3 ms·
Scientists pinpoint the singularity for quantum computers
- nthompson 9y agoI think the title should be "Efficient classical algorithm for boson sampling discovered". I don't get the whole singularity thing.
- sp332 9y agoA singularity originally referred to a single point where (the mathematical description of) a field has infinite strength. For example, a black hole that had collapsed to an infinitely dense, infinitely small point. But lots of people now are referring to the event horizon around the back hole as the singularity. So when something starts to tip inevitably, it's called a singularity even though that's just the beginning of getting there.
- amelius 9y agoI think in the "Kurzweil sense" a singularity means that after the tipping point is reached, no human involvement should be necessary to reach the "infinite strength point" (the true singularity). Note that this holds for black holes at least.
- Udik 9y agoI always intended it as "the point beyond which no description is possible", from the mathematical concept of singularity as a point in which a mathematical object is not defined. Which sort of fits with the idea of a point in progress beyond which no description of the future is possible.
- dwringer 9y ago"Wait. I've seen this. I stand here, right here, and I'm supposed to say something. I say, 'Everything that has a beginning has an end, Neo.' . . . What? What did I just say?"
- danbruc 9y agoA singularity originally referred to a single point where (the mathematical description of) a field has infinite strength. That's not really true. The term singularity was almost certainly first used in mathematics. Most physicist don't believe that there are singularities in nature, it's just our incomplete or simplified physical theories that have them in their equations. And in mathematics there are quite a few kinds of singularities, of isolated points that have drastically different behavior than their neighborhood, and diverging to infinity is just one example.
- zitterbewegung 9y agoAlgorithms that don't use quantum computation and plain silicon devices are such a hard hurdle to overcome. I can see a possible future where silicon reaches its limit and maybe then we will be forced to engineer Quantum Computation but even so that is still 90 years of research to get them practical. I found that out when studying Quantum Computation at school.
- Strilanc 9y agoReferring to the point where quantum computers are better at one esoteric thing that's not even useful as a "singularity" is laughably atrociously ridiculous. The actual relevant technical term is "quantum supremacy" [1], which is already misleading (implies complete dominance but actually refers to not being completely dominated). There's no need to make it worse! Also, the theorists didn't "pinpoint" anything. They showed that quantum supremacy via boson sampling was harder than previously thought. They improved the classical simulation algorithm, raising the bar quantum computers will have to jump over. I guess popsci has standards for terribleness that just weren't being met? They couldn't pick a merely semi-terrible title, like "Scientists raise the quantum supremacy bar"? 1: https://arxiv.org/abs/1203.5813 https://arxiv.org/abs/1203.5813
- vpribish 9y agoSkip it, friends. This is a badly-written, and unimportant article. also, phys.org using clickbait? I thought they were good.