4 ms·
Despite the huge fans and heatsinks on modern desktop GPUs, I presume that a GPU would still use less energy than a CPU for the same workload, yes? Do mobile GP
by kibwen 9y ago
Despite the huge fans and heatsinks on modern desktop GPUs, I presume that a GPU would still use less energy than a CPU for the same workload, yes? Do mobile GPUs have a sleep mode comparable to mobile CPUs? Completely agreed that some measurements would be nice.
- TylerE 9y agoA modern high-end GPU can draw upwards of 200w. Edit: Not sure why I'm being downvoted for stating a simple fact. The top-of-the-line AMD and NVidia cards have TDPs of 200-250w.
- 0xffff2 9y agoYour comment is both true and utterly irrelevant to the person you replied to who asked about comparison between CPU and GPU efficiency. The important information to answer the question is how much power the GPU will use, not how much it can use.
- lightedman 9y agoBut how much it can use gives you an upper limit on how much it will use. To boot, that also gives you an idea of how much power one can expect to draw under full load at any given time over any given time frame.
- imtringued 9y agoHigh end desktop CPUs draw around 90W and 200W GPUs can do one or two orders of magnitude more computation in specialised workloads than CPUs.
- ChoGGi 9y agoTDP for the i9-7980 is 165W, and the 1080ti is at 250W
- pohl 9y agoThe Radeon Pro 560 on my MacBook Pro can draw "up to 75W". I don't know anything about how it manages power, but I do recall that Apple recommended in a WWDC session on writing energy-efficient apps that one should be careful to not trigger the discrete GPU when the integrated Intel GPU is sufficient. So that leads to another question: on my machine, which GPU would Webrender be using? I suppose I could find out experimentally, but I thought I'd ask in case someone here knows.
- epmaybe 9y agoSince the 15" MBP charger can deliver up to 87W, if you have full power draw on the MBP will you actually not be able to fully supply power over AC? I assume that the CPU also takes up around 20-30W.
- metajack 9y agoFor WebRender, we targeted the integrated GPUs. You still need some logic to ensure you don't accidentally kick the discrete one into gear, but the integrated ones definitely have enough performance for almost anything WR will throw at it.