3 ms·
Richard Thaler made economics more messy
- eecc 9y agoOh look, is this finally the moment where the "Rational Choice theory" is put to rest? Good riddance, although not soon enough to avoid all the damage of the last 30 years of Neoliberist nonsense.
- dang 9y agoThis sort of instacomment is easy and tempting to post to a fresh thread, but it damages (potential) discussion badly. It's glib, contains little information, and uses the tropes of an ideological rant ("neoliberist nonsense"). We're hoping to avoid that here, so would you please re-read https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html https://news.ycombinator.com/newsguidelines.html and stick to that spirit when commenting? That means posting civil and substantive comments, or nothing. (This has nothing to do with rational choice theory, only internet comment theory.)
- eecc 9y agopoint taken
- abrax3141 9y agoIsn’t all this the same thing that Simon got a Nobel for in 1978? (And Kahneman in 2002.) Why does economics keep rediscovering that people’s thinking is complicated, and thinking its a new discovery?
- KingMob 9y agoIt's because very few of them listened to, or believed in, their psychologist colleagues. And given how difficult it is to conduct experiments at the macroeconomic level, the field as a whole has a poor tradition of running experiments and collecting evidence, which would have burst that bubble decades earlier.
- vonmoltke 9y ago> Isn’t all this the same thing that Simon got a Nobel for in 1978? My understanding is, no. Simon's work dealt with microeconomic decisions, which is exactly what Thaler said many were dismissing as self-cancelling noise at the macro level. Kahneman's demonstrates it does not, at least for a subset of macro decisions.
- matt4077 9y agoBecause "it's complicated" isn't usually considered an exhaustive exploration of the topic? It's also a great symbol, emphasising how economics is trying to incorporate new knowledge of all the "failure modes" of classical models. There are enough people retelling that "square chicken" joke over and over, and such prices help to spread the word that, contrary to public opinion, there are lots of efforts to make the models match closer with behavioural realities.
- abrax3141 9y ago> Because "it's complicated" isn't > usually considered an exhaustive exploration > of the topic? Okay, fair point. Maybe what tweaks me is the media always reporting just what the Nobel committee says, which is just the same gloss as S&K: cognition matters. In physics they don’t keep saying the same thing about each Nobel’s contribution. Maybe it’s just that physics is easy, and cognitive science is hard.
- ghaff 9y agoSimon was more about decision-making in organizations. But Kahneman certainly did a lot of work in psychology that helped form the basis for behavioral economics work.
- abrax3141 9y agoFunny to think of Simon, who is credited with being the grandfather of cognitive science, as being known for organizational behavior.
- dang 9y agoComments moved to https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15432617 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=15432617.