4 ms·
Elevators have pretty good safety mechanisms. Even cutting the cable wouldn't have killed anyone. I'd probably leave too, but just because I wouldn't want to g
by icebraining 9y ago
Elevators have pretty good safety mechanisms. Even cutting the cable wouldn't have killed anyone.
I'd probably leave too, but just because I wouldn't want to get stuck inside it if it stopped in the middle of two floors, especially since it was full. But for fear of death? Nah.
From Wikipedia: "In fact, prior to the September 11th terrorist attacks, the only known free-fall incident in a modern cable-borne elevator happened in 1945 when a B-25 bomber struck the Empire State Building in fog, severing the cables of an elevator cab, which fell from the 75th floor all the way to the bottom of the building, seriously injuring (though not killing) the sole occupant — the elevator operator. (...) In Thailand, in November 2012, a woman was killed in free falling elevator, in what was reported as the "first legally recognised death caused by a falling lift".
That's a pretty good safety record. Certainly much better than stairs.
- mrob 9y agoalrs was probably in no real danger, but why should they be expected to memorize the exact risk profile of every mechanism they're exposed to? In practice we delegate most risk management to government regulation. It would be very time consuming to evaluate everything on a case by case basis. It's a reasonable heuristic to assume things are safe when they act as they usually do and dangerous when they act differently. Weird behavior is a sign that the regulations might have failed, and weird behavior is by definition rare, so the cost of avoiding it is likely lower than the cost of calculating the true danger.
- icebraining 9y agoI'm not saying alrs should. The decision to leave is reasonable. The decision to judge others ("What is wrong with people?") is not.
- namelost 9y agoThat depends whether the other occupants knew about the safety features and record of elevators. If they did, then they were making a sound judgement. If they didn't, then they were being completely reckless.
- icebraining 9y agoI guess it's possible the parent poster took a poll before leaving the elevator, but I have to say I find it unlikely.
- musage 9y agoThey're saying they think it was unreasonable to stay, you say it was reasonable to leave. Both are judgements about the decisions of others.
- icebraining 9y agoI don't think all judgements about the decisions of others are equivalent. Do you?
- marcosscriven 9y agoThe gym I used to go to had an incident with someone being killed by the lift falling: http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1278427/Health-club-fined-250k-banker-crushed-death-lift-shaft.html http://www.dailymail.co.uk/news/article-1278427/Health-club-... Admittedly it’s rare, and personally I wouldn’t be worried about it as a liklihood.
- amelius 9y agoApparently, in that case it was in fact a good idea to avoid the elevator after it started failing: > Too much had gone wrong for too long with the lift at Broadgate Health Club in the City of London before it dropped on March 12, 2003, killing Polish-born Katarzyna Woja, Southwark Crown Court in London was told.