2 ms·
> US gov't was acting irrational/anti-freedom/for-no-good-cause/destructive. How old are you? Valid question. My younger friends who missed being alive during
by matwood 9y ago
> US gov't was acting irrational/anti-freedom/for-no-good-cause/destructive.
How old are you? Valid question. My younger friends who missed being alive during the real fear of Russia/Communism often say exactly what you said. People who are old enough to remember that time period, even if it was the very end, understand a little better the mood of the world at that time.
History does not happen in a vacuum. While it may have been irrational in hindsight, at the time the spread of Russian communism was a real and valid fear (the documentary even talks of France telling the US if it did not help in Vietnam they would consider aligning with Russia). If only the US knew then that it would basically win a culture victory barely ~20 years later.
Your TLDR is seems to say ignore history and believe the very simplistic view of a war mongering US. If wars were only that simple, they could probably be avoided.
- cies 9y ago> How old are you? 30s > My younger friends who missed being alive during the real fear of Russia/Communism often say exactly what you said. That fear was mongered. Socialist ideology is there to help the workers: only capitalists have to fear it. It's not worked out well, even for many workers -- I blame that on a bad (highly authoritarian) route to implement socialist ideals, not on those ideal by themselves. Capitalists made the US workers afraid of commies, because they saw it as a thread. You've been fooled. > at the time the spread of Russian communism was a real and valid fear Seriously? I call it an unfounded and irrational fear, mongered by super wealthy (that were really afraid to have "their" assets seized by the workers). Valid? Not for the working class. > Your TLDR is seems to say ignore history and believe the very simplistic view of a war mongering US. If wars were only that simple, they could probably be avoided. No! I advocate not to watch this doc because it is a waste of your time. Nothing new is there. And it does say "US was evil, lets learn from it and do not do it again" -- which I believe in the current geo-political mess it the right think to do. (Yes I'm talking to you: ALL RECENT US PRESIDENTS) How can you justify the US has not been war mogenring recently. I see huge military (they call it defense, lol) budgets. I see no WMDs in Iraq, no danger for the US in Libya, no danger for the US Afgan/Iran/Syria. These are not peace missions. People die and US seems to make it worse. Gadaffi->Isis; Saddam->Isis; Assad->Isis. And now aggression to NK. Have some restraint, c'mon! > If only the US knew then that it would basically win a culture victory barely ~20 years later. Please explain this, and how it matters to the discussion.