9 ms·
Why We’ll Have Evidence of Aliens–If They Exist–By 2035
- jmiserez 9y agoFYI: The title sounds like clickbait, but is actually explained in the article. As technology improves further in the next few years, we’ll be able to scan so many more stars simultaneously that a possible discovery would be have to be made (if they exist). Overall an interesting article by Seth Shostak of the SETI Institute.
- actuallyalys 9y agoAgreed on it not being clickbait, although I wish he went into more detail about how Sagan et al came up with their estimates, since that seems to be key to his whole argument.
- rbobrowicz 9y agohttps://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Drake_equation
- goatlover 9y agoThe Drake equation along with the Fermi Paradox are well known in conjunction with SETI's goal for the past several decades. Seth, Frank Drake, Carl Sagan and Jill Tarter have all publicly talked about their justification for being confident in SETI's eventual success. Sagan even wrote a science fiction book about it that was made into a movie.
- AlexCoventry 9y agoMaybe not clickbait, but he sure buried the lede. Thanks for the TL;DR. Wasn't clear what his point was from a quick skim.
- puranjay 9y agoI fail to see any reason behind proclaiming 2035 as the deadline within the article. The author could have very well said 2030 or 2040 and it would have been the same article.
- gooseus 9y ago> Within two decades, SETI experiments will be able to complete a reconnaissance of 1 million star systems, which is hundreds of times more than have been carefully examined so far. SETI practitioners from Frank Drake to Carl Sagan have estimated that the galaxy currently houses somewhere between 10,000 and a few million broadcasting societies. If these estimates are right, then examining 1 million star systems could well lead to a discovery. I think he's basing the date on the assumption that we'll have searched 1 million star systems by 2037 and there are a few million broadcasting societies. Personally I think the odds are pretty damn long, even on the optimistic end of Sagan's and Drake's assumptions. Assuming there are 200-400 billion star systems in our galaxy, that gives us a 1 in 200-400k odds of finding one by 2037? I'll take the bet. Still a great read, I'm much more fascinated by the idea of artifacts. I believe that the longer we go without finding things, the more seriously we should be thinking about leaving things.
- jackmott 9y agowould need to be a few million broadcasting societies, broadcasting in a way we can detect. and there could be aliens in other galaxies! we wouldn't detect them by 2035 article was pretty nonsense imho
- aetherson 9y agoOn the optimistic end of Sagan's range, there are "a few million" broadcasting societies, call it 2 million. If there are 400 billion stars, that means that there's one broadcasting society per 20,000 stars. If they're evenly distributed, and we sample 1M stars, then our odds of missing with all 1M samples are negligible (about 1/10^22). (I don't think that there are a few million broadcasting societies in our galaxy. But if there are, we'd expect to find them soon.)
- cryptoz 9y ago> possible discovery would be have to be made (if they exist). ...and if they want to be found.
- sillysaurus3 9y agoI've never understood claims like this. For all we know, the universe could be infinite. Yes, that would mean the universe contains an infinite amount of energy and that we'd find dopplegangers of ourselves if we travel far enough, but we can't be sure it's not true. We can't even be more or less confident in one hypothesis vs another. Articles like this would be more persuasive if they had qualifiers like "Within our observable universe."
- liberte82 9y agoA lot of people don't realize just how much bigger the universe might be than "the observable universe".
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- PoachedSausage 9y agoI thought it had been established that the universe, as a (hyper)volume of spacetime is finite? That doesn't mean infinity isn't lurking somewhere beyond though.
- posterboy 9y agoMaybe in theory but I don't think that's something that could be empirically verified. An axiomatic theory is rather a working assumption, because anything else is mathematically intractable. How could anyone understand something that's too big to understand? My impression is that Multiverse Theories are a fad playing on semantics.
- goatlover 9y agoThe size of the universe is irrelevant to SETI, since they're just trying to detect alien civilizations in our neighborwood, which would mean the Milky Way.
- posterboy 9y ago> For all we know, the universe could be infinite if an infinite number of trees fall and and nobody is there to hear it, do they make a sound?
- visarga 9y agoSounds great, but there is slim chance of finding them, and even if we do, they will be too far away. We should instead prepare to meet the artificial intelligences of tomorrow, which are a sure bet. It will be like Lee Sedol trying to understand AlphaGo, not like the linguist professor from the movie Arrival trying to understand Alien language.
- kylec 9y agoThese methods focus on finding extraterrestrials with an equivalent or greater technological advancement to our own. How would you find an alien civilization with a 17th-century Earth level of technological development? We were not emitting radio signals or using light pulses to communicate, nor were we flying around in antimatter-powered rockets.
- jaclaz 9y ago>These methods focus on finding extraterrestrials with an equivalent or greater technological advancement to our own. ... AND actually willing to communicate with us, which is not IMHO to be assumed as given. We need to find a rather "narrow" set of aliens with a technology similar enough to ours, and animated by a similar curiosity about the rest of the universe.
- api 9y agoWe could perhaps detect distant alien life by finding signatures of oxygen or another oxidizer in a planet's atmosphere. These would be highly unlikely to persist long without something alive to keep the thermodynamic gradient up. O2, F2, etc. are extremely reactive.
- nkoren 9y agoIn the main, I think we'd simply have no chance of detecting such civilisations. In the next couple of decades, however, advanced space telescopes with starshade coronagraphs could be able to start doing spectroscopy on exoplanet atmospheres.[1] This would definitely reveal (some kinds of) biologically-active atmospheres, although it wouldn't necessarily to be able to tell the difference between a complex biosphere with a low-tech civilisation, and a uni-cellular algae soup. I suppose there's an outside chance that such a telescope could detect combustion compounds that are difficult to explain geologically or biologically, and that might be used to hypothesise a civilisation. Something like lead smelting might leave a pretty distinct signature, for example. But that would just lead to a hypothesis, not proof, and I imagine it'd be pretty contentious. Longer-term, it should be possible to create arbitrarily large space-based optical interferometers[2], to the point where one would be capable of imaging cities and agricultural activity on exoplanets. That'd settle matters (Unless it's under water or impenetrable cloud decks, and then you're just out of luck). But that level of resolution is probably a couple of centuries and/or one singularity away from happening, so don't hold your breath. 1: http://www.planetary.org/blogs/guest-blogs/2017/20170623-starshade-helping-space-telescopes.html http://www.planetary.org/blogs/guest-blogs/2017/20170623-sta... 2: https://www.noao.edu/meetings/interferometry/workshop-files/Carpenter-Space-comp.pdf https://www.noao.edu/meetings/interferometry/workshop-files/...
- evanlivingston 9y agoMy amature take on intelligent alien life is that humans as a technological society have developed extremely quickly, if other intelligent species exist and have a focus on technics, then I think it's safe to assume they've developed with as much speed. Continuing with that assumption, it seems extremely unlikely to me that other technological civilizations are at the same point in the timeline as we are, or slightly further ahead. I would imagine them to be massively further ahead. As such, they would surely know about us, but haven't made contact. Why not? I think this is a very important question to ask in the search for other advanced cultures.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- api 9y agoI can think of loads of reasons they haven't made contact, from the altruistic (something like the prime directive) to self-preservation interests. Even if they're massively more advanced, why invite trouble? We're much more intelligent than fire ants but I for one know I'm not in the habit of sitting on fire ant mounds. These two can go together. If they contact us and we become belligerent, they may be forced to annihilate us. That would be morally reprehensible to them, so the solution is not to make contact.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- jerf 9y ago"altruistic (something like the prime directive)" Related to the solutions to the Fermi paradox, explanations for why the putatively abundant aliens have not contacted us need to cover all the aliens. And the "Prime Directive" is a very, very, very particular definition of "altruistic". I, for one, don't even agree that it's altruistic. Even Star Trek, where it has basically magical dramatic force severed from real concerns, couldn't really argue consistently that it was altruistic: http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Pen_Pals_(episode) http://memory-alpha.wikia.com/wiki/Pen_Pals_(episode) Why wouldn't there be a species that looks at us, concludes we're ultimately irrelevant, and just converts our solar system into computronium anyhow? Why wouldn't that be the cosmic evolutionary winner? (They could even altruistically upload us into an equivalent simulation; while I don't particularly "believe" it, my favorite pet solution to the Fermi paradox is that Earth was uploaded an arbitrary amount of time ago and we've just been simulated ever since out of ethical concerns, a simulation which for simplicity and perhaps even ethical reasons has no other civilizations in it. For all we know they actually digitized Earth in the dinosaur era and in realtime it may in fact still be "millions of years ago" if our simulation runs faster than real time.)
- gwbas1c 9y agoFrom reading the article, I don't believe the statement "We’ll Have Evidence of Aliens–If They Exist–By 2035." An alien civilization broadcasting via radio at the same moment we're looking could be very unlikely. [Edit] Who's to say that we're going to broadcast via radio for thousands or millions of years? What if, in 300 years, we discover a much better system? Then we can reasonably assume that a 400 year radio burst is the sign of a species developing intelligence. We can also reasonably assume that SETI chose a poor indicator in their search.
- imglorp 9y agoOr more reasonably, assuming only current physics and assuming they mostly stay in their system, they simply don't incur the inefficiency of broadcast radio any more. For example point-to-point using lasers is reasonable, and we'd never see it here unless we were the target.
- bluGill 9y agoRadio is likely to be useful for millions of years. Each form of communication has pros and cons. Radio has some advantages over the alternatives, and so we are likely to use it. How much we cannot know without first knowing what the alternative is though.
- planteen 9y agoThe alternative is optical which is superior to radio waves at planetary distances and further from the perspective of NASA. https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/heo/scan/engineering/technology/txt_opticalcomm_benefits.html https://www.nasa.gov/directorates/heo/scan/engineering/techn...
- bluGill 9y agoright, but we are trying to detect on planet communications, which we believe we can do. Once we determine that someone is out there we can ask if/how we can contact them.
- yodon 9y ago
- m1n1 9y agoA key decision for any sentient species would be whether to broadcast one's existence or snoop around quietly first.
- steve_adams_86 9y agoThis reminds me of a trilogy called Remembrance of Earth's Past by Liu Cixin. He creates a sort of analogy in the second novel, saying civilizations in space should be like hunters in a dark forest (The book is called The Dark Forest). He hypothesizes that you should sneak around quietly, looking to kill others, lest you be killed yourself. I won't say more - it's a great read.
- MarkPNeyer 9y agoSecoding the recommendation. The trilogy is incredible.
- richsinn 9y agoA great summary of the Dark Forest theory without giving away too much of the plot. This trilogy is one of the best books/stories I've ever read.
- t1o5 9y agoAccording to my tinfoil hat, if we plugin sensible defaults to the drake equation, the aliens should have been broadcasting something around 21,000 light years ago for us to get something in 2035.
- DougN7 9y agoThis seems to be the very definition of hubris.
- 0xdeadbeefbabe 9y agoScience can't tell me how to lose weight, but SETI can find intelligent life or the absence of it? Maybe the scientists at SETI are better, or maybe searching for intelligent life is an easier problem? Didn't Carl Sagan already find the answer by doing math?
- maxerickson 9y agoScience knows the mechanics of losing weight. Monitor and restrict calories. For example, lots of people do this successfully with their pets.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- aaroninsf 9y agoYawn. All such proclamations, predictions, and earnestness about the Drake Equation is limited, absolutely, by the boundaries of what we currently believe is possible. To be specific, it has always seemed to me hubris of the first order to presume that we know the principles underlying a more advanced civilization's communications (or, maybe, travel). We aren't aware of mechanisms more efficient, fast, whatever, than e.g. radiowaves, or, polarized lasers, or [insert latest notion]'. But what the authors of these things seem to never take seriously is what we don't know, is almost certain to be a lot more significant than what we do. There is a chart in my office lounge showing the advancement of human symbolic reasoning and technology from pre-history, through 15 years ago. What is striking to me is that in a few brief thousand years, utterly insignificant evolutionarily speaking, we have gone from first formulating written language and mathematics, to e.g. Cassini, rovers, and LIGO. Ever if the pace of advancement were plateaued (and it isn't) it is baffling to me that someone would think, oh, we've got the basic constraints now in hand; it's just an exercise of application at this point, to e.g. detect other civilizations. That doesn't even begin to get into the Liu Cixin style game theory issues... Anyway. Lack of evidence merely means we're not looking in the right way, IMO.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoSo if we don't find evidence of aliens by 2035, we should assume they don't exist? Cynically, I'm pretty sure that's not how this will play out...
- gooseus 9y ago> We can never prove that aliens are not out there, only that they are. No, he's just saying if we don't find them by 2035 he owes the Internet coffee. Pretty excited, though I'm hoping I can substitute tea.
- AnimalMuppet 9y agoBut the contrapositive is logically equivalent to the original statement. "If aliens exist, we'll have evidence by 2035" is logically equivalent to "If we don't have evidence by 2035, aliens don't exist". But it won't be taken that way. Now, I'm overstating the attention-grabbing headline to reflect a greater degree of certainty than Shostak genuinely believes. But he's stating it with more certainty than he genuinely believes, at least in the headline. If he really believed the headline, he'd say, "If we don't find them by 2035, I will believe that they don't exist" instead of "I will buy everyone coffee".
- civilian 9y agoNope, it just means that our estimate for the number of alien civilizations in the galaxy has to decrease, and we needa re-examine the Drake equation. From the article: > We can never prove that aliens are not out there, only that they are.
- jpm_sd 9y agoWhat if "typical" technological civilizations only go through a very brief period of broadcasting detectable TV signals and then they wire up the entire planet with leak-free fiber optic cables? Then all we can count on is intentional transmissions that say "find us here"?
- InitialLastName 9y agoPresumably, they would still need a way to communicate with remote (unwireable) entities? We find quite a lot of use for devices in orbit. It's hard to imagine that use disappearing, especially as we move towards mining resources in our local solar neighborhood.
- bluGill 9y agoWe know that humans like to be connected on the go. Wireless works well for this, I'm not sure how to do leak-free fibre to my car (my wife driving - lets be safe here)
- bluGill 9y agoNot quite true. If Aliens exist AND they had radio technology in use [distance from us in lightyears] years ago we will find them by 2035. Aliens 200 light years away will not detect life on earth for 100 years or so yet (depending on if they are listening and how sensitive their radios are). If they immediately send a reply it will be 200 more years before we can get their reply. Note that 200 light years is insignificant even on the scale of our galaxy, much less the universe. What this means is even if we detect aliens that doesn't mean they still exist, we could well detect them, learn about them and then watch as die (war, plague, or any other doomsday scenario) before we can get our "we are here" message to them. That is we might find aliens that do not exist anymore! The universe is large enough that this would not surprise me (though it might be my great-great-great grandchild who discover they have been dead for thousands of years). Or maybe we will not find any, and then in 2036 discover the first radio transmission of some aliens only a few light years away.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- civilian 9y agoWell, yeah, no shit. We're obviously just looking at the "observable universe", which means light-as-it-is-arriving-now.
- ChuckMcM 9y agoThe short version is: "Hypothesis: there are millions of alien civilizations, by 2035 we will have sampled enough possible stars to achieve statistical significance, and either there are no aliens or we'll see a positive result." Which I agree with (and I also agree with folks who point out that at some point being found may be a bad thing which would encourage hiding). Like many people I know, I assume there must be other civilizations out there. However it is fun to ask the question, "What if we are unique in all the galaxy?" (really it would be the light cone associated with what we can perceive) What sort of responsibility would it put on humans to get their act together and keep from dying out if we knew we were unique?
- iokevins 9y agoDr. Shostak quoted 2015-2025, in 2008, as the expected dates to discover alien life: http://www.saukvalley.com/articles/2008/02/12/news/national/doc47b1e094681c3055532104.txt http://www.saukvalley.com/articles/2008/02/12/news/national/... Just under 10 years later, he quotes 2035. Not saying he's wrong.
- civilian 9y agoWhat's it called when a research event is always 20 years away?
- squatsandsci 9y agoThe author of this article is focusing only on SETI-based methods of finding extraterrestrial life. The most promising IMO, and one that I don't see talked about much, is the James Webb Telescope's ability to measure contents of the atmospheres of exoplanets. From what I understand O2 is only known to be created by metabolic processes of living organisms. Also one thing that's curious to me is the math here assumes these millions of civilizations all exist now or have set up systems to broadcast these beams forever whether or not they go extinct. So if we make the following assumptions: These civilizations only last a couple hundred years after they create these powerful directional radio wave beams (which if we use ourselves as an example seems to be a reasonable assumption) One civilizations dies and another sequentially starts broadcasting radio waves (most favorable option) It takes 2 billion years to create life Galaxy is about 13 billion years old There's been about 2M advanced civilizations in the Milky Way That means there's a 3.6% chance there's a civilizations broadcasting right now. This goes up if some last longer than 200 years, and if some create machines that can broadcast either indefinitely or for a long time. Within 1 magnitude of relative certainty is pretty good I guess.