4 ms·
What I'm doing is pointing out the straw men used in this thread to attack something the writers don't like. I'm fine with disagreement, but I think it should b
by wpietri 9y ago
What I'm doing is pointing out the straw men used in this thread to attack something the writers don't like. I'm fine with disagreement, but I think it should be done honestly.
People here get all exercised about rights. So to wrongly claim that the original article is interfering with somebody's rights will get people falsely riled up. Making up a new definition of "moral rights", which is something else entirely, seems even worse to me. If echan00 and seankimdesign want to say it's ok, then they can just say it's ok. No need to puff up their claims.
- Dylan16807 9y agoThe normal definition of "moral right" is equivalent to whether something is "ok". It's just "a right of the moral variety", not the legal term about copyright. That legal term is very much not the everyday definition. People use a casual phasing like "they have the right to X" to mean that X is defensible all the time. It's not an attempt to mislead people about the article.
- wpietri 9y agoIf that's the normal meaning, would you be so kind as to link me to a definition that matches the way "moral rights" was used here?
- Dylan16807 9y agoIt's not going to have its own dictionary entry because it's two separate words and not a phrase. The first few google results for [[moral right]] are about the legal term, but then there are many not about it. And while this is not the best comparison, I would assume that most pages talking about the legal term will have the word "copyright" on them somewhere. Is that a reasonable assumption? Because [["moral right" -copyright]] has almost as many results as [["moral right"]].
- wpietri 9y agoDictionaries are not the only places you find definitions. E.g., the IEP has a dozen definition of concepts with "moral" in them, like "moral luck": http://www.iep.utm.edu/moralluc/ http://www.iep.utm.edu/moralluc/ It doesn't have anything for moral rights used this way. I think your google-counting approach is an ineffective way to get at anything. If you read the citations that come up from your suggestion, it's not at all clear that everybody's talking about the same thing. And some of them are definitely doing what I think seankimdesign: puffing up some other perfectly good concept by adding the word "right" to it to make it stronger. So no, I definitely do not agree that the normal definition of "moral rights" is what you get when you subtract the actual normal definition of "moral rights" from the search results.