4 ms·
The commentary doesn't specify, but what private sector use of OSS might be declining rapidly? Does this claim have any merit? It seems like almost all web stac
by dahart 9y ago
The commentary doesn't specify, but what private sector use of OSS might be declining rapidly? Does this claim have any merit? It seems like almost all web stacks rely heavily on OSS, but coming from Oracle, I assume they could be talking about databases specifically. Would it be true to suggest use of OSS databases, e.g., MySQL, is declining?
Oracle positioning themselves against OSS is interesting, and might be telling. I would assume that a message to the govt that OSS is bad means that OSS is actually winning, and Oracle is more scared of open source than it is of other for-profit competition.
This is also in line with the government defining OSS as "commercial" software. From the government's perspective, the line isn't whether they paid money, it's more like whether the software comes with a license. http://dodcio.defense.gov/Open-Source-Software-FAQ/#Q:_Is_open_source_software_commercial_software.3F_Is_it_COTS.3F http://dodcio.defense.gov/Open-Source-Software-FAQ/#Q:_Is_op...
I feel like that's where Oracle's commentary trips up a bit, because they're painting a picture of the fears of bad things that can happen when using OSS, without realizing the government already figured out that most of the implications and liabilities of any software come from the licensing, and not the dollar costs.
- kristopolous 9y agoYou could say "make sure customers don't consider alternatives" is his job description.
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- syshum 9y ago>>>The commentary doesn't specify, but what private sector use of OSS might be declining rapidly? Does this claim have any merit? It seems like almost all web stacks rely heavily on OSS The trend for Open Source has been for a long time to Open Source Tools, Libraries, and other code that is used to create propriety closed source software for companies and individuals to consum This is why you see a massive decline in GPL and other copy left licenses and a Huge increase in Apache, BSD and MIT licensed code as there are no legal issues with including Apache, BSD or MIT code into your Proprietary end user application SaaS, and PaaS (aka Cloud) are also leading the downward use of Open Source as most of these applications are at best Freemium where the supported version of the Software is closed source paid for and they might have a "community edition" that is open (if you are lucky)
- uiri 9y agoIf you are the copyright holder, you can do whatever you want with the software. You don't need to obey any license since you're the counterparty for anyone accepting the license. If your premise is correct, and open source projects have become dominated by tools, libraries, etc that support a proprietary end product, it would make more sense to me that most of those tools would be released under the GNU GPL so that the original author can incorporate it into their own proprietary software but no one else can do the same and the original author gets back any improvements contributed by outside parties.
- a_e_k 9y agoWhere I work, our open source stuff is released under fairly liberal licenses because we want it incorporated into other companys' proprietary software. If they adopt our code and our standards that makes it easier for us to interoperate with them. Improvements tend to be upstreamed anyway, regardless of license, because it makes maintenance easier and reduces fragmentation.
- jacobr1 9y agoTools might be fine as GPL, but companies don't want to touch strong copyleft with libraries and subcomponents for fear of needing to disclose the proprietary additions. And one of the larger reasons to open source something is to get external involvement and funding in the project. So you don't want to license it in a way that will disincentivize contributions. Copyleft protects you from proprietary forks, but if your building common infrastructure with peer companies across different industries this isn't a concern, instead maximizing involvement is the objective.
- syshum 9y ago>> If your premise is correct There is no if, my premise is a fact >open source projects have become dominated by tools, libraries, etc that support a proprietary end product, One look at Github proves this to be fact > it would make more sense to me that most of those tools would be released under the GNU GPL so that the original author can incorporate it into their own proprietary software No infact it would not, because if they accept code contributions those would be GPL with a copyright attached to the 3rd party developer, and if they then incorporated those into their closed code base they would be in violation of GPL and the 3rd party dev could sue them, This has happened many times Some organization attempt to get around this is CLA's but CLA's are universally frowned upon and completely kill contribution from 3rd parties as such most Open Source projects that operate with CLA's end up having very few contributors that are not being paid directly by the primary company behind the project.
- cirgue 9y ago> The commentary doesn't specify, but what private sector use of OSS might be declining rapidly? Does this claim have any merit? I'm an engineer at a fortune 50, and from where I am sitting this is claim as no merit at all. Our dev shop is pretty much entirely open source excepting databases. The rest of the company prioritizes open-source first for all new development. Open source is alive and well in private enterprise, and I suspect that's why Oracle (and some other companies) are diversifying their PR strategies right now.
- davedx 9y ago> The commentary doesn't specify, but what private sector use of OSS might be declining rapidly? Does this claim have any merit? Given that his claim has no citations or data to back it up, I think the default position is to reject it as anecdotal at best and bad faith at worst. Microsoft and Apple are busy open sourcing huge swathes of their software. (.NET alone has huge enterprise penetration). So I cannot see how it can be true whatsoever.