3 ms·
It's a problem, but given their pop, they can sustain more corruption and fraud than anyone else. They can sustain 4x our fraud and be even, given their produc
by mc32 9y ago
It's a problem, but given their pop, they can sustain more corruption and fraud than anyone else. They can sustain 4x our fraud and be even, given their production.
I think the NYT and others keep clawing at China simply because China has an agenda which diverges from the globalist vision of the NYT. They care for themselves and will do it by themselves by their own philosophy which happens to be less introspective. This means that while it can bring great value to Chinese, they may not feel like redistributing their largesse in any way with the rest of the world.
- hugecynic 9y agoa major component of the nytimes' function is to align the american populace against any country the US may eventually go to war with. if you just assume that you're being conditioned for war, everything makes a lot more sense.
- mc32 9y agoI think in the past that may have been true, but they are now pretty anti the current admin. If we evaluate on their rhetoric then we should be on the verge of war with Russia rather than N Korea.
- wybiral 9y agoReally? So exactly who is deciding where the US goes to war with? And who pulls the strings to control the media to align the people? It seems like that would be quite a conspiracy if it were true...
- dilemma 9y agoAnd it's happened before - read up on NYT's Iraq War lies told on behalf of USG. This is how America works.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> read up on NYT's Iraq War lies told on behalf of USG. This is how America works TL; DR the New York Times unquestioningly published what the government told them, that Iraq possessed weapons of mass destruction [1]. This reminds me of the faith Americans had in their government preceding the Vietnam War. Saying this is "how America works," however, is a willful short-circuiting of cognitive faculties. It's how any trusting society works until it's burned. We got burned, again, and now the press is more critical of anything the government says. I know a few reporters at the Wall Street Journal and New York Times. Catching the government (or anyone occupying a position of power) in a compromising lie is a prize they aggressively seek. It seems like whenever articles critical of significant foreign governments come up on Hacker News, these sorts of comments materialize. Just because the American media is criticizing a country doesn't mean (a) the criticism is invalid, (b) it was directed by the U.S. government or (c) said organization isn't similarly critical of the American government. (It's still good to read multiple countries' newspapers, though. On the topic at hand, Der Spiegel and Le Temps have written extensively.) [1] http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/media/features/9226/ http://nymag.com/nymetro/news/media/features/9226/
- jessaustin 9y agoYou haven't noticed that USA is in constant war in many different parts of the world? You might be a Washington Post reader! Many other nations are not in such a state of constant war, since their respective military-industrial complexes do not dictate acceptable public discourse in the way that ours does. It doesn't require a "conspiracy" as such. Reporters and pundits sing for their suppers, as it were, and they find that singing some tunes gets them on the right shows, the right "inside" access, etc. Singing other tunes leaves them on the outside looking in, with "insane" pacifists. This is how we can all be "sure" e.g. that Assad used chemical weapons against Syrians when not a shred of evidence ever existed for that.
- wybiral 9y ago> Many other nations are not in such a state of constant war, since their respective military-industrial complexes do not dictate acceptable public discourse in the way that ours does. That seems like an oversimplification. I can also say that many countries around the world _are_ involved in multiple ongoing military conflicts just as the US is. You bring up Syria as though the US were the only other country involved... But that's not the point I was making. My response was to the notion that the news and government were somehow masterminding the flow of information in order to prepare the population for specific wars. As though multiple parties were conspiring. Which seems a bit hard to swallow to me.
- mc32 9y agoIn addition to other countries like France, Russia, Iran, African Union, etc involved different ways in foreign affairs, some times, or often times those involvements are stabilizing. Sometimes they're very destabilizing.
- frozenport 9y agohttp://existentialcomics.com/philosopher/Noam_Chomsky http://existentialcomics.com/philosopher/Noam_Chomsky
- omejanmar 9y agoWhat don't you understand about China being evil? It has a dictator. It imprisons democracy protestors. It kills its leadership critics. It floods the ocean with plastics, and pollutes the air with no abandon. It acts like a crybaby whenever a free standing democratic Taiwan seeks to gain international acceptance. It acts like a bully against all of its neighbors with regards to south Asia sea. It gives its poor neighbors loans and then takes their national assets when they can't pay. It sends its fishermans around the world and depletes those sea life. It floods the world with shoddy products and destroys their community, jobs, and well beings. It steals technologies from other countries with forced tech transfers or espionages. Etc etc etc
- mc32 9y agoThe NYT could give a rat's ass about Taiwan and SEA politics when it does not dovetail into their worldview. China is complicit in much of what you say, but the great majority of Chinese will take that bargain, no questions asked. When China looked a little different, the NYT sang a different tune --perhaps they thought China could be "westernized" and coopted into their vision, but as that has not come to fruition and China cares about China and little else, they are coming down on it --not because they care about Chinese people (Chinese overwhelmingly approve of their leadership) but because they want to promulgate their vision of the world.
- louithethrid 9y agoWhat don't you understand about the _______ being evil? It has a globe spanning empire a secret ruling organisation. It imprisons democracy protestors. It vannishes its leadership critics. It floods the atmosphere with C02, and wages war for ressources. It acts like a crybaby whenever a dictator trys to wriggle out of its totalitarian rule by building a nuke. It acts like a bully against all of its neighbors. It gives its poor neighbors trade agreements and then takes foreign citizens rights when they actually live democracy. It sends its data-fishermans around the world and buys up any meaningfull competition to silicon vally life. It floods the world with shoddy products and destroys their community, jobs, and well beings. At least cheating allows to fullfill the diversity quota.
- librexpr 9y agoI don't think it works that way. Fraud in Chinese academia doesn't just mean that westerners can't trust their academics: it also means that their fellow countrymen can't trust each other's research. If there's 4 times as much fraud in China, then good Chinese researchers have to sift through 4 times as much bullshit, and are much less likely to trust and expand upon any new research, which slows down progress. If anything, I expect that the country the most hurt by Chinese research fraud is China itself.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoMany Chinese feel like this. When the NYT was banned for exposing the wealth of...I think Wen Jiabao's family, many Chinese shrugged it off as common knowledge (all the senior leaders are corrupt, Xi didn't send his daughter to Harvard on just his official salary after all); that the NYT was just rubbing it in their face. At no point did the argument against the NYT go to false or fake data. WSJ, Bloomberg, etc...have all been banned on stories that the Chinese never tried to seriously refute. It was more about face than fact.