duplicate. For those of you curious enough to adventure into this field of alternative science, I wish you luck."