4 ms·
Trump administration FEMA says it's "not our job" [1] to distribute food/water in PR. Trump administration has also declined to extend the Jones Act exemption
by r00fus 9y ago
Trump administration FEMA says it's "not our job" [1] to distribute food/water in PR. Trump administration has also declined to extend the Jones Act exemption allowing non-US built ships to send aid tariff/tax free [2].
Therefore non-US approved international aid incurs fees/taxes. So we don't treat Puerto Ricans as US Citizens but don't allow other countries to assist without impounding taxes and duties on the supplies.
Willful negligence.
[1] https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2017/10/10/1705685/-FEMA-Not-our-job-to-deliver-water-and-food-to-Puerto-Ricans-Think-I-am-making-this-up-Wrong https://www.dailykos.com/stories/2017/10/10/1705685/-FEMA-No...
[2] https://www.cbsnews.com/news/dhs-will-let-jones-act-waiver-for-puerto-rico-expire/ https://www.cbsnews.com/news/dhs-will-let-jones-act-waiver-f...
- m52go 9y agoThere's more to the story. Don't get caught up in propaganda rooted in domestic American politics (i.e., #theresistance). It's a disservice to the people of Puerto Rico. Report that Puerto Rican mayors were holding supplies for political gain: https://www.metro.pr/pr/noticias/2017/10/09/fiscalia-federal-confirma-pesquisa-alcaldes-se-apropian-ayuda-fema.html https://www.metro.pr/pr/noticias/2017/10/09/fiscalia-federal... First-hand account corroborating report above: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Uc1pPsKt_s https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5Uc1pPsKt_s EDIT: it's fair to question the authenticity of the video, but the article simply announces an investigation. Not sure what's "racist" or "nonsensical" about posting that.
- octonion 9y agoWhy would you post this nonsensical, racist garbage? What is wrong with you?
- drawkbox 9y agoIt is classic propaganda "whataboutism"[1]. Very popular in the Cold War and in modern day Russian botnets. Crazy enough, it was also popular this last election. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Whataboutism
- sergiotapia 9y agoWhat is racist about his comment? Are we at the point where we can just shout whatever we want with no need for logic, you pedophile?
- KekDemaga 9y agoIt used to be capitolists called political opposition communists now communists call political opposition racist.
- maxerickson 9y agoYou mean "recording of anonymous radio call in". It might be a first hand account, the video does nothing to establish the veracity of the account, or to establish that the person giving the account is informed (vs speculating/parroting rumors). I have no idea what the situation is on the ground, I'm commenting on the quality of the evidence you have presented.
- m52go 9y agoThat's fair--I edited my comment accordingly.
- mikeash 9y agoI'm fascinated and scared of this "the buck stops anywhere but here" attitude displayed by the administration and its supporters. Aren't leaders supposed to have ultimate responsibility?
- ensignavenger 9y agoThe US President is not the leader of every facet of the US. He is Commander in Chief of the Military and head of the Executive Branch, but outside of those domains, he is not the 'leader'.
- mikeash 9y agoPuerto Rico is a territory under the direct control of the US federal government, and the executive branch of that government is the appropriate one to handle short-term emergency relief. So while your comment is correct, I don't see the relevance.
- ensignavenger 9y agoI am not familiar with the specifics of the political/legal situation. Based on Wikipedia, it sounds like Executive Agencies such as FEMA treat Puerto Rico as they would a state, to the extinct possible. FEMA is not responsible for every aspect of emergency response in a state. Puerto Rico even has their own National Guard, which is under the command of the governor, and traditionally bears much of the burden for the footwork in disaster response situations (supplementing the permanent resources). FEMA then provides aid to support local agencies in the immediate aftermath and then funding for recovery efforts. (FEMA also provides resources to support local emergency preparedness efforts, but it is a bit late for that now). I may be wrong, I am certainly no expert, but this is what I have learned from reading about it and what I have observed from other disasters and come to expect of the ways things generally work in the US. FEMA has been accused of negligence and incompetence as far back as I can remember, under presidents of both parties- usually the loudest by those of the party opposite the current president. Are there specific accusations of things FEMA isn't doing that they have done in other areas that would help in PR?
- forapurpose 9y agoIf you want to call someone else's statements 'propaganda', please provide evidence of it. Without it, the word has no meaning. Why is the GP, in particular, propaganda? It's substantiated with good sources. Someone could as easily call your statements "proganda' and dismiss them. I could declare every comment on this thread or everything anyone says that disagrees with me to be propaganda. But what does the word mean at that point? Nothing - it becomes just a sound I make when I don't like something. Getting down to evidence: On the Internet, we can find links to support any claim; metro.pr and someone's YouTube upload are not particularly persuasive to me - is there a better source? Also, if true, I'm not sure of the point of it - what does the conduct of Puerto Rican mayors have to do with the GP's post? If some mayors are behaving badly, it's ok for the federal government to fail in its responsibilities? It's an impossible standard. Let the government without sin throw the first stone ...
- m52go 9y agoTo be clear, I didn't meant to call the GP's statements propaganda. I meant to call the barrage of anti-Trump media propaganda, because that's typically what one calls anything that's almost exclusively one-sided. It seemed to me that GP's statements were rooted in such media reports, which doesn't mean the GP's statements are propaganda, but could mean they aren't entirely true. I should have been more specific there. I don't know what the actual situation is on the ground, and I'm not claiming I know what it is either. I'm simply questioning the prevailing narrative: specifically, that the US federal government did less than it could have, leaving the Puerto Rican government stranded for resources in an unbelievably difficult time. Fpr example, FEMA reports indicate a LOT was being done [0, 1] WHILE reports spun it another way [2]. Is [2] flat-out wrong? Not necessarily, but it's clearly trying to get people to think in a certain way. Granted, the source of my video source is not clear. But the metro.pr article I cited merely states the announcement of an investigation into Puerto Rican distribution of crisis resources...it makes no other notable claims. The company behind this publication is a multi-national media firm that publishes newspapers in 19 countries. While it may not be recognized here in the States, it's not some rinky-dink blog someone threw up for clickz. [0] https://www.fema.gov/news-release/2017/09/23/federal-government-moving-resources-support-puerto-rico-and-us-virgin https://www.fema.gov/news-release/2017/09/23/federal-governm... [1] https://www.fema.gov/news-release/2017/09/24/federal-response-teams-assisting-puerto-rico-and-us-virgin-islands https://www.fema.gov/news-release/2017/09/24/federal-respons... [2] https://www.facebook.com/NowThisPolitics/videos/1719745518056931/ https://www.facebook.com/NowThisPolitics/videos/171974551805...
- turbohedgehog 9y agoTo be clear, the Jones Act allows other countries to use their ships to go direct to PR, but they can't use their ships to ferry goods from the US mainland to PR.
- Aloha 9y agoThe Jones act only prevents cabotage[1], which is to say shipping something between two places in the same country. It in no way prevents the Dominican Republic from shipping supplies or people, or any other country for that matter in shipping stuff there. It's my opinion that while the Jones Act probably does increase the cost of shipping goods two and from the island, its not a magic catchall fixit - and beyond that, every report I've read makes it clear we've enough stuff there to take care of people, but its not making it from the places where it landed, to the places where people are - and therefor complaints about the Jones Act seem mostly to be political haymaking - as the old saying goes, never let a good crisis go to waste. [1] - https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabotage https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Cabotage
- forapurpose 9y agoInteresting thoughts but ... > It's my opinion that while the Jones Act probably does increase the cost of shipping goods two and from the island, its not a magic catchall fixit No offense, but based on what? And then what is the impact of the Jones Act? If you have expertise in that industry to support the analysis, that would be great. Could you link to some of these reports?
- mikeyouse 9y agoThe Federal Reserve thinks that it doubles the price of shipping between Puerto Rico and the US Mainland: > It costs an estimated $3,063 to ship a twenty-foot container of household and commercial goods from the East Coast of the United States to Puerto Rico; the same shipment costs $1,504 to nearby Santo Domingo (Dominican Republic) and $1,687 to Kingston (Jamaica)—destinations that are not subject to Jones Act restrictions. Page 23 in the PDF (numbered 13): https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/regional/PuertoRico/report.pdf https://www.newyorkfed.org/medialibrary/media/regional/Puert... Terrible for disaster relief but also on a daily level, terrible for imports/exports. How can you have a competitive economy with that type of anchor weighing on your Ex/Im?
- Aloha 9y ago
- nradov 9y agoThe Jones Act was never an obstacle to Puerto Rico disaster relief. Supplies were delivered by ship but then stacked up in ports due to lack of trucks. Suspending the Jones Act won't conjure up more trucks and drivers. http://gcaptain.com/american-maritime-industry-fights-back-false-claims-regarding-jones-act-relief-efforts-puerto-rico/ http://gcaptain.com/american-maritime-industry-fights-back-f...
- true_religion 9y agoThe objection was that smaller ships flying foreign flags could be used to ferry supplies around Puerto Rico, using ports, and waterways that the large US-flag supply ships could not. Instead the Jone's Act ensures only large ports will be used, which leads to a backlog because PR's infrastructure is shot.
- nradov 9y agoThat doesn't make any sense. There are many small US flagged and crewed vessels around the southeast mainland coast. For example, the Gulf oil industry has idle work boats available. Anyone willing to pay the charter fees can hire them today and immediately start moving cargo.
- leereeves 9y agoDo you have another source for that Daily KOS story? Daily KOS based that article on a video from Rachael Maddow, but she's not credible. PolitiFact rated 48% of her statements that they reviewed "false", "mostly false", or "pants on fire". http://www.politifact.com/personalities/rachel-maddow/ http://www.politifact.com/personalities/rachel-maddow/ Perhaps the most egregious example, she once falsely claimed a political candidate had advance notice of the Oklahoma City bombing. https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2010/10/maddow-falsely-claims-politician-had-advance-warning-of-oklahoma-city-bombing/64870/ https://www.theatlantic.com/politics/archive/2010/10/maddow-...