9 ms·
Western news about China depends on intrepid Chinese ‘news assistants’
- friendwithwifi 9y agoChina under Xi Jinping has effectively turned into a dicatatorship, and so with a dictatorship, censorship and blackouts naturally comes along with it. That's the reason why Beijing has recently cracked down on VPN, sent many of the young, brave democratic protestors in Hong Kong to prison, silenced many of its Xi critics, etc. Will China suffer from the censorship and blackouts? As discussed heavily on HN, probably. Then again, it is most likely that China is already suffering through its own turbulence. Its economy is standing perilously on shadow debt (its going through its own 2007 real estate bubble deflation), while it engages in heavy protectionism - it recently disallowed South Korean companies from moving its assets out of the country, and its citizens, suffering from massive inflation in food and real estate, pollution, dirty water and food, are suffering.
- vkou 9y ago> China under Xi Jinping has effectively turned into a dicatatorship How was it not one before Xi Jinping?
- QAPereo 9y agoPreviously it was a sort of vaguely Maoist gerontocracy; power was concentrated in some central committees, not just the premier.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoYou mean party secretary. The premier is Li Keqiang, who is pretty powerless, at least compared to Wen Jiabao.
- QAPereo 9y agoYou’re right, my bad!
- vkou 9y agoWhat difference does it make to the common people, or to political activists, that power is spread out among the leaders of dozen CCP committees, versus a single man? The police will continue to repress, the press committees will continue to censor...
- QAPereo 9y agoDictators tend to collapse along with the stability of their countries. The more distributed power is, the more stable it is. China was already a huge country with massively centralized power. Now it’s still huge, but the power is concentrated in just one man, and thats even more unstable. So... worse crackdowns, even less freedom, and a much worse and less potentially flexible long term trajectory. Edit: to be clear I am not endorsing either system, just describing them as accurately as possible.
- owebmaster 9y agoThe secret is to continue raising the standard of living of the people as fast as it's been raising in the past 2 decades.
- stevenwoo 9y agoI thought the problem with that is that it is literally impossible to continue the trajectory.
- owebmaster 9y agoIt might be a better time to say this when the strategy start to fail but this seems like american wishful thinking as China keeps growing strongly.
- matt4077 9y agoThere's a case to be made that a government by a large number of committees and other institutions tends to be more benevolent. Many of the worst actions of repressive regimes have usually been motivated by emotions, not expediency. As more people get involved, the chance of any single personal obsession resulting in crass harm to, for example, a certain group of citizen is lowered. Competition for power among people and/or these institutions also results in a sort of crude "checks and balances". There are too many people with considerable power that it becomes impossible for all of them to move billions to Switzerland, and if only a few do so, they risk being taken down by others who get jealous. Of course, as China shows, this is still far below the standards set by real rule of law. But compare China with the half-bit dictators (Qaddafi, Barack Hussein) and it's hard to deny that it's not quite that bad.
- seanmcdirmid 9y agoXi is a strongish leader, almost as strong as Jiang zemin. Compared to Hu Jintao, he is much stronger, but this is mostly a return to normalcy.
- owebmaster 9y ago> sent many of the young, brave democratic protestors in Hong Kong to prison, silenced many of its Xi critics, etc. The crackdown on black people and BLM is very similar, but a lot more violent.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dilemma 9y agoThis is what you can't say in America - that the "democracy" is not so democratic.
- JumpCrisscross 9y ago> This is what you can't say in America Yes you can. You just did. It’s a stupid thing to say, in the same vein as likening the Civil Rights Movement to contemporaneous protests under Diem’s regime in Vietnam or the Cultural Revolution in China. But we have the First Amendment and courts to defend it. It’s not perfect, but it’s miles apart from a full security crackdown.
- dilemma 9y agoNo, you can't say it because it is heresy and a social faux pas. Additionally, just see what happens when you actually stand up to the American political power - the fates of MLK and Malcolm X, and in more recent times Manning etc. And on HN, you get massively downvoted so your post disappears.
- JumpCrisscross 9y agoYou’re equating downvotes with getting thrown in jail and exfiltraring conventional military secrets (video from a military aircraft, i.e. Manning) with expressing politically unpopular views in a public, civilian forum. Keep in mind, too, that we actually got civil rights laws passed and enforced, irrespective of what happened to MLK or Malcom X. That isn’t the case in repressive regimes.
- odiroot 9y ago> That's the reason why Beijing has recently cracked down on VPN. This is completely unrelated to Xi's reign. The point is to keep the population "harmonious" before the Communist Party congress that starts next week.
- kiba 9y agoFrom my perspective, it looked like China will overtake the world and maybe prove that democracy is optional for economic prosperity, a blow to Western values and ideal. But how true is that? I hear a lot about corruption and crackdown, and wonder how much does that impact their economy. How critical is good information about the world? Do Western Media do a good job of it, or at least a better one than those in less democratic societies?
- rukittenme 9y ago> maybe prove that democracy is optional for economic prosperity That was never in question. It's been known since at least Tocqueville and certainly long before that. "I admit that, in a democratic State thus constituted, society will not be stationary; but the impulses of the social body may be regulated and directed forwards; if there be less splendor than in the halls of an aristocracy, the contrast of misery will be less frequent also; the pleasures of enjoyment may be less excessive, but those of comfort will be more general; the sciences may be less perfectly cultivated, but ignorance will be less common; the impetuosity of the feelings will be repressed, and the habits of the nation softened; there will be more vices and fewer crimes. In the absence of enthusiasm and of an ardent faith, great sacrifices may be obtained from the members of a commonwealth by an appeal to their understandings and their experience; each individual will feel the same necessity for uniting with his fellow-citizens to protect his own weakness; and as he knows that if they are to assist he must co-operate, he will readily perceive that his personal interest is identified with the interest of the community. The nation, taken as a whole, will be less brilliant, less glorious, and perhaps less strong; but the majority of the citizens will enjoy a greater degree of prosperity, and the people will remain quiet, not because it despairs of amelioration, but because it is conscious of the advantages of its condition. If all the consequences of this state of things were not good or useful, society would at least have appropriated all such as were useful and good; and having once and for ever renounced the social advantages of aristocracy, mankind would enter into possession of all the benefits which democracy can afford."
- Cyph0n 9y agoThey might take over the world (I think it's unlikely), but in my opinion, the main reason isn't their political system: it's human capital (1/7 of the world population) and homogeneity (very cohesive culture due to China's history). Western countries lack the former, India and others lack the latter.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]