6 ms·
Jeremy Corbyn: Imagine an Uber run co-operatively by their drivers
- umanwizard 9y agoWell, minicab drivers had all the time in the world to band together and invent something like Uber, and they never did. Capitalism has plenty of problems, but let's not pretend it doesn't have advantages too.
- rnd33 9y agoYeah, it's almost as if the minicab drivers have neither the time (as in money to quit work for a year) or the skills to create something like Uber. I'm sure lots of them have had the idea, but an idea is worthless if you can't implement it. It's frankly a bit concerning that Corbyn doesn't realise this.
- Xylakant 9y agoMinivan drivers don’t need to own the skills or the time to create something like this. They need to organize in a coop and have someone build it. It’s frankly disconcerting that people think Corbyn could have called for the drivers to program the app themselves. This is, btw., how coops work all the time. People form a coop that does something. Raiffeisen in germany started as a farmers cooperative, Rewe started as a cooperative of food stores, the various Coop supermarket chains (Italy, Switzerland, ...) started or are still organized as cooperative. There’s no particular reason the drivers could not band together and form a Taxi cooperative that develops and maintains an app. All it takes is the will to organize.
- stuaxo 9y agoIndeed, and having someone suggest it with a platform like his brings it a lot closer to being implemented.
- AsyncAwait 9y agoThere are a bunch of ride-sharing apps not run by corporations, like [1], but they were not started by cab drivers as far as I am aware. It was always kind of fascinating to me that other industries did not try to apply the concept of open-source more widely to different problems, despite the clear benefits it has shown in software. From the outside, it looks like few other industries are willing to sink in the time/effort for the benefit of the community as a whole, with no clear, short-term financial incentive for doing so. [1] - http://libretaxi.org http://libretaxi.org
- camus2 9y agoIt's true in any sectors. Vegetable/Fruit producers could gather in co-ops as well to sell directly to the customer and side step super markets, using the web/apps .... But it's obviously risky and someone has to bear the risk, without investors, you can't really do that. Uber didn't bootstrap their own business, they got millions of dollars from big shots from the Silicon Valley to get started. Individual cabs can't do that.
- sheeshkebab 9y agobillions, fixed that for you there...
- devdad 9y agoWell, this doesn't even contradict what Corbyn is saying. Corbyn is saying that new technology should be used to enable a more socialistic society and having Uber as a broker isn't really needed if the tech development is shared between the drivers.
- dogma1138 9y agoThe problem is that it’s a fallacy. There were plenty of ride hailing apps before Uber all of them sorta failed becuase of bad tech, business model or both. Uber made it with millions if not billions of funding and sure now it’s more easy to copy since the model and the tech is better understood but that’s just it it too capitalism to refine the model and now they want to effectively socialize it. This might sound cool but in reality it won’t work since this is a chicken and the egg problem and while you can socialize the chicken some one had to design the hen and optimize it before hand. Taxi unions had no intention to take the risks Uber did despite likely having just as much access to funds with 40-50,000 cab drivers each could’ve easily funded a mini Uber with a few 100s to a few 1000s £s over several years but they chose not too.
- devdad 9y agoAnd Uber has from the start been anti-worker by it's pure existence. Their "successful" business model is based on illegal business actions, evading laws and regulations and turning poor people into API calls. Uber is also still losing lots of money. Which is often a great place to start turning the business into worker owned and aligning it with the workers best interest.
- vixen99 9y agoits pure existence
- dogma1138 9y agoI don’t think Uber’s model is sustainable with human drivers. Im pretty sure their plan from was to build a large enough user base to be in a leading position to switch to robotaxis as soon as they are available and I think that’s what many of their backers are funding. With robotaxis being likely about 5 year or so from being approved in major metropolitan areas without any shenanigans from the cab cartels Uber can afford to bleed money until then and then just switch. Audi is releasing L4 cars in Europe this year which will allow you to take the back seat during traffic. While I don’t think anyone will be releasing L5 before 2020 I wouldn’t bet against that for a 2022-2023 time frame. Don’t get me wrong I dislike Uber and AirB&B with passion for their predatory practices but I also don’t like cartels the cab and car hire companies in London had a decade to get their shit together when the ride hailing apps / websites began popping up in the late 2000s and in all honesty they only turned worse.
- mattbee 9y agoWhat if TFL did it? They have a £11bn budget, they license taxis, run the buses & tube. They could perfectly well build a taxi-hailing app, integrate it nicely with the Oyster card system, or mandate it, or build an API for other taxi apps to build on. https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/business-and-commercial/innovation-portal https://tfl.gov.uk/info-for/business-and-commercial/innovati...
- toomuchtodo 9y agoHuge fan of this idea because it doesn't need to be profitable (as public transportation infrastructure usually isn't).
- malandrew 9y agoIf it doesn't have to be profitable and is provided by the government, then you're still paying for it through taxes. No thank you. I much prefer to give my money to a private entity that needs to actively compete for my dollars by keeping their service comparatively cheap and high quality.
- toomuchtodo 9y agoI would not be surprised if this is something Uber employees (past or present) believe. Uber's services are only cheap because of VC dollars, and quality is not high.
- malandrew 9y agoBased on leaked figures, Uber has -8% losses to gross bookings and is still aggressively expanding globally and into new markets (Eats and Freight) and working on self-driving cars. It's been widely reported that its mature markets are already profitable, which means that it's not cheap because of VC dollars. The VC dollars are only being used to supplement growth into new immature markets. The profitable markets are also being used for the same purpose. Enough markets should be mature enough for Uber to be profitable by sometime in mid to late 2018 at the rate they've been reducing their losses relative to gross bookings.
- untog 9y agoIf I recall, the original iteration of Hailo was indeed founded by London cab drivers. But needed VC funding in order to compete when Uber and the like came to town, which ultimately ruined them. That's a problem you see again and again, I think. No matter what your intentions, it's incredibly difficult to compete when a company with huge pockets comes to town and subsidises rides.
- rtpg 9y agoBut in this scenario isn't it basically better for everyone (except Uber) to reorganize everything into a co-op? This is a great example of capitalism not being able to generate the best solution. In an alternate universe there would be a regulated exchange with ~0 cut of the profits, instead making sure drivers get the money since they're doing most of the work. Uber does handle pricing, but even then it has "cheated" to get a bigger slice of the pie. Imagine the NYSE taking even 5% of trades.
- rayiner 9y agoThat’s a bit of spin right there. Taxi companies could never “invent something like Uber.” Meter and fare regulations precluded the use of smart phones instead of approved meters, and surge pricing (which allows Uber to offer cheaper rides most of the time and make up for it during periods of high demand). Huge amounts of VC money and ignoring taxi regulations allowed Uber to “invent something like Uber.”
- umanwizard 9y agoI intentionally said minicabs, not taxis, to head off this exact sort of argument.
- thriftwy 9y agoThey could have been changing these regulations years ago, instead they behave like a vegetable which is now being eaten.
- radiorental 9y agoI can't think of an example at this scale where that happened without the incentive of disruptive competition.
- dagw 9y agoTaxi companies could never “invent something like Uber.” Of course they could. All the regulations you mentioned are only there because the Taxi companies lobbied hard for them. Had they lobbied half as hard to have the regulations loosened they could have gotten any regulations they wanted. The taxi companies bet big on using regulation to entrench their position and avoid competition rather than on improving their product. History will tell if it was a good bet or not, but so far it isn't looking too good.
- rayiner 9y agoDo you have a source for your elaborate narrative history of taxicab regulation? In reality, modern taxi regulations date back to the 1930s, when the prevailing view was that consumer protection was best served by a combination of limiting competition and government price regulation. This was all happening at around the same time as the government rate-regulated other transportation industries: busses, freight trucking, and airlines.
- melloclello 9y agoImagine if we nationalised Uber.
- AsyncAwait 9y agoNot every 'socialist' proposal has to mean 'big, bad government', as some political circles like to portray it. Look at the success of free/open-source software. It didn't involve any nationalisation, government protection etc. No, it beat the competition in the free market, many times even in a market that wasn't really 'free' because of vendor lock-in, lobbying etc. I don't see why this could not work elsewhere as well.
- cturner 9y agoFree software does not extend from socialist thought. Stallman's initial realisation was a reaction to crony capitalism: he could not modify the printer due to IP rules. Essentially, a deal is done between government and big business (the manufacturer and possibly the university), at the expense of hackers (individuals). The justifications for copyright are rooted in common-good arguments. The state limits individual freedom, claiming that it should because of (undemonstrated) common-good advantages. Hayek explores this, and takes a position against IP in _The Fatal Conceit: The Errors of Socialism_. A better political analogy for free software is a conflict from early US history: between landowner and state rights advocates (Jefferson) vs big-business visions (Hamilton).
- llcoolv 9y agoOpen-source is socialist, really? I just thought it was a fancy way of showcasing skills and did it for fatter invoices it leads to, not public approval. An investment which requires capital in the form of skill. How on Earth is this socialist?
- amelius 9y agoThat's a great idea, because: 1. A government regulating a market is one thing while a company regulating a market is yet another thing. 2. As Stallman puts it: "We should not allow a company to have a share over around 10% of any market. If in a certain field a single dominant company is beneficial for society, that means it is a natural monopoly, and should be served by a regulated utility."
- dogma1138 9y agoSo TaxiLdn or GettTaxi? Imagine a Black Cab driver willing to drive further than an imaginary 1.5 mile radius around Paddington* *Airports and Cannary Wharf excluded.
- tluyben2 9y agoYou are downvoted but that is a big issue. And Uber drivers try it too by calling you to ask where you want to go. Which they are not supposed to and I never answer. It is hard to get rides off the beaten path sometimes.
- dogma1138 9y agoI never had much problem getting an Uber for even 30-45min drives I don’t like Uber that much mostly because in the center I’ve pretty strange experiences with them but gettng a ride to Watford or even St Albans wasn’t a problem sure it costs 30-40£ but it’s still much cheaper than prebooked not to mention black cabs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- ape4 9y agoI always felt Uber takes a cut thats way too large. They don't own the car or drive.
- tyingq 9y agoThey just reported a second quarter 2017 loss of $645 million.
- harigov 9y agoIt's a little too early for something like that to happen. The reason being that a lot of technology that goes into optimizing routes, predicting user locations, developing ML models, etc., requires significant amount of expertise. Uber invested a lot of money and effort into this and that gives them an edge over other competitors. Few years down the line, many of these technologies will be readily available off the shelf as either commercial products or open source software. Even then, for drivers to unite and run a business is hard but at least they will have fewer challenges to deal with. All said, I do believe that ride sharing transportation should be treated like a utility with some regulations to ensure fairness; but this is not the time. This is the growth phase of the industry. Any regulations at this time will just slow them down and hurt society at large.
- Waterluvian 9y agoI strongly disagree that any of that technology is needed to run a ride share co-op. It all sounds nice and helps justify silicon valley's relevance in these industries. But really, you just need some basic business infrastructure, a request ride app, and drivers with a growing wisdom about the needs of their region.
- harigov 9y agoTo run a ride share co-op? Sure, you can run it without any of that technology. To run an _efficient_ ride sharing service? That's where all of this technology matters. Think of competition between companies that are efficient vs inefficient. The one that is efficient will eat the other for breakfast.
- Waterluvian 9y agoI'm picturing a single employee per shift whose job is to keep a simple GIS updated with a generalized map of demand density. Add markers for relevant info like major events that will affect demand. This individual could also be one of the CSR's jobs. I'm picturing this service being unique per region, so the co-opers are all locals who grok their region. Give the drivers these data and they will naturally find balance. They're intelligent people who are motivated by efficiency. You just need an organizational core to supply the right data and infrastructure. I feel frustrated by this idea that we need to replace the best source of wisdom we have: our drivers, with expensive technologies. It makes a simple problem complex. Feels like silicon valley is putting my juice in a bag to squeeze.
- pdog 9y agoThe collectivist dream: outsource innovation to a system that rewards owners with profits, then pretend like someone would invent the next Uber even if there's no incentive.
- cardamomo 9y agoI think you're thinking narrowly about the term "incentive." Incentives can be non-monetary as well. Consider the opportunity to work with increased autonomy, or a chance to move your industry -- and perhaps society at large -- away from hierarchical power structures that disadvantage and disenfranchise workers. Focusing solely on the monetary side of this disregards the many other ways in which people find meaning in their lives.
- amelius 9y agoImagine an Amazon run co-operatively by small shop owners.
- AzzieElbab 9y agoImagine an Uber run co-operatively by their drivers, collectively controlling their futures, with profits shared or re-invested... subsidizing rides from their own pockets
- tyingq 9y agoI'm imagining it wouldn't be so popular sans the VC subsidies.
- speeq 9y agoI used a local minicab company once to get to the airport to catch an early morning flight from Stansted. Found their website using Google, booked and paid online. Called the office the day before travel just to confirm the booking and they said it's all good. The next morning I get a call from a rather rude operator - just minutes before they were scheduled to pick me up - telling me that I haven't paid the full amount for the ride. I told them that I booked using their website and paid online with PayPal. He replied that he doesn't know why the website didn't show the correct amount but if I don't pay an additional £30 to the driver they won't give me a ride. I agreed because I just wanted to get to the airport asap and not deal with finding another company. The lesson I learned here was: I don't trust minicab companies to be able to deal with the tech behind something like Uber. Of course, this was just one bad experience with a single company but it did leave a bad taste in my mouth.
- austenallred 9y agoWho would bear the risk? Who would bear the losses? Also, what would happen to bad drivers on the system, would they get fired like Uber fires them? What if a ride is in a spot they don’t want to go to, what happens if they don’t go? What happens when a driver takes a bad route for extra fare? What happens if they get told their car smells bad or is unsafe or they’re driving aggressively or are using the phone to talk to some random person during the trip? The first time I got in an Uber the driver gave me candy and a bottle of water, charged my phone. Will the taxi co op do that? Uber is so much more than just an app to order a taxi. It created a new economy with new incentives around ride sharing. It’s not just better because it’s an app, and it’s not just better because it’s private. It also forces drivers to do things taxis don’t want to when it’s netter for the customer. Does anyone seriously think a co-operative Uber would be able to compete with Uber without making Uber illegal?
- rayiner 9y agoIs it better? It occurs to me that one of the reasons that cab drivers are relatively rude is because they’re insulated from grinding feedback. Uber drivers, in contrast, are terrified of reprisal from Uber. They’re paid like independent contractors, but under the microscope and can be “fired” like employees. Is that really the desired end game? Everyone being micro-optimied under threats of losing their jobs, like Wal-Mart and Amazon employees?
- vixen99 9y agoWhy shouldn't consistently rude drivers be sacked? Putting employment above customer service is putting the cart before the horse and is a lousy business model. Businesses that go bust don't employ anyone.
- zajd 9y agoUber already is illegal in most places it operates, so... yes?
- SEMW 9y ago> Who would bear the risk? Who would bear the losses? Also, what would happen to bad drivers on the system, would they get fired like Uber fires them? You're talking as if this were some bizarre new thought-experiment that no-one's properly thought through. Co-operative supermarkets exist. Co-operative department stores exist. Bad employees at Waitrose can get fired like at any other supermarket (though obviously they're generally better treated than at privately-owned ones). You seem to be imagining a cooperative as a collection of free agents who have complete autonomy and can never be fired. That model probably exists, but that's not what people typically mean when they talk about cooperatives, especially in the context of the UK, as the politician in the OP is. What they mean is a structure like the John Lewis Partnership (which has been around since 1929), wholly owned by a trust whose employees are its beneficiaries. Which means any profits are distributed among its employees, who also get a say in the running of the business. But it's still a limited company, so it's still run by its executive team (albeit one which is ultimately accountable to the employees), and risk, losses etc. all work as normal for a limited company.
- watwut 9y agoThey would not be able to subsidize rides nor run loses that long. That being said, there is zero guarantee collective ownership would lead to better behaved company. Collective ownership can be quite ugly.
- mdasen 9y agoI think the issue is that there aren't any profits, just billions in losses. I think where a co-op would fail is that it would have to charge higher prices as the drivers wouldn't want to sustain (and pay for) losses for many years. If the co-op owned company charged 20-80% more than Uber, but offered drivers ownership and/or other benefits, would it bleed enough drivers from Uber or would enough drivers stick with Uber that it would be a viable and cheaper alternative for riders? This isn't a new idea. Juno planned to have drivers own 50% of equity (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juno_(company) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Juno_(company)) and someone tried to create a driver-owned Uber named Swift (https://www.dailydot.com/debug/swift-uber-lyft-driver-app/ https://www.dailydot.com/debug/swift-uber-lyft-driver-app/). However, given the costs associated with effectively competing are high - especially as Uber subsidizes rides. In the long run, there won't be drivers and Uber has mentioned a bleak future for its company if it doesn't get to driver-less cars sooner rather than later. A solution with drivers won't compete against a driver-less solution regardless of ownership. Even in the medium term where Uber will be using drivers, they have a large pile of money to use as a weapon against alternatives - and there are more driver-focused alternatives. Fasten has launched in two cities and takes $1 per ride rather than 20-30% of the fare. But Uber has a lot of money to encourage riders to use Uber and encourage drivers they might worry about switching. Corbyn is taking the attitude that a company like Uber is making all the money while the workers aren't getting their fair share. But Uber isn't profitable and it's unclear how much of that is expansion into new markets and how much of that is the marketing and subsidies needed to keep the business rolling in current markets. Would ridership decline significantly with 20% higher fares? Would you be able to retain enough drivers without the constant marketing to get new drivers? Uber launched in 2009 during the peak in unemployment. Today, unemployment is near all-time lows which makes recruiting and retaining drivers much more challenging. Ultimately, a driver-owned co-op sounds great, but where would the money come from? Would drivers be willing to take home less for share of the company? Would riders be willing to pay more knowing that it was a "good" company?
- confounded 9y agoAt least from my reading of the tweet, he appears to be saying that a cooperatively owned version could exist, not making a prediction that it will, and will win the cab wars because of innate properties of cooperatives. I understand your questions are probably rhetorical, but > Ultimately, a driver-owned co-op sounds great, but where would the money come from? I could imagine banks and governments being interested in funding a good proposal. > Would drivers be willing to take home less for share of the company? I’m not sure if they would need to take home less. But, being a driver is a more enterprising job than you might imagine. Most drivers work for themselves, and commonly minicab companies in London are put together by (ex) drivers clubbing together. Even drivers who have only worked for Uber have to think relatively in a relatively entrepreneurial fashion to make it work for them. > Would riders be willing to pay more knowing that it was a "good" company? If the rest of the consumer-facing economy is anything to go by, the answer is quite possibly yes. Organic food, fair trade, paying a premium for domestic manufacture etc. are all doing rather well (though of course, cheap stuff made by monopolies will do better). I think a large part of the reason Lyft exist (also VC funded and subsidized!) is that they’re less toxic than Uber, and pay drivers slightly more.
- jarym 9y agoI bet if you asked Corbyn to pump up the cash for Uber's losses over the past few years he'll put his tail between his legs and head for a hasty retreat. Taxi drivers had years to do what uber did. They didn't, they were often horrible - all manner of dirty tricks to keep prices artificially high whilst sneering at customers who didn't go on a long enough journey. You'd book a Minicab and be told they're '2 minutes away' and still find yourself waiting after 30 minutes. Co-operatives can be trusted to look after their own interests - to an extent that might even pass the definition of racketeering. They can't be relied upon to make a compelling proposition to customers. Not saying private companies like uber are the answer either, but it's hard to judge which is worse.
- dhoulb 9y ago... sounds expensive
- joshuaellinger 9y agoCheck out ATX-Coop. http://www.atxcooptaxi.net/ http://www.atxcooptaxi.net/ Owned by the drivers. Has about 1/2 the traditional taxi drivers in Austin after launching which Uber/Lyft left. They were trying to get an app built but without the deep pockets of the VCs they appear to have abandoned it. You call them and they dispatch. I miss the payment side more than the ordering side but I only use them to go to the airport of it isn't really the core case where Uber/Lyft excels. There is a sense of pride and ownership among the drivers. Feels better than both Uber/Lyft and other taxi companies. Doesn't have that desperate feel about it. Co-Ops do work. They have a different set of owners and thus a different set of incentives.
- ada1981 9y agoI'm curious if the riders would also be able to be owners. I co-own a cooperative grocery store with about 17,000 others; we do about $50MM in revenue annually. We are all owners / workers / shoppers.
- yomritoyj 9y agoA responsible politician should say why he thinks cooperatives have not been successful in the past, why driver owned cab aggregators are rate, and how he thinks those problems can be corrected. Just asking people to imagine stuff is lazy.
- owebmaster 9y agoA responsible successful politician pushes discussions and arguments and people's imagination is the best tool available other than manipulation and dictatorship (directly or indirectly via media and technology).