12 ms·
How a ’50s-Era New York Knife Law Has Landed Thousands in Jail
- adwmayer 9y agoNeeds a (2014) on it. Looks like not much has changed in the mean time and the bill to sort this out was vetoed at the beginning of this year. https://patch.com/new-york/new-york-city/officials-advocates-react-veto-gravity-knife-bill https://patch.com/new-york/new-york-city/officials-advocates...
- nailer 9y agoIt's the Village Voice, which is a pretty bad source, but I've read most of the article anyway, expecting a definition of 'gravity knife' at some point and now given up.
- Terretta 9y agoSwitchblade that opens one handed by gravity or flick of wrist instead of a spring.
- cchurch 9y agoI believe that any knife that can be opened one handed would qualify, no? This would be a "gravity knife": https://www.amazon.com/Victorinox-Swiss-Trekker-Pocket-Knife/dp/B001DZT0M0/ref=sr_1_1?ie=UTF8&qid=1506777869&sr=8-1&keywords=swiss+army+one+handed+trekker https://www.amazon.com/Victorinox-Swiss-Trekker-Pocket-Knife... For context, I carried one of these throughout college for random boxes, cutting wires, etc.
- StavrosK 9y agoWait a minute, I have one of those and they're hard enough to open two-handed, your arm would break the sound barrier before you could flick this thing with enough speed to open it one-handed. Is this really considered a gravity knife?
- zhengyi13 9y agoFlicks aren't required. The thumbhole on the blade is there specifically to enable a one-handed opening, and would likely therefore qualify as a "gravity knife", whatever we might think of such a classification.
- KGIII 9y agoAccording to the article, flicks are the requirement. It's a long article and they don't get into it until quite a ways down. One handed would be okay, so long as it can't be flicked open by officers who practice flicking knives open on a regular basis and have pretty much perfected the art. But, yes, the flicking is a requirement - according to the article.
- maxerickson 9y agoEven holding the blade?
- StavrosK 9y agoYou can't really hold the blade, the blade in mine is so recessed that you can only open it by putting your thumbnail in a notch on the blade, but which is pretty hard and takes effort. I can definitely not hold the entire thing from the bit of blade that protrudes.
- dunham 9y agoIt looks like the linked knife has a handle sticking out of the blade specifically for grabbing on to. Perhaps you have a different model?
- StavrosK 9y agoAhh, I missed that that was a handle. Mine looks more like this: https://www.swiss-knife.com/media/catalog/product/0/_/0.9523.c.jpg https://www.swiss-knife.com/media/catalog/product/0/_/0.9523... When the blade is folded, only the little notch sticks out. Very hard to open.
- tomatsu 9y ago> I believe that any knife that can be opened one handed would qualify, no? This would include things like box cutters (utility knifes).
- huffmsa 9y agoNo, the opening needs to be done with some centripetal motion.
- whathaschanged 9y agoIt's not a switchblade. That's like calling a handgun a 'rifle with a shorter barrel'. There is a distinction between a switchblade (which opens at the operation of a switch or button), a gravity knife (which opens as you described),and a spring assisted knife (which has a spring but not one strong enough to open the blade on its own). It's dangerous to mix and match words when describing an item that could or could not get you in a heap of trouble for carrying and or possessing in your particular jurisdiction.
- Terretta 9y agoAgreed it’s not a switchblade, it differs fundamentally in that it doesn’t have a spring and is not automatic. You take that thing, remove a bit, have this thing. Wikipedia: A switchblade is a type of knife with a folding or sliding blade contained in the handle which is opened automatically by a spring when a button, lever, or switch on the handle or bolster is activated. Most switchblade designs incorporate a locking blade, in which the blade is locked against closure when the spring extends the blade to the fully opened position. The blade is unlocked by manually operating a mechanism that unlocks the blade and allows it to be folded and locked in the closed position. Wikipedia itself contrasts gravity knife with switchblade (as of time of this comment): A gravity knife is a knife with a blade contained in its handle, and which opens its blade by the force of inertia or gravity. As the gravity knife requires gravity or spinning motion to propel the blade out of the handle, it differs fundamentally from the switchblade, which opens its spring-propelled blade automatically upon the push of a button, switch, or fulcrum lever. I’d think the distinction should be design intent: the Buck knife and Home Depot knife shown in article photo are not designed to actuate through a spring or gesture. A gravity knife, like a switchblade, is. So certainly closer to a switchblade without a spring rather than a locking blade folding knife. In Africa we called these knives that were not fully automatic but required a gesture “flick blades”. Some of them are not folding, they slid straight out (or down, gravity assisted) and had a double edge like a dagger. Many of these could become switchblades again if you disassembled them and added a spring. I also agree with you the enforcement interpretation sounds like they want it to mean any knife you could possibly shake to an open and locked position.
- 9y ago
- matt4077 9y agoThis is a deeply-researched, well-written exposé on a troubling, ongoing injustice. But you're giving up after two paragraphs, badmouthing the publication, and the author, because they don't start with the glossary? FWIW, "gravity knifes" are defined when the article turns to the legal situation. In making readers wait a bit, the article may actually be trying to recreate the thoughts of these people caught up in the law: "WTF is a gravity knife?" But, wow, it must suck to be a good journalist these days with these sorts of readers.
- nailer 9y ago> But you're giving up after two paragraphs No. As other posters have mentioned the definition appears at 3,376 words through. Have you read the article for yourself, or did you just make up 'two paragraphs' to attack others? It's not a 'well written expose'. It's clickbait hiding the meat of the article 3000 words deep for more ad views at the expense of a working narrative. You could happily title it 'guess what this obscure new york law is' and then made a series of slides hiding the answer on the tenth.
- GlenTheMachine 9y agoAs defined by New York, basically any modern folding knife. If you can open it one-handed, it’s a “gravity knife”. I went to NY last year. I could have been prosecuted under this law.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoSpring assist folding knives don't meet the NY definition of a gravity knife even though they are easier to deploy than many thumb stud knives. They can be purchased in the city.
- mikeleung 9y ago"Under Penal Law 265.01, a gravity knife is defined as any knife that opens with “the force of gravity or the application of centrifugal force” and has a blade that locks into place by means of a “button, spring, lever, or other device.” Courts have interpreted that to mean that any knife that can be opened with a “wrist flick” — a movement something like what a fan dancer might do — qualifies as a gravity knife. A long list of court cases have turned on exactly that question, which seems straightforward enough." I think spring assisted folding knives do meet this definition, and the article also does mention many folding knives sold in the city also meet this definition
- TomK32 9y agoYou've give up far too early, the definition is in the article: "Courts have interpreted that to mean that any knife that can be opened with a “wrist flick” — a movement something like what a fan dancer might do — qualifies as a gravity knife. A long list of court cases have turned on exactly that question, which seems straightforward enough."
- dunham 9y agoYeah, I the description of the law is buried pretty deep in the article: Under Penal Law 265.01, a gravity knife is defined as any knife that opens with “the force of gravity or the application of centrifugal force” and has a blade that locks into place by means of a “button, spring, lever, or other device.”
- TazeTSchnitzel 9y agotl;dr: racial profiling and quotas. It's just an exploitable law (if using a dubiously-stretched interpretation) which is a handy pretext for arbitrarily arresting people. The title is essentially wrong, in that it's not the law itself that has landed people in jail, it's the police wilfully mis-enforcing it.
- CydeWeys 9y agoThe law itself still needs fixing though, as it's open to such willful misinterpretations.
- SloopJon 9y agoMassachusetts General Law (Part IV, Title I, Chapter 269, Section 10) includes a long paragraph that describes a variety of knives as dangerous weapons. I was on a grand jury that considered a spring-assisted knife charged under this statute. Our legal guidance was to have the ADA read this dense paragraph out loud. A majority voted to indict.
- specialp 9y agoMy brother got charged as a result this law as the police wanted information about one of his friends. It is enforced very selectively too. If you can swing it down very hard and it opens, it is a gravity knife and thus criminal possession of a weapon. It is a bad law, and according to their definition nearly every pocket knife is a gravity knife. There was an effort to repeal it, but for some reason governor Cuomo decided to veto it. https://kniferights.org/legislative-update/new-york-gravity-knife-reform-bills-filed-again/ https://kniferights.org/legislative-update/new-york-gravity-...
- dogma1138 9y agoMost weapon bans are pretty silly and arbitrary. Look at the old AWB... Flash hider? Banned.. Muzzle Break? ok... Bayonet Lug? Banned... Grenade launcher oh sorry I mean “flaregun attachment” is ok as long as you can’t fix a bayonet on it...
- dangerbird2 9y ago"Flash hider? Banned.. Muzzle Break? ok" In all fairness, muzzle breaks have practical civilian use as a way to reduce recoil for target shooting, while flash hiders just make it difficult for authorities to spot the location of a shooter. Muzzle breaks actually increase the noise level of a firearm, making more detectable than a stock barrel.
- LgWoodenBadger 9y agoFlash hiders don’t hide a flash. They’re used to protect the shooter’s eyes from the flash affecting their (night) vision.
- dogma1138 9y agoFlash hiders don't actually make gunshots harder to spot, the change the direction of the flash away from the shooter line of sight allowing the gun to be used in low light conditions without blinding oneself, and in modern days allow you to use nightvision devices. Muzzle breaks don't make a gun louder, the make it louder at the muzzle which is why some ranges don't like them. Muzzle breaks don't reduce recoil they reduce muzzle rise which is only really useful for follow up shots.
- newsmania 9y agoCops get a bad rap, but the DAs haven’t come under fire. They knowingly ruin many many more innocent lives than cops. And unlike cops who may shoot in a poor split second decision, DAs knowingly and willingly destroy the lives of the innocent for their own personal gain. It’s time we put blame where it is due.
- huffmsa 9y agoMeanwhile, all of the officers involved are probably carrying a fully automatic knife as part of their kit. Parity
- everybodyknows 9y agoDAs are rewarded for convictions, the heavier the charge the better. Police are rewarded for arrests. Only one of those two drops the blight of a criminal record onto someone's future. What we as citizens can do is demand that elected officials hold DAs accountable for their wrongful convictions.
- emn13 9y agoGiven the injustice of justice, "wrongful" won't do much. "Unreasonable" would be a better standard. E.g.: have a retrospective sample of cases analyzed and ranked by independent reviewers; punish those deemed unreasonable; reward those deemed reasonable (explicitly regardless of the law at hand). Better yet, fine lawmakers that voted for laws involved in the convictions. Doesn't have to be a lot. Good luck with that ;-).
- curun1r 9y ago> What we as citizens can do is demand that elected officials hold DAs accountable for their wrongful convictions Way to pass the buck. In 47 states, district attorney is an elected office, not an appointment. If we want better behavior from district attorneys, we need citizens to be better at monitoring that behavior and holding them accountable.
- maxxxxx 9y agoI have read quite a bit about innocent people who were convicted and later released. In pretty much every story the prosecution kept fighting to the end even against overwhelming evidence. Only one prosecutor apologized to the exonerated person. I don't know what the culture is in prosecutors' offices but it seems they have lost touch with common sense and the real purpose of their work.
- arca_vorago 9y agoThis is a single symptom of a larger issue, namely an excess of laws to the point that any law can be arbitrarily used to prosecute you if you are of an unwanted class, race, etc. Add on top the police quota system and you have a recipe of this type of injustice that runs the gamut, from antiquidated knife laws to the drug war. To me, this is largely a result of lawyers fucking ruining everything they touch, and then not giving a shit about the lives they ruin by extension (for example, congress and k-street). It's the lawyers that are out of control here. They are the ones who got the bad law passed, they are the ones who keep allowing prosecutions to happen, they are the ones who keep the law from being challenged, etc. It's like lawyers want to be the gatekeepers to the world, but only if you pay them hefty fees. Hell, I even had someone try to tell me I shouldn't talk about GPL licensing because only lawyers understand licensing! I know lawyers are a needed entity, but they seem to have far too much power of the daily lives of people in this sense. You know what really grinds my gears though, is that these lawyers who are often at the heart of almost every injustice (even if by silent acquiescence) always pretend to be such awesome pillars of the community. I think we should start throwing lawyers in jail for such bullshit laws until you hit one powerful enough and watch the bullshit law suddenly disappear. For anyone who wants to see video of what a real gravity knife is: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZjXuiC8t1E https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=RZjXuiC8t1E or a modern version https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5IhZWyV0QI https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=v5IhZWyV0QI
- jowiar 9y agoLawyers aren’t the ones who propose the laws, or write them, or vote on them. Professionally, lawyers are the ones who represent people in disputes. Arrogant jackasses like you are what give techies a bad name.
- leesalminen 9y agoI’m guessing you’re a lawyer? Are you salty about your student loan debt, poor job prospects, and declining respect from society? Ha. You did this to yourselves.
- huffmsa 9y ago
- huffmsa 9y agoSave a life, bin that knife. Only criminals need knives. /british-persona That said, shouldn't the retailers be prosecuted for being in legal possession of the item prior to sale? They legally own all of the products in their inventory
- dangerbird2 9y agoThe article mentions that most of the knives would have been law-abiding when sold, but due to wear, the blade hinge loosens enough that an officer can flick it open.
- huffmsa 9y agoSo it's a compliance issue. Then the law is fine. A person should be responsible for keeping their property legally compliant, be it automobile, knife or propane tank. That said this is a silly law.
- jdavis703 9y agoKeeping an automobile or propane tank in poor maintenance is likely going to end in an innocent third party being harmed. Not keeping your knifes sharp and properly "detented" is only going to wind up hurting the person who owns that knife.
- petre 9y ago> Only criminals need knives. And cooks, hunters, electricians, plumbers, casual restaurant goers etc. Try slicing your steak with a fork or a spoon next time.
- huffmsa 9y agoWow, okay did you just assume my food preferences? Try not murdering innocent life for your next meal. (I jest)
- 9y ago
- cat199 9y agoMeanwhile, in the Free State of Texas... swords! woo! https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2017/08/30/en-garde-texas-open-carry-sword-law-takes-effect-friday/619064001/ https://www.usatoday.com/story/news/nation-now/2017/08/30/en...
- TomK32 9y agoMeanwhile Florida Man follows the way of the Samurai: http://www.foxnews.com/us/2017/07/27/florida-man-wields-samurai-sword-during-road-rage-incident-police-say.html http://www.foxnews.com/us/2017/07/27/florida-man-wields-samu...
- graycat 9y agoIANAL, but in such an absurd knife case, on the jury, why not just vote to acquit, for innocent? As I understand the situation, a juror can vote whatever based on whatever, for any reason or no reason, and never give their reason. So, for a nonsense knife case as in the OP, really just a way for a lot of lawyer politicians to posture before the public and a lot of other lawyers to throw innocent citizens in jail just for the jollies, why not just vote innocent?
- Simon_says 9y agoA lot of people don't know about this or jury nullification. In particular, one juror from TFA says they felt compelled to vote guilty.
- graycat 9y agoSo, we have a combination of lawyer politicians pushing total nonsense laws and posturing before the public, some cops looking to make arrests as sadists to attack innocent people, and a lot of lawyers -- judges and prosecutors -- out to be with the sadistic cops to throw as many innocent citizens in jail as possible. So, with this situation: (1) Stay the heck out of NYC. (2) Try to stay the hack out of NYS. (3) Stay the heck away from cops. (4) Look the part of the powerful, upstanding, responsible, politically influential citizen. E.g., don't drive an old car. Etc. Ah, a lot like what a lot of wild animals in the jungle have to do -- stay out of areas with potential attackers, stay away from potential attackers and generally out of sight and to any potential attacker look strong. So, right, NYC is a jungle with vicious wild animals; cops, lawyers, and lawyer politicians are among the most dangerous wild animals in that jungle.
- madengr 9y agoScrew all gun and knife laws. Wholly unconstitutional. In my state, I can carry a concealed gun and switchblade, no license necessary. That’s the way it should be nationally.
- maxerickson 9y agoAt least until we repeal the 2nd Amendment.
- refurb 9y agoGood luck with that!
- microcolonel 9y agoNew York (State and City) has an obsession with blaming weapons (and potential weapons) for crime, they have a web of arcane and nonsensical laws which tend to penalize common people who want to believe that the laws are reasonable, and are surprised to find out just how unreasonable they are. The officials of course love these laws. They've made the public so wary of "weapons" that it's valuable for them to invent as many "weapons offenses" as possible. I wonder if New York's approach to weapons laws has roots in their switch from slave state to free state (which was late for the region) like so many laws in other states. Texas took until the '90s to manage to annul their prohibitions on the concealed carry of handguns (they were no-issue up until 1995) which were clearly initially intended to be enforced selectively against the emancipated.
- CalChris 9y agoNew York abolished slavery in 1799 and New Jersey in 1804. Pennsylvania was first in 1780. What you're 'wondering' is right wing nonsense.
- theWatcher37 9y agoRacism totally existed in “free” states. His argument his the laws were more sneaky about it, since you couldn’t just say “no guns for blacks”
- CalChris 9y agoNope. He didn’t say racism. He said slavery. I’m quite familiar with these slippery slope style arguments.
- microcolonel 9y agoRacism was a major factor in the public's wariness of the emancipated slaves, so it's part of it. Either way, new laws intended to be selectively enforced against emancipated slaves and other undesirables are a feature of the 1800s (and to a lesser extent, the early to mid 1900s). That was what I was getting at. By "late for the region" I meant compared to their neighbours to the North and East (Maine, New Hampshire, Massachusetts, Rhode Island, Connecticut, The Vermont Republic†) and Pennsylvania. † Not a state at the time, for the obvious reason of being an unrecognized secession from New York, for the purpose of (among other things) abolishing adult slavery.
- headShrinker 9y agoI used to carry a pocket knife in in NYC. Nothing huge, just a 3 inch folding knife clipped to the inside of my front pocket. On some random day near Times Square a cop asked me about it. I noted that he checked the hinge to see if the blade would fall under its own weight. I didn’t realize how close to a criminal charge I was. In the end he cited me for $50 because the clip of the knife was visible. The cop was nice and I was polite and respectful but it should also be noted if I was black I think the outcome would be completely different
- MertsA 9y ago> The cop was nice The man was looking to imprison you over a ridiculous perversion of a law that no reasonable person would ever conclude they were violating. I don't care about the B.S. legalese justification for it, if a law is that morally repugnant then the man enforcing it bears some of the responsibility.
- Simon_says 9y agoCan some lawyer on here explain how this law is not plainly in conflict with the Second Ammendment? How can a city just decide they don't like knives? In part of the article, someone describes these knives as "dangerous weapons" -- well, yea, that's the idea ...
- Pinckney 9y agoThe courts haven't yet decided whether or not the "bear arms" part of the second amendment means you have a right to carry arms outside your home. Wrenn v. DC recently ruled in favor of that interpretation, and DC is now deciding if they want to try to take it to the supreme court. The 9th circuit found otherwise in Peruta v San Diego, so there's a good chance SCOTUS takes it if appealed.
- Simon_says 9y ago> The courts haven't yet decided whether or not the "bear arms" part of the second amendment means you have a right to carry arms outside your home. Absurd
- roywiggins 9y agoIt wasn't decided that there was a right to bear arms outside of a well-regulated militia until the Heller decision, which is quite recent and the court chose to make a narrow determination based on the circumstances of the case (which is common).
- dawnbreez 9y agoAs I understand it, the dispute is over the meaning of 'militia'. At the time, the 'militia' was considered to be any able-bodied male under the age of 40, and under the law's current definition of the militia, any able-bodied person between 17 and 40 is considered to informally be part of the militia (as opposed to the national guard, who are formally part of it)[1]. The question is whether 'militia' means just the national guard or includes the 'irregulars' who would've been expected to fight despite not formally being part of the military. [1] https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/246 https://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/10/246
- joshuaheard 9y agoThe guy in the story received the "maximum sentence" of 6 years just for carrying a knife? I think there is more to this story than stated in the article. That being said, vague laws can be abused by the state to criminalize anything or anyone the don't like.
- huffmsa 9y agoNo he had 3 priors. At least one of which was a felony, meaning he got the maximum.
- 21 9y agoThey explain in the article. Because of his prior convictions, his charge was "bumped up" to the next level. They also say in the article that police officers are told to look for prior convictions (presumably over the radio when they check identity) so that they can "bump up" the charge.
- SubiculumCode 9y agoThis makes me so mad. Posession of a pocket knife used for work ruins 6 years of a mans wife...and I tell you. We know this was used on the poor or the brown.
- jokoon 9y agoI'm not American, but I don't understand, how did this man get those 6 years added in a tribunal? Did he go to court? I mean what kind of legal people put this guy in jail for that? I mean did anybody blink on it? Sure the law is a problem, but I don't see what motivations the justice system can have to apply the law like that, can somebody explain it to me?
- mcheshier 9y agoIt's difficult to tell from the article. Unfortunately in the USA the poor don't have the same ability to defend themselves as the rich, and it often skews along racial lines. We also have repeat offender laws that can catch up reformed criminals as well as repeat ones.
- Clubber 9y agoI would say most of the middle class doesn't have the ability to legally defend themselves either. They might be able to, but it's financially catastrophic. You can pay a lawyer to plea for you, but if it goes to trial, it could be in the 10s of thousands. It all depends on how long the prosecutor can draw out the trial. Also keep in mind while this is going on, you've probably been fired, so you don't have any income to pay for it, so it depends on how much you have saved. (You probably won't get a loan with no job). https://www.thumbtack.com/p/criminal-defense-attorney-cost https://www.thumbtack.com/p/criminal-defense-attorney-cost
- deleted 9y ago[deleted]
- Clubber 9y ago>I don't see what motivations the justice system can have to apply the law like that, can somebody explain it to me? They're chasing statistics to make themselves and their departments look better. If you can't measure the important things, the important things become what you can measure.
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoOh you understand, getting sent to the Gulag was more democratic than what poor Americans deal with.
- redler 9y ago"She still feels sick about the conviction she was compelled to hand out, to a man who was initially stopped by police for being in a city park after nightfall. Although the law was, in her view, deeply flawed, she felt she had no choice but to vote with the majority. Glaser herself carries a Swiss Army knife on her keychain. “It just seemed like a trumped-up charge,” she says. “And it certainly doesn’t seem like it’s enforced equally across the board.” This reads like a textbook example discussing the case for jury nullification.
- kevin_thibedeau 9y agoOr you know, just hold out and force a mistrial. This really speaks to the colossal susceptibility of jurors to blind groupthink.
- mcheshier 9y agoCame to post this exact same thing. Rational potential jurors out there, don't dodge that summons! You're the last safeguard against tyranny.
- microcolonel 9y agoI hear that in New Hampshire, people regularly inform jurors of this feature of the jury trial; but in some places it is illegal to do so. Most places try to rule it out as part of jury selection (which is understandable).
- Pinckney 9y agoI think it's useful to view these laws as a way to get around the standard of "beyond a reasonable doubt." The actual societal problem -- the one that's been illegal forever -- is robbery. But it's hard to catch robbers. If they aren't caught in the first few minutes, there's a good chance they get away for good. When the police stop somebody and find a knife on them, they might think "this person is probably using this to stick people up." The legislature can't pass a law that says "conviction for robbery requires now requires only probable cause", but they can try to achieve the same effect by making it illegal to carry a knife.
- mirimir 9y agoOops, I have a Luftwaffe paratrooper's knife.[0] Yes, an actual gravity knife. But I doubt that I'd ever carry it on the street. It's worth too much, for one thing. 0) http://www.germaniainternational.com/images2/unknown/Paratrooper_Wood_Handle_knife/MVC-010S_lg.jpg http://www.germaniainternational.com/images2/unknown/Paratro...
- ringaroundthetx 9y agoWhy isn't this enough to get all the cases thrown out under the 14th amendment's guarantee of equal protection under the law? Black and hispanic people are prosecuted while white ones were not? Owners of corporate persons were personally liable under criminal charges while chains only had to pay a fine?
- ebfd 9y agoThat would be equally applicable to all types of criminal charges.
- jdavis703 9y agoWhat's crazy is any folding knife that can be opened with the flick of the wrist is considered a gravity knife. I don't understand how all manner of firearms are legal, but even the most simple knifes are illegal.
- pavel_lishin 9y ago> I don't understand how all manner of firearms are legal, but even the most simple knifes are illegal. All manner of firearms are explicitly illegal in New York City, unless you have a difficult-to-get exemption.
- jdavis703 9y agoThat might be true, but gravity knife bans extend far outside of NYC. Many U.S. states and cities have similar laws.
- pasbesoin 9y agoOk, I'm about halfway through this "novella", and while I find the story itself very pertinent, I still haven't seen it define what a gravity knife actually is -- what differentiates it from other classes of knives. Admittedly, I've taken to half skimming, as I didn't intend to make a significant time investment in learning this. Here are some pertinent -- essential -- details, from mid-way through the article. First, I guess I should add that the article talks earlier about the problem of knives being perhaps deliberately mis-classified as gravity knives (without actually defining this). Gravity-knife arrests may be popular for another reason. Most, like Neal’s, result from simple observation of a “pocket clip,” often readily visible. All officers need to do is keep their eyes peeled, and they can add another misdemeanor to their tally — or, if they’re lucky, a felony. Matt Galluzzo, a former assistant district attorney in Manhattan, now a defense attorney in private practice, says that for many officers, a gravity-knife arrest is simply a hard collar to pass up. “You don’t have to fight the guy, you don’t have to chase him,” Galluzzo says. “It’s an easy way to make an arrest. And they’re under pressure to make arrests.” A poster on Officer.com, a verified online message board for law enforcement officers, put it bluntly in 2013 when he advised a rookie to be on the lookout for “GKs”: “make sure they have a prior conviction so you can bump it up to that felony!!!” Most of the D.A.s in the state “have never prosecuted a gravity-knife case, or haven’t prosecuted one in 30 years,” according to a spokesperson for the District Attorneys Association of the State of New York. Even just beyond the city limits, gravity-knife prosecutions are exceedingly rare. While the population of the Bronx is roughly equal to that of Suffolk County on Long Island, the Bronx prosecuted more than 10 times as many likely cases in 2013 as its counterpart across the water. Even worse, critics charge, is that officials have prosecuted knife users aggressively while doing little to address the source of those same knives, which are sold openly at reputable retailers all over the city. New York State assemblyman Dan Quart, a Democrat from Manhattan, says there’s an obvious contradiction at play: “You can walk in and purchase one of these knives over the counter,” he says, “and then walk out and get arrested.”... The racial breakdown of stops is also striking. Of the thousands of arrests that resulted from stop-and-frisk encounters, 86 percent of the total involved black or Hispanic suspects. And a Voice analysis also shows that white suspects are significantly more likely to be let go, even when they’re caught carrying knives. Only 35 percent of white suspects found with knives — virtually any of which might meet the NYPD’s ecumenical definition — are arrested, while 56 percent of black and Hispanic suspects are ultimately booked. Ah, and finally, a definition of what a gravity knife is: The original gravity knife — the type legislators targeted when they banned them half a century ago — bears no resemblance to the kind that landed Richard Neal and thousands of others in jail over the last decade. Developed by the German military for use by paratroopers during World War II, the idea behind a gravity knife was simple: An unlucky parachutist who found himself in a tight spot — tangled in a tree, for example — would be able to access the knife even with injuries or limited mobility. Simply press a button and the blade would literally fall out of the handle and lock in place... The legislature didn’t target gravity knives at the time — they were still rarely seen in the U.S. But after switchblade bans went into effect, the knife industry saw an opportunity. Even though they were nearly identical in design, gravity knives lacked a spring, a key characteristic of the newly illegal switchblades. So manufacturers stuck with warehouses full of worthless knives simply removed the springs and went on selling, calling the new products “gravity knives.”
- zmix 9y agoI wonder what those six years cost the taxpayer.
- giardini 9y agoGood reason to carry a fixed-blade knife (legal blade length and style of course).
- fencepost 9y agoArticle is from 2014. Reform of the law passed in 2016, basically to make knives with a spring that holds them closed legal. https://www.villagevoice.com/2016/06/15/gravity-knife-reform-passes-legislature-over-objections-from-de-blasio/ https://www.villagevoice.com/2016/06/15/gravity-knife-reform...