8 ms·
I think we have seen for ourselves how dangerous democracies can be when mixed with fears. Alas, people will continue to argues that democracy is the best form
by kiba 16y ago
I think we have seen for ourselves how dangerous democracies can be when mixed with fears.
Alas, people will continue to argues that democracy is the best form of government despite its various flaws.
- deleted 16y ago[deleted]
- Alex63 16y agoI will defer to Winston Churchill: "Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time."
- jacoblyles 16y ago"Divine-right Monarchy is the worst form of government, except for all other forms which have been tried" - some guy committing the same error as Winston Churchill a few hundred years earlier.
- sophacles 16y agoWhich means we should stop trying to come up with a better one right?
- Alex63 16y agoNo. If you have a new alternative, let's hear about it. Churchill wasn't saying there can't be a better system - he was saying that in his view democracy was the best of the alternatives tried to this point.
- igravious 16y agoWell he would say that, being the leader in a democratic system and all.
- Symmetry 16y agoWhen he said that he had just been voted out of office, and therefore perhaps not as enthusiastic about this whole "democracy" thing as he usually was.
- Alex63 16y agoI really didn't think this would be a particularly controversial quotation. The full quotation (according to wikiquote) is: Many forms of Government have been tried and will be tried in this world of sin and woe. No one pretends that democracy is perfect or all-wise. Indeed, it has been said that democracy is the worst form of government except all those other forms that have been tried from time to time. As Symmetry points out, it is from a speech (to the House of Commons) in 1947, after Churchill's first tenure as Prime Minister.
- sophacles 16y agoThe quote is frequently used by fanatics (those who look at democracy with a religious fervor), as a conversation ender -- particularly when used after criticism of some democratic process. It almost always implies "we cannot discuss the shortcomings of this system because it is the best". It also often has an implication of "this is the final word on democracy, it is defined as the best, therefore whatever you come up with cannot be as good". This second association is why I replied as I did in my original comment -- it is the same as "love it or leave it". tl;dr: the quote itself isn't bad, it just has been coopted by those with a certain fanatic mindest.
- igravious 16y agoWell he would say that, being the leader in a democratic system and all.
- anigbrowl 16y agoas opposed to what? Every time I try to come up with an answer for that question I get stuck at 'dictatorship headed by the fairest and wisest person I know.' It's probably just a coincidence, but that person usually turns out to be me :) What's your alternative good?
- BrandonM 16y agoIn The Republic, Plato argues that the best form of rule is philosopher-kings; your answer seems to be the same. I tend to agree, but of course the logistics of finding such a ruler are difficult and subject to corruption.
- pfedor 16y agoHe also advocates slavery. And proposes a system in which all women are grouped into a pool of common wives, on the basis that when no one knows which child was fathered by whom, every man will have fatherly feelings for every child and every child will respect every man as they would respect their father. And argues that theatrical performances should be illegal. As well as many other things.
- BrandonM 16y agoDo you believe that discredits his argument for philosopher-kings? Ideas rule, it doesn't matter who had them or what other ideas they had.
- zackattack 16y agoUm, the problem with your statement is that.. if you recall from reading The Republic, Plato's Socrates's definition of justice is a defined society with a lot of moving parts. If you discredit some moving parts then you dismantle the entire argument.
- bff 16y agoI much prefer Zeno's Republic, where everyone is equal but strives to be wise. Really, I think that there is no such thing as a perfect government, only a perfect citizenry, because the power of a government is always derived from the people within it. A philosopher king would not be able to maintain power unless either A) he was omnipotent or B) the people allowed him to remain in power.
- mcantelon 16y agoA democracy is only as good as the citizens involved in it. Some regions have stronger cultures, valuing education and liberty, than others.
- Dove 16y agoRaw democracy is dangerous. Democracy with limited and enumerated state powers is actually kinda okay. For example, we could start interpreting the commerce clause the way any reasonable and sane person would. That would go a long way toward fixing this sort of problem, by making us less of a pure democracy.
- jrockway 16y agoBut the State governments are just as corrupt or more corrupt than the Federal government. Remember Rod Blagojevich?
- michaelkeenan 16y agoI used to believe, fervently and automatically, that democracy was the best system. Can you blame me? No-one in my society opposes democracy. No-one sane anyway. In the last couple of years, I've encountered well-reasoned opposing views for the first time. Let's back up, and consider how to get an effective x, where x is a cup of coffee or a laptop or anything else. One way might be to get everyone to vote on what kind of x they like, and then give that to everyone. This is of course a terrible system, and not Starbucks nor Apple have that kind of system. Much better to have competition. I'd be terrible at making coffee or a laptop, and it's best that I'm not trusted to make those things, or to choose who would be good at making them. Nor ought I to be trusted with running a country or choosing who to run it. So, I think an ideal world might be a world of many smaller governments, each competing for consumers/citizens. Apply the creativity and efficiency of startups to the governing industry. I want a world of Singapores and Hong Kongs and Liechtensteins, where I can pick my government provider approximately the same way I pick my ISP or my employer. Of course there are problems. So solve them! What better decrepit, corrupt, monopolizing old industry to fix than the governing industry? A Peter Thiel-funded startup is trying (http://seasteading.org http://seasteading.org). See also Arnold Kling on competitive government vs. democracy: http://smartdemocracy.com/papers/kling_competitive_government.2008.pdf http://smartdemocracy.com/papers/kling_competitive_governmen... And also see the reading list at the Let A Thousand Nations Bloom blog: http://athousandnations.com/recommended/ http://athousandnations.com/recommended/
- Ardit20 16y agoThe only problem is that you ignore the nature of men and his history. Nation states are a relatively new thing. People used to live in city states, principataes, and that sort of thing, but then you get Persia for example who wants more and more territory and to rule everyone, then you get Rome, Alexander of Macedonia, Islamists in 600s, etc. I think we all want to be one world with no border without any government whatsoever. It is unfortunate however that a government is needed. Personally, I favour Aristocracy combined with some form of accountability to the people. Thus a combination of Aristocracy and democracy.
- notahacker 16y ago