5 ms·
I feel calling all 8 of these companies "analytics" is a little unfair. Pusher is a SaaS product for websockets and push notifications. I think it's reasonable
by danpalmer 9y ago
I feel calling all 8 of these companies "analytics" is a little unfair.
Pusher is a SaaS product for websockets and push notifications. I think it's reasonable that a company like CircleCI might outsource this instead of maintaining the infrastructure for it in-house.
Launch Darkly is a feature flagging service. While I feel the value is much less than Pusher (and I'd be inclined to just build an in-house solution), I think it's still a relatively reasonable tool to use to create a better user experience.
Intercom when used for customer communication is also something that I feel I'd want as a user, although this could perhaps only be loaded when requested by the user.
- tptacek 9y agoWhy does this matter? Most 3rd party services are "reasonable" in some setting. When you build a highly-sensitive application, the bar for reasonableness changes.
- 45h34jh53k4j 9y agoThis is a world where internet banking and healthcare, arguably the canonical 'highly-sensitive applications', are using 3rd party js services like this. I think we need to redefine 'reasonable' as the industry clearly isn't acting reasonably (IMHO).
- xorcist 9y agoThere is no reason to accept that your bank runs javascript from third parties. Complain and use only in an environment where you can block them. While it may seem futile to report these transgressions to big institutions, the fact that your complaints are logged helps those fighting these stupidities from the inside.
- avip 9y agoThe overwhelming majority of online financial services would self-host everything. It's not strictly a PCI-DSS compliance requirement, but it is common sense and industry standard.
- zAy0LfpBZLC8mAC 9y agoYou wish!
- rhizome 9y agoSo, startups and companies hire for standard, coglike (CTCI) CS skills, yet they outsource basic functionality. There should be a corollary to NIH Syndrome[1] that takes into account 3rd party APIs. The way I see it, it's not about reinventing the wheel, it's about having your house in order. 1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_invented_here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Not_invented_here
- convolvatron 9y agoif you can't even _run your own software to perform tests_ then maybe you should reconsider developing software
- johnksawers 9y agoWhether we can run the tests ourselves, and whether we want to spend the engineering time to build and/or maintain an in-house CI system are two very different questions. Whether a developer (or business person) made a business decision to outsource CI has nothing to do with technical competence. Using SaaS for any business data has a risk, but usually it's worth it. I'm sure you use slack, slack could be breached, and I'm sure no one at your company has ever slacked a password to someone else.
- bdcravens 9y ago> whether we want to spend the engineering time to build and/or maintain an in-house CI system are two very different questions Developers tend to trivialize this: we tend to only consider the initial setup time, and pretend no further work is necessary.
- iamdave 9y agoI've been spending the last year unravelling a ball of yarn wrapped in another ball of yarn because of "guy before me" syndrome who believed this. Fully.
- convolvatron 9y ago
- ballenf 9y agoI feel like narrowing down what any of those companies could do to what they are doing today irresponsible. And analytics is one of the could-do's that many third party tools do offer or add on later to increase monetization or perceived value to customers. The important point is that there are now 8 attack surfaces instead of 1. Whether they're analytics or pad-string doesn't really matter.
- danpalmer 9y agoI agree there are now 8 attack surfaces, but to call all 8 "analytics" I does not think does justice to the reasons why CircleCI may have chosen to use some of them.
- imtringued 9y ago>The important point is that there are now 8 attack surfaces instead of 1. That's the best case scenario. What if these 8 companies also give the source code to other companies?