6 ms·
State Borders Were Drawn in the Distant Past. Time to Reimagine the Map? (2014)
- hprotagonist 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_evolution_of_the_United_States https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Territorial_evolution_of_the_U... January was "the distant past"? Granted, that modified state line affected 19 properties, but it's not trivial _to them_.
- KGIII 9y agoRight? I'd have to check but I might be older than one State. Distant past? To whom? There's quite a bit of neat history and a silly series called How The Stats Got Their Shapes is worth watching. It was on the History Channel, about a decade ago.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoIf you were born before 1959 (or August 1959 to be more specific). My mom was born in the territory of Alaska, for example.
- KGIII 9y agoI thought so. Born in '57. Why yes, yes I am old. But I'm kind of skeptical about that being the 'distant past.' Damned kids! ;-) Either way, as someone pointed out, it's really not that long ago and there are still changes being made. On December 8th, 1941, they were going to hold a vote about separating a part of Northern California. December 7th, of course, meant that the legislators were preoccupied and the vote was never held. I think they were going to call it Jefferson? I dunno... I watched the documentary series for amusement and it wasn't a scholastic pursuit. It's probably out there to be watched, if people are curious. I think there was a book by the same title?
- vacri 9y agoThe transfer of a few acres of land does not a state shape make - sellers of state-shaped fridge magnets don't have to go get their stock remade as a result. The last significant transfer of land in the mainland US was michigan and wisconsin's quarrel almost a century ago. Saying that state shapes are still in flux because 19 properties were shifted from state X to state Y earlier this year is a bit like saying you've got a new computer because you replaced your mouse.
- KGIII 9y agoYou base your State shapes on magnets and not cartographers? Ah well, at least the map makers got some work to do. There's also a number of other examples besides what they mentioned. It's a nice documentary series, of you're interested.
- vacri 9y ago> You base your State shapes on magnets and not cartographers? You can see the transfer of a few square miles on a continent-scale map like the ones in the article? The North/South Carolina border change represents about 700 sq miles changed over. The smallest state in the US is Rhode Island, with 1.2M sq miles - four orders of magnitude more. South and North Carolina are 30M and 50M sq miles respectively - five orders of magnitude more than this parcel of land. Do you think that miniscule corrections every few decades are really enough to counter the author's claim that the state shapes were 'drawn in the distant past'? Seems excessively pedantic to me - especially since the shapes involved didn't change all that much.
- KGIII 9y agoYes, yes I do. Not to mention I'm older than the most recent State. So, yeah, I think distant past is quite an exaggeration. You're not required to agree, of course.
- vacri 9y agoHawaii has no state borders, drawn now or in the past, so I'm not sure why that's relevant here, given we're talking about the article's byline. Alaska also has no state borders, though it does have national borders. In any case, if you were born several generations ago and still don't consider your childhood to be in the distant past, remind me not to get on your bad side :)
- vacri 9y agoThe January edit in your own link is listed as "too small to map".
- hprotagonist 9y agoand does that mean it isn’t real? (adding hawaii was also "too small to map"
- vacri 9y agoWell, it's more that the shapes of the states were pretty much all set back in the 19th century. Trying to construe a miniscule alteration between states as "the state lines are still in flux" is pretty disingenuous. Doubly so, given that the edit made this past january was about making the state lines truer to the demarcation set out back in the 19th C. These little corrections are tiny, and there's been no state border changes of any real significance for almost a century.
- everdev 9y agoOr just direct representation? Why am I represented by someone the majority of my neighbors elect instead of who I choose?
- thaumasiotes 9y agoA congress consisting of half the population might be a little too large to work well.
- rabidrat 9y agoI think how it works is that you take the top N.
- jachee 9y agoI still believe that Legislative Duty should be compulsory, like Jury Duty. 538 citizens, selected randomly per state in the same ratios as today's house and Senate. Tele-commute, and make/update laws for the good of all with minimal direct outside influence. I'm not sure how long a session would last, but it sure would be interesting.
- everdev 9y agoChances are someone else might want my same representative, maybe just not my neighbor. Right now, 50% of a state minus 1 can be represented by someone they don't want. Why not take a national vote and if your real is in the top 100, they become a senator, or the next top 538 and they become a representative.
- d3sandoval 9y agoRelevant xkcd: https://xkcd.com/1902/ https://xkcd.com/1902/
- peterburkimsher 9y agoPlease can someone add (2014) to the title?
- dang 9y agoAh yes. Thanks!
- Glyptodon 9y agoI'm much more on board with equal area boundaries than equal population.
- notacoward 9y agoWhy? Acres don't vote. People do. Dividing by area will just keep "one person, one vote" from being true, as long as we assign two senators (and thus two extra electors) per state. What's the benefit, other than giving each rural voter more power than each urban one?
- Glyptodon 9y agoTo me your view of "one person, one vote" sounds more like a new kind of colonialism - a way of making it so that the concerns of less population-dense areas are ignored and population-dense areas basically exert hegemony over them. Even if not a single person lived in Alaska it would deserve representation. Likewise, if just native tribes lived in Alaska it would not be appropriate for everything in the whole area be dictated by non-natives somewhere else just because more people lived there. While I view our current situation and system as imperfect, I do think one of its redeeming characteristics is the attempt (not really successful) to create a system that can both protect from the tyranny of the majority and the tyranny of locality. Equal population redefinition seems likely to merely exacerbate urban/rural tensions and vast geographic differences and create more conflicts. On the other hand, equal area represents a cleaning up of our current system - Senators would now clearly represent something: land/area, apportioned equally, as a more appropriate check on a hypothetical population-only apportionment of a house of Reps, which should have its size uncapped so as to have the proper granularity for purely population based representation.
- notacoward 9y ago> concerns of less population-dense areas are ignored As I said, areas don't vote. People do. Why should ten people living on a hundred acres get more representation than ten people living on one? Painting "one person one vote" as colonialist is flat-out dishonest. It's the alternative that's discriminatory, treating some people as more deserving than others because they own more land.
- galaxyLogic 9y agohttps://medium.com/organizer-sandbox/liquid-democracy-true-democracy-for-the-21st-century-7c66f5e53b6f https://medium.com/organizer-sandbox/liquid-democracy-true-d...
- jdonaldson 9y agoPowell's watershed map lays out administration zones based on the major flows of water. http://www.npr.org/programs/atc/features/2003/aug/water/part1.html http://www.npr.org/programs/atc/features/2003/aug/water/part... It gets my vote, watersheds are the strongest constant we have next to continents. Technology, language, rivers, and coastlines all shift.
- EADGBE 9y agoNever understood cities split by two states. Born and bred in one. Being on one side of the state or the other tends to complicate simple things. At least they're not independently operating countries, I guess.