5 ms·
Not enough. A 250M fine is almost a joke. Companies like Amazon, Google, Facebook, etc, save Billions of dollars every single year by setting up "creative" tax
by simonebrunozzi 9y ago
Not enough.
A 250M fine is almost a joke. Companies like Amazon, Google, Facebook, etc, save Billions of dollars every single year by setting up "creative" tax schemes.
A 250M fine is almost an incentive to keep doing it.
- jahnu 9y agoIt sets a precedence.
- ulfw 9y agoIt does indeed. A precedence for trying to pay no taxes and paying just a tiny percentage if one gets caught.
- kryptiskt 9y agoThe modest size of the fine is probably just because Amazon isn't all that into making profits and thus has little taxable income. Apple had to pay a lot more.
- skrause 9y agoThis is not a fine, it's back taxes. That's a very big difference.
- jlebrech 9y agolegal tax schemes are legal
- singularity2001 9y agoand amoral
- jlebrech 9y agotrue, money follows the path of least resistance.
- runholm 9y agoWe can't run a society based on companies being moral. We need laws regulating it and in this case, it seems like the EU is actually enforcing them.
- kuschku 9y agoActually, that’s pretty much the point of the civil law system the EU uses, that the spirit of the law stands above the letter of the law, and if you violate the spirit of the law – even while abiding the letter of the law – you can be punished.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Stranger43 9y agoIt's a bit simplistic a view the more complex reality is that the code civil(unlike the common law) doctrine have a "bonus pater"(or informed citizen) standard that puts an obligation on especially large(and supposedly competent) companies to proactively make sure they follow the law as it is not as they think it is. I.E. apple's "but this guy down at the pub told us it was legal"* defence fails the bonus pater standard as apple highly paid legal council should have known better then accept it as a indication of actual law. *In reality there was a unpublished letter from some politician, who did not actually have the authority to speak on irish tax law, to apple stating that Irish revenue would not challenge apple's claims about not owing Irish taxes on money in transit. though all evidence point to apple knowing full well that was not an indication that their tax sceme was legal.
- jlebrech 9y agothere are plenty of immoral yet legal industries, for example porn and gun manufacture. morality is just a conservative-goodness.
- temporalparts 9y agoI agree that taxes are amoral, not a matter of moral consideration. Companies cannot be expected to pay more than legally required, as their competitors would be doing the same. It would be immoral to expect them to follow anything else but the legal requirement.
- jlebrech 9y agohaving an accountant is basically a "tax scheme" because poorer businesses might not be able to afford it. now scale that up to billions of dollars, and the accountant is now swiss. we should fix laws first so that loopholes like that cannot exist.
- Cthulhu_ 9y agoThe EU needs to find a balance though - too little and they'll just keep doing it, like what you're saying. Too much though, and a few things will happen: * They will spend 10+ years in courts to fight it; paying a team of lawyers to fight the ruling or at least postpone having to pay it will be cheaper than paying it. * They'll get out and find a new tax haven. 250 - 500 million seems to be a figure that gets paid eventually (see also EU/RealPlayer vs MS). Higher than that and they'll find a way to not have to pay it and annoy a lot of people - legally.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoAmazon will leave the EU to find a tax haven? Like stop trading?? Because if they're tradinging here then they've not left the jurisdiction of the EU - we're talking about Amazon, whose zero-hour workers have to be supported by social care, making slightly less profit. They reportedly paid £15M tax on profit of c.£20 Billion.
- plandis 9y agoThey are not being fined. EU decided to retroactively tax Amazon more. Amazon is required to payback the taxi that EU suddenly decided to charge even though Amazon legally worked with a country to come up with that taxing scheme.