7 ms·
If you're on the edge about trying FreeBSD on some server instead of Linux, I strongly suggest diving in. I decided to go with FreeBSD on my home server after s
by kqr 9y ago
If you're on the edge about trying FreeBSD on some server instead of Linux, I strongly suggest diving in. I decided to go with FreeBSD on my home server after some back-and-forth, and it has been nothing but a thoroughly positive experience.
- The structure of the system makes total sense to me, making it easy to do stuff.
- The system is relatively simple in its design, which means I actually feel like I could troubleshoot any aspect of it. With Linux I often end up in a situation where I think, "Okay, and that component is in $complex_subsystem_12 so I have no chance of fixing it."
- The documentation is great. For regular system maintenance, mostly everything you'll ever need is in the FreeBSD Handbook and you can often find separate, but equally complete, documents for more specific tasks like the Porter's Handbook, the Project Model documentation, the Developer's Handbook and the various system architecture/design books floating around.
- PeeryTwo 9y agoLatest Beta of Snort on FreeBSD has control-channel support now finally, making it easier to change the config without interrupting packet flows.
- teekert 9y agoI've been on the fence but tipped back. I'm also always on the fence about Arch vs Ubuntu. But the speed and ease with which you get an application like NextCloud fully running on Ubuntu is unmatched. I don't want to spend time tweaking php.ini (anymore), I just want to install nginx and php7 en find that <? phpinfo(); ?> just works. And when I want to VNC into the box for various reasons, I just want it to work and not mess with x configs or put up with very ugly theme-less windows. The BSD pull is there (even more from OpenBSD), I feel it, but after an evening of struggle I often revert back to Ubuntu LTS. I have run Gentoo on my server, back when I didn't have kids nor required regular sleep. Now I just want stuff to work and run after installing it. I want Snaps and Docker to just work after apt installing them.
- kqr 9y ago> But the speed and ease with which you get an application like NextCloud fully running on Ubuntu is unmatched What cooled these worries for me was realising that if I know something to be much easier in Linux, it takes very little to launch a virtual machine and run it in that. So far it hasn't been needed!
- olavgg 9y agoI agree, I would also like that add that I learned a lot more about Linux when I learned FreeBSD. It it also a nice system for Java applications these days too, which I struggled with 5+ years ago.
- cat199 9y agoDefinately agree with the overall point - That said, if using as a critical file server, etc be sure to do some system managment practice in a VM to get the commands down 1st - one of the major ways Linux differs from FreeBSD is that storage managment is radically different - and these are the kinds of commands you'll need to run in this context, only rarely, and typically when dealing with critical issues (disk fails, yadda).. so good to make sure you have solid fundamentals before putting all of your critical stuff there - not because of system issues, but because of potential PEBCAK issues..
- Mister_Snuggles 9y agoOne of the big differences between FreeBSD and Linux is that FreeBSD is designed and built as a complete system, whereas Linux is a kernel plus a collection of userland utilities from third-parties all of which has been configured by a vendor. Neither approach is necessarily right or wrong, just different.
- Koshkin 9y agoI keep hearing this ad nauseam, but what makes a system useful in the first place is the vast repository of third-party applications and not the base install (which you call "a complete system").
- bluGill 9y agoAs a user that is true. As an administrators the you are using those utilities more and so the complete system is important.
- jedberg 9y agoFreeBSD still has a plethora of 3rd party applications, it's just that they enforce things like what you can put in /etc and /var and so on, making things much more regular.
- sigjuice 9y agoCould you please list a few examples of these 3rd party FreeBSD applications that you have in mind? Thanks!
- PeCaN 9y agoHave 27,569 examples: https://www.freebsd.org/ports/index.html https://www.freebsd.org/ports/index.html
- CyberDildonics 9y agoDo you realize that you can compile open source programs for FreeBSD and FreeBSD can run linux binaries?
- bauerd 9y agoCan someone comment on the state of Docker on FreeBSD? I know I can have jails but what about Docker?
- soupbowl 9y agoFrom my experience and reading online, most people suggest spinning up a small Linux vm in bhyve and running docker from it instead of through FreeBSD.
- xenophonf 9y agoIt's still experimental: https://wiki.freebsd.org/Docker https://wiki.freebsd.org/Docker Using FreeBSD as the Docker host requires the Linux compatibility layer, like Windows and macOS.
- vertex-four 9y agoWindows and macOS literally spin up VMs for Docker - the compat layer in FreeBSD runs binaries natively, just translating syscalls in the kernel.
- eatonphil 9y agoThey used to. The native version has been in beta for a while and it's fairly stable. I've used it locally for about a year. https://thenewstack.io/native-docker-comes-windows-mac/ https://thenewstack.io/native-docker-comes-windows-mac/
- vertex-four 9y agoNo, that literally says they use VMs - they just internally manage them.
- eatonphil 9y agoWhoops, you're right. They switched from VirtualBox to xhyve on macOS but it's still a VM.
- loeg 9y agoI'll add that if you're installing a new system, install 11.1 or 12 (CURRENT), not 10.4. 10.4 is an update for people already on the old-stable 10.x branch.
- binaryapparatus 9y agoSame recommendation for desktop too. Switching from Arch to FreeBSD couple of months ago was the best move I could do. Silly way to compare stuff but my Arch always run with processor at 70-72 degrees Celsius. Same setup on FreeBSD and my processor runs at 39-45. Since everything else but kernel runs as exact copy it shows to me that FreeBSD either has less kernel overhead or does scheduling better.
- drsopp 9y agoI remember back in the 90s when I listened to my 100MHz CPU with a radio. FreeBSD sounded like gentle raindrops. Windows 95 screamed.
- CyberDildonics 9y agoYou should do that again, a writeup on that with audio would be garner plenty of attention.
- danieldk 9y agoSame recommendation for desktop too. A serious question, since such recommendations are regularly thrown around in these threads. Can you run FreeBSD with a recent AMD GPU (I know that there is the proprietary NVIDIA driver)? Does Wayland work? What about HiDPI screens with GNOME? Is there support for Dropbox now? Is Chrome supported? Does it use GPU acceleration for movie playback? (As far as I could gather the answer to most of these questions is still 'no'.)
- binaryapparatus 9y agoSorry I have no need or use for any of the listed packages/items. Nvidia works extremely well. I don't have AMD. I won't be using Wayland any time soon even if I could. GNOME is or is becoming systemd hostage so I won't install it ever on any system. Dropbox is not welcome for me. Chromium works well. I think GPU acceleration works well. It all depends on what you use but definitely works well for my needs.
- 9y ago
- foo101 9y agoDo you or anyone similarly have any suggestions or recommendations about NetBSD or OpenBSD? With Linux, the decision to choose Debian and CentOS has been easy for me. Ubuntu is very popular and Debian is at the top of the lineage tree. Similarly, RHEL or CentOS is very popular in the industry where RHEL is at the top of the lineage tree and CentOS is just the rebranded RHEL made available for free. But with BSD, inspite of being very interested in it, I have not been able to pick one due to analysis paralysis. If I have enough time only to spend time with one of the BSDs, what possible criteria should I use to evaluate them against one another and pick one?
- chousuke 9y agoGive OpenBSD a try. Of the BSDs I've tried, it's the one that feels the most "tasteful", if that makes sense. Everything in the base system is well-documented, well-executed and feels consistent, and most things just do the right thing with minimal configuration.
- kqr 9y agoThe two things that made me install FreeBSD rather than OpenBSD was (1) the better hardware support when it comes to Intel-derived architectures, and (2) not as opinionated and, frankly, in many cases plain rude, project leads. From a technical and documentation standpoint, OpenBSD is utterly fantastic and FreeBSD is doing its best to get ahead.