19 ms·
"Humans violate the rules in a safe and principled way...." Thanks, it's nice to start my morning with a good laugh. Maybe the author lives in some magical wo
by mikeash 9y ago
"Humans violate the rules in a safe and principled way...."
Thanks, it's nice to start my morning with a good laugh.
Maybe the author lives in some magical wonderland filled with good drivers, but this is not what I observe at all. People drift out of their lane for no reason. They careen past the stop line because they can't be bothered to push the brake pedal a bit farther down. They refrain from signaling because they just don't care. They blast through stop signs and red lights without heed to traffic or pedestrians. They brake spontaneously in the middle of a fast moving road. They drive fast in dangerous conditions and slow in safe conditions. They spend half their drive texting because they think they're the one person on the planet who is able to safely text and drive. How is any of that safe or principled?
- reacweb 9y agoAs a Parisian driver, I think I understand exactly what he means. Other Parisian drivers violate the rules with a nicely predictable scheme where non Parisian may respect the rules but are very dangerous and get horned continuously.
- cordite 9y agoWhat are the rules for if following them makes them dangerous?
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoWith traffic, agreement often matters more than the specific rules.
- yoz-y 9y agoThe rules are supposed to be a universal agreement. Otherwise it makes it very dangerous to drive in a different city even though the laws are the same.
- mannykannot 9y agoTo provide some means for censuring those people who flagrantly disregard the unwritten rules (I know that, formally, that looks nonsensical, but in practice it is not.)
- Iv 9y agoThe rules are not "for" something in France. They just appear out of committees and political compromises and are often half-assed implementations of nonsensical middle-ground between two coherent positions. Some may occasionally align with public interest. One of the things you learn living in France is a sense of the rules that make no sense and that everybody is probably disregarding, and the ones that are actually useful and probably enforced. Always smile to a clerk. They will tell you which mandatory paper is not mandatory and which rule you can break. They will also tell you which rule the state is incapable of following and how to get around it.
- stephengillie 9y agoTo selectively enforce against people you arbitrarily do not like.
- mannykannot 9y agoIt is rather self-serving to say that people following the rules are creating danger. If you are driving in such a way that a dangerous (as opposed to merely inconvenient) situation results from someone following the rules, you are not driving with sufficient caution.
- reacweb 9y agoFor example, to change lanes, a Parisian will put on his flashing light and change lanes just after even if a car is arriving. He knows that in Paris everyone is attentive to other cars and have seen his flasher. A non-Parisian guy's gonna put on his flasher and wait for space. This never happens and he ends up changing lanes very unexpectedly.
- yoz-y 9y agoSo... when there is somebody who isn't a Parisian and they hit a car because they did not know this, are they in fault? I live in Paris, and although I do not drive I have the impression that most drivers here are extremely inconsiderate. As an example, there is a crossing which is constantly congested with buses and lorries stuck in the middle here. This is mainly because nobody respects the rules or priorities. When an officer comes in to control the traffic instead of the lights, it gets "magically" cleaned up and the circulation is fluid.
- mannykannot 9y agoIf that driver is signaling, then a move should not be unexpected, especially if the unwritten rule is that one must force one's way into another lane. You are actually providing an example that the Parisian way of doing things is not as benignly efficient as you suggested in your first post.
- reacweb 9y agoIf you adopt the Parisian way, you can change lane very easily and quickly even if there is a big traffic jam. I have drive in traffic jam in smaller towns (like Cherbourg), it was more difficult to change lane. The fact that you can not change lane without forcing is a normal consequence of the increase of the traffic. I think the unwritten rule is that people should not turn on flashing lights too early before acting. The better communication of the intents and a fair level of trust that other drivers will understand it (and not try to block you) makes driving a lot easier (in Paris).
- ynniv 9y agoI saw the same thing in Boston. Instead of "violating the rules", I would say that local drivers obey a set of unwritten local rules that are more appropriate for the situations they encounter. These local rules make things safer and more efficient because the global rules that are written for wide, straight highways don't map well onto low visibility corners, confusing or incorrect signage, low speed side roads merging onto fast thoroughfares, roads (sometimes purposely) without painted lines, etc. I felt that Boston drivers often adopted Right of Way, a notion familiar to boaters. Faster cars with more maneuverability are in general expected to avoid slower cars or those with less maneuverability. If someone pulls out in front of you (perhaps because they were stopped and couldn't find a better time to merge), it's your duty to not hit them. On the other hand, if you are on a side street waiting to merge, it's expected that you wait for a break that's "big enough", then pull out and accelerate as fast as possible. None of these rules are written, but they are still consistent and safer than trying to rigidly apply global rules to the situation.
- whafro 9y agoThe roundabout on the Cambridge side of the BU bridge, which I unfortunately have to take home most evenings, is something I can't imagine a driverless car handling. Sometimes it's a single-lane roundabout, but at peak hours it can support as many as five cars wide, eventually merging into a single lane over the bridge, and the traffic pattern is different every day. Driving on highways is easy, and solving that is still valuable, but it's going to be amazing to see these things work in situations like those.
- FussyZeus 9y agoWell first you're conflating a few things that are totally safe and reasonable corner cutting measures versus things that are actually illegal and should be. Second, we're not going to replace all cars with autonomous cars overnight, so autonomous cars need to be able to deal with unpredictable human drivers, even if only temporarily. Thirdly, in my experience, it is oftentimes the overly cautious driver that causes more accidents than anyone else. If the self-driving cars are emulating the people who do the exact speed limit on the highway in the left lane, this is not a good thing because the deviation from the established norms of any given highway is the best indicator for where accidents are going to occur.
- gglitch 9y agoSurely it would be ridiculous to deliberately program the machine to break the law, though. It sounds like in the best case scenario, you're describing a situation in which the law should be changed to correspond to how people actually drive.
- FussyZeus 9y ago> Surely it would be ridiculous to deliberately program the machine to break the law, though. In my driver's ed course, it was explicitly covered that police will often not pull you over for doing 5 mph over the limit. If we're training drivers to casually break the law, then it's only logical we'd be doing the same thing to self-driving car AI.
- emodendroket 9y agoIn fact in this very article they suggest such a thing may be necessary.
- mikeash 9y agoWhat am I conflating? Everything I described is unsafe. Note that I'm not talking about failing to signal on an empty street or rolling a stop sign when there's good visibility and no traffic. I'm talking about failing to signal when there are lots of other cars around who could really use that information, or rolling a stop sign too fast to tell if you need to stop, or just without bothering to look. It's really weird that you use driving the speed limit in the left lane as an example of dangerous rule-abiding behavior. That's against the rules in most jurisdictions, and definitely should be in any where it's not. I agree that it's possible to break the rules safely. Rolling a stop sign in a situation with good visibility or exceeding the speed limit by a bit is perfectly fine. I agree that humans sometimes break the rules safely. But I disagree with the statement that humans violate the rules in a safe and principled way. When humans break the rules, it's almost never based on any principle besides sloth or selfishness, and while humans do break the rules safely sometimes, it's almost always safe by accident. The larger point that autonomous vehicles need to not be slaves to the rules is a good one. But humans are not the model to emulate!
- graphitezepp 9y agoAlso understand what author means, coming from Pittsburgh where the roads are simply not meant for cars. There are many intersections so confusing where it takes too much time to even interpret the rules. You regularly find yourself in situations where eye contact and gestures inform your driving more than the rules.
- zolthrowaway 9y agoTo add to this, there is literally a term "the Pittsburgh Left"[1]. Informal etiquette does really help prevent things like a lane getting blocked for three lights when someone needs to make a left at a busy intersection. However, humans definitely aren't perfect and they likely add a lot of congestion on their own from stuff like following to closely, not maintaining speed, etc. I feel like this is going to be a huge problem if we have mixed human operated and self-driving vehicles on the road at the same time. If we ever move to entirely self driving cars we could move to some sort of protocol for cars to communicate about ambiguous self driving actions. It's really common to see the Uber Volvo's driving around, but it definitely causes me to tense up when driving around them. I have no idea why, I realize there is significant risk when around any other car on the road. It's new. Hopefully these issues get worked out in a reasonable time frame, but it is software. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_left https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pittsburgh_left
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ynniv 9y agoLet's not overlook that once a single self driving car understands these local, informal rules, ALL self driving cars will. That's about a million times better than the current situation where every new human driver has to learn them. I was going to use a number smaller than a million, but 10k or 100k doesn't seem to properly describe the situation. Literally, these systems will be hazards until the day they aren't, and then they will, for all cars, forevermore, be better than every local.
- Retric 9y ago
- DonHopkins 9y agoHumans complement themselves on being safe and principled when they violate rules.
- Bartweiss 9y agoWould you accept "humans violate the rules in a safe and principled way, plus lots of other ways"? I mean, you're obviously correct, human drivers do idiotic and deadly things all the time. But I think we can distinguish that from the behavior in the article. Gently rolling a stop sign at a high-visibility intersection sounds like a safe and principled violation. Driving around a car waiting to turn left is a bit less safe, but still a principled or predictable violation. The Pittsburgh left is a (fairly) safe and principled violation. None of those things are comparable to texting and driving, or ignoring a red light. They're informal adjustments to the traffic code that other drivers really do anticipate, and which aren't nearly as dangerous as general "bad driving".
- mikeash 9y agoNo, that still goes to far. I'd accept "humans violate the rules in ways which are very occasionally, inadvertently safe."
- emodendroket 9y agoOh, come on. Coming to a rolling stop at an empty, clearly visible intersection is not some sort of insane suicidal behavior.
- mikeash 9y agoI'm not saying it is. A rolling stop at a busy intersection where you barely miss other cars and/or pedestrians is insane behavior, though, and that's what I'm talking about. Yes, there are people who carefully evaluate the situation and only roll their stops when it's safe. They make up a minuscule percentage of the population, though. Most people just do it out of laziness or selfishness, and when they do it safely, it's a happy accident, not a deliberate policy.
- emodendroket 9y agoI disagree.
- hugecynic 9y agoyou forgot my favorite one: reversing down a busy road to get a parking spot they overshot.
- rootlocus 9y agoI wouldn't be quick to assign blame. Most of the lateral parking spots can only be occupied by driving backwards, and drivers don't usually leave enough room for the one in front to make the maneuver. If the car in front of you is signaling right (meaning it's looking for a place to park), please stop before the parking spot.
- hugecynic 9y agoi'm not talking about parallel backing into a spot, i'm talking about reversing down the street a few hundred feet.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoHow about reversing on the expressway because you missed your exit? Self driving cars in Beijing are going to be fun.
- monochromatic 9y agoProbably better to say they violate the rules in predictable and expected ways.
- mikeash 9y agoThat still doesn't remotely match the way I see people drive.
- emodendroket 9y agoSo you never make any judgments at all about what other drivers are likely to do while driving yourself?
- mikeash 9y agoSure I do. And I often get it wrong because people are extremely unpredictable. I'm coming up to an intersection and I see someone edging out, so I slow down and prepare to panic stop in case they pull out in front of me. They don't, so I proceed. That's good defensive driving, but a failed prediction. I see someone with their signal on in the next lane, so I back up and give them some room to move over. Turns out they just forgot their signal was on. Again, good defensive driving, but an incorrect prediction. People don't break the rules in anything like a consistently predictable manner. Not around here, anyway.
- TylerH 9y agoPredicting someone "might" do something is not a prediction. You would have to predict that they will pull out in front of you or that they won't. Noticing some behavior and thinking of all the possibilities is not predictive behavior. What you are doing is making a reaction based on the action by another driver. In one case, you notice a driver edging forward, so you slow down in case they pull down. If you were predicting that they were going to pull out, you wouldn't just slow down, you would slam on your brakes. In another case, you notice a driver with a blinker on, so you assume they are changing lanes, and slow down to give them additional space. This one is closer to a prediction, but in reality a driver would notice the blinker before they get anywhere near the car in question and would have plenty of time to tell whether it's a forgotten blinker or a conscious attempt at changing lanes. Or they don't see it from far away because traffic is moving very fast and/or is very heavy, so they just keep going making the prediction that the car w/ a blinker on will wait until the lane is clear (aka after you pass them) to change lanes.
- ksk 9y ago>Maybe the author lives in some magical wonderland filled with good drivers, but this is not what I observe at all. The author of the article has not said those words. They were said by Karl Iagnemma who is a scientist from MIT, and the CEO of a company that makes software for self-driving cars. It didn't sound like something a reasonable person would say so I tried to track down the context of the quote, and it seems to be a mystery. My guess is that the quote came out of a larger interview, and it obviously meant to highlight the fact that 'standing out' by following rules in a way that other drivers are not expecting you to, makes things much more worse. That makes sense to me, as opposed to your interpretation.
- mikeash 9y agoGood point, I shouldn't have said the author there.