7 ms·
Some of these arguments assume a single fixed-supply cryptocurrency, instead of the ecosystem of cryptocurrencies we actually have, which is more like Hayek's p
by DennisP 9y ago
Some of these arguments assume a single fixed-supply cryptocurrency, instead of the ecosystem of cryptocurrencies we actually have, which is more like Hayek's proposal for competing privately-issued currencies. He thought it would be stable without the need for active management.
As a payment system I think cryptocurrency is vastly better; the more I use my hardware wallet, the more I'm horrified by legacy systems that work by giving vendors the ability to withdraw as much as they want. It's a fundamentally insecure system, made sort of workable by layers of hacky mitigations.
In theory, fiat payment could use a hardware wallet that gives vendors the ability to withdraw only as much as specified in a signed transaction. I doubt that'll happen unless crypto is successful enough to drag fiat providers kicking and screaming; in the meantime we could use fiat-backed tokens on a blockchain if governments didn't make that near-impossible with AML/KYC laws.
Reversibility could also be implemented in a token smart contract, if the market really does value that enough to put a central admin in control. So far that doesn't appear to be the case, but maybe just because that market segment hasn't been reached yet.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoI think that feature could be summed up as: With criptocurrencies, if your software and opsec are good, you're a lot less vulnerable to identity theft and overcharges.
- DennisP 9y agoYes, and with a hardware wallet, opsec is trivial. In my ideal world everyone has one in their leather wallet or on a keychain, and also uses it for secure 2FA on websites.
- notyourday 9y agoThis is laughable. An investment of $700 (http://www.gunbroker.com/item/696279983 http://www.gunbroker.com/item/696279983) makes content of one's hardware wallet non-recoverable. Right of redress does not help as the transaction is not reversible.
- speakeron 9y agoHardware wallets use a seed to generate key pairs using a cryptographic random number generator. The seed is usually a sequence of words which you backup on a piece of paper. If the hardware wallet is destroyed you can simply generate the keys again with either a new hardware wallet or a software one.
- DennisP 9y agoRead up on hardware wallet passphrases. You can have as many wallets on your hardware wallet as you like, and there's no way to tell how many there are. The hidden funds certainly won't be vulnerable to a fast mugging. And of course, if you have a large amount of money you probably shouldn't put it on the hardware you carry around anyway. Apply a little common sense and put it in a safe deposit box.
- notyourday 9y agoOh no, your attacker will point a Desert Eagle at your head and you will unlock all your wallets. After the money is transferred you won't be able to recover it. The reason why currency in current form is so interesting is that it is not easy to move massive amounts currency into a form that can be easily consumed. Even uncut diamonds is a small market so in event crime happens the proceeds of crime will likely be recovered given determined tracking party (i.e. nation state) and returned to the victim of the crime. This, essentially, is the single most important part of the non-crypto currency UX. I can provide you with an example another extremely popular ( much more popular than BitCon ) currency that does not have such UX - it is cocaine. I think we all can agree its main UX property is violence.
- DennisP 9y agoThe attacker would need to spend significant time on that. It'd work in a home invasion, but street muggings are over fast. And again, safe deposit box for large amounts, spendable money in the portable. With a simple smart contract you don't even need to go to the bank to refresh small amounts every few days.
- emiliobumachar 9y agoYou're trusting your hardware provider similarly to how I trust my bank. They need to opt out of attacking you, and prevent rogue employees and suppliers from being able to attack you.
- AgentME 9y agoIf my bank was open source, modifiable, and runnable in a private instance on my own hardware, I might trust banks more. (Ignore that it might not be right to call it a bank at that point...)
- gersh 9y agoWhat happens when you lose your wallet, or someone steals the peace of paper with your private key? Credit cards and atms get stolen all the time.
- dsacco 9y agoA few questions: > As a payment system I think cryptocurrency is vastly better; the more I use my hardware wallet, the more I'm horrified by legacy systems that work by giving vendors the ability to withdraw as much as they want. It's a fundamentally insecure system, made sort of workable by layers of hacky mitigations. Do you think cryptocurrencies are vastly better because they don't allow transaction peers to withdraw arbitrarily from your wallet, or for some other reason? If the former, do you consider cryptocurrencies to be better than simply implementing this functionality in fiat systems like ACH? > Reversibility could also be implemented in a token smart contract, if the market really does value that enough to put a central admin in control. Why do I want a smart contract for this, instead of just trusting that the vendor will be heavily penalized for trying to arbitrarily take funds from my account? In fact, why do I want anything to be trustless? In a trustless transaction system, there is less transparency: it might be harder to take more funds than allowed from my account, but in the event the vendor finds a way to do it, what is my recourse without a trusted third party for arbitration? It feels like a lot of this debate circles back to one group of people saying, "Cryptocurrencies are great for when you don't trust the government" and the second group of people responding, "Yes, but why would I not trust my government or the people I transact with, and don't I have worse concerns than my currency if that's honestly the case?" From my perspective, perfect feels like the enemy of good here: you sacrifice efficiency in the average case for catastrophe in the worst case. The problems solved by solutions that don't require trust seem to be sort of decently solved in the average case using brittle technical features (e.g. smart contracts that prevent a vendor from double dipping your personal wallet); on the contrary, we have solutions for those now in basically every stable country's fiat currency, and fiat currencies at least solve the worst case, but cryptocurrencies do not (e.g. your smart contract was hacked and your entire account is gone, but no one knows who the vendor was that did it). Basically, I trust smart contracts less than I trust my government, and to be honest I don't endorse strong trust in my government either way. I kind of want my currency to be backed by people with guns and a complex legal system instead of a distributed ledger and whatever half-baked smart contract system is used by the vendors. Stripe has one of the best security teams in tech right now, and routinely hires security consultants from excellent firms like NCC Group. If Stripe put out a new cryptography library, I would default assume it's broken in some way, at the very least in implementation. Whenever the "Stripe of cryptocurrency payments" emerges, I am basically going to assume that it's critically broken and will be catastrophically exploited after a huge number of users and vendors are vulnerable. Solving a fully technical smart contract system to abstract away all of these concerns (like arbitrary ACH transfers) isn't feasible in the current state of software security.
- simias 9y ago>instead of the ecosystem of cryptocurrencies we actually have, which is more like Hayek's proposal for competing privately-issued currencies. That's interesting, it's the first time I hear about this concept. I just barely skimmed a few articles about the concept but I'm not sure how this would solve the problems in TFA. In particular deflation: if I need to invest in a currency why would I even elect to use an inflationary one? What would be the incentive? Also a currency is only as good as the things it can buy, if you end up having to convert your WhateverCoin to BTC or ETH before spending, does it change anything? You could use special-purpose crypto currencies to replace frequent-flier miles, starbucks credit and other privately owned "currencies", but what would be the point of that? >As a payment system I think cryptocurrency is vastly better; the more I use my hardware wallet, the more I'm horrified by legacy systems that work by giving vendors the ability to withdraw as much as they want. It's a fundamentally insecure system, made sort of workable by layers of hacky mitigations. Is it a problem in practice? If a vendor overcharges me I complain to my bank, the charge is reverted and then the bank takes care of dealing with the misbehaving party. If anything it's the opposite that's usually the problem in practice, people using chargeback fraudulently. Meanwhile in the crypto world if your wallet is compromised or if you get scammed you're on your own. Bitcoin is great for buying drugs but for legit purchases Visa is a whole lot more convenient. It's quicker, easier and offers much stronger guarantees. From the vendor's point of view it's less great but as TFA points out "Sellers bear costs from reversibility, but those are offset by increased buyer confidence." No citation though, unfortunately. That's one of the weaknesses of crypto IMO, it's all about "trustless" transactions, except that when you actually use your currency to buy something outside of the blockchain at some point you have to trust somebody (or somebodies) to actually provide the goods or services you're purchasing. All the systems that try to work around that so far seem to simply reinvent the banking system with extra steps (trusted 3rd parties etc...).
- DennisP 9y agoHayek points out that you wouldn't choose an inflationary currency. He relies on that to limit overall inflation. But you also don't have the deflationary problems of the gold standard, since it's possible to make more money at will if you need it. Regarding payments: suppose we were starting from scratch, with two proposed systems: (1) user signs transactions that authorize transfers with specific recipients and amounts, or (2) user gives multiple parties enough information to withdraw unlimited amounts, hoping unauthorized parties don't get hold of it, and we make up for the inevitable thefts with statistical antifraud protection, manual intervention, and banks just eating the losses. I can't imagine anyone choosing the second option.
- Nursie 9y ago>> the more I use my hardware wallet, the more I'm horrified by legacy systems that work by giving vendors the ability to withdraw as much as they want While this is still the case for online transactions, in-person payments with chip cards and contactless methods like contactless EMV, apple pay and android pay do not allow this.
- jbrun 9y agoWe had privately created money in Europe for centuries. It was a disaster.
- marcosdumay 9y agoIt wasn't too different from the recent ICO stuff. Except that it was mainstream. In other words, I completely agree.
- neonnoodle 9y agoYep, and we had it in the U.S. as well before the advent of the Constitution. Similarly a disaster.
- rphlx 9y agoI would strongly disagree with that characterization. The bank note system - the major form of private money - worked reasonably well for centuries in Europe, evolving into the check clearing systems that virtually every first-world nation has today.
- jbrun 9y agoThat was much later on. I am talking about basically end of Roman Empire to 1600.