11 ms·
Intel Coffee Lake Core i7-8700K review
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- atom_enger 9y agoDoes this remind anybody of Intel Pentium 4 Prescott? https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_4#Prescott https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pentium_4#Prescott Intel claimed that NetBurst would allow clock speeds of up to 10 GHz in future chips; however, severe problems with heat dissipation (especially with the Prescott Pentium 4) limited CPU clock speeds to a much lower 3.8 GHz
- smitherfield 9y agoIn what way?
- jandrese 9y agoPresumably in relation to power draw? The 8700K seems kind of like one of those "Overclocked straight from the factory" deals that you see a lot with Video cards.
- atom_enger 9y agoIntel's historical response has been run it hotter when AMD introduces something that's competitive.
- GrumpyNl 9y agoThe issue with heat.
- olavgg 9y agoYeah I wonder how hot it gets when doing matrix multiplications with numpy. My i6700K starts throttling within a few seconds, with air cooling rated for 130w. Though for gaming it is most likely a dream.
- dom0 9y agoHeat dissipation has been problematic for Intel not just with the recent 2066 disaster but way before that. Most Haswell desktop processors are not that easy to keep from throttling. This is exaggerated by large temperature gradients of 15 °C and more across the cores, and obviously the hottest core is limiting overall performance.
- jandrese 9y agoThe fact that you can significantly improve the thermals by delidding the processor and replacing the TIM is really an embarrassment for Intel, especially on >$200 chips.
- apk-d 9y agoI'm curious, does this mean that upgrading the cooling is an alternative to overclocking (better heat dissipation -> longer performance bursts) or is the effect negligible in practice?
- kar1181 9y agoI was thinking about this the other day when I first started reading the Coffee Lake reviews. This thing runs toasty. Yeah it's fast, but it's hot enough to boil water faster than a US kettle. I hope the next step on Zen really closes the gap. It's only then we're going to be set for some real innovation from intel.
- revelation 9y agoSomeone overclocked an i9 to 6 GHz and it consumed a cool 1 kW: https://youtu.be/_alRb9dMQjQ?t=14m48s https://youtu.be/_alRb9dMQjQ?t=14m48s
- danieldisu 9y agoSo... great benchmarks but they couldn't even gain more than +2 average fps in most games compared to last gen 7700. The title makes you believe that it has some serious gains over previous gens but nope. I wonder how much Intel paid for this review...
- epmaybe 9y agoThe title? "The best gaming CPU you can buy". Not sure how that indicates "serious" gains, but you keep on telling yourself that Intel influenced them into use that title.
- vogon_laureate 9y agoArsTechnica is hardly 'pop tech'. Their technical analysis is reliably high calibre, they do excellent benchmarking and thorough testing, and they also do some stellar long-form science journalism. I can't really see how you could say that.
- pitaj 9y agoThink you replied to the wrong person.
- dabockster 9y agoSome games have microcode optimizations that specifically target Intel processors. So it makes sense that, as things stand currently, Intel has the advantage. Give it a year or two for AMD to solidify Ryzen in the consumer market, and we should see the real playing field emerge.
- piyh 9y agoMicrocode optimization looks awfully similar to better single threaded performance.
- AriaMinaei 9y agoA sentence can be technically accurate and practically misleading at the same time. I would think twice before defending something on technicality alone.
- throwaway2048 9y agoIt would be a great CPU if you could buy it, it is very much a paper launch, seems significant quantities wont be available until Q1/2 2018. No retailers I checked have it in stock. https://www.kitguru.net/components/cpu/damien-cox/intels-coffee-lake-to-possibly-face-shortage/ https://www.kitguru.net/components/cpu/damien-cox/intels-cof...
- kpil 9y ago"The marginally better gaming CPU, that you can't buy until next year." Not as catchy.
- 0xcde4c3db 9y agoRight; I don't think this is practically a product launch so much as a "please don't buy Ryzen" marketing campaign.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoi wonder if we'll be forced to buy an iMac Pro to get this chip in a mac
- jclardy 9y agoI doubt it, since iMac Pro's will be running Xeon processors.
- wmf 9y agoI expect the regular iMac to have Coffee Lake and the iMac Pro to have Skylake-X Xeon W.
- HillaryBriss 9y agoah. the Xeon goes on the heavy workstation. got it. thanks.
- std_throwaway 9y agoMore accurately: The best gaming CPU you can't buy.
- AquaMorph 9y agoThat's so true. I currently have three orders opened from three different sites
- std_throwaway 9y agoEdit: The title was edited and "The best gaming CPU you can buy." was removed. Smart move.
- seanalltogether 9y agoIt seems that most games are not cpu limited if you're anywhere under 80 fps. You really have to crack into super high frame rates to bottleneck on the cpu.
- dvlsg 9y agoDepends on the game, too. Guild wars 2 annihilates my i5-4670.
- alfredxing 9y agoBeing limited by CPU/GPU depends a lot on what kind of hardware you have for each. For example, I have a 1070 and an i5-4690k and I'm CPU limited in some games (below 80-100fps)
- vbezhenar 9y agoIt's probably a truth, but I'm playing almost exclusively WoW and it's known that even 7700K wasn't able to sustain 60 FPS in hard conditions, limited by CPU single-thread. So for some games single-thread performance is all that matters, unfortunately and it pushed into Intel direction if you want the best configuration.
- bhouston 9y agoIt seems like an out of the box overclocked 7700k with more cores. The article says it can not really be further overclocked without liquid cooling. That does suggest it is out of the box overclocked as compared to previous chips. Does its hotness reduce its lifespan? But that weirdness aside, nice to see the additional cores, that Intel stayed at 4 cores for the desktop for so long has been unfortunate.
- sddfd 9y ago> that Intel stayed at 4 cores for the desktop for so long has been unfortunate That's why my next cpu will be AMD: Intel needs competition to stay sharp.
- vbezhenar 9y agoI think that the part of the problem is thermopaste between crystal and cover. It limits amount of heat that cooler can dissipate, therefore limiting possible overclocking options. Delidding should be easy enough with good tools, so I would consider it as an option if you want to overclock. It would void warranty, but overclocking voids warranty anyway, so it shouldn't be a problem.
- mtgx 9y agoHaven't read yet, but did they test for gaming stuttering, too, or just synthetic benchmarks? From what I've seen AMD's new Ryzen CPUs do better in maintaining a constant framerate than Intel's CPUs, possibly because AMD's SMT implementation and the switching between threads is better than Intel's. Also this Intel CPU seems to run hot, which means this is a compromise Intel made to be able to "win" these benchmarks. I wonder what sort of problems that will create in the day to day use of it, or in the long term (dying more quickly?) Finally, like someone else said, this won't be available for purchase for most people until early 2018. By then AMD's updated Ryzen CPUs should be out. Strange that Intel would give out its chips almost half a year earlier for review...
- kllrnohj 9y agoThe title's enthusiasm is completely out of whack from the actual review. From the cons section (and this is in line with other reviews of the chip) "Coffee Lake is the third "optimisation" of an existing architecture with no IPC improvement" The performance gains exclusively come from the small bump in clock frequency which you could trivially get with a minor OC on the previous gen(s), and from 2 extra cores in multithreading tests (no real impact to games currently). If you're already in the market for a new CPU and motherboard it should be on the short list. If you're not already in the market this won't make you want to upgrade. It also means the 2- & 4- core Coffee Lake chips have no redeeming qualities over what came before, hardly a smashing success. Side note it seems the author isn't even able to read their own charts? The author lists as a con "The 8700K runs very hot and pulls a lot of watts" but the 8700k was the lowest power consuming chip in the entire lineup that they compared it against. It has a similar power consumption to the 7700k and comes in at ~90w under load. That's peanuts for this category of CPUs.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- dabockster 9y ago> with no IPC improvement Unacceptable. It's now 5+ years since major improvements. And they released a new socket too, breaking upgrade paths. Meanwhile, my Ryzen 1600 is overclocked at 4ghz and running smoothly with 6 cores/12 threads. Intel better release something worthwhile soon. AMD is well into its comeback.
- RandomInteger4 9y agoThis is a random tangent, but I've been meaning to build my first PC and was thinking of going with Ryzen. Do you by any chance run Linux or Linux dev tools on it and if so have you experienced hard crashing issues that I've been reading about?
- floatboth 9y agoCompiling a ton of stuff on my R7 1700, never encountered any issues. (But with LLVM on FreeBSD, not gcc on Linux.)
- userbinator 9y agoIt's odd that, despite the big emphasis on increased power consumption in the review, the TDP is still specified as only 95W. I was expecting something much higher, at least in the 130-140W range. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_CPU_power_dissipation_figures#Intel_Core_i7 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_CPU_power_dissipation_...
- trynumber9 9y agoIn measurements it is often worse: http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-coffee-lake-i7-8700k-cpu,5252-12.html http://www.tomshardware.com/reviews/intel-coffee-lake-i7-870...
- diab0lic 9y agoTo call this "the best gaming CPU you can buy" is a bit disingenuous. A $379 processor which can turbo boost up to 4.7GHz is pretty impressive. It is however still limited to 16 PCIe lanes which means you get one GPU at PCIe 3.0 x16 and are very limited in the additional expansion cards you can run. Sure there are additional lanes for a single NVMe disk and the motherboard's onboard components but: Want to add a PCIe x1 wifi card? Your GPU now runs at 8x. Want to add a second GPU? They're both running at 8x. This is a pretty solid processor for the most common use case of single high end GPU + everything else built into the motherboard (including wifi) but that is far from the "best gaming CPU you can buy." I have friends who are going threadripper for the additional PCIe lanes, I know it belongs in a different price class but this is about the best CPU not the most cost efficient -- I suspect this processor would not land in the best bang for buck category either.
- vbezhenar 9y agoWhat's the difference between x16 and x8 for gaming GPU? Textures will load for 0.25 seconds instead of 0.125 seconds at startup? I was under impression that there's virtually no gain for games with x16 compared to x8.
- diab0lic 9y agoIt seems you're right, at least as recently as last year [0] the difference seems very negligible. I had read that it was in 2013 but had assumed increases in GPU speeds exacerbated the effect. [0] https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/2488-pci-e-3-x8-vs-x16-performance-impact-on-gpus https://www.gamersnexus.net/guides/2488-pci-e-3-x8-vs-x16-pe...
- compton_effect 9y agoTo add on, even pcie 3.0 x4 has plenty of bandwidth for a gtx 1080. https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/NVIDIA/GeForce_GTX_1080_PCI_Express_Scaling/25.html https://www.techpowerup.com/reviews/NVIDIA/GeForce_GTX_1080_... This is the same reason why nvidia didn't bother with HBM for the 10 series. Those gpu's do not need that much memory bandwidth and in most cases GDDR5 provides plenty of bandwidth as it is.
- snicky 9y agoIf you are buying a CPU for gaming you would be better off with i5-8400 which is half the price and performs equally well in most games. Oh, and it comes with a stock cooler (8600k and 8700k don't).
- MrMember 9y agoWhen did Intel stop including fans with some of their processors? The last processor I bought was a k branded i5 in 2012ish and it came with a fan.
- zanny 9y agoAMD doesn't include coolers with their X chips either. It makes sense, you really only should buy those chips if you intend to overclock, and you won't get a reasonable OC on stock heatsinks. As long as they were including those heatsinks they were just wasting the aluminum almost every sale.
- panopticon 9y agoA few of generations now. I was looking at replacing my aging 2600K with something in this generation and was surprised as well.
- jandrese 9y agoIt's just on the -K processors, because those are the one that are unlocked for overclocking. If you're not planning to overclock there's no point in paying more for the -K.
- vbezhenar 9y agoK series provide faster boost rate, so they are faster without any overclocking. Also overclocking voids warranty, so I'm not sure if many buyers are really going to overclock it.
- katastic 9y ago"The best gaming CPU you can buy"--if you've never heard of AMD or even looked at other Intel CPUs. It's basically just an ad.
- mmanfrin 9y agoAMD is still at least a generation behind. They're more competitive in terms of $/perf value, but the i7-7700K still beats all the new AMD chips except in heavy-MC tasks, which gaming is not (outside of maybe GTA V).
- katastic 9y agoI agree they're a gen behind. However, my thesis statement would be, that's not that big a deal for 99% of people: - CPU speeds aren't increasing quickly anymore. Last gen and current gen are often like 20% different. - Most people (should?) care more about "Best performance I can get, for the price I can afford." You have $100/$200 in your budget, and you buy the best CPU you can when your old CPU can't run modern games. And AMD fits that quite nicely. - Very few games "don't run" on an AMD. Heck, a last-gen AMD even. PUBG is notoriously under-optimized and my FX-8370 runs it just fine even though my "single-threaded" performance is complete crap compared to "the best of the best" Intel has to offer. But a company would have to be insane or stupid, to design their games to only run on CPU's that cost >$400. The barrier-to-entry is too high. - Furthermore, since I/we have to upgrade every couple years, I'd rather not buy a $600-800 CPU that's worth $25 in a few years. I'd rather pay $200 for a CPU that's worth $25 in a few years. You may think I'm exaggerating (and perhaps slightly) but I've literally had Xeon workstations and servers that were worth thousands and their CPU can be found... for $25 on eBay. I think it's great that many people have much larger disposable incomes than I do. Geniunely, I'm happy for them. But spending >$600 on what will eventually be a glorified room heater / paper-weight seems very wasteful. I'm all about the best I can get, for a reasonable sum of money, and AMD (and Intel when they compete on similar models!) fits into that realm. These "enthusiest" grade CPUs are so expensive (and even worse the MOTHERBOARDS are >$300 for an i9 or Threadripper!) that they might as well be fictional. I'll never see one in real-life in the same way I'll never drive a Bughatti, so (in my opinion) they're not relevant in your usual collection of datapoints. You wouldn't compare a possible Toyota Camry to a Lambo and think "Well, the Lambo is so much faster, which is important for my calculations on a possible grocery getter car." I currently play PUBG in 2560x1440 with my gens old, AMD FX-8370, and a GTX 1060. I could "almost" get 4K but it's only like 20-30 FPS. So if I've got eight-cores (4 of which I use to run a full Win10 VM with SQL server), using a one/two gen old CPU, and I can play the most modern games... what's the benefit? Higher FPS? Sure. But the problem is, the cost-to-benefit ratio (higher CPU $$ vs FPS) quickly goes to zero. You're not getting much more to be "ahead of the technology curve." As long as you're high enough in the curve to not be "unable to play modern games" you're set. If you spend bigger money you're not actually increasing your longevity of your workstation by much. The next gen will still make your "upper end" previous gen look like crap--especially when you consider the premium price you paid. It would be much better to just be patient, and buy the current gen, when the next gen comes out. My current CPU dropped to HALF the price the second Ryzen came out, and is 2nd to the top in terms of performance-per-dollar: https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_value_available.html https://www.cpubenchmark.net/cpu_value_available.html My CPU has a mark of ~9000 and costs $100 and the highest i7 is 20,000. (~2x) and costs... $1,600. 16 times the price for 2 times the performance and we can still play the same games. I'm considering (and saving for) a Ryzen build... except I'm waiting till Ryzen 1.5 (<-actual thing) and 2.0 come out. I don't need to upgrade my machine to "be cool." My machine is a tool, and as long as it does what I want, it's fine. It compiles fast, it easily runs >180 chrome tabs, and can run a VM and a video game at the same time. What's more to want? If it's video encoding, the SSD's I have are 10x more important than the CPU.
- dom0 9y ago> Despite the similarities between Coffee Lake and Kaby Lake, Coffee Lake requires a new chipset to function. Shamed be he who thinks evil of it. Intel would never, never I tell you, make upgrading your mainboard a necessity, but there are just these stringent technical requirements to replace PCIe-I/O-Expander and sell some extra electronics garbage with every iteration.
- greggyb 9y agoAny reason to drop ThreadRipper from arbitrary benchmarks?
- TwoNineA 9y ago8700K is mainstream like Ryzen. ThreadRipper and Intel X299 are high end workstation chips.
- greggyb 9y agoSo why include ThreadRipper in any of the benchmarks? Some include ThreadRipper. Some include 7900X, some include one or the other. Some include neither. That's the confusing thing to me.
- vbezhenar 9y agoI think that they tested TR on some tests earlier, so they included test results if available. I guess, for gaming and workstation processors sets of tests are different, but with some intersections.
- rocky1138 9y agoI think the biggest disadvantage to this chip is that it's not an upgrade path for us i5/i7 6600/6700 CPUs due to a change in processor socket, requiring a new motherboard.
- wmf 9y agoUpgrading from Skylake to Basically Skylake is a waste of money anyway.
- zanny 9y agoSomewhat related, I wonder why the PC gaming ecosystem has always focused on the extreme high end for everyone. I very rarely see anyone trying to get into PC gaming considering a very reasonable $600 budget that would in real world performance get them 90% of the way to a system twice as expensive. Back in, say, 2008 the diminishing returns threshold was much higher. But builders have never adapted to how good cheap parts are - games are being designed for the average hardware, and nowadays that is extremely old relative to how it would have been ten years ago. The real winners of Coffee Lake and Ryzen for me are the 8100 and 1200. Quad cores with, respectively, high frequencies or an unlocked multiplayer on almost all motherboards that come in under $120. These chips beat the pants off an i5 2500k and until this year that kind of performance was barely trickling down when suddenly it just windfalled as soon as AMD was competitive again. Same way the winners in the GPU market are either the 1060 or 580. At least before the mining boom, they were both available under $200 and delivered performance comparable to $500+ cards three years ago. The real advent of recent years has not been pushing the envelope in terms of tech - even the most ludicrous builds still cannot handle 4k and VR is still in its infancy - it has been in driving the cost of admission to great looking 3d games at 1080p down to a fraction what it was five years ago. I'm not sure what it will take to break that 4k barrier. Maybe once we are near a mature 5nm node we will be able to stuff enough transistors onto a die to push that many pixels. But until then we should appreciate how affordable PC gaming is becoming for anyone just getting into it. At least when GPU prices come back down to Earth...
- 0xcde4c3db 9y ago> I very rarely see anyone trying to get into PC gaming considering a very reasonable $600 budget that would in real world performance get them 90% of the way to a system twice as expensive. It's not especially mainstream in PC gaming culture, but if you search for "console killer" it's pretty easy to find people talking about such builds.
- diab0lic 9y agoI just built a PC and tried to budget as cheaply as possible while still retaining reasonable performance. It ended up costing $1200 (plus monitor, another $200). I went with a Ryzen 3 1300x and a RX580. I'd love some feedback about how I could have got the price down closer to $600 as I was disappointed in myself for only being able to get it down to $1200 + monitor. That said the performance is incredible. https://pcpartpicker.com/list/F87BCy https://pcpartpicker.com/list/F87BCy (NOTE: The GPU price isn't added into the total as they don't seem to have a value for it right now.)
- holtalanm 9y agohttp://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i7-8700K-vs-AMD-Ryzen-7-1800X/3937vs3916 http://cpu.userbenchmark.com/Compare/Intel-Core-i7-8700K-vs-... i7 benchmarks higher than the Ryzen
- trynumber9 9y agoExcept in the multicore workloads. Which is why you'd buy a Zen chip.
- holtalanm 9y agoagreed. Single-core, it looks like the i7 is the winner for now.
- vbezhenar 9y agoIt depends of whether your tasks are able to fill all cores with useful work all the time. Otherwise faster Intel would provide better value. I considered between ThreadRipper and 8700K and decided to go with Intel for the time. I can make use of ThreadRipper cores sometimes (project rebuild, reindexing, heavy multitasking with launching numerous VMs, IDEs, games at the same time), but 90% load will be on 1-2 cores and here Intel is clear winner, so having those 15 idling cores won't help that much in my case. Now difference between AMD and overclocked Intel is just too huge (30% or more), but I hope that with new Zens they'll be closer and it might be easier choice (if I would give up 10% of single-thread performance for 10 more cores, I would choose otherwise).
- walrus01 9y agoThe more important news in my opinion is the cheapest core i3 in the price range of $105 to $125, which is now quad core and reasonable budget workstation competition for the also-quad-core Ryzen 1300X.
- dynamoa 9y agoI can completely disregard the rest of the review if the reviewer does not know how to present benchmark graphs properly.