5 ms·
Winnie-the-Pooh brought joy to readers, but misery to the Milnes
- shakna 9y agoAlways interesting to see people's take on my family's history, but I can't agree that the original Winnie-the-pooh books were rosy and cheerful. The philosophy of A.A. Milne bleeds through into them, in ways that few children of today could be expected to grasp, and life and death aren't dealt with as something as taboo as you find today. Poverty, hunger and war all appear in their own small ways, if just by their impacts. Being said, I do think most people of today think of Disney's rendition when they think of the bear and his boy, which is far more light-hearted and rosy. It may be a shock to see the dysfunction between father and son, who birthed such a famous story.
- athenot 9y agoI enjoy reading Winnie-the-pooh to my daughter. Every character is dysfuntional in their own way, but at the end of the day they all stick together. I find it a great tool to plant the seeds of diversity: the world is not made up of "all the people who share my interests and live like me", it's colorful, messy, sad, spontaneous, full of surprises and generally a much better place when sticking together.
- jasonmaydie 9y agoThe biography of the kid obviously shows he disliked the way he was exploited but this review sounds like it was something completely horrible.
- mfoy_ 9y agoI mean, if he didn't speak to his mother for the last 15 years of his life it was probably pretty horrible.
- pacaro 9y agoI’ve spoken with my father just once in the last 15 years or so, and that 9 years ago. It happens, not all people are good parents, not all relationships can or should be healed. I doubt I’ll speak to him again before he dies, that could be tomorrow, it could be in 20+ years. I’ve made my peace. Does that mean my childhood was “pretty horrible”? Parts of it weere, and I’m not sure that there is a calculus of human experience that would allow me to calculate a net horribleness quotient. But even with my father I remember happy and sweet moments.
- Razengan 9y agoAs someone who has lost people that I wish I could have done more with, I think you should still talk to him now and then, if only because you and him and your relationship with each other is never going to occur again in the infinity of this Universe..
- pacaro 9y agoI understand that you mean well.
- BrandoElFollito 9y agoAs someone who lost some people who I should have done more with (or see more) AND people I am so happy to see dead that I almost celebrate their funeral every year by a big party - I think one should not offer such philosophical ideas to a random stranger without knowing the whole story.
- Razengan 9y agoI still think it's a terrible thing to live with resentment for anyone, especially long after they are gone, and I'm free to voice my thoughts, but of course I'm not telling anyone what they should do. I've had people I despised too, where the best course of action for all involved was to completely cut contact, but letting them influence my feelings after they're out of my life just means allowing them victory over me.
- pbhjpbhj 9y agoBut then one of the horrors is fame, another fortune both of which appear relatively easy to avoid for an author -- use a different name for subsequent works, make the previous works public domain with "anon" as the author. For a child to be forced in to a position of promoting a book series, in those times, not much to be done; but the rest of it seems like complaining that your wallet is so full it makes the pockets in your silk trousers pull too much.
- mncharity 9y ago> Winnie-the-Pooh brought joy to readers, but misery to the Milnes [...] [...] and, functionally, a constitutional amendment to the United States. Disney's Winnie-the-Pooh annual merchandising revenue are said to be north of 5 billion dollars a year. As much as the mouse, preventing the escape of the bear has paid for two copyright extension acts, defeat of various constitutional challenges and copyright reform attempts, support for US adoption of the Berne convention, and for TPP's Investor State Dispute Settlement provisions (aka regulatory capture insurance - "if we pay your legislature to get us a windfall, and you someday change it's mind, you'll have to reimburse us for our lost windfall - it's only fair"), and for a multi-decade press PR campaign. While the bear remains in bondage, so long will copyright law remain unable "[t]o promote the progress of science and useful arts". Free the bear! ;)
- shakna 9y agoWorth noting that almost all the rights for Winnie-the-Pooh rest with Stephen Slesinger, Inc and Walt Disney, and not with the Milne family. In '98, Clare, Christopher's daughter, attempted to prevent Slesinger from expanding their copyrights, but the US courts didn't agree.
- Ibethewalrus 9y agoAre they bein considered part of the cannon since their character design is quite different?